In 1973, Janice Law Trecker conducted a study assessing how women were being portrayed in U.S High School History Textbooks. The article, Women in US History High School Textbooks, highlights the results of that study. The study focused on female representation during colonial and revolutionary times, education, the women’s rights movement and suffrage, reform movements, abolition and the Civil War, labor, the frontier, both World Wars, family patterns, intellectual and cultural trends, as well as the current for the study - 1970s - position of women in society.
Her analysis found that at the time, textbooks not only omitted many women in history, they downplayed the adversities they faced based on their social, legal and cultural differences. Her research noted that efforts had been made to increase Black History content, yet it mostly focused on the achievements of black men. Trecker’s call to action: a new attitude that “breaks away from the bias of traditional views of women and their `place’, and attempts to treat both women and men as partners in their society.”
A little over a decade later, in 1986, Mary Kay Thompson Tetreault published a follow-up article, Integrating Women’s history: The Case of United States History High School Textbooks, which served as a report card on the status of women’s representation in U.S. History textbooks published since 1979 in response to Trecker’s call to action.
Revising incomplete and stereotypical history
Tetreault observed that attempts had been made since the 1970s to right the picture of women in history, yet what had been added to textbooks was more of a supplement to history instead of integrating with history. Additionally, she found that “copy and visuals which can be properly categorized as women’s or relational history [were] miniscule.” Ultimately, Tetrault stated that in order to assist women to think of their own situations in history, our textbooks must be rid of stereotypical thinking.
What changes have occured over the decades?
Fast forward three decades. The National Women’s History Museum released A Report on the Status of Women in the United States Social Studies Standards in 2017. Scholars from the National Women’s History Museum analyzed standards from all 50 states as well as the District of Columbia. The goal, to understand how women’s history is being characterized and to identify if women are being excluded in the standards’ framework. After all, the report notes, textbook companies rely on state standards when creating and developing content.
The National Women’s History Museum’s report found that standards prioritize women for national or regional accomplishments, further emphasizing the importance of leadership. State standards address a small sample of topics and groups. Standards overemphasize women’s domestic roles and do not reflect current trends or ideals in society and education. When looking at women referenced in History standards, 63% of women are White, 25% are African American, 8% are Hispanic, 4% Native American/Alaskan and less than 1% of Asian American or Pacific Islander race, which only highlights one individual from Hawaii.
The report stresses that while women might not be mentioned within a standard, that does not mean they must be excluded. Educators should include women and their experiences into their curriculum while meeting the standard’s goals. Overall, the National Women’s History Museum’s hope is that “this report will inspire teachers, scholars, students, and parents to examine the ways in which women’s historical experiences are presented in classrooms.”
Here is a great place to start.
1. Mary Church Terrell, Civil Rights Activist
Mary Church Terrell was an American civil rights activist, and one of the first African-American women to earn both a Bachelors and Masters degree in the United States. The daughter of former slaves, Terrell was one of the first anti-lynching advocates as well as supporters of the women's suffrage movement. She was also one of the founders of the National Association of Colored Women (NACW) and the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP).
2. Jovita Idar, Mexican-American Journalist
Jovita Idar was a Mexican-American journalist, nurse, and civil rights activist. Growing up as a Mexican-American in Texas Idar witnessed segregation, lynching, and various other injustices against Mexican-Americans and other people of color. Using journalism as a form of activism, she publicly tackled some of the toughest subjects such as racism, inequality, and educational deficits in schools such as the lack of bilingual education in schools at this time.
3. Susan B. Anthony, American Women's Rights Activist
Susan B. Anthony was an American women's rights pioneer and activist. At the start of Anthony's career as an activist women's rights were almost non existent. By being resilient, focused, and staying dedicated to her beliefs, Anthony converted several others to the cause. Anthony played a key role in the start and success of the women's suffrage movement. This movement was a decade long struggle that ultimate resulted in women gaining the right to vote in the United States.
4. Malala Yousavzai, 2014 Nobel Peace Prize Winner
Malala Yousavzai made headlines as the youngest person to receive the honor. From a young age, Malala saw herself as an advocate for girls’ education. She gave speeches and blogged about her own experiences living under constant threats to her education from the Taliban. In 2012, she was shot in the head by a Taliban gunman as she was traveling home from school. After surviving the attack, she continued to advocate for education and women’s rights.
5. Dolores Huerta, Activist and Labor Leader
Huerta worked to improve social and economic conditions for farm workers while also fighting against discrimination. Having grown up as the daughter of immigrant farm workers, Huerta had experienced, first-hand, many of the issues she has stood up against. She started the Agricultural Workers Association in 1960 which eventually combined with the National Farm Workers Association and became the United Farm Workers.
Stay up to date on the latest blog posts, content, tools, and more from PBS Education!