Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Dover Caskets
June 25, 2004    Episode no. 743
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: The Pentagon has clarified its policy on letting families of those killed in Iraq go out to the runway at Dover Air Force base, in Delaware, and meet the caskets as they come off the planes.

Some parents had complained that they had been forbidden from doing that, but the Pentagon now says, formally, they can. But the administration wants no pictures taken at Dover -- by families or anyone else, and that has set off a sharp debate. Lucky Severson has our special report.

LUCKY SEVERSON: Victims of the embassy bombing in Kenya arriving at Andrews Air Force Base in 1998. A solemn President Clinton was there to pay his respects.

The coffin ceremony was televised nationally.

Photo of Dover caskets But on the eve of the U.S. invasion of Iraq in March of last year, the Bush administration reinstalled a ban on pictures of the arrival of war coffins and expanded it to include all U.S. bases. No more pictures like these of arriving coffins. Some Americans say the ban allows the administration to hide the body count of the Iraq war. Others, like Kirk Morris of Gurnee, Illinois, say the blackout prevents a media circus at a very tragic and private moment for the families.

KIRK MORRIS (Father of Geoffrey Morris): You have to be reverent towards those who have given their life, given their all for this country.

Photo of Geoffrey Morris SEVERSON: His 19-year-old son Geoffrey, a Marine machine-gunner, the big brother of five siblings, gave his all in Iraq on Palm Sunday 2004.

Mr. MORRIS: I have three Marines knock at my door and wake us up. We are still grieving heavy -- this family -- for the loss of a son and a brother.

SEVERSON: Officials say the photo ban is in deference to the privacy and the sensitivity of the families of the fallen. And, that President Bush believes we should honor and show respect for those who have made the ultimate sacrifice. So when these pictures, almost 300, appeared on the Internet in April, the private Defense Department contractor who took them was fired and the debate about the policy rekindled.

Photo of Kirk Morris Mr. MORRIS: I believe pictures like that have the potential to be used in a negative way. And that frightens me. I do believe that the news media has been irreverent in certain cases and certain pictures that have come out of the war.

SEVERSON: Vicky Langley's son, Marine Private Jonathan Gifford, was killed in the invasion of Iraq.

Photo of Jonathan Gifford VICKY LANGLEY (Mother of Jonathan Gifford): My only son. My worst nightmare. The hardest thing I ever had to go through.

SEVERSON: She says when she saw the Internet pictures on TV at home in Decatur, Illinois, they gave her comfort.

Ms. LANGLEY: I was pleased people are seeing the respect they are treated with. It is nice to know that not only did they not die in vain, and all America knows it, but even their brothers treat him like they lost a brother.

Unidentified Teacher: On the other hand you might argue...

SEVERSON: Sam Hoff is a history professor at Delaware State University in Dover, home of the military's largest mortuary.

And his class is debating the merits of televising casket ceremonies.

Unidentified Student: My brother is in the Air Force. God forbid something should happen to him. I mean, I wouldn't mind showing his picture and saying his name and that he died doing his job, but then showing the casket, I think that's ridiculous.

Unidentified Student: I think it's twofold. Yes it's personal, but also the public should also know how many of these young men and women are being killed over there.

Photo of flowers and flag SEVERSON: That's the reasoning often used by opponents of the picture prohibition, that the administration doesn't want to publicize the cost of the Iraq war in American lives.

Dr. SAM HOFF (History Professor, Delaware State University): There is one thing that doesn't lie. The caskets don't lie.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
SEVERSON: It's been called the "Dover test," a reference to the pictures of coffins arriving at Dover Air Force Base. Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Henry Shelton, used the term in 1999, referring to the negative impact the pictures of caskets had on public support for the Vietnam War.

Photo of SAM HOFF Dr. HOFF: His very simple point was, before you commit American troops to foreign conflicts, you have to understand the ramifications of what occurs; you know, people die. And if the American people are not prepared for seeing those caskets in that manner, then they better think twice about supporting a conflict abroad.

SEVERSON: Vicky Langley thinks there ought to be a coffin ceremony at Dover and that it should be televised.

Ms. LANGLEY: They stand there and tell us that our sons and daughters will never be forgotten by anybody. But yet they don't want to show that and show the respect they are treated with. You know, if people are going to remember, you can't keep it a secret.

SEVERSON: Kirk Morris says there was nothing secret about his son's death.

Mr. MORRIS: I did not close the funeral. I did not close the memorial service for my son. You would have been very welcome there.

SEVERSON: Professor Hoff says the debate about pictures of war dead goes all the way back to the Civil War.

Photo of flowers and flag Dr. HOFF: If those pictures would have been broadcast or publicized at the time, we may never have gotten Gettysburg because of the extreme loss of life on both sides.

SEVERSON: In World War I, allies were so worried about flagging support for the war they made it a crime to bring a camera to the front lines.

In World War II, President Roosevelt deliberately lifted censorship because he wanted Americans to understand that they had to make sacrifices.

Photo of Gifford gravesite The ban on pictures here at Dover was imposed by the first President Bush. It was after the networks carried a split screen showing the president laughing at a press conference. The other screen showed the grim pictures of the caskets of U.S. soldiers killed in the invasion of Panama, arriving at Dover. The split screen left an unfair impression and an angry president.

SEVERSON: But after the first war with Iraq, the edict was often lifted or ignored during the Clinton Administration.

Cameras were allowed at Dover for the coffin ceremony of Commerce Secretary Ron Brown and 32 others who died in a plane crash in Bosnia in 1996. And for the victims of the embassy bombing in Kenya in August 1998. And again for the sailors killed in the terrorist bombing of the USS Cole in October 2000. Cameras were also allowed by the current Bush administration for Americans killed in Afghanistan, at least in the beginning.

Vicky Langley believes the administration is deliberately censoring pictures of her son Jonathan's coffin, as with all the others. According to a recent NEW YORK TIMES poll, 62 percent of Americans think the public should be allowed to see pictures of coffins of soldiers killed in Iraq.

Photo of VICKY LANGLEY Ms. LANGLEY: I don't think they want people to know how many are dying, but people have the right to know.

SEVERSON: Kirk Morris is resolutely in favor of the photo ban.

Mr. MORRIS: Do we need to see the bodies to know the numbers? I believe these pictures give the potential of a narrow-minded general public, the impression that young men are dying, therefore we need to pull out. Not [that] young men are dying because the cost of freedom is so high.

SEVERSON: Kirk is making plans to build a memorial to his son behind the family home. It's the big picture that his son gave his life for his country, he says that's most important. Not all the small pictures of flag-draped coffins.

For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Lucky Severson in Gurnee, Illinois.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP