Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Prayer and Healing
September 12, 1997    Episode no. 102
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
BOB ABERNETHY: And now our Cover Story: prayer and healing. Medical researchers have long acknowledged that spirituality can heal. Now, increasingly, patients are asking their doctors to pray with them, and doctors are learning to practice what their patients preach. Our chief correspondent, Maureen Bunyan, reports.

Photo of praying Dr. IRIS KEYS (Coppin State Nursing Center) (Praying): ... asking you to send us what we need is to continue to heal her, Lord. We're just grateful today that the medication is working so all things can come together for those who love the Lord.

I guess I'm unique because of being a physician and a minister. A lot of us are believers, but it's just something we don't usually bring to work.

MAUREEN BUNYAN: But that seems to be changing as more and more patients are asking their doctors to join them in prayer, and doctors are responding. A recent poll shows that seven out of 10 family physicians believe that doctors should pray with their patients if they request it.

Dr. KEYS: I think it's always been there. I just think that doctors are coming out of the closet.

Photo of DALE MATTHEWS Dr. DALE MATTHEWS (Georgetown University Medical Center): In one sense it's a revolution, but in another sense, it really is an evolution because in the past 25 years we've begun to understand that patients are not just simply biological machines that we need to fix like we do our cars, but that there are also important psychological and social issues.

BUNYAN: Dale Matthews is one of those doctors who believes that prayer and spirituality can have a role in medical treatment.

Dr. MATTHEWS: (To patient): Hi, Joann.

JOANN: Hi, Dale, how are you doing today?

Dr. MATTHEWS: It goes without saying that we need to be very respectful of all patients' religious traditions. This is a medical business, and the purpose of talking about religion and spirituality as it affects health.

JOANN (To Doctor): ... Go to the quiet place and rest.

Dr. MATTHEWS (To Patient): Yes, that's very important. All of us need that rest and to be one with the Lord. We have research, from several hundred studies, actually, that shows that religious commitment is associated with beneficial health outcome. People who have a strong religious commitment live longer, and they're less likely to have medical illness, and they're more likely to recover from medical or surgical illness.

Photo of Matthews and patient praying (Praying): We don't want to do anything without your presence. We just pray that your presence will always be with her and through her and around her; and walk with her and continue to encourage her and her spirit be powerful and her heart. ...

In fact, we have data from two scientific studies that indicate that many patients, anywhere from a half to two thirds of patients, would actually like their doctor to pray with them. So if that's the case, we in the medical profession have to be responsive to that and figure out what we're going to do with this particular information.

BUNYAN: Dozens of U.S. medical schools are now teaching courses in spirituality and medicine, and research is being conducted at some of the most prestigious medical establishments to see just how the relationship between belief and health works.

Photo of Dr. Herbert Benson For over 30 years, Harvard's Dr. Herbert Benson has studied the physiological changes that occur during repeated meditation or prayer. In his best-selling book, THE RELAXATION RESPONSE, he shows that patients can successfully battle a number of stress-related ills by repeating a word, a sound, or a prayer.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
Dr. HERBERT BENSON (Harvard Mind/Body Medical Institute): So a person could use the number one, the word "peace," the word "love," or "The Lord is my shepherd," "Our Father who art in Heaven," "Shema Yisroel," "Insh'Allah" -- it didn't matter; carry out these basic steps and therefore these physiologic changes would occur.

In my experience, I found most people -- most of my patients, 80 percent, will choose a prayer. So I found myself teaching prayer.

BUNYAN: Dr. Benson, how do your personal religious views fit in with your work?

Photo of Dr. Herbert Benson Dr. BENSON: I really am not a religious person, but scientifically, the data proved that belief is good for you. Belief can keep you alive.

Unidentified Woman #2: I think if someone had said to me before I was sick, "Oh, I'll pray for you on something," I would have felt really uncomfortable about it. And now I'm in like every prayer circle across the country, you know, and I just go, "Thank you, I need it."

Dr. BENSON: In many, many disorders, upwards of 60 to 90 percent of symptoms can be relieved and actual physical changes in the body occur through belief.

Photo of JOHN LYNCH Dr. JOHN LYNCH (Chairman, Bio-Ethics Committee, Washington Hospital Center): How you measure that in a scientific way, to say that the patient with religion and the patient with spirituality did better, I find extremely difficult. And I think that there's so many variables in any given situation, to say whether this is spirituality or whether this is medicine.

Dr. MATTHEWS: Medicine and religion arose together. They're really the twin traditions of healing because the oldest symptom of any patient is "I'm in pain, I suffer." And medicine and religion arose together out of a common effort to address the cry of a suffering person.

BUNYAN: But not all doctors agree that prayer belongs in the physician's office.

Dr. LYNCH: That's why we have priests, rabbis, and ministers. I don't get into their job; they don't get into my job.

Dr. KEYS (To Patient): And you're all up to date on your blood pressure too.

BUNYAN: But there is a shift afoot as patients and more and more doctors see a connection between healing and faith.

Photo of IRIS KEYS Dr. KEYS: We're taught in medical school to do a patient history, but we don't take nearly enough time to discuss the patient's religious foundation. And the doubting Thomases, I think if they would just take that opportunity to get to know the patient in that area, they'll find out that it does make a difference.

(Praying): All the praise and all the glory ...

Woman #1: All the glory.

Photo of Keys and patient Dr. KEYS: ... that you and our Lord are worthy to be present.

Woman #1: Thank you. Thank you, Lord.

ABERNETHY: According to RELIGION NEWS SERVICE, at a recent meeting of the American Academy of Family Physicians, doctors were asked, "Can religious belief contribute to healing a patient?" Ninety-nine percent said "yes."

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP