|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
COVER:
Democrats and Religion
October 20, 2006 Episode no. 1008
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: Former President Bill Clinton this week urged candidates to put aside what he called the politics of division and personal destruction in order to create a better society for all people. Clinton spoke in Washington at Georgetown University, his alma mater:
President BILL CLINTON: Ideological, divisive, demonizing, distracting politics -- they may be very good for an election, particularly when people feel unsettled and insecure, but they don't do much to advance the common good.
BOB ABERNETHY:
That term "common good" comes from Catholic social teaching, and it has become a major theme for Democrats this campaign season. Party strategists believe talking about the common good will resonate with people of faith but not offend secular supporters. Overall, Democrats have not fared well with religious voters in recent elections. Surveys have shown the more often people attended religious services, the more likely they were to vote Republican. As Kim Lawton reports, the Democrats have begun a wide-ranging new effort to change that.

Rep. SHERROD BROWN (Senate Candidate, OH, during speech): As a Lutheran, I do not claim to know God's perfect will, but as a public servant I've tried to do what is right.
KIM LAWTON: There's been a lot of God talk on the campaign trail this year, but in a major shifting of gears much of it is now coming from Democrats.
ROBERT CASEY, Jr. (Senate Candidate, PA, during speech): There is a beautiful definition of faith in the book of Hebrews…

Senator BARACK OBAMA (D-IL): My Bible tells me that if we train a child in the way he should go, when he is old he will not turn from it.
LAWTON: In recent years, the Democratic Party has struggled over how to deal with religion. Many Democratic leaders rarely spoke about faith and appeared uncomfortable whenever they did. And while Republicans actively mobilized inside churches, Democratic campaigns were often reluctant to reach out to people of faith.
Professor Clyde Wilcox teaches government at Georgetown University in Washington.

Prof. CLYDE WILCOX (Georgetown University): As the Christian right began to dominate the Republican Party discourse at some level, the Democrats then began to pull back on the religious rhetoric and began to use it less effectively.
LAWTON: Democrats continue to have a big perception problem when it comes to religion. According to a recent Pew Forum survey, while almost half of all Americans think the Republican Party is friendly toward religion, only 26 percent say the Democratic Party is. That's a sharp decline from just three years ago. And even among Democrats themselves, only about 40 percent think their party is friendly toward religion.
Prof. WILCOX: They fully understand this is a problem, and there's a couple of efforts now in town for think tanks to begin to study the problem -- do surveys, do focus groups to try to figure out how they can frame authentically religious issues in ways that are appealing to Democrats but also don't turn off some other Democratic voters.
LAWTON: Illinois Senator Barack Obama has been one of the most high-profile Democrats to do this, and he is actively urging his fellow Democrats not to run away from faith.
Sen. OBAMA (during speech): Secularists are wrong when they ask believers to leave their religion at the door before entering into the public square.
LAWTON: Eric Sapp is a senior partner at Common Good Strategies, a new consulting firm that tries to help Democrats improve their outreach to religious communities across the spectrum.
ERIC SAPP (Senior Partner, Common Good Strategies): We are trying to create relationships, let people know authentically who we are, let them know that the Democratic Party is open to people of faith.
LAWTON: Some Democratic candidates, such as Maryland gubernatorial hopeful Martin O'Malley, have been holding listening meetings with local clergy.

Mr. SAPP: Earlier on in the campaign, many of them just sat down with people of faith saying, "I want to hear what is important to you. I'm not going to preach to you. I'm not going to try to campaign to you. I just want to listen."
LAWTON: And in addition to talking about their personal faith, more and more Democrats are openly tying their political positions to their beliefs. Congressman Sherrod Brown is running for the Senate in Ohio.
Rep. BROWN: It's no leap of faith for me to get from the New Testament and the Old Testament to progressive social justice issues and concerns. It's why I fight for fair trade; it's why I fight for minimum wage; it's why I want to figure out a way, as quickly as possible, to get us out of Iraq.
Prof. WILCOX: I think one of the things the Democrats are trying to say is that their faith leads them to important values also. Faith leads to more than just attitudes on abortion and same-sex marriage.
LAWTON: Senator John Kerry admits many Democrats have not always done this well, including himself.

Senator JOHN KERRY (D-MA): There are people of extraordinary range of faith on both sides of the political aisle in America. But on our side there's been a greater reluctance to push that in a religious context in the public sector. I think we have to make clear how we are in fact translating our faith into the moral choices that we make.
LAWTON: In a September speech at Pepperdine, a Christian university in California, Kerry laid out his vision of how faith can -- and should -- play a role in public life. It was much more detailed than what he discussed during his run for the presidency.
Prof. WILCOX: There were a lot of people who were urging him to talk much more early in the campaign about his faith, which was real, and to talk about how his faith intersected with politics. His advisors told him this was risky because of the abortion issue and maybe he should just not talk about it at all. I think that was a mistake.
Sen. KERRY: When someone asked me are you sorry that you didn't give this speech during the campaign, I said no, because during a campaign it's not sort of the appropriate moment at least to begin that conversation.
|
 |
 |
 |
LAWTON: Strong Democratic support for abortion rights has been a major issue for conservative Catholic and evangelical voters. Now, some Democratic leaders are urging new approaches. In Pennsylvania, Bob Casey Jr., a Roman Catholic, is running for the Senate as a pro-life candidate.
Mr. CASEY (during speech): There have been times when members of my own party, the Democratic Party, have vigorously opposed me because of my position on the issue of abortion.
LAWTON: In 1992, Casey's father, who was then governor of Pennsylvania, was forbidden to speak at the Democratic National Convention because of his opposition to abortion.
Mr. CASEY (during speech): I believe things have changed in those 14 years. I have been encouraged to see Democrats in this new century become more open to people who are pro-life.
Rep. ROSA DELAURO (D-CT, during press conference): We are affirming our principles as Democrats, and we affirm our principles and our commitment to promoting life.
LAWTON: Meanwhile, Democratic members of Congress have introduced legislation designed to lower the number of abortions by providing more support to pregnant women.
Mr. SAPP: The Republicans have traditionally used that as a wedge issue, and Democrats are now saying, "Look, you all have been talking about this for 20 years. What have you done?" We are going to start tackling the problem. We are going to start addressing the need and number of abortions. We are going to start focusing on reducing abortions.
LAWTON: Kerry believes this should appeal to opponents of abortion.
Sen. KERRY: If you're against it, you want to reduce it. You ought to make it rare. It ought to be rare in America, under any standard, and we need to be more upfront. I don't know any Democrat who's for abortion.
LAWTON: In the 2004 election, more than three-quarters of all evangelicals and more than half of all Catholics voted for George W. Bush. Many of them cited abortion as a factor in their vote. But Wilcox says there is also the risk of alienating a key base.
Prof. WILCOX: Pro-choice activists are very nervous about Democratic candidates beginning to talk about middle options and moderate approaches. At some point, then, this becomes a moral condemnation of the abortion decision then. Both parties are beginning to say that you really shouldn't make this choice.
LAWTON: Democrats are also emphasizing concern for the environment or "creation care" as a moral issue they hope will appeal to the religious community, including growing numbers of evangelicals.
Mr. SAPP: That's an issue that has so much power, because it is a deeply theological, religious issue. It's one that evangelicals have started to rally around and saying, "This is something we should be voting on."
LAWTON: The Democrats new outreach comes as moderate and progressive people of faith are trying to mobilize their own movement of values voters to counter the religious right. One of the most visible leaders of the effort is author and minister Jim Wallis.
Rev. JIM WALLIS (Editor, Sojourners Magazine, during speech at event): I am an evangelical Christian, and when I find 2,000 verses in my Bible about poor people, I insist fighting poverty is a moral values issue, too.
LAWTON: A new group called Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good is distributing non-partisan voting guides which emphasize that Catholic values encompass more than just abortion.
ALEXIA KELLEY (Executive Director, Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good): When asked what they consider the most urgent moral issues facing us today, for example, they would cite poverty and economic justice, the war in Iraq. I mean, they understand those issues as moral issues.
LAWTON: Democratic strategists sense big new opportunities here. Catholics are one of the most important blocs of swing voters, and contrary to conventional wisdom, not all evangelicals are firmly in the Republican camp.
Mr. SAPP: Strategically, we don't have to win 50 percent of evangelicals to make a big difference. If you get a small number that will -- could really create seismic shifts throughout the political sphere.
LAWTON: But Sapp emphasizes that for many Democrats, incorporating faith is more than just political opportunism.
Sen. OBAMA (during speech): We cannot abandon the field of religious discourse.
Mr. SAPP: We have to be authentic, and we have to speak with a vision. That's the most important thing. That's what people will resonate with.
LAWTON: Wilcox says Democrats also have to supply the actions to back up their words, and if they overdo the religion language, they could turn off their secular supporters and generate cynicism among the faithful.
Prof. WILCOX: I think the worst thing that anyone can do is appear to be using religion for political advance.
LAWTON: But if they can get it right, the electoral payoff could be huge.

Prof. WILCOX: I don't think, at the end of the day, many people sort of look at their Bible and decide who to vote for, or listen to the pope and decide who to vote for. I think there's a lot of other things wrapped into this. But for a lot of voters who find themselves torn between two candidates and wondering, in the confusion of the campaign, who they're going to trust, I think religion then serves as probably one of the very most effective cues to say these are the core values of this particular candidate.
LAWTON: If the Democrats new religious outreach helps lead to success on November 7, experts expect lots more faith-based campaigning going into 2008.
I'm Kim Lawton reporting.
ABERNETHY: Next week, a look at how the Republicans are reaching out to people of faith.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Related R & E Material:
Read more of Kim Lawton's interviews with Professor Clyde Wilcox and Senator John Kerry.
Explore a roundup of past and current R & E campaign reports, election stories, interviews, commentary, surveys and resources on religion and politics.
|
 |
 |
 |
Related Reading:
THE POLITICS OF HUMAN FRAILTY: A THEOLOGICAL DEFENSE OF POLITICAL LIBERALISM by Christopher Insole
CHRISTIAN, EVANGELICAL & … DEMOCRAT? by George G. Hunter III
THE AUDACITY OF HOPE: RECLAIMING THE AMERICAN DREAM by Barack Obama
ONE ELECTORATE UNDER GOD: A DIALOGUE ON RELIGION AND AMERICAN POLITICS edited by E. J. Dionne et al.
WHAT'S GOD GOT TO DO WITH THE AMERICAN EXPERIMENT? edited by E.J. Dionne and John DiIulio
THE DIMINISHING DIVIDE: RELIGION'S CHANGING ROLE IN AMERICAN POLITICS by Andrew Kohut, John Green et al.
PUBLIC DIMENSIONS OF A BELIEVER'S LIFE by Monica Hellwig
RELIGION AS SOCIAL CAPITAL: PRODUCING THE COMMON GOOD edited by Corwin Smidt
JOINING HANDS: POLITICS AND RELIGION FOR SOCIAL CHANGE by Roger Gottlieb
POLITICS, RELIGION AND THE COMMON GOOD by Martin Marty
RELIGION AND POLITICS IN AMERICA: FAITH, CULTURE, AND STRATEGIC CHOICES by Robert Booth Fowler et al.
GOD IN PUBLIC: FOUR WAYS AMERICAN CHRISTIANITY AND PUBLIC LIFE RELATE by Mark Toulouse
Related Links:
Religion News Service: "With the help of a dozen, Democrats learn to get religion'" by Daniel Burke et al.
Catholic Media Report: "'Common good' unifies Dems for election" by Rachel Zoll, AP, October 17, 2006
Chattenooga Times Free Press: "Counting Christian voters" by Michael Davis, October 17, 2006
Philadelphia Inquirer: "Casey joins Democratic push to attract religious voters" by Thomas Fitzgerald, September 15, 2006
NPR: "Democrats seek middle ground on abortion" by Julie Rovner, September 15, 2006
"Restoring America's Moral Compass: Leadership and the Common Good": Speech by Robert Casey, Jr., September 14, 2006
Ethics Daily: "Why Democrats face a God problem; what they must do" by Robert Parham, September 8, 2006
Christian Science Monitor: "Religion in public life: Americans yearn for a middle way" by Jane Lampman, August 30, 2006
National Catholic Reporter: "Left seeks to revive 'common good' as new strategy" by Joe Feuerherd, August 25, 2006
|
 |
|

|

|

|
 |
Columbus Dispatch: "Religious liberals join forces for political comeback" by Catherine Dandisky and Alan Johnson, August 13, 2006
Christian Century: "Voters and values: The divided mind of the religious left" by David Heim, August 8, 2006
Boston Globe: "Pious and prochoice" by Rebecca Tuhus-Dubrow, July 30, 2006
Sen. Barack Obama: Call to Renewal Keynote Speech, June 28, 2006
Washington Post: "The new temptation of Democrats" by Ruth Marcus, May 23, 2006
Charlotte News & Observer: "Dems out to convert Bubba" by Rob Christensen, April 9 2006
Washington Post: "Public officials under God" by E.J. Dionne Jr., February 28, 2006
Democrats for Life Introduces the 95-10 Initiative, June 17, 2005
Boston Globe: "The God gap: How religion divides the Democrats" by Alan Wolfe, September 19, 2004
Faithful Democrats
CrossLeft
Institute for Progressive Christianity
Faith in Public Life
We Believe Ohio
The AMOS Project
|
 |
 |
 |
United Church of Christ: Our Faith Our Vote
Center for American Progress: Securing the Common Good
Center for American Progress: Faith and Public Policy
Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good
Common Good Strategies
Interfaith Alliance: "One Nation, Many Faiths: Vote 2006"
Human Rights Campaign: Out in Scripture
Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life: "Do Democrats Have a God Problem?" by Gregory Smith and Payton Craighill
Democratic National Committee: Faith in Action
Democratic Faith Working Group
U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops: Statements on Political Life
Sojourners
Network of Spiritual Progressives
Hip Hop Caucus
Progressive Democrats of America
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
|
|