This website is no longer actively maintained
Some material and features may be unavailable

‘Gotcha’ videos gone wild

A new wave of opposition researchers is harnessing the power of the web to upend campaigns and reshape the political conversation this election season.

James Carter, grandson of former Democratic President Jimmy Carter, always assumed that he would go into the family business, until he ruled out running for public office. But the 35-year-old graduate student may have inadvertently found his political calling earlier this year after he noticed that former House Speaker Newt Gingrich was gaining ground in the Republican primaries.

On a spur, Carter decided to embark on a digital dig, starting with a broad Google search: “Newt controversy.” Several pages in, he stumbled upon an incident where Gingrich clumsily implied that Spanish was “the language of the ghetto.” To Carter’s surprise, the provocative comment had received little play in the blogosphere and talk radio circuit. So he made a beeline for the C-SPAN video archives, and found the footage from the March 31, 2007 conference for the National Federation of Republican Women, where Gingrich said, “We should replace bilingual education with immersion in English so people learn the common language of the country and so they learn the language of prosperity, not the language of living in a ghetto.”

Image from CSPAN video of Newt Gingrich from March 2007.

Using free video editing software, Carter stitched Gingrich’s “ghetto” comment together with his subsequent mea culpa (delivered in Spanish). He then uploaded this video pastiche to his YouTube channel, and headed off to class.

Hours later, the video was discovered by enterprising political bloggers and went into heavy rotation on the cable news shows, and was even linked to by the Pulitzer Prize winning fact-checking website PolitiFact. Carter’s amateur video garnered more than 10,000 views and went on to become part of the larger political dialogue for several days.

A self-professed liberal and political junkie, Carter brings his sharp research skills and contrarian streak — he loves to prove others wrong, especially if they’re Republicans – to bear on his consuming hobby.

“The news is on in the background all day,” said Carter. “When I disagree, I yell at the TV, then go online to find supporting evidence to just make myself feel better.”

But these days, Carter is receiving more than personal validation. His independent research of GOP politicians has gone mainstream, and is frequently showcased on liberal mainstays like MSNBC’s “The Rachel Maddow Show.”

Depending on whom you ask, Carter is a shrewd strategist with a partisan agenda or an Internet addict with an unhealthy interest in politics. Regardless of which side you fall on, many politicos agree that Carter represents a new breed of opposition researcher, who is harnessing the power of the web and social media platforms to upend campaigns and reshape the political conversation this election season. Working from their parents’ basements or from the comfort of their beds, these civilian operatives are on a quest for the Holy Grail: raw video footage of a candidate’s flip-flop or off-message speech.

* * *

The indisputable poster boy for this growing trend is 22-year-old Andrew Kaczynski, whom Carter calls his “hero.” While studying history as an undergraduate at St. John’s University in Queens, Kaczynski would spend his spare time watching old footage of speeches from the C-SPAN archives as well as clips on YouTube and Google Video. For Kaczynski, these pastimes, which might sound tedious to the average co-ed, qualify as “fun” thanks to his intense interest in American politics and history.

Back in October of last year, Kaczynski began to upload his digital finds to his YouTube channel. At first, his channel consisted of old political campaign commercials and quirky videos of candidates’ off-guard moments. But soon, his channel evolved into a curated playlist with more teeth. Standouts include a 2004 video of Mitt Romney lambasting then-Democratic nominee John Kerry as a flip-flopper and a grainy video from 2005 showing Newt Gingrich supporting the individual health care mandate alongside Hillary Clinton.

Kaczynski’s finds have driven news cycles and and spurred hours of talk on the cable networks. And his YouTube channel and Twitter feeds have become destination sites for political reporters. “It gets addictive after a while, you’re just like, ‘Man, I’m having an impact on the presidential race’ and then you just want to keep finding this stuff.”

  • thumb
    Memorial Day every day
    Beyond the backyard BBQ: Honor and aid those who have served.
  • Fast and too furious?
    Can accuracy and the demand for instant information coexist in the media?
  • thumb
      Steinbeck's Salinas Valley
    John Steinbeck's hometown came to worldwide notice through the Grapes of Wrath. Not all city fathers were pleased by the portrait. Explore what has changed and what remains the same in Salinas.


  • Anonymous

    So long as politicians keep ‘forgetting’ that they’re being recorded and spewing nonsense they late whine is ‘out of context’ or ‘not what i really meant’, then these guys will have a job.  It doesn’t keep the politicians honest, but it gives the voters a clearer picture of who they really are.

  • Maureen Magovern

    This is EXACTLY what we need! Yea! Thanks you guys!

  • Willijames
  • madastrota

    Rejebian complains about these amateurs taking things out of context with sound-bites. But how is that ANY different from what happens in mainstream media? At least now we have the potential of getting a fuller picture by folding the underground sound-bites in with the mainstream sound-bites. Kudos to the politico-nerds!

  • Danielgantt53

    Funny that Rejebian complains about soundbites! That has been one of my worst complaints for many years now! I turned my cable off after “W” was elected the second time because I recognized the”EVIL” of 24 hour news feeds in the political process.It always seemed that so much misinformation and half truths were circulating that it was impossible to check facts due to the bombardment that has become so out of control. It’s nice to know that people are interested in searching the archives and checking facts,even if the timing may be a bit late. I look forward to the day when all politicians will have to “back their political smack”and all parties and players will hesitate before making any public or political statement before dotting their I’s and crossing their T’s ! People need to start taking time to check facts on their own,and hopefully the day will come when they don’t feel too overwhelmed by the volume of BS out there to try!!!!!!!!!!

  • Anonymous

    This is fascinating. I love that there are still people out there who care enough to find real facts instead of just slinging mud. There’s a lot of double-talk and, well, politicking on both sides of the aisle, but it’s great that these folks are helping clear the waters by doing some careful research. Not sure how many Republicans will care, but it needs to be shown that candidates are being less than honest (at best). 

  • Danielgantt53

    Nonsense! This guy should back away from his computer and go see his Dr,sounds like he’s been choking on his own bile! Maybe he’ll have time to check his facts and history during his recovery!