Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Cover
Profile

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
President Bush's Spiritual Counselors
December 14, 2001    Episode no. 515
Read This Week's October 3, 2008
Go
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: Now, our cover story on presidential prayer. Where does George W. Bush worship? Is he getting any spiritual counseling?

Kim Lawton reports on the phenomenon of a president who speaks often about religion in public but whose personal religious practices have turned out to be very private.

KIM LAWTON: President Bush says in the difficult days since September 11th he has drawn strength from faith and prayer.

President Bush at services PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH, (at National Cathedral): There are prayers that help us last through the day or endure the night. There are prayers of friends and strangers that give us strength for the journey.

LAWTON: A United Methodist who says he has committed his life to Jesus, Bush speaks openly about his personal faith.

PRESIDENT BUSH (in Florida meeting): I'm passionate on the subject because I understand the power of faith in people's lives, and I understand what it can mean.

LAWTON: He may be passionate, but the president is also very private about how he exercises his own faith and where he looks for spiritual guidance.

Shaun Casey SHAUN CASEY, Wesley Theological Seminary: As far as I can see, there are no public religious figures that are going into the White House and coming out and then talking about some kind of conversation with the president. So if there is a circle of counselors, it is very private. It is very personal.

LAWTON: During the last administration, President Clinton designated several spiritual advisers. One of them was evangelical author and speaker Tony Campolo. Campolo believes it's important for a president who claims strong religious beliefs to have regular spiritual counsel.

Tony Campolo TONY CAMPOLO, Eastern College: We must never allow a president to feel that he or she is legitimated by God in the role that he or she assumes as president. All of us must recognize -- and certainly the president -- that we are prone to error, we are prone to shortcomings, and we need to be challenged in what we do and what we say.

LAWTON: Since September 11, President Bush has held a few meetings with religious leaders, including two largely policy meetings with Muslims and one with Sikhs.

Some spiritual counsel apparently was offered on September 20, when the president invited 26 prominent leaders from across the religious spectrum to the White House, just hours before his address to a joint session of Congress.

CARDINAL BERNARD LAW, Archdiocese of Boston, (Statement in front of White House): It is significant that in this time of crisis, President Bush should invite a group broadly representative of the religious communities in this land to pray with him and to offer counsel.

LAWTON: Participants said the president prayed with them, holding hands in a circle.

Cardinal Law CARDINAL LAW: I came away from that meeting, as I think all of us did, powerfully impressed by the president as a man of deep faith.

LAWTON: President Bush has attended religious memorial services, including this interfaith gathering at the National Cathedral on September 14th. But he has not been participating in regular public worship services. Instead, he appears to have made Camp David his primary place of worship.

Camp David sign At Camp David, religious services are held in the Evergreen Chapel, a nondenominational facility built a decade ago with private donations. Former President Bush dedicated the chapel in 1991 in a ceremony attended by national religious leaders.

Weekly Christian worship services are held for the military personnel and staff posted at Camp David and their families. Since 1991, Navy chaplains have been assigned to three-year tours of duty there. The Bushes apparently attend services there often.

FIRST LADY LAURA BUSH: The Sunday after the attacks, we attended church at Camp David. We were so glad to see members of the congregation, the 70 or so people, mostly young couples with children, who attend regular services there.

LAWTON: In the wake of September 11th, the military and the Secret Service have tightly restricted information about Camp David. The current minister is Chaplain Robert Williams, who has been posted there for more than two years. Officials would not release his photo or let us interview him.

The First Lady speaks highly of Williams.

FIRST LADY BUSH: The young chaplain is a graduate of the Perkins School of Theology at my alma mater, Southern Methodist University, and he has a quiet and strong and sincere faith.

LAWTON: Some observers wonder whether Camp David provides the president adequate spiritual sustenance.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
CASEY: I would argue that military-led chapel services at Camp David are not the equivalent to a permanent membership in an ongoing community of faith.

LAWTON: Why not?

CASEY: Because it is a rotating community. It is not a community that has gathered around a specific confession. It is simply people who have gathered because they happen to be there.

Michael Cromartie MICHAEL CROMARTIE, Ethics and Public Policy Center: Of course it is real church. It is a chapel. It is at Camp David. It is a Navy chaplain. It is people gathered to worship. That is church.

LAWTON: The Secret Service has increased security around the president. But even before September 11, he had only attended church in Washington a few times.

CAMPOLO: If he has a private worship, as President Nixon did, he will be criticized for doing it privately and not in a normative church. On the other hand, Bill Clinton did do that. He went to Foundry Methodist Church with great regularity, with his Bible under his arm. The net result was what? He was making a show of his religion. In short, you can't win when you're president of the United States.

LAWTON: In Texas, Bush was close to three United Methodist ministers, one of them the Rev. Kirbyjon Caldwell of Houston, who has prayed with Bush over the phone. At the National Cathedral service, Caldwell read Psalm 27, a passage that has been prominent in recent weeks.

REV. KIRBYJON CALDWELL: "The Lord is my light and my salvation. Whom shall I fear?"

LAWTON: The First Lady says at Camp David Chaplain Williams used the same text on September 16th.

First Lady Laura Bush FIRST LADY BUSH: He based his sermon that Sunday on the psalm outlined in the lectionary for that September day, Psalm 27: "Your face, Lord, do I seek. I believe that I shall see the goodness of the Lord in the land of the living."

LAWTON: The Bushes chose that verse for this year's White House Christmas card.

REV. CALDWELL: (reading Psalm 27): "When evil-doers assail me ..."

LAWTON: The president has also borrowed some of the psalm's language in his speeches about the war against terrorism.

President Bush PRESIDENT BUSH: All our allies and friends will now be familiar with these evil-doers.

LAWTON: Professor Shaun Casey has been studying Bush's speeches since September 11. Casey says while the president has talked a lot about evil, prayer, and the comfort of God, he has been less clear about the influence of his faith on his policies.

CASEY: If a candidate presents himself as a person of faith and claims on the stump that God, and their relationship with God, sustains them, then they owe a debt to the country to explore that and to explain why that is the case and what difference does your personal faith make for your politics. But I don't see him trying to make those connections or bringing in people who can help him make those kind of connections.

LAWTON: Some observers aren't concerned that President Bush is being low-key about any spiritual counsel.

CROMARTIE: It would bother me more if we had, like some recent presidents, at least five or six spiritual advisors going in every month -- where you had a different minister of the week meeting privately with the president. That would bother me more, especially during a time of war, because it looks like the pastor or minister or preacher is being brought in to sort of legitimate something that could well be controversial.

LAWTON: Tony Campolo took a lot of flak for being President Clinton's spiritual advisor.

CAMPOLO: You know, a number of my evangelical brothers and sisters were, you know, saying, "Why are you dealing with a man who has been involved, as he has been involved, with Monica Lewinsky?" And my answer has to be that this is the role of Christians. I mean, if somebody called you and says, "I need help; I've messed up my life," what do you say -- that I only pray with Republicans?

LAWTON: But Campolo admits there is always the possibility of political exploitation.

Clinton and Campolo CAMPOLO: The first few times you go into the Oval Office, you're awestruck. You know, you kind of brace yourself and say, I'm not going to be impressed by this. When you get there, you are impressed. During my time, I had to constantly ask myself that: Am I being used?

LAWTON: Despite all the possible questions, many are urging President Bush to continue seeking out spiritual guidance -- whether he makes it public or not.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP