Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories
Headlines
Election Coverage
Calendar
TV Schedule
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
For Teachers
Resources
Feedback

COVER STORY:
Episcopal Rift
August 1, 2003    Episode no. 648
Read stories by week: 
Go
Photo of Archbishop of Canterbury
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: The debate over gay marriage heated up on several fronts this week. The Vatican launched a new global campaign against same-sex unions, saying homosexual behavior is "against the natural moral law." In a new 12-page document, Vatican officials told Catholic politicians that support of same-sex unions is "gravely immoral." The document also opposed adoptions by gays.

In Washington, President Bush weighed in on the subject. At a Rose Garden press conference, the president urged tolerance for gays. But he also supported the traditional view of marriage.

Meanwhile, more and more gay American couples are heading to Canada to get married. Two Canadian provinces legalized gay marriage in June. But the U.S. public remains conflicted about the issue. As we reported last week, a poll by the Pew Forum conducted at the end of June showed that opposition to gay marriage dropped 10 percent since 1996. However, a new CNN-USA TODAY-Gallup poll found that an increasing number of Americans, almost half, believe homosexual acts should be illegal.

Photo of National Cathedral The U.S. Episcopal Church is locked in a battle over a similar issue -- not gay marriage, but the blessing of same-sex unions. It's part of a critical showdown over gay issues that many fear could lead to a major church split. Nearly 800 local church representatives and 300 bishops arrived in Minneapolis this week for the denomination's 10-day-long triennial convention. At the top of their agenda: whether to confirm the church's first openly gay bishop, and whether to develop liturgies to bless same-sex unions. Conservatives say movement on either front will provoke "a dramatic realignment" in the Episcopal Church and in the worldwide Anglican Communion. Kim Lawton reports.

KIM LAWTON: At a downtown chapel in Minneapolis, the worship is exuberant, sometimes emotional, as conservative Episcopalians praise the Lord -- and pray for the future of their church. Most gathered at this service are from the evangelical wing of the U.S. Episcopal Church. They believe the Bible clearly condemns homosexuality, and they're deeply worried about where their church is headed. They feel a sacred obligation to uphold traditional church teaching.

Photo of David Anderson Canon DAVID ANDERSON (American Anglican Council, in sermon): The test is not to be successful in the worldly sense, by winning a vote or whatever. The test is to be faithful, to be obedient to Jesus Christ our Lord.

LAWTON: Canon David Anderson heads the American Anglican Council, an umbrella group of conservative Episcopalians.

Canon ANDERSON: I think the future of the Episcopal Church and even the future of the Anglican Communion is at stake. This is a point at which I think history pivots.

LAWTON: In Santa Barbara, California, members of Trinity Episcopal Church are also concerned about the future. They interpret Scripture more liberally and believe gays and lesbians should be fully incorporated into all aspects of church life. Trinity's rector, Reverend Mark Asman, is himself gay. He says this is a defining moment for all gay and lesbian Episcopalians.

Photo of Rev. Mark Asman Rev. MARK ASMAN (Trinity Episcopal Church, Santa Barbara): The church has the power to make a decision about where we stand at the table and how welcome we are at the table.

LAWTON: The two very different views have coexisted in the Episcopal Church for decades -- albeit uneasily. But now, many observers wonder how long coexistence can last.

Photo of David Earle Anderson DAVID EARLE ANDERSON (Religion News Service): The alienation of the two sides on this is very profound and very deep -- virtually unprecedented. And it has probably led to -- it's certainly the church's biggest crisis in decades, and perhaps since Henry VIII and the split from Rome.

LAWTON: The Episcopal Church -- George Washington's church -- is one of the oldest denominations in America. And it is poised to make history again. While most other mainline denominations continue to debate the role of gays in the church, in the next few days, Episcopalians may confirm the church's first openly gay bishop, Gene Robinson, who was elected in New Hampshire. And they may approve development of liturgies to bless same-sex unions.

Mr. ANDERSON: It would put them at least two steps ahead on that issue of where most other denominations are now.

LAWTON: That's what worries conservatives such as Canon David Anderson.

Canon ANDERSON: It would represent a departure from established Christian doctrine. God revealed to his people what his intention for human life was and how we are to live. And that has come down, and I don't think God has changed his mind or become better educated.

LAWTON: But other church leaders say biblical injunctions against homosexuality must be interpreted in a contemporary cultural context. Bishop John Bryson Chane of Washington, D.C. says church teaching should be set by a combination of Scripture, tradition -- and reason.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
Bishop JOHN BRYSON CHANE (Diocese of Washington): Scripture can be read in a multiplicity of ways. If we, in fact, believe that everybody is equal in God's eyes, then how in God's name can we say that we don't have enough theology to work this issue through? And how can we say that a person's sexuality does not allow them to enter into the full life of this communion?

LAWTON: Where the Episcopal Church comes down will have major ramifications around the world. The U.S. church is a member of the global Anglican Communion, which is made up of 38 independent national and regional church bodies, or provinces. In 1998, bishops from those provinces passed a nonbinding resolution asserting that homosexual behavior is incompatible with Scripture.

Photo of Rev. kendall Harmon Rev. KENDALL HARMON (Diocese of South Carolina): This is something where the worldwide Anglican community has made its voice heard, and it's made its voice clear. And yet you have a church which is, it seems, going to willfully contradict that.

LAWTON: Reverend Kendall Harmon was part of an international group of conservative Anglicans who last week warned of a looming "realignment" in the church. They say it's the liberals who are forcing division.

Several international archbishops, particularly from Africa and Asia, say they would consider breaking ties with the U.S. church.

Photo of Rev. Peter Akinola Archbishop PETER AKINOLA (Diocese of Nigeria): These events are going to determine the future and the fate of our communion. Definitely, something must happen.

LAWTON: Many American conservatives say they have more in common with African Anglicans than they have with their own church leadership. And they say they represent the majority in the communion, since most Anglicans live in the Third World. Official U.S. church leaders say they see inappropriate foreign interference.

Photo of  Bishop Chane Bishop CHANE: Each province of the communion is autonomous. I really resent bishops coming in from other parts of the world, wherever that might be, and bishops from our own Episcopal Church inviting them in to act as movers and shakers and pushers on this issue.

LAWTON: African leaders say because the provinces are interconnected, they too are affected by whatever the U.S. church does.

Photo of ministers at Minneapolis Coonvention If gay issues move forward at the Minneapolis convention, numerous conservative Episcopalians -- individuals, congregations, even entire dioceses -- say they would no longer want to be associated with the U.S. church. But they don't want to leave the Anglican Communion. It's not clear what they can do.

Mr. ANDERSON: Schism is a very difficult thing to pull off, particularly in the United States. It's very difficult to leave the Episcopal Church and bring your property with you. So both sides want to maintain control of the institution.

LAWTON: Bishop Chane says he does not think the church is headed for schism. He believes Anglicans can find unity within their diversity.

Bishop CHANE: Anglicanism is kind of a messy thing. The question that I ask is, do we have the ability and the will and the faith and the compassion to claim that diversity and to live into that messiness, respecting the fact that it's not going to be always that simple?

LAWTON: The new Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, has also pleaded for unity. He's the spiritual head of the Anglican Communion, but he has no authority to intervene in local church affairs. He is personally supportive of the role of gays in the church, but his primary task as archbishop is to hold the global communion together.

Leaders on both sides of the debate say unity is not the only principle at issue.

Rev. ASMAN: I believe that we risk losing our moral voice if we cave in to pressure to preserve unity at all costs and sacrifice a principle of justice.

Rev. Dr. KENDALL HARMON (Diocese of South Carolina): Real communion is only possible in truth. Communion is participation in common fellowship with God and the truth of his witness to the world.

LAWTON: Both sides do agree the events in Minneapolis could set the course for a dramatically different day in the U.S. Episcopal Church.

The business meeting here officially lasts 10 days. But the debates will continue long after [the] General Convention ends. If the controversial actions are adopted here, conservative international church leaders say they plan to convene an emergency meeting to respond.

I'm Kim Lawton in Minneapolis.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP