|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
NEWS FEATURE:
Supreme Court Abortion Case Update
November 10, 2006 Episode no. 1011
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: This past Wednesday (November 8), the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in two of the most closely watched cases of the term, both involving the federal ban on what some call "partial-birth" abortion. Three lower courts have found the law unconstitutional, and this was the government's appeal. Tim O'Brien was at the Supreme Court.
TIM O'BRIEN: Abortion opponents held a vigil outside the Supreme Court Wednesday, while inside justices and lawyers grappled over whether Congress needed to make an exception to the federal ban when the health of the mother is at risk.

Father FRANK PAVONE (Priests for Life): Congress has made a determination, contrary to the claims of the other side, that there is no medical necessity for this procedure, and a big part of the argument was that deference should be given to the findings of the people's elected representatives.
O'BRIEN: But six years ago, in a challenge to a Nebraska state law brought by Dr. Leroy Carhart, the Supreme Court held that a health exception was required. Carhart is also one of the doctors challenging the federal ban and was at the Supreme Court Wednesday.
Dr. LEROY CARHART: It's a victory for women if we win, and it's a great loss to American women if we lose.
JAY SEKULOW (American Center for Law & Justice): At the end of the day, as the Solicitor General just said, this case is about the borderline between abortion and infanticide.
Dr. CARHART: At 16 weeks, at 18 weeks, there's no possibility of life for this fetus in any studies that have ever been performed in the United States, so I don't think "infanticide" is ever in play.
|
 |
 |
 |
O'BRIEN: Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose vote could be crucial, wanted to know if there is any quantifiable evidence on how often health is an issue. Carhart's lawyer conceded she didn't know of any, but insisted the procedure in question sometimes can prevent catastrophic complications.
PRISCILLA SMITH (Attorney): Ösuch as uterine perforation, which can result in hysterectomy, hemorrhage, sepsis, infections, and that all of these doctors testified that they perform these procedures for no other reason except for that they are safest for their patients.
O'BRIEN: Six years ago, when the Court invalidated the Nebraska law, the vote was 5-4, with Justice Sandra O'Connor, now retired, in the majority. Wednesday, her successor  Sam Alito was the only justice not to ask a single question. The Court still seems sharply split, probably again 5-4, but who will get the 5 votes? The single switch, Justice Sam Alito for the more moderate Sandra O'Connor, just might be enough to turn this Court around and uphold this controversial law.
For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Tim O'Brien at the Supreme Court.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Related R & E Material:
Supreme Court Abortion Case, November 3, 2006
Abortion Healing, May 12, 2006
U.S. Supreme Court and Abortion, November 25, 2005
Rove v. Wade 30th Anniversary, January 17, 2003
Anti-Abortion Cam, September 20, 2002
Late Term Abortion Debate, July 24, 1998
|
 |
 |
 |
Related Links:
Los Angeles Times: "Abortion foes energized by their losses" by Stephanie Simon, November 9, 20206
Washington Post: "Justices have pointed abortion discourse" by Mark Sherman, AP, November 8, 2006
NPR: "Supreme Court considers abortion-ban arguments" by Nina Totenberg, November 8, 2006
Chicago Sun-Times: "High Court weighs upholding partial birth abortion ban" by Mark Sherman, AP, November 8, 2006
Baptist Press News: "Supreme Court weighs federal ban on partial-brith abortion" by Tom Strode, November 8, 2006
Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life: "Judicial Showdown: The Supreme Court Returns to the Abortion Debate," November 2, 2006
Boston Globe: "Pious and prochoice" by Rebecca Tuhus-Dubrow, July 30, 2006
Catholics for a Free Choice: "Is there life after Roe? How to think about the fetus" by Frances Kissling in Conscience, Winter 2004-05
|
 |
|

|

|

|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
|
|