Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

FEATURE:
The "Left Behind" Phenomenon
February 2, 2001    Episode no. 423
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
Apocalypse: Next Right
by Gershom Gorenberg

"O Lucifer, son of the morning! I have worshipped you since childhood," whispers Nicolae Carpathia, the man who has turned the U.N. into a one-world government and brought global disarmament. Carpathia is alone in his office in New Babylon, his capital, after a meeting in which he plotted yet another murder. Now he's praying to the Devil -- not knowing that one of his heroic born-again Christian opponents has bugged his room and is listening. "I shall do all your bidding ..." the world dictator promises the Evil One.

Gershom Gorenberg That strange scene comes midway in THE ASSASSINS -- Book Number 6 of Tim LaHaye's and Jerry Jenkins's wildly successful LEFT BEHIND thrillers about the Last Days. Carpathia, a.k.a the Antichrist, is the serialized saga's villain, ruling the earth during history's final years. But he can't prevent the horrors predicted in the Book of Revelation -- war, plague, catastrophic earthquakes. And, readers know, Carpathia will be defeated at the end of the world as we know it, when Jesus returns. That finale is planned for Book 12 of the series. Book 8, THE MARK, was released recently and leapt to the top of bestseller lists; LEFT BEHIND: THE MOVIE brings the popular series to the screen.

Viewed from mainstream culture, all this sounds wacky. Popular opinion assigns belief in imminent apocalypse to offbeat sects and men on street corners with signs saying "The End is Nigh." When I tell friends and journalistic colleagues that I track apocalyptic believers, they assume I'm writing about "crazies."

LEFT BEHIND's immense popularity, however, demands a reappraisal of apocalyptic belief. Millions of Americans have been reading books that portray the end of the world as something that could happen today. Fascination with the End didn't evaporate on January 1, 2000; it is increasing. And crucially, the theology promoted in the LEFT BEHIND books is joined seamlessly with the political vision of the far right. Along with the catechism of apocalypse, the thrillers' readers gain instruction in conspiracy theory, demonization of political opponents, even divine sanction for assassination. The books' anti-Jewish message is exceeded only by their anti-Catholic venom. Expecting the apocalypse today may not be realistic -- but the expectation itself could have a very real impact on society and politics.

LEFT BEHIND, the novel that gave the series its name, appeared in 1995. Jenkins did the writing; LaHaye provided the framework of ideas. That's reason enough for the series to deserve more public attention. For in America's culture wars, the Rev. Timothy LaHaye has served as a general, a lesser-known comrade-in-arms to Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson. He headed the mid-'80s American Coalition for Traditional Values, an umbrella group dedicated to boosting the voting clout of the religious right. In 1987, he served briefly as co-chairman of conservative Republican Jack Kemp's presidential campaign -- resigning after THE BALTIMORE SUN reported that he had called Catholicism "a false religion" and had written that Jews' rejection of God was responsible for Jerusalem's troubles throughout history. He's still a member of the arch-conservative Council for National Policy.

That political resume is strikingly missing from LaHaye's bio in his end-of-the-world novels, but I'd venture that they are his most successful efforts yet to promote his views. As of March 2000, the first six novels in the series had sold a total of 11 million copies. By January 2001, two more books had appeared -- and total sales had climbed to 25 million. These numbers are readouts from a cultural weather station, revealing a storm front of apocalyptic hopes across much of America.

LaHaye's and Jenkins's novels flesh out the theology known as dispensational premillennialism, a set of ideas that exerts wide influence among evangelical Christians. And Evangelicals, surveys consistently show, make up 20 to 25% of the American population. What's more, notes Professor Brenda Brasher, an expert on fundamentalism, the average age of Evangelicals is significantly lower than that of mainstream Protestants -- meaning that "in another generation, these people will be American Protestantism." Fervent belief in the End is restricted to the Bible Belt only if you stretch that belt wide enough to include Michigan, Oregon, and southern California.

Nor is such belief the preserve of the uneducated. Indeed, in my research, I've found that apocalyptic faith often has a particular appeal to those with scientific or technological training. The Web site of a physicist I interviewed presents his research alongside essays on the End. Chuck Missler, a prominent promoter of apocalyptic prophecies, is a former high-tech executive. Dispensationalism, it seems, allows such people to read Scripture as the instruction manual for the final, fantastic upgrade of the universe: Here's how history will reach its climax, sinners will be punished, and Jesus will return. That affinity may explain the technophilia of LEFT BEHIND's heroes, who are nearly as fascinated by laptops, exec jets, and bugging devices as they are by the Book of Revelation.

The LEFT BEHIND books took off because expectations of the End were already rife. Passed from friend to office mate to neighbor, the novels have further spread anticipation of apocalypse. This isn't new -- non-fiction works fitting current events into biblical prophecies of the End have long enjoyed popularity, though the tabulation methods of bestseller lists often leave them underrepresented. In 1996, for instance, the major hit for Christian booksellers was Texas preacher John Hagee's BEGINNING OF THE END: THE ASSASSINATION OF YITZHAK RABIN AND THE COMING ANTICHRIST. And in spreading the message, books almost certainly take second place to cassette sermons, cheaply produced and vastly distributed.

The advantage of fiction, notes Brasher, is that it's hard to argue with. Rather than presenting logic, it creates a mood. The LEFT BEHIND books, she says, have succeeded in reaching beyond the evangelical audience; members of mainstream denominations are reading them, and being frightened by their vision.

The books are meant not as fantasy but realism, intended to show readers just what apocalypse will look like if it begins this moment. In the series' first pages, dozens of passengers on a transatlantic airliner vanish in the same instant, leaving their clothes on the seats. Worldwide, we learn, millions are gone. Driverless cars crash; fetuses vanish from wombs. The survivors are clueless. But readers from the self-defined "Bible-believing" audience understand: As predicted by dispensationalist doctrine, God has physically removed true born-again Christians and innocent babes from the earth. Everyone else, left behind, will have to suffer through the seven apocalyptic years known as the Tribulation. The books' heroes are those who belatedly accept Jesus, spread the Word, and battle the Antichrist. Since the Last Days are set in our day, the protagonists drive all-options Land Rovers and live in the burbs, where they build underground survival shelters to protect themselves against the coming evil.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
In LaHaye's and Jenkins's depiction, the Tribulation backs up all the present fears of the far right. In the first of the thrillers, a source in London's City tells a journalist that a cabal of international financiers controls global economic developments. The reporter voices a reasonable person's dismissal of dark conspiracies -- until the source is murdered, followed by the detective who investigates the killing. And then the conspirators, aiming to create a single world currency, pull strings to have a 33-year-old Romanian named Nicolae Carpathia appointed U.N. secretary general.

Watch the logic: Doubters of conspiracy theory have been proven wrong. And if the Last Days could begin any day now, LEFT BEHIND readers must deduce that the cabal of bankers already exists, and is already pulling the strings in world affairs. The conspiracy is demonic, for it will crown the Antichrist -- using the United Nations as its tool. Good Christians are presumably requested to read their newspapers in that light, and to regard economic unions and shared currencies as evidence of the cabal's efforts to subjugate once-free countries.

Prisoner StudyingBy book two of the series, TRIBULATION FORCE, Carpathia is transforming himself into world dictator. "I want peace. I want global disarmament. I want the peoples of the world to live as one," he declares. Obediently, nations destroy most of their weapons, and give the rest to the U.N., renamed the Global Community. By implication, every form of international cooperation, from arms control to U.N. peacekeeping forces, foreshadows the Antichrist's evil.

But disarmament has its foes: the American militia movement. In TRIBULATION FORCE, the militias gather heavy weaponry, then launch a rebellion against the Antichrist. They are tragic heroes whose defeat is foreknown, but at least they go down fighting. The paramilitary "patriots" of the radical right couldn't ask for better PR.

In the series, the Antichrist's program also includes "proper legislation regarding abortion" to control the population. The pro-choice position, therefore, isn't just wrong; it's diabolical. Protest at an abortion clinic, and you are fighting the devil.

Indeed, an underlying theme in the LEFT BEHIND books is that virtually anyone who disagrees with the authors' opinions is doing the devil's work. That includes supporters of interfaith dialogue. In a parody of ecumenism, leaders of the world's religions join to create a single world faith, sponsored by the Antichrist. To indicate their view of theological feminism, the authors make the second-highest cleric in the evil religion a woman, who speaks of "the great one-gender deity."

And yet, the central pillar of the new faith is the Roman Catholic Church, and Carpathia designates a Catholic archbishop as the world's "Supreme Pope." Catholicism, viewed in the mirror of the Last Days, is not just a "false religion," but the devil's handmaiden -- or to use standard apocalyptic jargon, the "whore of Babylon." LaHaye, a long-ago alumnus of the fundamentalist Bob Jones University, apparently learned that institution's anti-Catholic lessons well.

The series' depiction of Jews is as revealing. An Israeli scientist helps bring Carpathia to power, arranging a treaty by which the new leader brings Mideast peace. "God's chosen people ... had signed a deal with the devil," readers are informed. Jews must also pay for a more ancient error -- rejecting Jesus. "Israel remains largely unbelieving," announces a divine messenger at the Western Wall, "and will soon suffer for it." But the series presents some Jews positively: those who accept Christianity and become Last Days evangelists.

Again, the apocalypse lends urgency to the Christian right's positions today: Support the most intransigent of Israeli politicians because the Mideast peace process is another dark plot -- yet preach contempt for Judaism and target Jews for conversion.

ASSASSINS takes the logic of apocalypse a step further, suggesting a means of dealing with a demonic enemy. At the denouement, Carpathia is speaking at a mass rally in Jerusalem. And out in the crowd is one of the true believers, armed with a high-tech handgun. He prays for God's guidance, and finds himself firing what seems to be a fatal shot.

Intentionally or not, this is an eerie rewrite of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin's assassination at a Tel Aviv peace rally in 1995 -- and the authors are on the side of the fanatic killer. In THE INDWELLING, the apparent assassin's daughter asks her pastor if her father is a murderer. "I believe we are at war," he reassures her. "In the heat of battle, killing the enemy has never been considered murder."

I have to wonder who else might be reassured by that rationalization. Oklahoma bomber Timothy McVeigh enjoyed the neo-Nazi novel, THE TURNER DIARIES, which describes the truck-bombing of a federal office. If he took the book as instructions for murder, he was unusual among its readers -- but one such reader caused enough carnage.

That's a worst-case concern. The impact of the LEFT BEHIND books is likely to be subtler and hard to measure -- but powerful, as a historical precedent shows. In 1970, writer Hal Lindsey published THE LATE GREAT PLANET EARTH, a popularization of dispensationalism. Lindsey predicted a "future fuehrer" who would rule the world, and a nuclear apocalypse that would fulfill biblical predictions of the End. His book became the top nonfiction bestseller of the '70s. The results showed in the following decade, says University of Southern California Professor of Communications Stephen O'Leary, an expert on how apocalyptic ideas are presented in the mass media. The book, O'Leary asserts, was "both a harbinger and helped to create" the religious right of the 1980s.

In the same way, the LEFT BEHIND books reflect a mood -- and intensify it. Though framed as fiction, their purpose is to serve as a vehicle for ideas. Along with dispensationalist theology, the series fosters intolerance and the politics of paranoia -- and it's being read by millions. Supporters of an open society ignore the heralds of the End at their own risk.

Gershom Gorenberg is the author of THE END OF DAYS: FUNDAMENTALISM AND THE STRUGGLE FOR THE TEMPLE MOUNT (The Free Press).

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP