Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Democrats and Religion
July 23, 2004    Episode no. 747
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
Photo of John Edwards
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: Religion continues to be one important factor in how people vote. A majority of Americans say they want a president who is religious. But there is deep ambivalence about how much the president should talk about -- and be guided by -- religious beliefs. Many Republican politicians talk openly about faith, while Democrats are perceived as being less comfortable with religious language. Is there a "God gap" in American politics? Kim Lawton has our special report on Democrats and religion.

Photo of kids holding vote sign KIM LAWTON: In the heart of Texas Bush country, kids at the Central Dallas Ministries day camp are getting a civics lesson about voting. The goal is to encourage their parents and their neighbors to register to vote. It's part of a project to help low-income people get their voices heard.

The Reverend Larry James is executive director of the faith-based ministry. The voting project is nonpartisan, but James is a lifelong Democrat -- a Democrat who is frustrated with how his party is handling religion right now.

Reverend LARRY JAMES (Central Dallas Ministries): The Republican Party has carried away the issue of faith, and the popular notion is that Democrats are not people of faith.

LAWTON: Analysts say this election season Democratic leaders have struggled over how to deal with religion.

Photo of SHAUN CASEY Dr. SHAUN CASEY (Professor of Christian Ethics, Wesley Theological Seminary): On the one hand, they read the polls. They understand the demographics of the country, which would lead one to say that religion is extremely important in this current election. They see the need, but on the other hand, they lack the experience, they lack the confidence, frankly, to reach out to those communities with great ease.

LAWTON: According to recent surveys, the more often voters attend religious services, the more likely they are to vote Republican. The majority of Americans say they like expressions of faith from their politicians. Forty-one percent believe there haven't been enough such expressions. This poses some big political challenges for Democrats.

MIKE MCCURRY (Public Strategies Group): Many Democrats are not accustomed to speaking of their faith and relating their faith to political action. This is something that's just not part, hasn't been part of the culture of the party. So it's a new vocabulary for many Democrats, and I think that's what we're getting used to.

Photo of ROSA DELAURO Representative ROSA DELAURO (D-CT): We shouldn't shy away from that. We should say it because it reflects who we are and what we are about, and people should know that.

LAWTON: Connecticut Representative Rosa DeLauro is a Roman Catholic who chaired the Democratic Platform Committee. She says Democrats need to more actively communicate what motivates their policies.

Rep. DELAURO: There is a nexus between religion and politics. We do have a separation of church and state. No one is talking about going over those bounds. In my view, Republicans use politics to push religion. I don't believe we ought to emulate that. But what we ought to do is reflect our values in the work that we do. And we ought to say it. We ought to say it.

LAWTON: President Bill Clinton's former press secretary, Mike McCurry, is an active United Methodist. He's also among the few high-profile Democrats urging the party to pay more attention to religion. He admits this is not always a welcome message.

Photo of MIKE MCCURRY Mr. MCCURRY: I think it's met with discomfort by some party leaders. I think some people are just not comfortable wearing their religion on the sleeve. And particularly, if you are imbued with certain Yankee taciturnity, like a certain candidate we have running for president, it's not a natural thing to talk about a faith life, even though in the case of Senator Kerry, he happens to be a particularly faithful person.

LAWTON: Religion has been tricky for Kerry and his campaign, as evidenced by the highly publicized flap over whether he should receive Communion in Catholic churches because of his stand in favor of abortion rights. The candidate himself is reluctant to make connections between faith and politics, as he acknowledged in a December interview with the Interfaith Alliance.

Senator JOHN KERRY (Speaking to Interfaith Alliance): Affairs of state are affairs of state, and they ought to be based on the discussion we have day to day about how we fund education or how big the military ought to be. And affairs of faith are affairs of faith. And they're separated.

LAWTON: But many grassroots Democrats believe the two areas should be more connected. In Dallas, Larry James has dedicated his life to helping the poor. His Central Dallas Ministries has a multipronged approach that includes a massive food bank as well as medical, legal, and housing assistance. James says all the projects are directly motivated by religious beliefs.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
Rev. JAMES: Isaiah is replete with passage after passage of how God's people collectively are responsible for caring for the least among them. The law of Moses, the Torah, is filled with passage after passage on how an economy is to be structured so that no one is left behind. The values, the deep, deeply rooted values of justice, fairness, equity, how an economy is supposed to work -- all those things need to be reclaimed theologically by the Democrats.

LAWTON: Democrats, James says, can emphasize these broad spiritual values without coming across as self-righteous or exclusive.

Photo of LARRY JAMES Rev. JAMES: And if I were John Kerry or John Edwards, I think I'd get with some astute theologians and I'd hammer out some of these, because I think that resonates with Christians and with Jewish folk and with Muslims as well, to say nothing of Buddhists and Hindus and others, because these values are in all the holy texts.

LAWTON: The key, according to Mike McCurry, is being authentic and not appearing to pander to or exploit religion.

Mr. MCCURRY: I'd like Democrats to not, you know, brazenly do what Republicans sometimes do, which is to lead with a faux religion. I would really like to see Democrats speak genuinely and authentically about how religion and how faith informs the positions we take on so many issues.

Rep. DELAURO: I also say that one has to take a look at deeds and not just words or photographs. Both John Kerry and John Edwards have demonstrated by their deeds that they are men of faith, that they are men of values.

LAWTON: Another aspect of the dilemma is the growing group of Americans who identify themselves as "secular." In 2000, they accounted for 20 percent of Al Gore's total vote. Many of them agree with Joanna Citron Day, a local Democratic activist who doesn't want to see any more religion injected into the campaign.

Photo of JOANNA CITRON DAY JOANNA CITRON DAY (Democratic Activist): Religion really doesn't have a place in American politics, and I think that it's not about, you know, what your religious background is. Really, it's public service to all Americans, regardless of their religion. So why should your religion as a candidate or as president play into it?

Dr. CASEY: There's a fear, frankly, that they may alienate part of their own base, the so-called "seculars" or "nonreligious" -- that if a Democratic candidate appears too explicitly religious, that may alienate part of their base.

LAWTON: But in an electorate that is so evenly divided, Casey says, both parties also need to persuade undecided religious swing voters, especially the undecided in key states.

Dr. CASEY: You see Roman Catholic voters represented in large percentages, but also very significant evangelical constituencies as well. If you're going to persuade those folks, you need to come at them with every possible persuasive lever, and religion happens to be one of those most persuasive levers among those undecided voters.

LAWTON: In recent days, the Kerry campaign appears to be trying. They've hired a point person for outreach to religious communities and established a special area on the official Web site for people of faith, complete with buttons and bumper stickers.

Photo of John Edwards Many Democrats were hoping John Edwards would bring the ticket more comfort in dealing with religion. Edwards is a United Methodist who has been active in the National Prayer Breakfast. So far, on the stump he's been talking a lot about values, but not explicitly tying those values to religion.

Both Edwards and Kerry have made obligatory election-year visits to black churches, another core constituency for Democrats. During a speech to the African Methodist Episcopal denomination earlier this month, Kerry indicated that faith does indeed have a role in his political agenda.

Sen. KERRY (During Speech): We should never separate our highest beliefs and our values from our treatment of one another and our conduct of the people's business.

LAWTON: Experts say he'll have to offer still more details in order to convince religious voters.

Dr. CASEY: He needs to take the time in telling his own story about how his own faith has shaped his politics. That's going to resonate with a lot of religiously motivated voters in this country. If he chooses not to do that, then he allows the other candidate, frankly, to fill in the blanks for him, and I suspect that will not be a very pretty picture.

LAWTON: And in a race as tight as this one appears, the stakes are high. Every voter convinced could make all the difference. I'm Kim Lawton reporting.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP