Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

FEATURE:
Iowa Cougars
June 10, 2005    Episode no. 841
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: There's an issue in Iowa and other parts of the Midwest that raises the question: What should humans do about endangered but also dangerous animals? Kill them, capture them, or leave them alone? What if you saw, or thought you saw, a cougar -- also known as a mountain lion -- in your backyard? Lucky Severson went looking for cougars early this past spring.

LUCKY SEVERSON: This is Iowa: 55,000 square miles of soybeans and cornfields. Before the farms, the landscape was wild prairie. Cougars prowled the high grass.

That was way back when -- back when settlers like Alice Walsh were first farming Iowa's rich soil in the mid-1800s. But now it seems the cougars are back: a few tracks in the river bottoms, an unlikely picture.

Photo of hunters with dead cougar Several cougars have been killed -- a cold welcome after an absence of almost 140 years. More are out there haunting farmers and terrifying mothers and raising the question, Can man and beast survive together in today's world? Does man have an ethical duty to protect the beasts among us, even when they're dangerous? Would we be the less if they disappeared?

Listen to Ron Andrews.

RON ANDREWS (Biologist, Iowa Department of Natural Resources): It would be a crying shame on earth when we lose an animal, and particularly an animal that's been abundant in Iowa. I just hope it doesn't happen.

SEVERSON: Of course, this may be only hypothetical because many of the reports are simply hearsay. The only place you're certain to see a real cougar in Iowa is a zoo, or Rick Braaksma's farmyard.

Photo of cougar He keeps Harley and Cheyenne in a makeshift cage that was built to hold corncobs.

RICK BRAAKSMA (Farmyard Owner): There's been a lot of people out to look at them.

SEVERSON: But it's not pet cougars in corncribs that are attracting so much attention in Iowa; it's wild cougars on the loose in the countryside.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN (At Town Meeting): About 10 days ago, about, I saw two together early in the morning about 8:30 -- going in just, like, just complete rhythm.

SEVERSON: Over the past 18 months, there have been 21 documented cougar sightings in nine Midwestern states, including Iowa -- places cougars aren't supposed to be and aren't welcome.

Photo of Iowa neighborhood Iowa has the least amount of public lands of any state in the country, hardly anything you would call wilderness. There's a farm on nearly every horizon. So why are mountain lions immigrating here?

Wildlife experts say the reappearance of mountain lions out on the flatlands can be traced to mankind and mismanagement. There's no longer enough room in the mountain West for the expanding cougar population, so they're moving eastward.

James Mahaffy is a professor of zoology who maintains a Web site that tracks Iowa cougars.

Photo of JAMES MAHAFFY Dr. JAMES MAHAFFY (Biology Professor, Dordt College, Sioux Center, IA): Because of the biology of the cougars, males have to -- when they wean from Mom -- have to leave the territory, or Dad will kill them.

SEVERSON: There's been no official poll, but most Iowans seem to agree with Gary and Jason Klaiber and their hunting dogs about having cougars in their backyard.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
GARY KLAIBER (Hunter): All the hunters feel the same way I do. They don't think we need these cougars underfoot, and talking to their neighbors, their neighbors just -- nobody wants mountain lions around.

SEVERSON: Mahaffy does. He believes preventing the demise of the cougar is man's moral responsibility.

Photo of Dr. MAHAFFY: The Lord gave us a responsibility to be stewards, or care for the animals. And that's my belief, and [it] springs also from my Christian beliefs.

SEVERSON: Until the early 1900s, most midwestern states viewed cougars as varmints, a menace to civilized man, and they were wiped out. In Iowa, they've been gone so long they have no legal status at all.

Given the cougar's nonstatus, there was no legal or ethical consideration when the Klaibers were called in with their radio-collared coon dogs to track down a cougar.

Photo of JASON KLAIBER JASON KLAIBER (Hunter): And I didn't go right in under the tree because, you know, I didn't know how the thing would act. I just stood back and shot it.

SEVERSON: Over the past 110 years, wild cats have attacked 117 people in the U.S. and Canada and killed 19, considerably fewer than fatal bee stings. But the rate of cougar attacks has increased sharply since 1970, largely because the boundaries separating man and beast have been disappearing.

Photo of town meeting Mr. ANDREWS (At Town Meeting): But it's scaring a lot of people. But I'm also saying there is no reason for you to, you know, quit going outdoors, quit enjoying the great outdoors, that sort of thing. That is absurd.

SEVERSON: This is a town meeting conducted by Ron Andrews, a biologist for the Iowa Department of Natural Resources. He's been spending a lot of time explaining the cougar situation.

Photo of RON ANDREWS Mr. ANDREWS: First of all, people for the most part that live on the land hate these things, and they're going to kill them, given the opportunity.

SEVERSON: Any attempt to put cougars on the Iowa endangered species list will almost certainly be defeated, but the Sierra Club's Wally Taylor is going to try.

(To Mr. Taylor): There are some people who would say, "Why protect dangerous animals?"

Photo of WALLY TAYLOR WALLY TAYLOR (Legal Council, Sierra Club, Iowa): Well, humans are dangerous sometimes, too. If you learn to live with them and give them enough space, they're not going to be a problem for humans.

SEVERSON: The dilemma, 'most everyone agrees, is that there is no longer enough space, enough wilderness, to dedicate to dangerous wild animals. Nor is there the public will.

Mr. ANDREWS: It's got to be a wonderful experience if you just savor the moment of seeing a mountain lion and realize that you're one of the few people that have had that great experience.

Photo of construction SEVERSON: As we continue to invade their territory and, as a result, they ours, it's an experience that may become more common, unless someone gets hurt. Then what happens to the cougar? Will they survive -- only in a cage?

For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Lucky Severson in Chariton, Iowa.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP