Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

FEATURE:
Teaching Evolution in the Public Schools
July 28, 2000    Episode no. 348
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
BOB ABERNETHY: As the presidential election season gets into full swing this coming week with the Republican National Convention in Philadelphia, several church-state issues are in the news. The Christian Coalition won a round this week in its ongoing battle with the Internal Revenue Service over the proper boundaries between religion and politics. A federal judge ordered the IRS to refund $169.29 in taxes paid by the coalition in 1990. At issue was whether the coalition qualified for religious tax-exempt status. Last year, the IRS ruled that some coalition projects were partisan politicking and, therefore, not tax exempt.

Another church-state issue -- an old, familiar one -- has resurfaced in politics in Kansas, where campaigns for next Tuesday's primary elections reflect that state's new argument over teaching evolution in the schools. Should it be evolution alone or evolution and creationism? Who should decide? Our reporter is Judy Valente.

Photo of candidate and voters JUDY VALENTE: The normally obscure race for state board of education is getting the most attention here in Kansas and around the country.

Unidentified Woman: All in favor of the amendment, raise your hand please.

VALENTE: The reason? In a controversial vote last year, the state board decided to deemphasize the theory of evolution, allowing local school districts to make the teaching of evolution optional and opening the door to the teaching of creation theories.

Photo of LINDA HOLLOWAY Ms. LINDA HOLLOWAY (Republican Incumbent): We didn't ban the teaching of evolution. We've never -- that was never the intent of anybody, nor is it true today. Evolution was being presented as a fact, and we wanted children to have the opportunity to investigate.

VALENTE: Linda Holloway was president of the board at the time of the vote and is now in a tight race for reelection. She is a publicly avowed conservative Christian. Her church displays her campaign signs. Evangelical Christian churches are expected to play a pivotal role in the primary. Many observers see the vote as a referendum on the strength of conservative Christians to promote a political agenda. The election has given rise to challengers, all eager to show their own religious credentials, running as pro-evolution candidates. Ron Patton, a Presbyterian minister, is among them.

Mr. RON PATTON (Democratic Candidate): Kansas education has been thrust back at least a century by the decision [of] the state board of education regarding creation stories being -- faith-based stories being equivalent with science-based theory.

Photo of SUE GAMBLE Ms. SUE GAMBLE (Republican Candidate): Our kids need a good, strong basic education, and that basic education includes evolution and the geologic time line and the age of the Earth and the age of the universe and the Big Bang theory. It includes all of that.

VALENTE: The issue goes far beyond Kansas. It gets to the fundamental questions of how the world began, what was the origin of life, and how should the schools handle the question of God. Nearly all scientists and science textbooks affirm Charles Darwin's theory of evolution. They say the evidence is overwhelming that higher forms of life evolved from lower forms over billions of years through a series of natural changes.

Professor MARY ASHLEY (Professor of Biological Sciences, University of Illinois): To ask me what the evidence for evolution is is analogous to asking an electrical engineer what the evidence for electricity is. To me, the evidence for evolution is just overwhelming and comes from all areas of biology and geology. We have -- from paleontology, we have the fossil record that shows a progression of life forms through time. That's indisputable.

Photo of The Creation of Adam by Michelangelo VALENTE: Creationists recognize the role of a supreme being. Some of them take the creation story in Genesis literally. They believe the Earth is only several thousand years old and that God created life in the forms it has now. Other creationists accept evolution, but insist God set the process in motion and that it has continued over time, as God intended. Still others believe that nature and human beings are far too complex to be the result of random events in the natural world. Evolution, they say, doesn't explain human creativity or consciousness. They argue the universe is the work of an intelligent agent, the theory of intelligent design.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
Mr. GREG QUIGGLE (Moody Bible Institute): You pull any creator out of the factor, that makes human beings merely part of [the] material realm; you become materialistic so that all we are are collections of DNA, energy, matter, etc., etc., etc.

VALENTE: Public sentiment is so intense that Kansas City Public Television recently produced a dramatic reading from the famous Scopes Monkey Trial. The current debate echoes the arguments made in the Scopes trial, held 75 years ago this month in Tennessee.

Mr. JAMES CROMWELL ("Charles Darwin"): What we find today is a brazen and bold attempt to destroy learning as was ever made in the Middle Ages. The only difference is we have not provided that they should be burned at the stake.

Photo of ED ASNER Mr. ED ASNER ("William Jennings Bryan"): For these parents have a right to say that no teacher paid by their money to rob their children of faith in God and send them back to their houses skeptical infidels or agnostics or atheists.

VALENTE: Though John Scopes was ultimately convicted of violating state law, the teaching of evolution has become a standard part of science classes, to the exclusion of other creation theories. These Kansas educators, attending a forum on the intelligent design theory, say they don't want to be locked into the teaching of evolution alone.

Mr. ROGER DeHART (Science Teacher): I wish my school board members would realize that what I'm trying to do is promote an openness, an open dialogue.

VALENTE: It is unclear whether any Kansas school districts are now teaching creation theory to the exclusion of evolution.

Photo of KEN BINGMAN Mr. KEN BINGMAN (Biology Teacher): Some of the newer teachers are a little more reticent to teach evolution and to bring up the topic because of all the controversy.

VALENTE: The evolution debate has even spilled over into the Kansas congressional race, where candidate Greg Musil has made it the leading issue in the Republican primary.

(Excerpt from political advertisement)

Photo of political advertisement Unidentified Announcer: Have you read what they're saying about Kansas? "They're ignorant country bumpkins." "It's really Oz." "The Kansas school board's evolution decision reeked of absurdity and ignorance and was a national embarrassment."

Mr. GREG MUSIL (GOP Congressional Candidate): I'm Greg Musil, Republican for Congress.

VALENTE: Musil claims the board's decision has blackened Kansas's reputation for high academic standards.

Mr. MUSIL: Kansas always had trouble recruiting companies to Kansas. We're not the first choice of people. Now we have another problem.

Photo of CAROLINA McKNIGHT Ms. CAROLINA McKNIGHT (Mainstream Coalition): I'm saddened -- I'm truly saddened by the fact that this has come to our state. I don't think we'll ever recover. I don't think the state will ever recover from the bad publicity that we've received. Kansas has been known always as a place where we had strong and progressive public education for our children. And this has cast a pall on that.

VALENTE: The outcome of the election is hard to predict, but a wide range of groups from around the country will be watching the vote. For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, this is Judy Valente reporting.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP