Later, Sister Mary Xavier, the name she took, and several others from the convent left to try to start a less sequestered order. But she says she remains committed to a religious life.
Sister MARY XAVIER (Novice, Carmelite Sisters of the Divine Heart of Jesus, St. Louis): When I first entered the convent, it was so different. It was like a culture shock. Everything was just so holy. It was like walking into another world. I didn't really have a desire to go into a convent and never see anyone again. I didn't want to be a nun. I mean, I had so many other things I wanted to be. I wanted to get married. I wanted to have kids. I wanted to be a normal person. You know, what everyone else does -- what all my friends are doing: going to school, and having a career, and all that kind of stuff.I want to have an impact on the world, and I wanted to be somebody. I had all these dreams, and all these aspirations that I wanted to do and to be. Like I love acting. I love theater, and you don't really get much of that in the convent.
The convent was like, you know, throwing your life away. But I still felt that tug. I knew it was something in me. You know, I just knew it was God saying, "I want this."
My father, I would say, just did not want me here.
JESSE MCCULLOUGH (Father of Sister Mary Xavier): We lost a son. It was like cutting off an arm, you know. And then, when she goes away, it's like cutting off another arm. You're hurt, you know. You think you're not going to see her again for a long time. You know, you're not used to that. You know, you think, "Me -- why's this happening to me? Why am I losing another child?"Sister MARY XAVIER: They were so against it. Like I would get letters, and, you know, "you shouldn't be there, you're throwing your life away," and all this. It was hard. A number of times I cried over those letters.
I'm a novice -- a second-year novice. The novitiate, it's a time of intense preparation, intense formation, that you're going to be religious and stuff, and so it's a kind of stripping away of all your attachments to, like, to the world. On December 8, that's when I make my first profession. The profession of the three evangelical councils are vows, which are of poverty, chastity, and obedience.
Sister MARY LELIA (Novice Mistress, Carmelite Sisters of the Divine Heart of Jesus, St. Louis): The three vows kind of are an epitome of what the whole life is going to be. All of your life before this moment of the taking of the vows is kind of a preparation. It all comes up to that moment. Everything in your life is going to flow from that moment. Chastity -- chastity can have a very negative connotation.Sister MARY XAVIER: In high school I dated a little bit. But it was nothing major. I was never, like, in love or anything like that, like I was going to marry a boy or something.
Sister MARY LELIA: Chastity is a freedom. It's a freedom to love more purely, more perfectly. And the three vows are how we bind ourselves to him. Poverty in the negative sense is that I cannot use anything without asking permission for it.
Sister MARY XAVIER: Like me and my brother would spend weekends at the mall. It's all we would do, is shop for clothes. But I love clothes, clothes and shoes.
Sister MARY LELIA: We can be so greedy. And poverty is to help us be free of greed so that I can again attach myself more completely to Christ. And then the third vow, obedience, which for some congregations, that's the only vow they take, because it encompasses everything. Part of obedience is, I am not to determine anymore that I do this or do that -- where yourself is going to be. It's not going to be choices you make, which people you're going to work with.Sister MARY XAVIER: What toothpaste I use.
Sister MARY LELIA: That's right, that's not the choice you're going to make. This period's going to decide. This is how you're going to use your talents. I give my talents to God. It's not for me to determine.




Sister MARY XAVIER: I mean, I have doubted. Am I supposed to be here? Am I not supposed to be here? You know, I have doubted that. And I miss theater, very much. But I want to go to heaven. I want to be a saint. Going to Hollywood wasn't going to get me to heaven. Really, I believe that God called me here, and I believe that he loves me, and I believe that he is out there, you know. I know it, I know it, you know. But sometimes you can doubt. He can't come down and say, "I love you."
UNIDENTIFIED PRIEST (At Ceremony): In our ceremony this morning, Sister Mary Xavier, after making her profession, belongs completely to God, and is totally devoted to him. Sister Mary Xavier, of the divine bridegroom, are you resolved to be more closely united to God by the new bond of religious profession?
Sister MARY XAVIER: My hands are shaking. I hope I can get through this. I, Sister Mary Xavier of the divine bridegroom, Tiffany Irene McCullough, with the firm determination of consecrating myself totally to him, with my whole heart, I join this religious congregation.
ABERNETHY: For the time being, Sister Mary Xavier is using her family name, Tiffany Irene McCullough. She and several other former nuns are living in Louisiana, where they are waiting for permission from their bishop to start a new congregation to counsel and evangelize those she calls "the wounded," who have slipped away from the Catholic Church. She says she has no qualms about eventually taking her final vows.