Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Pregnancy Centers
June 24, 2005    Episode no. 843
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
Video - Watch this story
Requires Real Player
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: As the national standoff continues over abortion, there is a new practice in growing use designed to discourage women from ending pregnancies. At anti-abortion women's clinics, free sonograms are permitting women to see images of their fetuses, and those pictures seem to be persuading more women not to abort. Lucky Severson reports.

Unidentified Nurse: And that's the baby's head, and this is the spine.

LUCKY SEVERSON: This is Tina Minshall's fourth sonogram at the Women's Clinic in Jacksonville, Florida.

TINA MINSHALL (Patient, Women's Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida): I've had several here because there's times when I wonder and doubt. You know, did I make the right decision? Am I making the right decision?

Unidentified Nurse: You can see the heart. This is the heart -- valves opening and closing.

SEVERSON: Now when she sees the sign of life in her belly, she knows she made the right decision not to have an abortion. The first sonogram was the turning point.

(to Ms. Minshall): What did you see in that ultrasound?

Photo of TINA MINSHALL Ms. MINSHALL: A little bitty thing, it looks like a kidney bean. But it has a little heartbeat. And that's mine. That's a life. That's mine -- I made that.

SEVERSON: Pregnancy centers are usually free. Women often come to these places thinking they can get an abortion, but that's the last thing they'll find.

Colleen Garson, director of the Women's Clinic, says the mission here is to prevent abortions.

COLLEEN GARSON (Director, Women's Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida): It does have a religious undertone. We were started by a religious group.

SEVERSON: Her clinic is funded in part by the Catholic Church, and last year she counseled almost 1,800 girls.

Photo of COLLEEN GARSON Ms. GARSON: If they call and they ask, you know, "Do you do abortions here?" I will say, "No, we don't." I will not, you know, try to drag it out. I'll just say, "No, we don't do it. But I have information for you."

SEVERSON: Her information is about the health and psychological risks of abortion, but the biggest news is that the woman can look at a free sonogram of her tiny fetus. Some clinics even offer three-dimensional sonograms with life-like images, although the machines are still too expensive for most clinics. But the costs are often underwritten by religious organizations, including Catholics and Southern Baptists.

In many communities, these centers now outnumber Planned Parenthood clinics, and Karen Pearl, executive director of Planned Parenthood, says they often do more harm than good.

Photo of pregnancy center KAREN PEARL (Executive Director, Planned Parenthood): They pretend to be centers that women think when they go in there will be providing unbiased information. They're not providing good women's care. They're actually not providing women with the information that they need. They're lying to women. They're deceiving women. They're manipulating women.

SEVERSON: Young women we spoke with, like Sheila Valdomar at the Jacksonville clinic, said they did not feel coerced into keeping their baby.

Sheila was 16. Her mother had told her she would kick her out of the house if she got pregnant.

(to Sheila Valdomar): So when you found out you were pregnant, what went through your mind?

SHEILA VALDOMAR (Patient, Women's Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida): I was just scared.

SEVERSON: So Sheila called the Jacksonville Women's Clinic.

(to Ms. Valdomar): Why did you call this place?

Photo of SHEILA VALDOMAR Ms. VALDOMAR: I wanted to know how much an abortion was. I really did. I know six people off the top of my head who have had them. A lot of my friends were telling me, "Oh, just get it done. Hurry, quick. You know, don't even think about it."

SEVERSON (to Ms. Valdomar): So you thought this was an abortion clinic?

Ms. VALDOMAR: Yeah, kind of, yeah.

SEVERSON: When Sheila called the clinic, Colleen answered.

Ms. VALDOMAR: She started telling me what could happen to me if I had an abortion.

SEVERSON: If you had an abortion it might ...

(simultaneously) Ms. VALDOMAR: ... increase your chance of breast cancer.

SEVERSON: My understanding was that doctors now say that's not true.

Ms. GARSON: Well, that's what we -- that's what the -- all of the information had come to us that it did.

Ms. PEARL: That's been shown not to be true in study after study after study. And that's a rumor that goes around. But it is simply not true.

Photo of sign reading 'Chapel of the Unborn' SEVERSON: Critics say these pregnancy clinics offer only information that suits their ideology or misleading information -- that they literally scare young women out of getting abortions.

Karen Pearl says unlike the so-called pregnancy clinics, Planned Parenthood counsels women on all their options, not just one.

Continue to top of next colum
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
Ms. PEARL: What we take very seriously at Planned Parenthood is the obligation to make sure that women are told truths, are told true facts based in science -- not based in ideology -- that are based in medicine, that are not meant to scare people.

SEVERSON: Sheila said she was told if she had an abortion, she couldn't get pregnant again. Not true.

Ms. VALDOMAR: That scared me. She gave me a card to sign that -- basically a document that the doctor had to sign to hold them responsible for the procedure they were doing on me. She gave me one of those just in case, because I told her, "Yeah I'm going to get my abortion."

Photo of Valdomar and Kayleen Rosales SEVERSON: But in the end, Sheila didn't have an abortion. She had Kayleen Rosales, now eight months old.

(to Ms. Valdomar): What was it that convinced you not to get an abortion?

Ms. VALDOMAR: The sonogram.

SEVERSON: Colleen Garson says before she bought the sonogram, only about 40 percent of women chose not to abort their fetuses. Since the sonogram that rate has gone up considerably.

Ms. GARSON: It's really nice to give the girls an opportunity to actually see their baby. We -- it changes their minds and their hearts.

SEVERSON: It was the sonogram that convinced Tina not to get an abortion. She's 33. The pregnancy was unexpected.

Ms. MINSHALL: My child is going to be biracial, and there are a few family members that I'm very, very close to that probably won't be able to accept that. And I hope in the end that they can. If they can't accept it, well then, I feel sorry for them. But my child's not going to die for it.

Ms. PEARL: This sonogram is not being used for medical purposes. It's being used for ideological purposes.

SEVERSON: Unlike many pregnancy centers, the Jacksonville Women's Clinic has a medical professional on hand. Judy Timby is a retired nurse.

Photo of JUDY TIMBY JUDY TIMBY (Retired Nurse): We're having a lot of success because the girls are taught in school that this is a blob of tissue -- and if they can see that little heartbeat.

SEVERSON: She is first and foremost a nurse but says this is a religious calling.

(to Ms. Timby): If you thought the best thing in terms of helping them was to have an abortion, would you advise that?

Ms. TIMBY: I would never advise an abortion. I would give them the information. That is their decision. We don't tell them what they should do.

SEVERSON: Like many women who work in both abortion and pregnancy clinics, Colleen Garson is doing the work because of a personal experience -- in her case, a daughter she dearly loves that she almost aborted.

Ms. GARSON: It's a very uneasy, unsettling time, and women need love, affection, support.

SEVERSON: Colleen says she can't understand why Planned Parenthood doesn't provide routine sonograms.

Photo of Karen Pearl Ms. PEARL: If a woman wants to see a sonogram, we would make that available to her. But that's her choice. That's not part of the coercive care that's given to force a decision, to put people down a particular path. Women have three options when they're facing a pregnancy. They can continue and deliver and choose to parent that child. They can continue and deliver and use adoption services. Or they can terminate the pregnancy and have an abortion. At Planned Parenthood we don't have a value on any one of those.

Unidentified Nurse: It looks like the baby is praying there -- kneeling, praying.

SEVERSON: It is rapidly becoming one of the most effective tools in the battle against abortion. But critics caution that a sonogram cannot raise a child.

Ms. VALDOMAR (feeding Kayleen): Yummy.

SEVERSON (to Ms. Valdomar): Is it tough?

Ms. VALDOMAR: Being a mom and still trying to be young?

SEVERSON (to Ms. Valdomar): Yeah.

Ms. VALDOMAR: Yes, it's hard, and school, and sometimes I do feel like I'm kind of trapped.

SEVERSON: And Sheila has only been taught that birth control can cause sexually transmitted diseases, not that it works most of the time.

(to Ms. Valdomar): In the future will you use contraceptives?

Ms. VALDOMAR: Well, yes, but I haven't used any now. But, you know, I'm not, I'm being...

SEVERSON (to Ms. Valdomar): Did they tell you here that maybe you should?

Ms. VALDOMAR: No, they didn't. I don't think they referred to that kind of thing.

Photo of sonogram SEVERSON: Sheila and Kayleen are the only proof needed at the clinic that they're doing God's work. That's why religious organizations plan to fund even more pregnancy clinics with sonograms.

For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I'm Lucky Severson in Jacksonville, Florida.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP