Daniel Barenboim: Sound has several very interesting aspects, I think, worth observing. One is duration—that there is a connection between sound and time. But before that there is a connection between sound and silence. When one speaks about sound, very one speaks of the color of sound— a bright sound or a dark sound. Which is of course nonsense because what may be dark for one is light for the other, and vice versa. It’s very subjective. I could say “It’s a beautiful sound.” What is a beautiful sound? So it’s very subjective and not really a definable characterization. Whereas the duration of sound and it’s relation to silence is a very objective thing. I sing a note or I whistle a note and when I have no more air, the note goes. Where does it go? Into the silence again. And when we observe that really more clearly we see that sound has a relationship with silence not unlike the law of gravity. In order to lift a certain object from the ground we have to use energy. But then to sustain it at that level, we have to keep on adding energy or otherwise the object falls to the ground. It’s exactly the same thing with the sound. We need a certain amount of energy to produce the sound. But then to sustain it we have to give more energy or otherwise it goes and it dies in silence. And therefore sound is absolutely, inextricably connected to time, the length of time. And this, I think, what gives it or even more so when it becomes music. It’s really tragic element of the fact that it can die, of the fact that it is a lifetime. Every note is a lifetime for itself.
Daniel Barenboim on the Duration of Notes
Daniel Barenboim offers a concise yet profound definition of the most fundamental element of music; rhythm. And yet rhythm encompasses so much more than meter and rests. A musician’s relationship with silence, tension in that silence, his or her comfort level with it and the energy within the sound created in time is what makes art. It is fleeting, temporal and glorious. His definition is as eloquent as his music making. Thank you.
[...] Physics of Sound: Daniel Barenboim on the Duration of Notes | Music Instinct | PBS [...]
I absolutely loved his piano playing. Is there anyway to find out which compositions he played on this show?
Barenboim comments, “It’s really tragic element of the fact that it can die, of the fact that it is a lifetime. Every note is a lifetime for itself.” This is most amusing because if the “tragedy” — a word from literature and theater, not music — did not exist, then sounds would never stop, and the world would be an unending cacophony of sound. a brilliant pianist, he is not a music philosopher of the same depth. He uses words like a politician, not a musician. Stravinsky taught us that it is difficult to speak about music, and Barenboim has just proved this with an illogical though emotional statement which is musically and theatrically untrue.
Barenboim’s idea of notes living and dying is a beautiful one. Comments from the peanut-gallery of academia, such as offered by Mr.Wagner, serve as a disheartening reminder of why Classical music will never gain a broad audience.
Thank you Jim Ludoviconi! Yes Mr S. Wagner, Give it a rest!
Absolute hogwosh. Ludoviconi is a pretencious bore; there is nothing beautiful about the idea of notes living and dying.
Time and music are indivisible for each note, each pause, has a certain duration.
Food for thought: there are millions of people who experienced near death (NDE) who state that time does not exist. It is a human construct without which man cannot live on this planet. Yet they heard music.
hi mr barenboim i am an algerian violonist and i am your great fan here how are you i am searching 5th beethoven symphony 2 nd mouvement and it is not here can you please sent it for me and are you coming here in algeria with your wedo orchestra good bye yours fares chicha



(4 votes)

