Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories
Headlines
Election Coverage
Calendar
TV Schedule
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
For Teachers
Resources
Feedback

FEATURE:
Pope John Paul II's Consistory
May 25, 2001    Episode no. 439
Read stories by week: 
Go
KIM LAWTON: They came from every corner of the Roman Catholic world: The College of Cardinals, also known as the princes of the church. These are the men who will elect the next pope -- in modern times, someone chosen from their own ranks.

Cardinals at ConsistoryThey worshipped togetherÉand they worked, discussing the church's agenda in the new millennium. In the end, they crafted a statement calling for a recommitment to applying to the gospel message key global problems. They endorsed new efforts to spur both ecumenical and interfaith dialogue, appealed for solidarity with Africa, and urged an immediate cease-fire between Israelis and Palestinians.

During medieval times, popes often held advisory meetings, or consistories, with the cardinals, but the practice stopped in the late sixteenth century. Pope John Paul II revived these consultations in 1979 because he wanted to hear from his cardinals. This was his sixth extraordinary consistory.

Pope John Paul IIJohn Paul called this gathering, he said, to build on last year's Jubilee, or Holy year.

MONSIGNOR TIMOTHY DOLAN, Pontifical North American College: He's saying, 'Wait a minute, we just had a great Jubilee and now we don't sort of close that book and put it on a shelf and say let's go.' He said, 'No, what we've got to do is almost sort of freeze-dry that great enthusiasm and energy and exuberance and promise that we saw.'

LAWTON: Previous consistories were organized around a very specific agenda. This meeting had no one theme, but featured wide-ranging discussions on a host of issues, from family problems and sexuality to ecumenical dialogue and church administration. Church officials said there were frank conversations, even differing opinions about some of the issues. Several cardinals said they were invigorated by the discussions.

Cardinal KeelerCARDINAL WILLIAM KEELER, Archdiocese of Baltimore: When we return home, we'll be energized by this exchange of ideas. We'll have some clearer ideas about the importance of our sacramental life, about our parish life, about the call to holiness for everybody, of the place of youth in our church, and also of our need as a church to relate to the media that report the news.

LAWTON: On top of their everyday duties, Cardinals have three special functions in the church: In addition to advising the pope, they are each given the title to one of Rome's historic churches. Cardinal Keeler's titular church is Saint Mary of the Angels and the Martyrs, designed by Michaelangelo. This huge building once housed the ancient Roman baths of Emperor Diocletian.

The third, and what many consider the most important, responsibility is electing the pope. According to church rules, all cardinals under the age of 80 meet in a conclave to select the pope by secret ballot. Some observers viewed this consistory as a 'dress rehearsal' for that main event.

Monsignor DolanDOLAN: It would be a mistake, I think, as some have portrayed this extraordinary consistory, as almost kind of like the antipasto to the conclave or the Iowa caucus almost. That's not intended. Does the pope realize that some of these men don't know each other very well and that it might be good for them to get to know each other, a good thing for the future of the church? Yes. He would be a very realistic pastor, so he would know that.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
JOHN ALLEN, NATIONAL CATHOLIC REPORTER: You have cardinals from 61 nations, many of whom have never seen one another in the flesh before this meeting. I was talking to one cardinal yesterday who said, 'Thank God we are all wearing name tags because otherwise I would have no idea who these guys are.' So given the fact that at some point these cardinals are going to have to come together and elect a new pope, the opportunity to get to know one another personally is very, very important.

LAWTON: Many believe even if it was never spoken aloud, the consistory was a prime opportunity for the cardinals to assess who among them may be, as the Italians call it, "pope-able."

Father ReeseFATHER THOMAS REESE, S.J., AMERICA magazine: "There's not going to be any one going around twisting arms and saying, 'Vote for me.' That's just considered totally inappropriate. But it's impossible not to think about this question for them. I think each cardinal is going to look at the other cardinals and say, 'How will that man go down in my part of the world as a pope? Would he be well-received? Would people like him?' Is he sensitive to the issues in my part of the world? And most importantly, does he listen to me?

LAWTON: It was also an opportunity to gauge the extent to which various cardinals' priorities align with the themes Pope John Paul II has emphasized in his papacy.

ALLEN: There certainly were some cardinals who have been closest to the work of John Paul who wanted to stress how important maintaining the line of John Paul is into the future. There were certainly other cardinals that wanted to talk about necessary changes.

LAWTON: The cardinals did specifically discuss one potential area for change: the amount of power the Vatican and its bureaucracies, the Curia, have over local dioceses. Some cardinals argued that more authority needs to be delegated to the local level. Others supported the need for a strong central authority. That and indeed nearly all of the issues raised at this meeting were left unresolved.

Vatican watchers say that doesn't mean nothing was accomplished.

Cardinals at ConsistoryALLEN: We in the West are sort of accustomed to the way in which the House of Representatives works. The way a Parliament works. That is, after a debate, we want a vote, and we want results right away. And that is not the way the Catholic Church functions. What happens in meetings like this is that the groundwork gets laid for those dramatic moments of change. Ideas have a chance to collect. Consensuses have a chance to build. People have a chance to do the thinking and the reflection that is necessary to make change happen.

LAWTON: And as they headed back home, many cardinals said the conversations with the pope, and with each other, will strengthen the sense of unity and purpose in the church worldwide.

KEELER: It was a reassuring experience to see how we share the same pastoral concerns and the same general faith vision into which we have to fit our particular pastoral concerns for the churches where we serve.

LAWTON: The pope will be hearing even more from church officials later this year. In October, he's called a month-long meeting here for representatives of all the world's bishops.

I'm Kim Lawton at the Vatican.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP