Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Sensitizing Police Toward Muslims
January 2, 2004    Episode no. 718
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
KIM LAWTON, guest anchor: Muslim and Arab-Americans say that two years after 9-11, they still face hostility and suspicion from the public and from law enforcement agencies. Many feel unfairly targeted in the war against terrorism. Hoping to improve relations with those communities, the Justice Department has begun a "sensitivity training" program for FBI agents and local police. Paul Miller reports.

Photo of LUBY ISMAIL and class PAUL MILLER: This Muslim-American woman has been brought before the Takoma Park, Maryland Police Department -- to teach them about Islam.

LUBY ISMAIL (Founder and President, Connecting Cultures): One of the key beliefs is (Arabic spoken) "I testify there is but one God and Mohammed is a messenger of God."

MILLER: Since 9-11, local police have had more contact with Muslim, Sikh and Arab-American communities.

Some cases involve hate crimes against the communities.

Others are part of counter-terrorism investigations. There have been well-publicized arrests. Some Muslims and Arab-Americans say their communities as a whole are being discriminated against.

Photo of JEAN ABI NADER JEAN ABI NADER (Managing Director, Arab-American Institute): Arabs and Muslims are being treated as if they're criminals -- and that's a very big difference and so it's very hard particularly for those who don't speak English well or for example women who wear the hijab, which is the head scarf -- it is a religious choice.

MILLER: Muslim and Arab-American leaders say old stereotypes that have haunted them were cemented by the events of September 11, and that innocent people have been harassed or arrested in the aftermath of the attacks.

Photo of LUBY ISMAIL Ms. ISMAIL: The stereotypes we are wanting to focus on are not that you necessarily believe them but you know exist out there in society.

Unidentified Woman: Hijackers.

Unidentified Man: Fanatics.

Unidentified Man: Terrorists.

MILLER: Luby Ismail tries to dispel the stereotypes -- her own history is a start. The daughter of Egyptian immigrants, she was raised a Muslim in Florida and says y'all almost as frequently as "God willing."

She also gives police practical advice on how to avoid conflict with Americans who are Muslim.

Ms. ISMAIL: What do they need to know when they enter into a mosque? What do they need to know when they come into a Muslim home? What do they need to know in order to build trust?

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
MILLER: She tells police cultural differences cause misunderstandings that lead to incidents. She gives an example of a Muslim woman who aroused suspicion by pulling away when a police dog sniffed her purse -- she had a Koran in the purse, and she did not want the dog, considered unclean, to come in contact with the Holy Book.

Photo of ED COURSEY Captain ED COURSEY (Takoma Park Police Department): In the post 9-11 era, obviously, the sensitivity to these issues has got to be heightened.

MILLER: Luby Ismail has trained FBI agents and local police around the country, working with the Justice Department's Community Relations Service.

They have now produced a video to be shown at police roll-calls, to reach more law enforcement and emergency personnel.

Unidentified policeman (in Justice Department training video): Could I come in and talk to you?

Unidentified veiled woman: Sorry, my husband isn't home right now.

Narrator: This may seem suspicious -- but it may be inappropriate to enter a home if only someone of the opposite sex is present.

MILLER: The Justice Department says that in counter-terrorism and emergency situations the safety of the public -- and law enforcement officers -- is paramount, and the nature of police work sometimes ruffles feelings. But the department says it is committed to improving relations with minority communities, and it wants to reassure the Muslim and Arab-American communities they will benefit from closer ties to the police.

Photo of SHAREE FREEMAN SHAREE FREEMAN (Director, Community Relations Service, Department of Justice): We do the best we can to assure the communities that they'll be okay -- by open dialogues, by town hall meetings, by having the program that we run, the initiative that we run for Arab, Muslim and Sikh cultural training.

MILLER: Muslim and Arab-American leaders say they endorse the community relations effort, but continue to be concerned by some of the hard-line rhetoric they still hear from some Justice Department officials.

Ms. FREEMAN: That message may be perceived as being mixed, I don't know -- but I think that once they understand what we do and see us work, it all falls away.

Mr. ABI NADER: There are political people in the Justice Department whose concern we think is as much with public posturing as it is with good law enforcement or counter-terrorism. So, what we are hoping is that actions speak louder than words.

Photo of Muslim men praying MILLER: Police hope to better explain police work to Muslims and Arab-Americans, who in turn want the police to better understand Islam and Arab culture, so that the "us versus them" mentality will disappear. For RELIGION AND ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Paul Miller.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP