Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Posted: May 13th, 2008
Sinking Atlantis
Using Sediment Layers to Solve Riddles

Sandy McGillivray, an archaeologist studying the Minoan ruins of Palaikastro on the eastern shore of Crete, had never seen anything like it. While strolling along the beach, McGillivray noticed bits of ancient pottery, building debris, and volcanic ash mixed into the sediment layers of an eroding cliff side.

How the debris ended up there had him stumped.

He decided to call Hendrik Bruins, a soil scientist from Ben Gurion University in Israel who specializes in dating and identifying unusual layers of sediment. Bruins examined the layers, but their composition confused him too.

“This, from a sedimentary point of view, is impossible to get by an earthquake and it’s impossible to get by natural archaeological stratification,” Bruins concluded.

As Bruins studied the sediment deposits under a microscope, he discovered something else mixed in with the ancient debris and ash: foraminifera – tiny marine organisms – along with coralline algae. What were marine organisms doing in a sediment layer a few meters above sea level? Bruins could think of only one natural force capable of such a feat.

A sudden, devastating, and powerful wave.

Below, investigate for yourself by comparing the three major classifications of sedimentary rock with the bizarre deposit Sandy McGillivray discovered in the cliffs at Palaikastro.

Sedimentary rocks fall into three categories:

Clastic rocks

Clastic Rocks

Clastic sediment layers, like sandstone (pictured) and shale, form when rock fragments are broken down by weathering – a decomposition process that occurs when rocks come into direct contact with heat, water, ice, pressure, and natural chemicals – and are then transported and deposited elsewhere.

Chemical rocks

Chemical Rocks

Chemical rocks, like halite (rock salt) and gypsum, form when minerals that exist in a solution are extracted after the solution evaporates. For instance, when large bodies of saltwater dry up, they leave behind halite (pictured).

Biochemical rocks

Biochemical Rocks

Biochemical rocks, like coal and oil shale (pictured), form when the remains of dead organisms such as coral and mollusks merge with existing sediment.

Often, biochemical rocks contain the same foraminifera that Hendrik Bruins found in the Palaikastro layer. However, it would be impossible for marine organisms and ancient pottery debris to exist in the same rock layer unless something forced them together, which is why Bruins suspected a fierce wave struck Palaikastro.

Now compare the three major types of sediment to the Palaikastro layer:

Palaikastro deposit

Palaikastro deposit

Mixed into the sediment, you can clearly see floor plaster, wall plaster, and fragments of typical Minoan pottery. The existence of the Minoan fragments in conjunction with the marine organisms suggests that a massive amount of ocean water swept ashore, destroyed Minoan structures, and then swept the debris back toward the sea when the water finally receded.

Find out how Bruins and McGillivray prove a tsunami destroyed ancient Minoan society in the full episode of “Sinking Atlantis.”


  • Bookmark
  • comments (6)
6 responses
Janis -- May 14th, 2008 at 11:55 pm

Sandy McGillivray!! You are truly amazing!! You have taken thoughts and ideas I have had for years and proven them… I always said that the Minoans didn’t just disappear… I said they had disintegrated and were in the sea. Little did I know you would prove me right. Thank you so much… so very much.

Gregory Carnevale -- May 15th, 2008 at 12:22 pm

Dear Mr. McGillivray. I can’t thank you enough for the wonderful discovery you made. I have been to all the ancient sites in Crete and took my students there. I taught Ancient Greek History and Philosophy at the American Community Schools in Athens and took my students to Crete as I did with my students here in Grand Rapids for 25 more years. Now it all makes sense. You have discovered the missing piece of the puzzle and for that I sincerely congratulate you. Wonderful!!!

Finn James -- November 27th, 2008 at 10:24 am

i love this website :) :)

delkhush -- February 12th, 2009 at 7:18 am

You’ll have given good info,but should have more pics on or about naturally formed brides.good job .take care.

sheila guthrie -- March 2nd, 2009 at 2:09 pm

May I use one of these images in an assignment for 4th grade. I am writing a lesson using google websites and Inspiration. The image would be on an Inspiration worksheet. The worksheet would be included on the webiste.

Sandra Shapley -- July 16th, 2009 at 9:21 am

Can anyone clarify where/when Linear A has been deciphered as asserted by Archeologist McGillivray? This is news to me and so far, unsuccessfully googled. Many thanks!

post a comment
Please note that the THIRTEEN editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness. No solicitations or advertisements will be allowed. Users may link to other Web sites relevant to discussion, but most often links to commercial Web sites will not be permitted.

Produced by THIRTEEN © 2009 Educational Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved. PBS Privacy Policy