|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
COVER STORY:
Anglican Primates Meeting
February 23, 2007 Episode no. 1026
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: After last week's meeting (February 13-19) of top Anglican leaders from around the world, U.S. Episcopalians face what amounts to an ultimatum: state clearly that they will not authorize any more blessings of same sex unions and no more consecrations of openly gay bishops, or they may be asked to leave the Communion.
One of the most prominent critics of the U.S. church for its actions regarding homosexuals is Archbishop Peter Akinola of Nigeria. He said this week if U.S. Episcopalians agree to the bans there will be a huge celebration. If they do not, "they will be told to walk away."
In the U.S. several officials have already said they prefer leaving the Communion. Meanwhile, the new Presiding Bishop of the U.S. Episcopal Church, Katharine Jefferts Schori, appealed for patience. She was in Tanzania and signed the communique. Also there was Kim Lawton of this program. Here is her report.
KIM LAWTON: It was a moment of history and controversy as U.S. Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori took her place among the highest ranking leaders of the worldwide Anglican Communion. The leading bishops worshipped together in public but in private debated intensely as they hammered out a new plan to try and cure what they called the "illness" of disunity that has jeopardized their church. In the end, no one left fully pleased.
Bishop KATHARINE JEFFERTS SCHORI (U.S. Episcopal Church): It was a challenging meeting. There was significant unhappiness with the Episcopal Church, and in some sense I think we are the identified patient in this issue.
LAWTON: American conservatives said the meeting did not ultimately solve any of the differences and may have made things worse.

Bishop ROBERT DUNCAN (Diocese of Pittsburgh): The division in Anglicanism has gone deeper. It's harder than it was when we started this meeting.
LAWTON: Relationships in the 77-million-member global Communion have been severely strained since 2003, when the Episcopal Church consecrated an openly gay bishop, Gene Robinson of New Hampshire, and permitted the blessing of same-sex unions. Leaders of more conservative Anglican churches in Africa, Asia and South America accused the Episcopal Church of violating Scripture and disregarding centuries of church teachings.
Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, spiritual leader of the Communion, appointed an emergency panel to study how schism could be avoided. In 2004, that commission called for an indefinite moratorium on actively gay bishops and same-sex blessings and urged the U.S. church to express regret for the pain its actions caused.
Delegates to the 2006 Episcopal General Convention passed resolutions designed to address those concerns. But Anglican leaders meeting here in Tanzania said the U.S. church still needs to do more work.

Archbishop ROWAN WILLIAMS (Archbishop of Canterbury, speaking at press conference): The response of the General Convention of the Episcopal Church to the recommendations of the Windsor Report -- the response made at General Convention last year -- represented some steps in a very encouraging direction but did not yet represent a situation where we could simply say business as usual.
LAWTON: The leaders' 11-page final communique wasn't released until shortly before midnight, with the intense debate extending hours beyond the scheduled ending time of the meeting.

The statement called on the U.S. Episcopal Church to unequivocally agree to follow the Communion's previous demands to ban same-sex unions and openly gay bishops. Failure to do that, the leaders said, would damage the future relationship between the Episcopal Church and the Communion.
While reconciliation efforts continue, the communique called for the appointment of a senior American bishop to provide pastoral oversight for conservatives who don't want to be under the authority of Bishop Jefferts Schori and the Episcopal Church. They hope this may stop the trend of conservative U.S. parishes affiliating with Anglican churches in places like Africa and South America.
And the leaders called for a ceasefire in legal battles over church property.
Archbishop WILLIAMS (speaking at Press Conference): None of us believe that litigation and counter-litigation can be a proper way forward for the Christian body. And we don't see that we can move towards sensible, balanced reconciliation while that remains a threat in wide use.
LAWTON: Anglicans, they said, have long sought unity amid their diversity.

Archbishop BERNARD NTAHOTURI (Anglican Church of Burundi): I have appreciated that diversity which is a gift from God, that though we may not have the same views, but still we have the same vision of serving the kingdom of God.
|
 |
 |
 |
LAWTON: In between their debates, the leaders took a two-hour ferry ride to the island of Zanzibar. There they worshiped at the historic Anglican cathedral which is built over a former slave market. The service marked 100 years since the last slave was sold on the site, and 200 years since slavery was outlawed in England, thanks in part to the efforts of Anglican Church members.
Tensions were evident here as well. A few archbishops chose not to take communion with Bishop Jefferts Schori because of what they see as her liberal theology.
Nonetheless, the bishop said she felt warmly received by her fellow leaders, called primates.

Bishop JEFFERTS SCHORI: I don't think it was any, you know, substantially different than any of the other new primates. There were 14 of us who were new to this gathering.
LAWTON: The emergence of new leadership from Africa, Asia and South America was evident throughout the meeting. Some of the largest and most vibrant Anglican churches are in these so-called Global South regions, which tend to be more theologically conservative. Their archbishops are increasingly clashing with the more liberal West.
Bishop DUNCAN: Here in Zanzibar, the service was partly a celebration of the end of the slave trade. The question they are asking is, isn't this northern dominance part of that slave trade? And how come this minority party, this very weak leadership in the West, this very weak church is dominating us when in fact we are the ones where clearly God is giving the blessing?
LAWTON: Bishop Duncan leads a conservative network which is forging close ties with the Global South churches. He says their fight is not just about homosexuality, but about defending classic Christianity.
Bishop DUNCAN: I see this as a battle for the faith in very, very vast terms. I've often spoken about a reformation that we're in the midst of, not just for Anglicanism but in fact for all of global Christianity, because at the heart of it Western Christianity has moved in a very new direction.
LAWTON: Meanwhile, gay advocacy groups see this as part of their larger cultural battle. They promise to continue pushing the Anglican Communion to reassess its stand.

Rev. SCOTT GUNN (Inclusive Church): The sooner the church is fully inclusive of gay and lesbian people, and bisexual and transgender people, and women, people of color and all people, the sooner we'll be living the Gospel fully.
LAWTON: The Episcopal Church is an autonomous church, and some American Episcopalians say they're getting tired of having to deal with international concerns. But others believe these conversations are positive.
Reverend ROSEMARI SULLIVAN (St. Paul's Church, Rock Creek): It presents an opportunity for us to say, what does it means to be an Anglican Communion? So we've really never answered that question.
LAWTON: Reverend Rosemari Sullivan was part of a special committee that studied the relationship between the Episcopal Church and the wider Communion. She says that relationship may not seem to affect the day-to-day life of parishioners, but it does have theological importance.
Rev. SULLIVAN: I understand something about God that maybe you don't. And you understand something about God that maybe I don't. And the conversation is what will bring the richness. And that's why the Communion is a precious vehicle.
LAWTON: Bishop Jefferts Schori signed onto the unanimous global communique. As she left for home, she said American Episcopal leaders will now consider their next steps.

Bishop JEFFERTS SCHORI: Nothing will change until the House of Bishops has had a chance to talk about this.
LAWTON: The American bishops meet again next month. The Anglican leaders emphasized the plan they worked out here is just an interim one while the Communion still seeks lasting reconciliation. There are already questions on all sides about how the details would get worked out. The answers will help determine whether the Communion ultimately hold does together.
I'm Kim Lawton north of Dar Es-Salaam, Tanzania.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Related R & E Material:
Visit R & E's archive of past stories on the Episcopal Church rift.
|
 |
 |
 |
Related Links:
Daily Telegraph: "Why the Anglican Communion matters" by Rowan Williams, February 23, 2007
Washington Post: "Some U.S. bishops reject Anglican gay rights edict" by Alan Cooperman, February 21, 2007
International Herald Tribune: "Anglicans give Episcopal Church an ultimatum" by Laurie Goodstein, February 21, 2007
Boston Herald: "Head of Episcopal Church asks for patience after Anglican demands to end support for gays," AP, February 21, 2007
Archbishop of Canterbury: Comments at final press conference in Tanzania, February 20, 2007
PBS: NewsHour with Jim Lehrer: "Anglican leaders demand U.S. church end gay unions," February 20, 2007
Christian Science Monitor: "After Anglican meeting, Episcopal Church on notice" by Jane Lampman, February 20, 2007
Episcopal News Service: "A Season of Fasting: Reflections on the Primates Meeting" by Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori, February 20, 2007
|
 |
|

|

|

|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
|
|