Daily Video
June 27, 2013Supreme Court Declares DOMA Unconstitutional
Watch Gay Rights Advocates Score Supreme Court Victories on PBS. See more from PBS NewsHour.
Gay rights activists claimed victory Wednesday after the Supreme Court decided to strike down the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which denied legally married same-sex couples the same rights as their straight counterparts.
DOMA, signed in 1996 by President Clinton, defined marriage as between only one man and one woman. Although gay marriages may be recognized in some states, couples did not receive the same federal benefits such as hospital visitation rights, a right to file joint taxes and inherit property.
Click to see “15 Federal Benefits Same-Sex Couples Can Now Look Forward To”
The decision was made by 5-4 vote at the Supreme Court. Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote the majority opinion, explaining, “DOMA’s principal effect is to identify a subset of state-sanctioned marriages and make them unequal.”
Although same-sex marriages may be federally recognized, portions of DOMA were left intact. States are still not required to recognize same-sex unions from another state.
While many took to the streets of the capital to celebrate, those opposing same-sex marriages were disappointed in the decision. One woman expressed concern about what the ruling would mean for the definition of marriage.
“I’m afraid that this ruling will affect the definition of marriage,” she said. “So that if it’s not one man and one woman, it can be any — anyone.”
The decision to make same-sex marriages legal still rests in the hands of the state.
Warm Up Questions
1. Why do people get married?
2. Is gay marriage legal in your state?
3. What is your definition of marriage?
Discussion Questions
1. Why do you think this marriage was argued at the Supreme Court?
2. Do you think states should decide if gay marriage is legal?
3. Why is the right to marry a central issue for gay rights advocates?
— Compiled by Carrie Waltemeyer for NewsHour Extra
Tags:
Related Stories
Tooltip of related stories
More Videos
Tooltip of more video block
Submit Your Student Voice
More Videos
-
Classroom Resource: During Black History Month, students reflect on their modern-day heroes
Reflect on one teacher’s project to help students see the living history in their own time Continue reading
-
Classroom Resource: Regina King’s directorial debut examines meeting of civil rights voices
Discuss the film One Night in Miami and the reasons it was made Continue reading
-
Daily News Lesson: Recovery may take months even as more help reaches storm-hit Texas
What do you think federal and local authorities should do in response to an emergency like the storms in Texas? Continue reading
-
Classroom Resource: NASA rover lands on Mars, resuming search for remnants of life
Discuss the significance of NASA’s latest mission to Mars. Continue reading
-
Classroom Resource: Is the recent wave of severe weather across the U.S. a harbinger for climate change?
Discuss the extreme winter weather this week and how it might be linked to climate change Continue reading