Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Logo
On Out Own Terms: Moyers on Dying
Choosing Death: The Debate end



The Debate Home

Support for PAS

PAS and End-of-Life Care

PAS and Terminal Sedation

PAS and Suffering

What's Next

Biography

Print Page

Close Window


Question
Dr. Timothy Quill Dr. Ira Byock
Requires Real Player
If you ask people in straight-out terms, do you support physician-assisted suicide, you'll get two-thirds to three-quarters who will say yes. If you ask a different question, would you rather have good palliative care, good hospice care, or physician-assisted suicide, people will say, "I would much rather have good hospice care" once they really understand what it is.

I think there is a preference for good palliative care if you're forced to make a decision between good palliative care and physician-assisted suicide. The question that hasn't been asked and that should be is would you rather have both: Would you rather have good hospice care, good palliative care, and access to physician-assisted suicide as a last resort? My guess is that people want all three.

I have philosophical and social policy problems with physician-assisted suicide. My sense is that P.A.S. could be used as an apology or as a pressure valve-- inhibiting an adequate social response to the true public health crisis that surrounds end-of-life care. If greater efforts were made to improve end-of-life care, then there would be less energy spent on promoting P.A.S. as a solution to this crisis.



 






Copyright 2000, Educational Broadcasting Corporation/Public Affairs Television, Inc.

 




On Our Own Terms - Moyers on DyingThirteen/WNET New YorkPBS Online