Saint Nicholas Tradition


Originally broadcast December 19, 2008

KIM LAWTON: It’s the season of Santa Claus, and it seems he’s everywhere. Children anxiously await the arrival of Santa who is, of course, bearing gifts. But some Christians are worried that most of those children, and their parents as well, don’t know who “jolly old Saint Nicholas” really was.

Canon JIM ROSENTHAL (Founder, UK/USA St. Nicholas Society): St. Nicholas was a real person — not a fairy, not someone who’s flying through the sky with reindeer, but an actual person who lived and worked and died and had a full life. He had a Christian life because he was actually a bishop, a pastor.

LAWTON: As director of communications for the worldwide Anglican Communion, Canon Jim Rosenthal was always on the lookout for images of bishops. He says he was captivated by a fourth-century bishop named Nicholas. Now Rosenthal helps lead an international movement urging churches to reclaim Saint Nicholas.

Canon Jim Rosenthal, founder, UK/USA St. Nicholas Society

Canon ROSENTHAL: I believe that Saint Nicholas and his tradition is something that needs to be recovered and now.

LAWTON: Rosenthal is founder of the UK/USA Saint Nicholas Society.

Canon ROSENTHAL: The children are getting these that say “I met the real and true Santa Claus and Father Christmas.”

LAWTON: Every year, he dresses up like Saint Nicholas, complete with the bishop’s staff called a crozier and his distinctive hat called a miter.

Canon ROSENTHAL: I have to decide if I wear one of those miters or this miter. This is the most pretty one.

LAWTON: He visits churches to help spread the Saint Nicholas message.

Canon ROSENTHAL: If we don’t recover this tradition, I believe that we are going to eventually lose Christmas, any semblance of a religious Christmas.

LAWTON: Nicholas was born in Asia Minor when the new Christian faith was beginning to spread across the Roman Empire.

Canon ROSENTHAL: He came from a very wealthy family. His parents died at an early age. His uncle was a priest. That was the undivided church in those days. There was no Roman Catholic Church or other kinds of churches — one church. And he became a priest like his uncle.

LAWTON: Nicholas rose to leadership in the early church and was named Bishop of Myra, a city on the southern coast of what is now Turkey. During a time of persecution by Roman Emperor Diocletian, Nicholas was imprisoned for his outspoken faith. He was eventually released and continued his ministry until his death on December 6 in the year 343.

Canon ROSENTHAL: He was known for his generosity and his good will because he was very rich. He literally, by the end of his life, gave away all of his fortune. Many stories talk about the fact that he was so generous that he became known as the Gift Giver.

LAWTON: More and more churches in the US and the UK are finding ways to keep the Saint Nicholas stories alive. For example, the Episcopal Cathedral of Chicago hosted a special Saint Nicholas exhibit.

Reverend JOY ROGERS (St. James Cathedral, Chicago, IL): The stories of Saint Nicholas are wonderful stories of a bishop who cared about his people, who cared very much about the poor.

LAWTON: There are numerous tales of Nicholas doing good deeds: performing miracles, calming the seas, stopping famine and rescuing children. Separating truth from myth can be difficult.

Rev. Joy Rogers

Rev. ROGERS: My guess is that some of the fanciful stories that have moved into the realm of legend and miracle had their roots in very concrete acts of very real kindness and generosity.

LAWTON: One of the most famous stories involves a poor family who couldn’t afford marriage dowries for their three daughters.

Rev. ROGERS: The parents were going to have to sell them off into slavery or into prostitution or whatever, and Saint Nicolas came by the house at night and dropped off three bags of gold coins.

LAWTON: Some legends say he secretly tossed the bags of gold through an open window, and one landed in stockings or shoes that were drying by the fire, thus launching the tradition of the Christmas stocking. Pawnbrokers have especially embraced that story.

Canon ROSENTHAL: If you go to a pawnbroker shop you’ll see three gold balls. Those represent the three bags of gold, which we now turn into chocolate coins that Saint Nicholas threw through the window to save three girls from slavery or prostitution.

LAWTON: Nicholas has been adopted by many groups beyond pawnbrokers.


Canon ROSENTHAL: So many people love him, and so many people wanted him as theirs that he’s the patron saint of almost everything: unwed women, children, which of course is the most prominent; pawn brokers; sailors and merchants and cookie makers, apothecaries. You just name it, and he’s got something to do with it.

LAWTON: Many European countries have a long tradition of celebrating the Feast Day of Saint Nicholas on December 6. Then Saint Nicholas evolved into Santa Claus and got all tied up with Christmas.

Canon ROSENTHAL: If you look at the name Santa Claus, you will see its “Santa” means saint, and “Claus” is simply an abbreviation from the “Nicholas.” But the reality is he became a secular image.

SANTA (reading to children): Not a creature was stirring, not even a mouse. The stockings were hung by the chimney with care, in hopes that Saint Nicholas soon would be there.

LAWTON: American writers and advertisers helped disseminate a new myth that made no mention of the jolly old saint’s religious connections.

Canon ROSENTHAL: We always talk about roots and being politically correct. Let’s be politically correct about Santa Claus and give him his proper title.

LAWTON: Church leaders emphasize that Saint Nicholas’s generosity was motivated by his Christian faith. The saint was following Jesus’ commands to love others, help those who are suffering, give sacrificially, and to do one’s good deeds in secret. They say Nicholas is a reminder that Christmas is really about the coming of Jesus.

Canon ROSENTHAL: The problem with Santa Claus as it stands now is that it’s a substitute for Christmas — Santa Claus instead of the creche, instead of the manger, instead of the nativity scene. This man we would find kneeling at the nativity scene saying, “This is what I’m here to celebrate as well.”

LAWTON: Nicholas may have been called the Gift Giver, but Christians teach that on Christmas God gave the world the ultimate gift — Jesus .

Canon ROSENTHAL: Symbolically, as a Christian leader St. Nicholas is pointing, like other Advent stories, pointing towards this event called Christmas, which as Christians we believe is the most wonderful night of the year.

LAWTON: And that, they say, is the true meaning of Saint Nicholas. I’m Kim Lawton reporting.

  • LIlly

    Cant you just put what night you put out your shoes? that is all I want to know!

  • Bill McElhannon

    I really enjoyed this story. It is very important for us to know the real story of Saint Nicholas. Thank you for bringing it to us. I will share this with my friends.

  • Nancy Kimos

    Wonderful piece about St. Nicholas. I am Catholic and my husband is Greek Orthodox.
    I can’t wait to show him this segment.

  • Jay Hunstiger

    Enjoyed your story, except for Canon Rosenthal’s revision of history. There was one church, and it was ‘One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. What he should have stated was that there was only one Church and it was the Roman Catholic Church. And yes, the Catholic Church is happy to share her saints with everyone, including Saint Nicholas.

  • Joe Jensen

    “If we don’t recover this tradition . . . we are going to eventually lose Christmas.” I’d like to put forth the idea, that they never truly “owned” it to begin with. The Nativity story was married to solstice festivals like the Saturnalia and Yule, and as a non-religious person who greatly enjoys Christmas, I think that it has been a happy marriage. Santa Claus is one of the children of this marriage. Santa Claus takes the generosity embodied by St. Nicholas and secularises it, he’s a secular personification of “the spirit of Christmas” (peace on Earth and goodwill towards men and that it is better to give than to recieve) they always talk about on those secular holiday tv specials. Christians don’t have a monopoly on those values. As a child I had always understood that Santa brought gifts to ALL the good little boys and girls. Honestly Christians, is all that so wrong?

  • Fran

    What does Santa Clause have to do with Jesus’ birth, life, what he taught (being truthful (don’t tell a lie) and his death? Absopositively nothing!!! Jesus knows if you’ve been good or bad, certainly not Santa. To have a lie perpetrated in the name of religion or man-made traditions is a travesty.

  • Christie

    For Joe, Actually the Church celebrated the birth of Christ at the date that comes down to us, Dec 25th, from the very beginning. A Roman emperor made a pagan solstice festival of that date a few hundred years after Christianity was established. Many of us have believed that the origins of the celebration was as you said, the Christianization of a pagan festival, and that would be OK, too. But it is not the fact. The birth of Christ was celebrated Dec 25 from the beginning, not as the overlay of Christianity on a pagan festival, but observing his actual birthdate. The conception of Christ is observed to be March 25, and His death is believed to have been on that date, too.

  • Θεοφιλος Χαριτος

    The name Santa Claus is a German derivation of the original name Saint Nicholas in Greek or in German the original was Santa Niclaus ( later changed to Santa Claus in later German shortening of the name)at the time !!! Saint Nicholas was a Greek bishop in Myra (Myra means fate in Greek) under the Hellenized Byzantine Empire of the Eastern Roman Empire that was Greek!!! Saint Nicholas or Agios Nikolaos in Greek is the patron Saint of sailors in the Christian Orthodox faith and not father Christmas ! Father Christmas for the Eastern Orthodox Christian faith is Saint Vasilios !!!! The day we celebrate Christmas is the pagan date for the pagan god Myrthra which the solders worshiped in Roman Empire ( and not the winter solstice as some say.)!!!

  • John Hayes

    I think you should go back and do a little more research. At that time there were several churches under several bishops. Not all considered Rome’s bishop to be the primary bishop. The churches of the East definitely did not. The Church was “one, holy, catholic (not Catholic) and apostolic.”