Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly -- An online companion to the weekly television news program
Keyword Search
Topic Index Stories by Week
Home
Current Stories

Perspectives
Profile
Web Exclusive
Survey

Headlines
Election Coverage
Special Issues
TV Schedule
Calendar
Newsletter
Subscribe or unsubscribe to the E-mail Newsletter, or edit your preferences.
The Series
About the Series
Funding
Biographies
Awards
Credits
For Teachers
Overview
Lesson Plan List
Tips
Teacher Resources
Resources
Viewer's Guides
Videotapes
Featured Sites
Feedback
Contact Us
Story Suggestions

FEATURE:
San Francisco's Homeless
June 23, 2006    Episode no. 943
Read This Week's November 7, 2008
Go
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: The religious obligation to help the poor and homeless has been a challenge for many people of goodwill, especially in cities with large homeless populations. But in San Francisco, a collection of new programs does seem to be working, at least for those most in need. Saul Gonzales reports.

SAUL GONZALEZ: The Golden Gate Bridge, graceful hilltop neighborhoods and, of course, the cable cars: These are the picture postcard sights that make San Franciscans proud of their city. But what often casts a shadow over their pride are other sights — the more than 5,000 homeless people who try to survive on this city’s streets.One of them is Kathleen Reeves, who panhandles with a friend near Union Square.

KATHLEEN REEVES: Can you please help us?

GONZALEZ: She says she has no choice if she’s going to eat.

Photo of Reeves Ms. REEVES: Why do you think I’m out here begging for money? I don’t like begging. I don’t. But I have to.

GONZALEZ: For years, San Francisco’s city government developed strategy after strategy to deal with homelessness, from the opening of temporary shelters to restrictions on panhandling. But nothing seemed to reduce the number of the city’s street people. Then, in 2003, San Francisicans elected Gavin Newsom mayor. He pledged to introduce new initiatives to end chronic homelessness in the city within 10 years.

Photo of Newsom GAVIN NEWSOM (Mayor, San Francisco): It’s a moral shame. It’s an assault on everyone —the old adage you can’t live a good life in an unjust society — to see in visual terms our failure as a society, to try to go about your day-to-day life where you’re stepping over someone on the sidewalk or you’re seeing someone passed out on the street corner. And now we’ve got to do something more and do better. Let’s try a new model, and let’s try to do it in a way where we can see real results.

BEN (Outreach Worker, speaking to homeless man): You just hanging out?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Yeah.

BEN: Yeah? My name is Ben. I’m with Homeless Outreach.

GONZALEZ: Newsom expanded the city’s existing homeless outreach teams. They try to encourage the indigent, many with drug and mental problems, to take advantage of available city services. The mayor also launched an initiative called Project Homeless Connect. Held every six weeks, it’s a kind of fair for street people where city departments, local companies and hundreds of private volunteers offer a range of free services to the homeless: vision testing and eyeglasses; clothing and food; wheelchair repairs; even the cleaning of dirty and infected feet.

Mayor NEWSOM: What Project Homeless Connect now represents is a sense of pride and spirit, a sense of community and purposefulness. So when people say, "Hey, what are you doing, mayor, about solving the homeless problem?" now I have something to say: "Hey, wait a second. What are you going to do to help this city?"

Photo of Hotel GONZALEZ: However the centerpiece of Mayor Newsom’s efforts to fight homelessness is a two-year-old program called Care Not Cash. It’s a carrot-and-stick approach to getting people off the streets. In exchange for a guarantee of long-term housing in newly renovated residential hotels, homeless people who receive county welfare checks agree to have their monthly payments cut from as much as $410 to as little as $59. The money cut from people’s welfare checks helps to pay for their monthly rent. Once they move into housing, usually small single rooms, the formerly homeless receive food stamps and assistance from on-site case managers.

UNIDENTIFIED CASE MANAGER (to homeless woman): Do you have any life insurance?

GONZALEZ: The case managers help residents find jobs, psychiatric counseling and drug addiction treatment. This extra support is supposed to ensure that once people receive homes, they’ll stay there.

Mayor NEWSOM: That is a much more difficult issue than giving someone a key, a lock and the dignity of a housing unit. You’ve got to have the wrap-around support services to deal with the underlying reasons at the same time. That’s our housing first model: housing and supportive services.

GONZALEZ (to Leo Patterson): Can you show me around your room? I mean, I know it’s not huge.

Photo Of Patterson LEO PATTERSON: Sure. It’s not a big room. But it’s home. It’s home.

GONZALEZ: Leo Patterson was homeless for over three years until he became one of the more than 1,300 people placed in a housing unit through the Care Not Cash program. Patterson says he couldn’t be happier.

Mr. PATTERSON: I am very settled, and I’m not on the streets anymore. And I don’t have to worry about food or nothing. And I’ve got a roof over my head, and it feels great.

GONZALEZ: Jim Tribble, who now just gets $64 a month in welfare, says he’s fine having his payment slashed in exchange for long-term housing.

Photo Of Tribble JIM TRIBBLE: That’s the price you pay. But if you think about it, the rent around here is astronomical. So I made that trade. I thought it was a great trade-off — take the check. I would rather have the residence and supportive staff, etcetera and all the other stuff that goes with the package.

Continue to top of next colum
Watch This Report
Requires Real Player or Windows Media Player
Tools:
E-Mail this article
Resources
GONZALEZ: However, not everyone in San Francisco embraces the city’s strategy to fight homelessness. Some housing advocates criticize the "tough love" approach of Care Not Cash and argue that the city still isn’t doing nearly enough to get its poorest citizens off the streets and into homes.

Photo of friedenbach JENNIFER FRIEDENBACH (Director, Coalition on Homelessness, San Francisco): Since specifically Care Not Cash, we’ve seen an increase in hunger, an increase wait in food lines and an increase in panhandling.

GONZALEZ: Jennifer Friedenbach is the director of San Francisco’s Coalition on Homelessness. She criticizes Care Not Cash for creating hardship by cutting people’s welfare payments. She also argues the program is too narrowly focused on chronically homeless welfare recipients, a group that accounts for less than half of the city’s total homeless population.

Ms. FRIEDENBACH: In this city, they’re picking welfare recipients primarily and trying to see if they can address homelessness in that particular population. So they’re leaving out families with kids, working people, veterans, disabled people — all get left out of the equation. And I think politically it is advantageous to go after chronic homelessness, because local mayors can actually decrease the visible homeless population by focusing on that population. And then they can, you know, talk about that -- "we’re ending homelessness" -- because all the hidden homeless people no one sees.

GONZALEZ: However, Mayor Newsom says in the long run it’s best for everyone in his city to help the chronically homeless first.

Mayor NEWSOM: Ten percent of our chronic homeless population, we estimate, uses well in excess of 50 percent of all our city resources. You help that 10 percent, you free up resources that helps everybody else within that system of care. So we are focused on the person that’s a high-end user of emergency rooms; the person that’s out on the sidewalk day-in and day-out, that has no hope or expectation. And when you can get that person housed, you’re saving a huge amount of taxpayers’ money, and ultimately you’re able to then turn your attention to others in need in a more effective way.

GONZALEZ: Even with its narrow focus, Mayor Newsom claims Care Not Cash and other homeless initiatives, such as a program to reunite San Francisco’s street people with their families, have led to a more than 40 percent decline in the number of people living on the city’s streets. That decline, though, is hard to see at a place like Saint Boniface Church in the heart of San Francisco’s gritty Tenderloin neighborhood. During the day, the church turns itself into a shelter for the homeless, allowing people to use the pews as makeshift cots.

Photo of church Franciscan friar Louie Vitale, a long-time homeless activist, says city hall shouldn’t be too quick to claim success in its fight against homelessness.

Father LOUIE VITALE (Franciscan Friar, St. Boniface Church): There’s a lot of people still on the streets. We have just as many people sleeping here during the day 'cause they’ve been wandering around all night.

GONZALEZ: Just as many as you did two years ago?

Photo of Vitale Fr. VITALLE: Yeah, pretty much so, pretty much so. You can look right now and see. The benches are pretty full, and it’s not a particularly cold day out. It is summer.

GONZALEZ: Mayor Newsom, seen here visiting the Operation Homeless Connect event, says he understands when it comes to finding homes for all the homeless there are no simple answers. But he insists that goal — in his city and others — isn’t a pipe dream.

Mayor NEWSOM: I think on the issue of homelessness success is not a place or a definition. It’s a direction. But I can guarantee this, I am absolutely convinced — I don’t think this, I know it — you can end homelessness in this country. It’s a question of resolve.

GONZALEZ: You can end it?

Photo of Newsom Mayor NEWSOM: You can end it. There is no reason to have a homeless problem in this country. It is absolutely about will. It’s about commitment. It’s about focus.

GONZALEZ: More than 200 American cities have pledged to end chronic homelessness within 10 years, with many of them using San Francisco’s strategies as a model.

For RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY, I’m Saul Gonzalez in San Francisco.

Did you like this story? How can we improve our program or Web site?
Resources






TOP