A new and special court system set up in over 20 jurisdictions around the country now gives veterans a chance at treatment and not simply punishment for their crimes. Like drug courts that began in the 1980s, they're based on the idea of treating defendants for underlying problems in order to prevent future criminal activity. Veterans in this system agree to plead guilty to their crimes in exchange for mental health counseling, drug addiction treatment and strict monthly court appearances.
While the courts handle some serious felonies it will not take murder, attempted murder, rape, sexual assault or domestic violence. Dan May, a district attorney explains "some of that isn't even going to be related to PTSD, quite frankly. But that's just too spectacular to be in this program."
While the courts have yet to be studied recidivism seems to be low; the first court in Buffalo has had 22 veterans graduate from its program, and, so far, none have committed new crimes.
Quotes
"I was on a mission in my neighborhood, and I was clearing houses.... I thought I was back in Iraq." - Nic Gray, veteran
"They are different than the average Joe that comes through the court system, in that many of them have sacrificed their own personal safety to protect my constitutional rights. To protect my rights, they fought in a war." Sheilagh Mcateer, Public Defender
"No, I don't feel I got a special deal. I feel I got a just deal. I think justice was served in this case." Nic Gray, veteran
Warm Up Questions
1. What problems or issues do veterans face when they return from a war?
2. What kinds of services does the government provide for men and women returning from war?
3. What do you think Post Traumatic Syndrome Disorder is?
Discussion Questions
1. What are the arguments for and against veterans having a special court?
2. What other groups might want special courts?
3. Think about the Marine who was denied access to the court, do you think that was a good decision?
4. Why do you think veterans who were tried in special courts thus far have not committed any more crimes?
Additional Resources
