|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
COVER:
Mormonism
April 20, 2007 Episode no. 1034
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: Now a look at the most important beliefs of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints -- the Mormons -- the fourth largest church in the country after Catholics, Southern Baptists, and United Methodists. Many non-Mormons admire Mormon family values, but Mormon beliefs are controversial, and that may be a big problem for former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney, a prominent Mormon, in his campaign for the Republican nomination for president. Our special report today is from Bob Faw of NBC News.
BOB FAW: This is the image the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints projects to the world: the majestic choir; the humanitarian efforts the church underwrites; earnest missionaries devoting 18 months to two years of their lives spreading Mormonism around the world; five-and-a-half-million Mormons in the United States, many prosperous and upbeat, respected for their lifestyle and family values, Mormons who neither smoke nor drink and who give 10 percent of their earnings to the church.

Dr. DALLIN OAKS (LDS Quorum of the Twelve Apostles): We make good citizens. There must be something good at the root when it bears that kind of fruit.
FAW: But to many Americans, and the Church is the first to admit this, Mormonism is shrouded in mystery and ignorance.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #1: They get married and I think if the wife gets too old they get another one. I'm not sure (laughs).
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: I don't think they worship anybody as far as I know.
FAW: And to some evangelical Christians, the church is little more than a cult. Raised a Mormon, Sandra Tanner is now running a Salt Lake City bookstore which tries to debunk the faith.
SANDRA TANNER (Utah Lighthouse Ministry): You are talking about a very radical theology from standard Christianity. They're a heresy of Christianity.
FAW: Sentiments like that handicap presidential hopeful Governor Mitt Romney, a devout Mormon and leader in his church. In one poll, 35 percent of voters say they do not want a Mormon in the White House.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN # 2: Their belief system is based on things that I do not hold as true.
FAW: Their fear, although Romney denies this could happen, is that if a Mormon becomes president the country's needs would not come first. Dr. Phil Roberts, president of the Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary:

Dr. ROBERTS (Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary): Mitt Romney is a temple-worthy Mormon, and one of the conditions for being temple-worthy is that you have to swear allegiance to the Mormon president whom they believe can receive from God direct revelation. So Mitt Romney in a very real sense has an allegiance to a personality, and a person that in most religious circles is unprecedented.
FAW: So who's right? For starters, some Mormon beliefs do differ from traditional Christianity. Listen to the church's spiritual leader on the Nicene Creed:

President GORDON HINCKLEY (Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, speaking to audience): Its basic elements are recited by most of the Christian faithful. Personally, I cannot understand it. To me the creed is confusing.
FAW: Other doctrines set them apart. Mormons believe Jesus returned to Earth and appeared to ancient Americans; that the Garden of Eden was in Missouri; that God was man and that men can be gods. Founder Joseph Smith said theirs is "the only true church" -- that all others were an "abomination." Dr. Dallin Oaks is one of the churches 12 Apostles.
Dr. OAKS: People say, "Where are you in relation to traditional Christianity?" I think our answer to that is we are traditional Christianity, because it is our message to the world that traditional Christianity had fallen away from the basic teachings of Jesus Christ, and it was necessary to have a restoration of the fullness of Christian doctrine and the original organization of the church with 12 apostles as Jesus established it.
SANDRA TANNER: Mormonism claims to be the only true church, not just a better church, not just another church. They claim to be the only true church and that in order to be right with God and go to the highest level of heaven you have to be Mormon, and for the Christian world that's, you know, fighting words.
FAW: Mormons have three books of Scripture other than the Bible - The Book of Mormon, which Joseph Smith said he translated from golden tablets revealed to him by God and the Angel Moroni. But it is in the books, Doctrine and Covenants, which contains the teachings of polygamy, and the Pearl of Great Price that includes the unique and, to some, non-Christian elements of the faith.
Dr. OAKS: We are different. That's the reason for our existence. The two main differences that separate us from other Christian faiths [are] some of the content of our doctrine and our belief in continuing revelation. Everything else follows from those two.
FAW: Dr. Dallin Oaks, a renowned legal scholar and former president of Brigham Young University, says Mormonism is part of mainstream Christianity. The primary difference, he says, is the Mormon concept of revelation and the Trinity.

Dr. OAKS: We believe in continuing revelation to guide us in the way we practice our faith, and we believe that God the Father and his son Jesus Christ and the Holy Ghost are separate and distinct individuals, and that causes us to look on our relationship with God and the mission of the Lord Jesus Christ in importantly different ways than other Christians.
FAW: Critics point out some of those differences.
|
 |
 |
 |
Dr. PHIL ROBERTS: Their doctrine of salvation is dependent upon the Mormon Church. It's not, as we would say, by faith alone, grace alone and Christ alone. Rather, it is due to your obedience and adherence to the Mormon Church. They baptize the dead for their salvation. They marry one another for time and eternity.
FAW: And critics say that there's little historical documentation for the church's teachings. For example, those golden tablets Joseph Smith said he translated as the word of God have never been found.

Dr. ROBERTS: There is absolutely no historical data. Nobody has ever found a manuscript of reformed Egyptian, which is what Joseph Smith said the Book of Mormon was written in. Nobody has ever found a part of the Book of Mormon like you might the Dead Sea Scrolls for the Bible.
FAW: For Mormons, that lack of documentation simply doesn't matter.
Dr. OAKS: I don't have to have proof, especially on those things that do not affect my faith and my behavior today. Where the Garden of Eden was located is an important but incidental doctrinal matter. The absence of empirical evidence that Jesus visited the Americas doesn't say that he didn't do it.
FAW: Mormon women are barred from being priests, and it wasn't until 1978, through divine revelation, that black males could join the LDS priesthood.
Dr. OAKS: The Lord revealed through his prophets that people of African ancestry would not have the right to the priesthood for a time. And then in 1978 revelation was received that they should have every blessing available to every other person. So now there's no distinction among men in who has the right to the priesthood. There is a distinction between men and women in that respect, and we don't know the reason why God has allocated responsibilities in that way. But we're loyal to it and have a witness that that's the will of God.
FAW: Like other critics, Sandra Tanner ridicules the church's belief that God's will is revealed to leaders or prophets of the church.

Ms. TANNER: Blacks couldn't hold the priesthood, and that was a theological position. But now it's been reversed, so how do you ever know when the guy's talking for God if there's no standard that he has to meet? He can just change it from one day to the next.
FAW: Polygamy was a revelation to Joseph Smith. He reportedly had at least 30 wives. Brigham Young had 50. It was a revelation by a church prophet many years later that banned it following intense pressure from the government which said no statehood for Utah unless Mormons stop polygamy. It has been estimated that polygamy is still practiced by 30, 000 people who call themselves Mormons.
Dr. OAKS: Those people are not Mormons. The media calls them fundamentalist Mormons, but they are not members of our church. Our church has not sanctioned this kind of practice for 115 years.
FAW: The church is also attacked because some of its rituals are secret and, say critics, bizarre.
Dr. ROBERTS: They're given the secret names. They're given simple undergarments to wear. They're given codes and watchwords whereby they will enter the celestial kingdom. That kind of secretive, magical practice we might say is totally foreign to any form of Christianity that I know anything about.
JIM MCCONKIE (singing with wife Judith and their children): "I am a child of God."
FAW: For some evangelical voters, strong moral values and family ties among Mormons trump any concerns about their doctrine. Jim and Judith McConkie of Sandy, Utah, have three grown children, eight grandchildren. For them the role of the family is paramount. Often they come together to study and discuss the Scriptures.
Mr. MCCONKIE: What binds us together is this yearning to understand and to draw ourselves closer to deity and to apply these ideals in our own life -- the Christ ideals.
JUDITH MCCONKIE (reading): "But I say unto you, love your enemies."
Mr. MCCONKIE: I think the evangelicals have engendered a suspicion about Mormonism. They sincerely believe we're wrong, just as we sincerely believe they're wrong.
FAW: Judith McConkie is optimistic a Mitt Romney candidacy for president will be a good thing for her church.
Ms. MCCONKIE: There is the opportunity for people to see that it is not a monolithic church, that it's okay, that people are reasonable and happy and not nuts.
FAW: So on this faith feelings are mixed: derision, even ridicule from critics; passion, indeed reverence, from believers. And neither side is likely to change.
For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, this is Bob Faw in Salt Lake City.
ABERNETHY: A four-hour special on the Mormons will be airing on most PBS stations beginning April 30.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Related R & E Material:
Read an advance excerpt from PEOPLE OF PARADOX: A HISTORY OF MORMON CULTURE by Terryl L. Givens.
African-American Mormons, March 31, 2006
Mormons and the 2002 Winter Olympics, January 25, 2002
God's Army: Mormon Missionaries, March 23, 2001
The Mormon Church, April 7, 2000
|
 |
 |
 |
Related Links:
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
PBS: The Mormons
On the Media: "Our Latter-Days," April 13, 2007
The Politico: "Mormons heighten public relations efforts" by Andrew Glass, April 9, 2007
Washington Post: "Mormon base a mixed blessing for Romney" by Alex MacGillis, April 4, 2007
WBUR: Here & Now: "Romney's Faith," March 1, 2007
Saint Anselm College: "Taking the religious test: The case of Mitt Romney" by Damon Linker, February 28, 2007
Deseret News: "Romney, a Mormon, tries to find way around issue of religion" by Adam Nagourney and Laurie Goodstein, February 8, 2007 (New York Times)
Boston Globe: "Romney defends Mormon strategy" by Michael Levenson and Scott Helman, October 20, 2006
Weekly Standard: "In 2008 will it be Mormon in America?" by Terry Eastland, June 6, 2005
|
 |
|

|

|

|
 |
Related Reading:
MORMON AMERICA: THE POWER AND THE PROMISE by Richard and Joan Ostling
JOSEPH SMITH by Robert Remini
BELIEVING HISTORY: LATTER-DAY SAINT ESSAYS by Richard Lyman Bushman
BY THE HAND OF MORMON: THE AMERICAN SCRIPTURE THAT LAUNCHED A NEW WORLD RELIGION by Terryl Givens
THE LATTER-DAY SAINT EXPERIENCE IN AMERICA by Terryl Givens
MORMONISM: THE STORY OF A NEW RELIGIOUS TRADITION by Jan Shipps
SOJOURNER IN THE PROMISED LAND: FORTY YEARS AMONG THE MORMONS by Jan Shipps
ALL ABRAHAM'S CHILDREN: CHANGING MORMON CONCEPTIONS OF RACE AND LINEAGE by Armand Mauss
THE RISE OF MORMONISM by Rodney Stark
HOW WIDE THE DIVIDE? A MORMON AND AN EVANGELICAL IN CONVERSATION by Craig Blomberg and Stephen Robinson
THE NEW MORMON CHALLENGE editd by Francis J. Beckwith et al.
|
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
|
|