Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Cover
Profile
Belief & Practice
Web Exclusive

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Iraq Shiites
December 19, 2003    Episode no. 716
Read This Week's July 18, 2008
Go
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: According to some observers, the capture of Saddam Hussein may intensify calls from Iraq's majority Shia community for a speedier transfer of power. This week, more attacks on Shiite leaders, presumably by Sunni Muslims concerned about their future in a government likely to be dominated by Shiites, who make up 60 percent of the Iraqi population. But what kind of government do the Shiites want? Islamic law? Secular and democratic? Something in between? We have a special report from Kate Seelye of National Public Radio.

KATE SEELYE: Of all Iraq's religious and ethnic communities, the Shia have good reason to celebrate the capture of former president Saddam Hussein. For decades the dictator brutally oppressed the Shia, who rose up against him after the 1991 Gulf War.

News of Saddam's capture can only give the community an added boost. The Shia have been enjoying a political and religious revival since the leader's overthrow last spring. This revival is already evident in Najaf, the holy city at the heart of the Shia world. Seminaries closed under the former regime are reopening and clerics are returning from exile. Rituals, forced underground for years, are once again celebrated publicly.

Photo of manpraying Najaf is home to Iraq's Shia religious leadership. Here in this shrine, the father of the Shia sect -- Imam Ali -- is buried. The son-in-law of the prophet Muhammad, Ali's followers broke from Islam's Sunni majority in the 7th century, after a dispute over succession. Najaf is considered so sacred that for centuries, the Shia have brought their dead here to be blessed and buried

Free to worship as they please, Iraq's Shia are now also free to voice their political opinions. These are diverse and often fractious.

These new freedoms are not without risk. The shrine of Imam Ali has been the site of several bloody assassinations.

Shortly after the fall of Saddam, two religious leaders were stabbed to death here in an internal Shia dispute. The shrine still bears the scars of the massive October car bombing that killed esteemed senior cleric Ayatollah Mohammed Bakr al Hakim. The violence and instability have tempered jubilation here.

ADEL HUSSEIN (Najaf Resident, Through Translator): We believe in dialogue and peaceful coexistence with others, and this threatens those who support Saddam.

SEELYE: Analysts say there is no proof of Sunni involvement in the car bombing. But having governed for centuries, Iraq's Sunnis are threatened by the prospect of Shia rule. At 15 million, the Shia make up 60 percent of the population. They will likely dominate the political future.

ABDEL MEHDI (Spokesman, The Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq): The Shia in Iraq is a majority. So they have to play principal role in the whole direction of the country. I don't mean they will impose their Shia beliefs on the country, but as any other country, the majority should be there.

Photo of protest sign SEELYE: But what direction that majority will take remains to be seen. While many closely follow the rulings of their religious leaders, others, like this Baghdad security guard, are secular.

HOSSEIN AL HOSSEINI (Baghdad Security Guard, Through Translator): Religion is a personal thing. It should be separate from politics. I don't want anyone telling me what to do.

SEELYE: Hosseini says he favors a democratic government. One recent poll indicated that 90 percent of Shia share the same view. At the same time, another poll found that two thirds of Shia also want religion to play a large role in politics.

Here at the Iraqi Governing Council, members are grappling with these issues

ahead of the establishment of a transitional Iraqi assembly next summer. The influential Iran-backed Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq is one of the parties involved in the debate. Its leaders say that because Iraq is a majority Muslim country, their goal is a state that bases its morality on Islamic principles.

Photo of ABDEL MEHDI Mr. MEHDI: Well, our agenda is to put forward a democratic state, this is the word; respecting Islam, a state that Islam is its official religion.

SEELYE: But others want a much closer relationship between mosque and state.

From his mosque in Kufa, cleric Moktada Sadr has called for the establishment of a religious state, bound by Islamic Sharia law. He has also been a vocal critic of the American occupation. Son of a revered deceased ayatollah, Sadr is viewed as a rabble-rouser by Najaf's religious establishment. But his message resonates with the disenfranchised in places like Sadr City, a slum suburb of Baghdad, where his party provides social services.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
Sadr spokesman Abbas al-Rubaie says after decades of corrupt rule, an Islamic state has wide appeal.

ABBAS AL-RUBAIE (Spokesman for Moktada Sadr, Through Translator): Islam has a long tradition of justice and tolerance and preserving the rights of others.

SEELYE: Not all Iraqis are convinced. Since the fall of Saddam, Islamic extremists have sought to impose their vision of society. They have pressured women to veil by threatening them with attack; liquor stores and cinemas have been forcibly closed.

Activist Leila Mohammad publishes a weekly women's newsletter. It urges readers to resist pressure to veil.

Photo of LEILA MOHAMMAD LEILA MOHAMMAD (Worker's Communist Party): The formation of an Islamic state will not give rights to society and certainly not to women. There are many verses in the Qur'an that give women a lesser role in society.

SEELYE: Iraq is a mosaic of ethnic and religious minorities. One of the largest are the Christians. Many, like this Assyrian shopkeeper, say they would prefer a secular state.

ABU SARAGON (Shopkeeper, Through Translator): I think that a democratic government, especially one that is secular, will better serve the needs of all Iraqis.

SEELYE: But while a secular state does not seem likely, few Shia are calling for an Iranian-style Islamic republic. Although Iraqi Shia share close religious and political ties with Iran's Shia, both laymen and clergy here say they reject authoritarian clerical rule.

Progressive cleric Sayyed Farkhad al-Qazwini says Iraqis do not want to replace one despot with another.

SAYYED FARKHAD AL-QAZWINI (Head, The Religious University, Hillah, Through Translator): I'm an Iraqi and a clergyman, and I tell you that the Iraqi street rejects me and others like me. The people do not want dictators any more.

SEELYE: Unlike in Iran, Iraq's senior clergy say they do not seek to rule. Instead, clerics say, their role is reserved to offering guidance -- whether on spiritual, social, or political matters. Mohammed Hussein al-Hakim is the son of and spokesman for one of Iraq's four Grand Ayatollahs.

Photo of MOHAMMED HUSSEIN AL-HAKIM MOHAMMED HUSSEIN AL-HAKIM (Spokesman for Grand Ayatollah Mohammed Said al-Hakim, Through Translator): There is no separation of religion and politics in Islam. This does not mean religious leaders in Najaf want to be politicians. They guide, they protect the interests of the people.

SEELYE: Hakim says conditions now are not suitable for the establishment of an Islamic state, but he acknowledges that, like many other clerics, this is his ultimate goal. Such statements feed into western fears about the rise of theocratic rule here. But former U.S. ambassador to Saudi Arabia Hume Horan says given the country's religious and ethnic diversity, the future Iraqi state will have to be built on compromise.

HUME HORAN (Senior Advisor on Religious Affairs, Coalition Provisional Authority): It would probably be a little more prescriptively religious and Shiite than some of the Shiites on the council want, but certainly less so than what those who are speaking for a specfically Islamic state, whether it be Shiite or Sunni, would want.

SEELYE: Horan adds that Iraqi Shia clerics could prove to be a progressive force in the future.

Photo of HUME HORAN Mr. HORAN: The Grand Ayatollahs, I think, incomparably, have been the most intellectually open Muslim thinkers that I have met. And they are extraordinarily tolerant in their viewpoint. And tolerance, says cleric Qazwini, is the essence of Islam.

Mr. AL-QAZWINI: Justice, peace, freedom, and democracy are the principles of Islam. What is practiced on the streets, this is not Islam.

SEELYE: Whether the Iraqis ultimately choose a secular state, a state based on Islamic principles, or an Islamic state remains to be seen. The hope for Shia like Qazwini is that if Islam is to underpin the future state, it at least be progressive.

For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Kate Seelye in Iraq.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP