This website is no longer actively maintained
Some material and features may be unavailable

‘Law & Order’: R.I.P

Photo: NBC

Has any show’s demise ever mirrored its own format as well as that of “Law & Order”? Last week began like any other sweeps week in the television industry, just like every episode began with a normal-seeming slice of life in New York City: a brisk jog around Central Park, a protracted wait for the subway, a late-night haul up the stairs to one’s apartment. Then, the whispers began that “Law & Order” might not be renewed for its record-breaking 21st season. Cut to the slow pan, the jump cut, the horrified reaction to something just off frame, and then — wham!— a body is discovered behind the tree, pushed in front of an oncoming train, bleeding out on the landing. “Law & Order” was canceled.


“Law & Order” premiered Sept. 13, 1990. That same year, 2,245 people were murdered in New York and the city was known as the murder capital of the nation. The nation itself was still reeling from the soaring crime rates of the past decade. Over the next two decades of the show’s run, crime rates fell dramatically in the United States and plummeted so dramatically in New York City that in 2009 one was almost as likely to play a murder victim on “Law and Order” (or it’s two spin-offs: “Special Victims Unit” and “Criminal Intent”) as to actually be murdered in Manhattan.

One is also infinitely more likely to be able to watch an episode of “Law & Order” than just about any other show on television. Thanks to syndication deals with TNT and USA network, “Law & Order” can be seen several times a day in any market in the United States. And it’s perhaps through these syndication deals that one gets the sense of just how many luminaries have guest starred on this now-iconic crime drama. Flip on the television and see a young Cynthia Nixon playing a gun-toting ballerina bent on revenge, a then-unknown Ellen Pompeo murdering her mother or an already famous Julia Roberts as a professional gold-digger. In fact, “Law & Order” became a right of passage for New York-based actors, providing on average 700 speaking roles per season and employing approximately 14,000 actors over its run.

As crime rates continued to fall and Manhattan became a place filled with more glitter than grit, “Law & Order” relied increasingly on “ripped-from-the-headlines” plots: an unfaithful talk-show host who falls victim to a blackmailing scheme, a New York governor with unseemly ties to an underground prostitution ring, an intoxicated mother who drives down a street in the wrong direction with disastrous results. These episodes, just like all the others, did what “Law & Order” did best: showing the myriad New Yorks that exist side by side, on top of and parallel to each other. From the penthouses of Park Avenue and the mayor’s office to the abandoned subway tracks below the city and the row houses in outer Queens, “Law & Order” highlighted both the mundane and fantastic entanglements of the lives of all kinds of New Yorkers.

And now the franchise heads west, “Law & Order: L.A.” or “LOLA” will premiere on NBC this fall. There has been some speculation that Benjamin Bratt may reprise his role as Detective Ray Curtis for the show for “LOLA.” (During an early episode of “Law & Order” this season, Bratt appeared as Curtis and alluded to living in California.) In the meantime, New York won’t be completely without “Law & Order.” Both “SVU” and “Criminal Intent” are slated to return for another season.

  • thumb
    Memorial Day every day
    Beyond the backyard BBQ: Honor and aid those who have served.
  • Fast and too furious?
    Can accuracy and the demand for instant information coexist in the media?
  • thumb
      Steinbeck's Salinas Valley
    John Steinbeck's hometown came to worldwide notice through the Grapes of Wrath. Not all city fathers were pleased by the portrait. Explore what has changed and what remains the same in Salinas.


  • Lauren

    Effective how this article doesn’t only read as a history of a show, but also a history of a city.

  • Joel

    Nice work, Gloria. Your writing reveals you to be a fan, no? And as Lauren says, nice clever ties to actual crime statistics. This was a fun read for a fellow fan.

  • blech

    I hate that Law and Order was cancelled. SVU was always too melodramatic and since they have added Sharon Stone to the cast, the acting is awful.

  • Jack

    Gloria, I really enjoyed this piece. As someone who always wanted to live in NY, I too will miss the show, but keep up the interesting and insightful commentary…and we should be hearing more from you!

  • Leroy

    Thanks, Gloria, for the way you encapsulated what this show meant to so many people.
    Great show, great city and a great article!