Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories
Headlines
Election Coverage
Calendar
TV Schedule
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
For Teachers
Resources
Feedback

COVER STORY:
Charismatics
August 17, 2001    Episode no. 451
Read stories by week: 
Go
MS. JODY CARTER (Charismatic): I grew up a Methodist, and I thought they were all nuts. I mean, what are all these people doing? They are singing and they are dancing and they are waving flags around.

Congregants MS. JUDY DORSY (Charismatic): I had never been exposed to anyone at church that acted the way these people were out there, and I came home and I said, "These people are crazy."

PROFESSOR MARGARET POLOMA (Charismatic): Here I was with the Ph.D., getting sucked into this movement that seems too, not rational. But I began to see the world differently.

LUCKY SEVERSON: So many say they were skeptics until they were "filled with the spirit." Now they are "praising the Lord" in churches all over the country. At last count, there were over 20 million Charismatics in the U.S. Many converts are immigrants, especially Hispanics, and an increasing number are from white-collar, professional neighborhoods, traditionally populated by more orthodox Christian churches. There are still skeptics and critics, of course, but even they cannot deny the pull and the attraction of the Charismatic movement.

Robert LiichowREVEREND ROBERT LIICHOW: There is just a whole different emphasis and I think that explains the growth of the Charismatic movement. We are this generation that seems far more experiential in our makeup.

PASTOR CHARLES SCHMITT (Immanuel's Church, Maryland): Why don't we pray for you?

SEVERSON: This is Pastor Charles Schmitt of the Immanuel['s] Church in Silver Spring, Maryland. He has 3,200 believers from 65 countries. Pastor Schmitt came for a conservative Dutch Reform background, until he "found the spirit" and held his first Charismatic service in his living room.

Pastor SchmittPASTOR SCHMITT: Why are people searching so, almost frantically now? Well, people are looking for reality, they're looking for life. They're looking for something other than just stagnation. And I don't mean to impugn any other group, but sometimes the longer a church is around the more formalistic it becomes, and the more irrelevant it becomes.

SEVERSON: Margaret Poloma is a sociology professor at the University of Akron, a Catholic turned Charismatic.

PROFESSOR POLOMA: Growing up Catholic, I certainly heard about healing, but I never saw any. I certainly heard about experiencing God, but that was left for the saints. And what this movement is saying is that everybody can have these experiences.

SEVERSON: This is a Charismatic healing mass at St. Veronica's Catholic Church in Hopewell, New Jersey. There are as many as half a million Catholics attending Charismatic services in Catholic churches nationwide. This is Father Brendan Williams.

Father WilliamsFATHER BRENDAN WILLIAMS (St. Veronica's Catholic Church): Primarily, a Catholic Charismatic is somebody who has come alive in their faith.

SEVERSON: And it's not only Catholics -- there are Charismatic Episcopalians, Methodists, Baptists, 'most every Protestant denomination.

FATHER WILLIAMS: It can be expressed emotionally, but it is something deep in the spirit that brings about a sense of calm, a sense of peace, and that takes away that tension, anxiety, worry.

SEVERSON: Forty years ago, outsiders might have called them Holy Rollers, or Pentecostals. Today the terms "Pentecostal" and "Charismatic" are usually interchangeable, with Charismatics leading the way, and being led by preachers who are not always schooled in theology. Reverend Robert Liichow says one of the reasons he left the Charismatic movement was because too many pastors have little or no theological education. Reverend Liichow has become a vocal critic of his former religion, and established his own Web site to, in his view, set the record straight.

REVEREND LIICHOW: We learned in seminary that many of the things that we used to believe were not biblically sound. So we have begun to take a very close look at what many of the national and international Charismatic ministers are teaching as biblical truth.

"Slain by the Spirit"SEVERSON: Many new disciples say it's not so much the theology that attracts them to the movement but what they call "the gifts of the Holy Spirit." Nothing is more important to Charismatics than the experience of "being born again," or "filled with the spirit," and it doesn't always take place during baptism. It can come anytime, and for Charismatics it is the "key" to the kingdom of heaven.
This young woman is being "slain by the spirit" -- a ritual that usually occurs at the end of a service. Even for the onlooker, it's a mesmerizing experience. For the believers, one, they say, that can change their lives. Others who have experienced "slaying" are skeptical.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
REVEREND LIICHOW: I have slain many and I have been slain by the best and I must say it did not produce any spiritual development in my life. There are a lot of reasons why people are slain in the spirit. Part of it has to do with learned behavior. There is a mild hypnosis that goes on in a large group of people.

SEVERSON: The music is hypnotic. It's no wonder people get worked up -- the beat discourages standing still. It's there to move you.

FATHER WILLIAMS: Music is a very important element really in opening ourselves to God.

SEVERSON: Healings are also very important to Charismatics. Rob and Judy Dorsey are converts to the movement, and they were recently at a revival gathering in Nicaragua where Rob says he healed a little boy who was blind.

Rob DorseyMR. ROB DORSEY: And I laid my hands on him and prayed that prayer of faith and just like that, he got his sight. It wasn't me. I did not heal a soul. Jesus healed him. And there was another boy that walked for the first time.

SEVERSON: On his Web site, Reverend Liichow encourages people to ask for proof that healings actually occurred. He says proof is rarely available.

REVEREND LIICHOW: Anecdotal stories to me. I am sorry, I am not impressed with them anymore. I used to be but now, no, I want the facts.

SEVERSON: But Anna Maria Garcia says she is not an anecdotal story. She was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis.

MS. ANNA MARIA GARCIA: MS can attack anywhere in your body. I would find myself on the ground and not know how. I had these severe dizzy spells, where I was literally walking into walls.

SEVERSON: Then she was given a blessing nine years ago, after years of searching for a spiritual remedy.

Anna Maria GarciaMS. GARCIA: And I got up there, these three people laid hands on me and started praying over me, and I hated it, it was terrible, I felt horribly, horribly self-conscious, and I went home that night and I really didn't feel any different. But I woke up the next morning and I was totally healed.

SEVERSON: Nothing sets Charismatics apart like the phenomenon known as "speaking in tongues." Gibberish perhaps to the bystander, but to disciples, a sign that the spirit of God is within.

FATHER WILLIAMS: All I sense when I pray in tongues is that there is something beautiful happening. That I am surrounding and allowing the Holy Spirit to pray through me to my Father.

SEVERSON: But as Charismatics attempt to gain wider acceptance and more members, converts are no longer always required to speak in tongues to prove they are filled with the spirit.
The most common criticism of Charismatics is that they rely too much on experience -- too little on doctrine.

PASTOR SCHMITT: Someone has said about the Charismatic movement that they perceive that it was an inch deep and a mile wide.

SEVERSON: But for believers, even those who were skeptics like Larry Levy, who has a Ph.D. in electrical engineering, if it's the experience that brings you closer to God, then so be it.

Larry LevyDR. LARRY LEVY: You end like, being kind of frozen chosen or semidead, whatever, because you know all the theology but you haven't experienced God, and you really need to experience God.

PASTOR SCHMITT: If I had to choose between education and an experience with God I would choose the experience with God.

PROFESSOR POLOMA: I found that once I was an agnostic, I could not reason my way back into faith. I had reasoned my way out quite successfully. It really took a touch of God, and it took experience of God in the Charismatic circles for me to come back to a faith.

Mr. Brij SharmaSEVERSON: Margaret Poloma is convinced that the Charismatic movement is only starting to gain steam, that it will continue to be a spiritual force to be reckoned with. The "experience" seems to be working. There are now 540 million Charismatics worldwide.

For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Lucky Severson in Silver Spring, Maryland.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP