Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

FEATURE:
Miracles
December 22, 2000    Episode no. 417
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
BOB ABERNETHY (anchor): For many religious believers, this is considered the season of miracles. Christians celebrate the miraculous birth of Jesus; Jews have been celebrating Hanukkah, when an oil lamp miraculously burned in the temple for eight days; Muslims have been observing Ramadan and the miraculous revelation of the Koran. Miracle stories are central to all the world's religions.

In our cover story this week, Kim Lawton reports on the search for modern-day miracles.

Miracle booksKIM LAWTON: Some do their seeking at a little adobe church in the mountains of New Mexico, where the dirt is said to have healing properties. Others come to a Jewish cemetery in New York City, to petition for a beloved rebbe's intercession with God. There are dozens of new books ... magazine articles ... a PAX TV series ... even Internet sites. The search for the miraculous, it seems, is everywhere.

PROFESSOR TERRY NICHOLS (St. Thomas University): People want miracles. People need to believe and want to believe that God is capable of acting in their life. And miracles are such signs.

LAWTON: According to a recent NEWSWEEK poll, 84% of Americans believe God still performs miracles today. Nearly half, 48%, believe they personally have experienced or witnessed a miracle.

One of them is novelist Ann Hood, who has just written a book about her personal search for a miracle.

ANN HOOD (Author, DO NOT GO GENTLE): My dad, who I was very close to, was diagnosed with inoperable lung cancer, and the prognosis was grim. And as we sat around our kitchen table one day, sort of absorbing that information, I just announced, without much forethought, "I'm going to get a miracle cure. There's a place in New Mexico, where they say the dirt has healing powers. And I'm going to go there."

Miracle dirtLAWTON: Chimayo [New Mexico] has been considered a sacred place for centuries, first by Native Americans, then by Spanish-speaking Christians, who came later. Today, tens of thousands of pilgrims still come here every year to pray for a miracle.

Like Ann Hood, they come to take dirt from a room adjacent to the chapel. Some pray over the dirt, others rub it on places they want to be healed. Many fill a small bag to take home. The area outside is covered with crutches, photos, and other mementos from people who say they were healed.

FATHER ROCA: I've been here 45 years, and I've seen hundreds of cases.

LAWTON: Ann Hood prayed that her father's lung tumor would disappear, and she brought back a bag of holy dirt for him. Twenty-four hours later, he went into the hospital.

Ann HoodMS. HOOD: A CAT scan they performed while he was there, they were certain that it would show that the tumor had indeed grown, and, in fact, it had disappeared.

LAWTON: It was gone?

MS. HOOD: Completely gone. Even with chemotherapy and radiation, they had hoped to shrink it by 20 to 30%, but this was 100% gone. The doctor, when he walked in, said the words we had been hoping for, "It's a miracle."

LAWTON: But the family's elation was short-lived. Doctors insisted Ann's father still go through chemotherapy, just in case. Weakened by the chemo, he contracted an infection and died, cancer-free.

Grief-stricken and her faith shaken, Ann set off on a series of journeys to places in Latin America and Europe, where people of many traditions say the miraculous happens.

Miracle stories are foundational to all of the world's great religions. In Judaism, the Red Sea is parted to free the Hebrew slaves. In Christianity, Jesus, God in human form, is born to a virgin and grows to perform numerous miracles. Hinduism's estimated three million local deities perform miraculous deeds.

The Buddha worked [through] many signs and wonders. And Muslims believe the Koran itself is miraculous.

In all the traditions, miracles help convey key theological understandings.

Ken WoodwardKEN WOODWARD (Author, BOOK OF MIRACLES): Miracles are little stories inside larger stories. The larger story is what you think reality is all about. The miracle stories really show you that to move from one religion, say from Hinduism to Judaism to Buddhism to Christianity, or vice versa, is to move, really, into different conceptual worlds.

Jews at cemeteryLAWTON: There are those in every tradition who believe miracles still happen. While the NEWSWEEK poll found that American Jews are the least likely to believe in modern miracles, the tradition is still strong among Hassidic Jews. Members of [the] Chabad Lubavitch community believe their late Rebbe, Menachem Schneerson, intercedes with God. People bring their petitions to his grave site in Queens. If they can't make it in person, they fax or call Rabbi Abba Refson, who takes down requests on his palm computer.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
RABBI ABBA REFSON: People do believe that there are miracles. They believe that, they see that their Rebbe has interceded on their behalf. I hear of quite a few miracles every single day that happen to different people. So, I can tell you that miracles do happen daily.

LAWTON: For the Roman Catholic Church, contemporary miracles -- at least those officially recognized -- are most important in the sainthood process. The Church conducts a complicated investigation in order to authenticate the two miracles required for canonization.

While some lay Catholics may see the miraculous in an image of Jesus on a tortilla or a subway water stain, the church itself authenticates few miracles.

Terry NicholsPROFESSOR NICHOLS: Most of the things you read about in the press are not going to be ever certified as miracles by the Catholic Church. They are going to be very guarded in their judgments. It's extremely difficult to get something certified. It normally takes a very, very long period of time.

LAWTON: Among Protestants, the belief in modern-day miracles appears to be strongest among Pentecostal and Charismatic Christians.

Members of the Bread of Life Church in Houston say they captured a miracle on amateur video. In July, Pastor David George appeared at church for the first time since an auto accident in which he suffered a severe brain injury. He had significant memory loss, and doctors said he might not recover. During the service, George appeared to get stronger and to regain his memory. Two days later, doctors pronounced him fully recovered and described his case as "unusual."

Much of the new miracle interest is coming from outside religious traditions. Many of those in the New Age movement, for example, look for miracles, but are reluctant to interpret them within the framework of an organized religion.

Ken Woodward, author of THE BOOK OF MIRACLES, says, this represents a disturbing trend in American spirituality.

WOODWARD: We want a God who is going to hug us like Mommy did. We don't want a demanding God. Therefore, our miracles don't demand anything. After all, miracles are cheap. They just happen. They don't demand anything of us. Going back to the traditions will allow us to see and see through an awful lot of the miracle mongering that we find today.

LAWTON: Skeptics have long doubted the veracity of miracle reports, but some theologians are also uncomfortable.

George W. Bush.REVEREND PHILIP HEFNER (Lutheran School of Theology): I think it is dangerous if you set up expectations in people's heart[s] and mind[s] that aren't very healthy. Tell a person if they pray, God will perform a miracle. They pray, God doesn't perform the miracle, their loved one dies of cancer anyway. That actually has a pathological effect on a person, or it could.

LAWTON: Reverend Philip Hefner directs the Lutheran School of Theology's Zygon Center for Religion and Science. He's calling for a moratorium on miracle-talk.

REVEREND HEFNER: There are a lot of things in this world that I don't understand. And it doesn't help just to paper over some concept, some term, [as a] "miracle," and paste it over and pretend that explains anything. The use of the word miracle often explains far too little.

LAWTON: Language may indeed be part of the problem. Religions don't have a neat and uniform definition of what constitutes a miracle. Some prefer to take a broad approach.

MASHI LIPSKAR (Chabad Lubavitch): The seasons; the sunset; the laughter of a child. These are incredible things. Where was that child, that two-year-old. Where was he three years ago. Is that not a miracle? And if we, if we have that sort of warming and illuminating [in] our daily lives, we're joyous. And it's there. It's all around us.

LAWTON: Others say that clouds the notion of the miraculous.

WOODWARD: When everything is a miracle, nothing is a miracle.

LAWTON: Despite the complexities, Americans still yearn for that which is not easily defined or easily explained.

MS. HOOD: I think we need it more than ever now. It seems we have everything figured out. We have technology. We move at a very quick pace. Science has made huge leaps, and I think that there's kind of a backlash to all of that. We want to go back to a time when reflection was important, and there were things that weren't explained. And that's the root of faith.

LAWTON: Ann Hood says, ultimately, her search led to a lasting miracle, the rediscovery of her faith.

MS. HOOD: I can't say it's the faith I was raised with, or even the faith that sent me to Chimayo that day, but it was a new faith, a renewed faith, and I'm happy to have it again.

LAWTON: I'm Kim Lawton in Chimayo, New Mexico.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP