Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

COVER STORY:
Kashmir Earthquake Relief Update
April 7, 2006    Episode no. 932
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: Kashmir has long been as troubled as it is beautiful. Fought over by India and Pakistan, it was devastated last October by an earthquake that killed perhaps 80,000 people. There were fears that winter would kill many more. But the worst did not happen. There's an enormous amount of reconstruction to be done, but massive relief work and a relatively mild winter have permitted the Pakistan government to insist now that earthquake refugees leave their camps and go home -- or to where home used to be. Fred de Sam Lazaro has the story.

Photo of People helping FRED DE SAM LAZARO: Not since Berlin after World War II has the world seen a humanitarian airlift on this scale. The airlift began last October. The earthquake wiped out a vast impoverished region isolated among the earth's tallest mountains. Relief workers had feared a second wave of exposure-related deaths over winter, especially among those who remained in the most remote villages -- places cut off after the quake. But spring arrived, and from all accounts a catastrophe was averted. In this village of Ghaipur, Shukriya Jan and her family got by in this tiny shed built near their collapsed home. It has served as kitchen and bedroom for nine people.

SHUKRIYA JAN (Through Translator): We used the warm clothes that we had before the earthquake. It was difficult, but God provided.

DE SAM LAZARO: More importantly, people here say God provided a mild winter. Also, some 300,000 people moved to tent camps with easier access to relief supplies. But now the government, which urged people into these camps, says it's time for them to go back.

ALTAF SALEEM (Chair, Pakistan Earthquake Recovery Committee): We have to take people back to their own place. If we linger on too long unnecessarily in the tents, there's the tendency to get used to easy supply of food, and this can create problems in the future.

DE SAM LAZARO: To keep people from becoming dependent on handouts, Pakistan's government ordered all free food distribution stopped last month, except to those widowed or maimed in the quake. The government promised money to build small homes, but not until after people have returned.

Photo of shelter Mr. SALEEM: The sooner they move to their homeland, the quicker they can start construction. And this will help them so they can make a shelter available to them before the next winter comes. I think we are looking at everybody moving to that place and starting their life in the next two months or so. I think 85 percent to 90 percent of people will move back and start some kind of construction.

DE SAM LAZARO: International agencies share the government's concern about fostering a climate of dependence. They will continue providing food, but now it will be in exchange for work, like clearing rubble. They've also promised seeds and farm tools, but they think the transition will take much longer.

KEITH URSEL (World Food Program): Most of them are going back to the same destroyed village or the same destroyed house or agriculture land that they left six months ago. That's why they left. So those people going back, we do consider them quite vulnerable.

DE SAM LAZARO: To ease the transition, relief workers are making sure returnees like the family of Mohammad Din are fit to travel -- that they have adequate provisions. After hours of loading and waiting, the convoy left north for the Neelum Valley. The treacherous drive is just one reminder of the legacy of the earthquake: almost daily landslides. A couple of hours later, Mohammad Din's family was dropped off six miles from their former home. The last stretch is accessible only on foot -- another two hours. For the moment he decided to join several relatives who had earlier pitched their tents in this spot.

MOHAMMED DIN (Through Translator): They told us, "Go to your village." So what could we do? They said, "You'll get everything there. Here in the camp you won't get anything." They said, "You'll be able to get building materials."

DE SAM LAZARO: But how to find a lot to build on? Din lost not only his home, but his property was buried under a landslide.

Mr. DIN (Through Translator): Never mind the money. There's just nowhere to stand. The government said they would give us 150,000 rupees. If I can get land, that would be enough to build a house. But until that time, we'll live in a tent.

Continue to top of next colum
Watch This Report
Requires Real Player or Windows Media Player
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
NOOR JEHAN (Through Translator): There are 10 people in this tent. The kids have no shoes, no clothes. It's cold in the tents, and we sleep together under a quilt.

DE SAM LAZARO: The extended family of Noor Jehan has been struggling to rebuild since last December. When we visited them then, they worried about the winter, living in a tent camp near Muzaffarabad. Noor Jehan's son Aslam stayed behind to begin salvaging and rebuilding at the family homestead -- three collapsed buildings that killed nine members of the family. Four months later, he's still pounding and clearing rubble. But they do have pre-temporary dwellings now, enough sleeping accommodations for all 20 family members. But sleep does not come easily for Noor Jehan.

Photo of survivors Ms. JEHAN (Through Translator): His son died (pointing to her left). His son died (pointing to her right). So many people in this family lie under the soil. So many young ones have gone. I don't even sleep.

DE SAM LAZARO: They worry whether the promised assistance will reach them by winter. The compensation offered won't fully cover building costs, they add, and materials are hard to find. The tent camps may well return.

DARREN BOISVERT (International Organization for Migration): Well, we are making plans for the winter. There will be some needs for -- emergency shelter needs -- next winter. Talking to World Food Program, I mean, they have already pre-positioned a lot of the food up in the upper elevations where people need to get home.

DE SAM LAZARO: The World Food Program itself is running out of money for its helicopters. The alternative -- trucks -- take longer and reach far fewer places.

Mr. URSEL: I don't think anyone will starve. However, it's going to be tremendous burden on the family to have to be walking days to go get, you know, food for the family, and have them walk days to go back with it on their backs. It's a tremendous burden, because we want people to be spending their time building their houses, getting their farmland going, building up their stock of livestock.

Photo of People helping DE SAM LAZARO: His agency has appealed for more funds, but there's growing concern that with the acute phase over, Pakistan will be like many other areas -- from Darfur to Iran -- that are contending for humanitarian aid. Pakistan's government received pledges of $6 billion in international aid for long-term rebuilding.

Out of the rubble of this tragedy, Altaf Saleem says, is a unique opportunity to rebuild a region and improve its standard of living.

Mr. SALEEM: There are close to 6,000 schools that need to be built; 800 medical facilities including basic health units; bigger hospitals. There are two universities that [have] to be built. So I think a lot of money will go there. And there's the transportation sector, we have to build some bridges, some roads, some waterworks. You will realize that, you know, this infrastructure was built over a 58-year time frame, and it collapsed in less than 58 seconds. And, you know, people expect that we will rebuild them in 58 days. It has to take longer.

DE SAM LAZARO: The most immediate challenge is just keeping the roads clear to help people return -- also to maintain their links to the rest of the world. Much of the earth remains unstable after the quake. So a region unsettled for decades by war will remain literally unsettled for years to come.

For RELIGION AND ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, this is Fred De Sam Lazaro in the Neelum Valley of Pakistan-administered Kashmir.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP