|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
FEATURE:
San Francisco's Homeless
February 19, 1999 Episode no. 225
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
BOB ABERNETHY: The issue of what to do about the homeless is back in the public eye, as cities around the country have begun cracking down on them. The poor, the mentally unstable, and the drug addicted are often lumped together as a public nuisance, not always deserving of charity, it's thought, even in cities considered havens for the homeless. Critics of the crackdown call it criminalizing homelessness, and argue that society has a moral obligation to care for the afflicted.
From San Francisco, Barbara Rodgers reports.
BARBARA RODGERS: In cities around the country, the number of homeless appears to be rising, despite a booming economy. But as the numbers climb higher, compassion seems to be running low, even in a city like San Francisco, known for its liberal attitudes.
Ms. CANDACE LOW: It's about empathy, and I think the more economically comfortable you become, the less you can understand people being on the streets.
RODGERS: Public impatience with panhandlers, addicts, and littered streets has led to a get-tough policy.

Reverend AMOS BROWN (City Supervisor): We're concerned about a safe, clean, orderly city.
RODGERS: City Supervisor Amos Brown is also a Baptist minister, whose church runs a weekly soup kitchen. The time has come, he says, to balance compassion with public responsibility.

Rev. BROWN: There's a difference between being homeless and being a street dweller. A street dweller hangs out on the streets and feels that he or she can engage in any conduct, at any time, at any place, even though that conduct may impact on the quality of life for others.
RODGERS: It's not just San Francisco that seems to be pulling in the welcome mat for the homeless. In at least 50 cities across the country, there are now laws on the books designed to keep people from living on the streets.
|
 |
 |
 |
Unidentified Man #1: Gettin' tickets, gettin' harassed, having our stuff thrown away.
Unidentified Man #2: Anyplace to sleep, they post signs, "No Trespassing." And therefore, that gives them the right to, you know, take you to jail if they want. And it's getting harder. It really is.
RODGERS: Homeless advocates have been protesting the recent police sweeps of public parks. They say the policy amounts to punishing people simply for being homeless.
Mr. PAUL BODEN (Coalition on Homelessness): Let people sleep in the parks until we have a viable alternative to offer them, and sure as hell don't criminalize them for doing it.
Unidentified Woman: We call all the way to City Hall behind us.
RODGERS: This week, a group of religious leaders began a fast in front of San Francisco City Hall to protest the city's crackdown on street dwellers.
Reverend LOUIS VITALE: We will truly suffer with the homeless, who have no choice but to do without.
RODGERS: Father Louis Vitale, whose church runs a homeless shelter, believes Americans have misplaced priorities.

Rev. VITALE: Our priority is really around living grandly, living materially. We're not willing to even look and see that people are not making it on the other end. And we have a moral responsibility to give them their fair share of the resources. Then they can make it.
RODGERS: But the notion that public policy should be guided by moral responsibility towards the homeless is not as popular today as it was in the '80s. In this age of welfare reform, the public is less inclined to spend money on a problem that just hasn't gone away. I'm Barbara Rodgers in San Francisco.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
|
|