Where is the Best Pizza in New York? | PBS Food
Where is the Best Pizza in New York? custom banner

Where is the Best Pizza in New York?

best-pizza600x400

When it comes to pizza, most people have their go-to place, but where can you get the very best pizza? We asked PBS fans to nominate their favorite spots, and here are the votes for the best pizza in New York.

Submit your suggestions using the form at the bottom of the page and we’ll add it to the list.

    Pelham Manor

    4 Corners Pizza

    Schuylerville

    9 Miles East Farm Pizza

    Baldwin

    A Youch of Zit Sly

    Rochester

    ACME Bar and Grill

    Monroe

    Amendolas Pizza and Pasta

    Whitestone/Flushing

    Amore’s

    Brooklyn

    Ana Maria’s

    Corning

    Annelios

    Bushwick

    Archie’s

    Manhattan

    Artichoke Basile

    New York City

    Arturo’s Coal Oven

    Astoria

    Basil Brick Oven

    Lackawanna

    Bella Pizza

    Stone Ridge

    Benny’s Pizzeria

    New York

    Big Nick’s Pizza Joint

    New York

    Bleeker St Pizza

    Buffalo

    Bocce Pizza

    Rochester

    Brandani’s Pizza

    New York

    Brunetti

    Niagara Falls

    Buzzy’s Pizzeria

    Irvington

    Capri

    Rochester

    Captain Tony’s Pizza & Pasta Emporium

    North Greece

    Carbone’s Pizzeria

    Rochester

    Chester Cab

    Brooklyn

    Ciccio’s Pizza

    Port Jefferson Station

    Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

    Endicott

    Consol Family Kitchen

    Binghamton

    Cortese Family Restaurant

    Troy

    DeFazios’s

    Patchogue

    DelFiore

    Staten Island

    Denino’s

    Brooklyn

    Di Fara

    New York

    Don Antonio

    New York City

    Eleven B

    Commack

    Emilo’s

    Brooklyn

    Emily

    Brooklyn

    Enoteca On Court

    Brooklyn Heights

    Fascati Pizza

    Rochester

    Fiamma

    Brooklyn

    Fornino

    Amronk

    Fortina

    Pelham Manor

    Four Corners Pizza

    New York

    Frankie & Peppers

    Brooklyn

    Frannys

    Bronx

    Full Moon Pizzeria

    Bayport

    Furcis

    Auburn

    Gaetano’s Pizzeria

    Long Beach

    Geno’a

    Brooklyn

    giuseppina’s

    Niagara Falls

    Goodfellas

    New York City

    Gotham

    New York City

    Grand Central Station Basement

    Brooklyn

    Grimaldi’s

    Saratoga Springs

    Harvest & Hearth

    Bronxville

    Il Bacio Trattoria

    Buffalo

    Imperial

    Latham

    Inferno Pizza

    Rosedale

    J&S Pizza

    Sherburne

    Joe and Vinny’s Pizzeria

    Staten Island

    Joe n Pat’s

    Manhattan

    Joe’s Pizza

    Maspeth

    Joey’s

    Bronx

    John and Joe’s Pizzeria

    New York City

    John’s of Bleecker St

    Mt. Vernon

    Johnny’s Pizzeria

    Brooklyn

    Juliana’s

    New York

    Keste

    Brooklyn

    Kings Pizza

    Brooklyn

    L & B Spumoni Gardens

    Kingston

    La Florentina

    Buffalo

    La Nova Pizzeria

    New York

    La Pizza Fresca

    Staten Island

    Lees Tavern

    Brooklyn

    Lenny and Johns

    Amherst

    Leonardi’s Pizza

    Lake Ronkonkoma

    Little Vincent’s

    New York City

    Lombardi’s

    Bronx

    Louie and Ernie’s

    Brooklyn

    Lucali

    Rome

    Luigis

    New York

    Luzzo’s

    Pawling

    Mama Pizza II

    Smithotwn

    Manninos

    Jamaica, Queens

    Margarita Pizza

    Oyster Bay

    Mario’s Pizza

    Dewitt

    Mario and Salvo

    Geneseo

    MIa’s Pizza

    Astoria

    Michaelangelo’s II

    New York

    Mimis Pizza Parlor

    Ridgewood Queens

    MiniItalia

    Buffalo

    Mister Pizza

    Montauk

    Montauk Pizza

    New York

    Motorino

    Buffalo

    MR Pizza

    Massena

    Nadeaus Pub ‘n Grill

    Nanuet

    Nanuet Hotel

    Jamaica

    New Park Pizza

    New York

    New York Pizza Suprema

    Hamilton

    New York Pizzeria

    Queens

    Nick’s

    Oyster Bay

    Nina’s

    Binghamton

    Nirchi’s

    Fort Greene

    Not Ray’s Pizza

    New York

    Numero 28

    Staten Island

    Nunzios

    Hamilton

    NY Pizzeria

    Stony Brook

    O Sole Mio

    Brooklyn

    Originals Pizza

    Bellerose

    Palermo

    East Aurora and Derby

    Pasquale’s

    Bronx

    Patricias

    New York City

    Patsy’s

    Brooklyn

    Paulie Gees

    Syracuse

    Pavones

    Pelham

    Pelham Pizza

    Bayside

    Pete’s Pizza

    New York City

    Piacere

    Astoria

    Pizza Palace

    Marlboro

    Pizza Town

    New York

    Pizzetteria Brunetti

    Queens/New York City

    Polito’s Pizza

    Rochester

    Pontillo’s

    Cohoes

    Pop’s Pizza

    Saratoga Springs

    Pope’s Pizza

    New City

    Poss Posa

    Brasher Falls

    Primabellas Pizza

    Elmie

    Pudgies Pizza and Subs

    Bayville

    Ralph’s

    New York City

    Ray’s Pizza Greenwich Village

    Phoenicia

    Resort Ridge Pizza

    Brooklyn

    Roberta’s Pizza

    St. James

    Rocco’s

    Brooklyn

    Rocky’s

    Brooklyn

    Roma Pizza

    Buffalo

    Romeo and Juliette’s

    Massena

    Rosario’s Pizza

    Maspeth

    Rosas

    Astoria

    Rose & Joe’s

    New York City

    Rubirosa

    New York City

    Sacco’s Pizza

    Astoria

    Sacs

    New York

    Sal & Carmine Pizza

    Mamaroneck

    Sal’s

    Cobble Hill, Brooklyn

    Sam’s

    Williamsville

    Santora’s

    Bayport

    Satelite Pizza

    Potsdam

    Sergi’s

    Harrison

    Sofias Pizzeria

    Sarasota

    Solazano’s

    New York

    Sotto 13

    Brooklyn

    Sotto Casa

    Brooklyn

    Speedy Romeo

    Elwood

    Spuntino

    New York City

    Spunto

    New York City

    Stromboli Pizza

    Rye

    Sunrise Pizza

    Hamburg

    The Now Pizzeria

    Dobbs Ferry

    The Parlor

    Bronx

    Three Boys

    Bronx

    Tommy’s Pizza

    Washington Mills

    Tony’s

    Bronx

    Top Banana

    Brooklyn

    Tottono Pizzaria Napolitana

    Massena

    Trombinos

    Syracuse

    Twin Trees

    New York

    Two Boots Pizza

    New Hyde Park

    Umbertos

    Brooklyn

    Unsure

    New York

    V&T’s PIzzeria

    Utica

    Venice Pizza

    New York

    Vezzo

    Cornwall on Hudson

    Village Pizzeria

    Lewiston

    Vincenzo’s

    Herkimer

    Vinny’s Pizzeria

    Warwick

    Warwick Winery-Pané Café

    Brooklyn

    Wheated

    Herkimer

    Yetty’s

    Bronx

    Zero Otto Nove

See Results from Other States

Getting Hungry?

Sign up for weekly recipes