Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Cover
Feature
Web Exclusive

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Women in Mosques
November 12, 2004    Episode no. 811
Read This Week's May 9, 2008
Go
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: In this country, immigrants of many faiths have struggled to adapt their traditional practices to American culture. Now, some American Muslims are trying to change the way mosques treat women. Muslim men and women traditionally pray in separate spaces, but in some mosques, women say their space is second-class. Bob Faw has the story.

BOB FAW: Outside this sanctuary, this oasis of calm, a storm is brewing.

Dr. INGRID MATTSON (Professor of Islamic Studies, Hartford Seminary): I would say there's a large group of women who feel that change isn't happening quickly enough.

FAW: Here, where the only voice heard is that of the prayer leader, or imam, other voices -- women's voices -- are trying to be heard.

Photo of sign reading 'Sisters Only' DR. MUQTEDAR KHAN (Director of International Studies, Adrian College, Michigan): They are not being treated as they see us men are being treated. They resent it; they are being discriminated [against]; they are very angry.

FAW: Women like journalist Asra Nomani. From her hometown in West Virginia she's taken to the streets, arguing that in mosques women are second-class -- that when it comes to prayer, Muslim women should be treated just like men.

Photo of ASRA NOMANI ASRA NOMANI (Journalist): Ultimately, barriers that are placed in front of women are barriers to full participation and leadership in our communities. They're symbolic of this greater denial of women's rights that we have to confront in the Muslim world.

FAW: By "barriers" she means women praying in balconies, behind glass; praying not with men but behind unwieldy partitions; cordoned off from men by lace curtains -- shunted aside, she argues, where they can't see or hear as well as the men.

Ms. NOMANI: I felt so depressed. I felt angry. I felt like I was nothing.

Photo of Muslim women behind glass FAW: She's not the only Muslim woman complaining. In this Boston mosque, Nakia Jackson and other women pray facing not the imam, but shelves used for shoes. Nakia is offended that women here are relegated to cramped and dirty quarters.

NAKIA JACKSON: They are urine stains. There was someone staying here who was ill and therefore incontinent, and these stains have been here for a number of years. And it is often used as an all-purpose room that has been shown very little respect, and I see that as a disrespect to the women who pray there.

FAW: Two voices in a movement that is growing.

Dr. MATTSON: I do find in many communities, maybe most communities, women feeling that they still need more voice in their community.

FAW: There were no barriers initially when women prayed in the same hall as the Prophet Muhammad, and many Muslims maintain that separation of the sexes is necessary to avoid distractions.

Photo of Muslim woman in burka Dr. KHAN: Over a period of time, a body of law emerged. In order to protect the wife, to have more security, they started introducing the whole business of veiling and separating women from the society and so on. So that sort of encouraged patriarchy. That group continued to marginalize women from the public sphere, and their unequal status in the mosque is a reflection of that same marginalization.

FAW: But clerics like Imam Abdullah Farruuq point out that attendance at Friday service is mandatory for men and merely optional for women, and often, he says, small mosques like his in Boston must be practical.

ABDULLAH FARRUUQ (Mosque for the Praising of Allah): We don't have adequate room to provide on the same level prayer space for both men and women around. We are a poor group, and we are doing the best we can. It's an economic issue.

FAW: For many Muslim women, the present prayer arrangements are acceptable.

Photo of HAFEEZA BELL HAFEEZA BELL: When you are with the women, you are with the women. You talk about things, you know. Womanly things, you know. With the brothers, you don't. We don't mingle with the brothers. That's the way it's stated. You know, women should be with the women, and men should be with the brothers.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
FAW: And because prayer for Muslims requires both space and movement, even some liberal Muslim scholars concede that women should pray in separate areas.

Dr. KHAN: If there was a woman, I don't know whether I would be able to concentrate on my prayer or not. So, on that ground alone, I would not be comfortable praying with women shoulder to shoulder.

FAW: But Asra and the others say this issue isn't comfort. It is justice.

Photo of Muslim women in room Ms. NOMANI: It's not at all about carpet space. It's not at all about how many chandeliers the men have versus the women. It's about whether our voices can be heard. It's just that simple.

FAW: In other words, the debate here isn't just about theology; it's also about empowerment.

Photo of MUQTEDAR KHAN Dr. KHAN: Muslim women are beginning to ask this question as to what is our role in speaking for Islam. I think the debate of Muslim women's place in the mosque is actually a metaphor for the debate in the community about the role of Muslim women in the public sphere and leadership.

FAW: Despite the signs, no one is saying mosques are men's clubs. But few Muslim women serve on boards which govern mosques. In nearly all affairs of the mosque, men -- especially the imam -- have the final say.

Photo of INGRID MATTSON Dr. MATTSON: Often the problem is people who do not have a very strong education, a solid theological education in Islamic sciences, mistake rigidity for piety, because they have a very narrow knowledge base. Whatever they know, they stick to.

Dr. KHAN: Not everybody is able to see the big picture. So some traditionalists in mosques essentially feel threatened of their own individual position and authority in that particular mosque.

FAW: Imams like Abdullah Faaruuq feel bound by tradition.

Photo of Iman Abdullah Faaruuq Imam FARRUUQ: When men pray with men, they are not attracted to the opposite sex; when women pray with women, they are not attracted to the opposite sex. I am living a tradition that is 1,400 years old; nothing is going to change from it.

FAW: In Seattle, Washington, Muslim women and men pray in the same room, as do women in many mosques all over the country. But Asra has been asked to leave her mosque, has even received death threats, largely because she has been so public with her complaints.

Dr. KHAN: She's not seen as a reformer from within the community; she is seen as an agent of the West who is intruding into Islamic theological practices.

FAW: Despite the criticism, Asra Nomani isn't wavering.

Ms. NOMANI: We're at a crossroads, because we can either build the kind of vibrant, inclusive community that the Prophet Muhammad built in Medina, or we can really sink to the lowest fears that we've got.

Photo of Muslim women praying FAW: It's a struggle others have waged when they've come to this country and found that equality -- applauded and sought outside -- was not carried over into places of worship. A struggle here which will not only shape the practice of Islam in America, but also its character.

Dr. KHAN: It is very American in that sense. What you are seeing is the clash of progressiveness against conservatism. This is also a sign of the democratization of the Muslim community, that is, the battle for equality.

FAW: Here, where some places of worship have become battleground, where prayer, meant to bring believers together, is tearing some apart.

For RELIGION AND ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Bob Faw in Chicago.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP