Lesson PlansBack to lesson plans archive December 10, 2018
Lesson Plan: Hawaii’s fix for food deserts | STEM Student Reporting Labs
Hawaii, for all its tropical splendor, is a relative food desert when it comes to native-grown produce. The islands import about 90 percent of its fresh produce. Larry Yonashiro is hoping to change that by starting an aquaponics movement, where locals can learn to grow high-quality produce in small outdoor spaces, using the wonders of aquaponics.
Introduction: Use the PBS NewsHour Student Reporting Labs video “Aquaponics Hawaiian Style” to understand the importance of organic farming in small urban spaces and how to build and sustain new systems.
Note: We recognize teachers have a limited time for current events, so you may choose to do just one of the activities below. Feel free to provide students with the agriculture resources you may not have gotten to at the end of the lesson, since you may have planted some seeds.
Estimated time: 30-minutes
Subjects: Social Studies, Geography, Science (Biology, Environmental Science, Ecology, Chemistry, Earth Science), Engineering
How is land used for agriculture in the United States?
How can urban aquaponics reduce environmental impacts of agriculture and add social benefits to communities?
This activity will ask students to consider the spatial distribution of modern food systems and understand how aquaponics can reduce land use impacts. This will allow them to evaluate aquaponics as a solution for reducing the impacts of human activities on the environment and biodiversity (Next Generation Science Standard HS-LS2-7).
Warm up (5 minutes):
Think about where your breakfast comes from, geographically. If you’re not sure, who could you ask? Since many teachers and students eat breakfast at school, ask the cafeteria supervisor or your principal from where the school orders its food. List the foods you ate and where you the ingredients were grown. Share with a partner.
Let your students know that food production and food distribution are major industries throughout the world and, as a result, come with a whole host of terms. One term which will be the focus of the lesson is aquaponics; another is food deserts. Food deserts are where a high percentage of low-income people live and access to stores with affordable fresh food is a mile or more away from places of residence. You can read more about food deserts at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Next, look at the USDA map of food deserts in the United States below, and if time, this article about the tool. Read through the question marks in the legend and decide which metric to look at. This is also an opportunity to discuss map legend choices. The color scheme and order of the layers don’t quite make sense, but this tool is comprehensive across the U.S., so it’s still useful. Toggle to the maps of Hawaii and Alaska. Tell students that the data is plotted by census tracts, so some are large and others are smaller.
Watch the video below produced by NewsHour Student Reporting Labs’ Philip’s Academy Charter School. This video shows one community’s solution for providing fresh food to families in need. To spare children and teens the embarrassment that sometimes comes with food insecurity and hunger, Toni’s Kitchen in Montclair, N.J., packs backpacks with meals that kids can pick up from their schools to deliver to their families in need.
Ask the class: What does the expression ‘to put food on the table’ mean? In America, the richest country in the world, why do people struggle with food insecurity? Could you empathize with those who may feel embarrassed and appreciate the subtlety that Toni’s Kitchen provides? Explain.
Produced by Marcelle Brooks, Kailani Day, Jalsa Drinkard, Savannah Love, Elijah Mosley, Oluwatofunmi Olatubosun, Kelsey Roberson and Lunabella Roman, students at Philips Academy in Newark, New Jersey. Instruction provided by SRL Connected Educators Sharon Alonzo and Sara Mosle, with assistance from William Blackman, a volunteer from Montclair High School in Montclair, New Jersey. Mentor support provided by NJTV.
Activity 1: Watch Aquaponics Hawaiian Style video (5 minutes). You may wish to turn on the “CC” icon for closed-captions to help students follow along.
Remember that Hawaii is a set of volcanic islands about 2,500 miles off the mainland United States. According to the video, 90 percent of Hawaii’s produce (fresh fruits and vegetables) is imported, which requires fossil fuels for shipping food across the ocean.
After the video, ask students: Where were the people in the story farming?
(Answer: Hawaii, in the city – in Yonashiro’s backyard).
How do aquaponic plants get nutrients if they don’t use soil to grow?
(Answer: fish waste and bacteria produce nitrogen, a chemical that plants use to grow).
Note: The following text can be developed into a worksheet or a lecture with projections in a PowerPoint.
Activity 2: Interpreting land use maps + agriculture introduction (5 minutes):
Step 1: Agriculture takes up a massive amount of land in the United States. [Project map on a screen] Take a look at this map via Bloomberg and locate “Food we eat” and “Urban housing.” Why are these spaces so small? What takes up much of the other land?
(Answer: livestock pasture and land for growing animal feed).
The kind of food we eat impacts the land use patterns of our country. As the map shows, we eat a lot of meat in the U.S., and export a lot of it, too. Hawaii’s profile in the US Department of Agriculture’s Census of Agriculture 2012 shows the state’s breakdown of farming activities.
Large-scale farming uses commercial fertilizer with added nitrogen and phosphorus. These methods often cause agricultural runoff, a problem that leads to algae blooms and toxic waters. Urban farming is one way to maximize dense land use and reduce impacts on the environment.
Step 2: Read the article (10 minutes), “How Urban Farming Could Change Hawaii” in City Lab by Janet Burns.
Activity 3: Discussion or writing assignment (5 minutes): Consider both the video and the articles. Discuss the following questions.
What are the inputs and outputs of industrialized, soil-based agriculture and aquaponics?
(Answer: soil-based inputs are: seeds, water, fertilizer, pesticides, sunshine, fossil fuels for harvesting. Aquaponic inputs are: seeds, water, fish, sunshine, electricity to power the pumps. Outputs for both are agricultural products. Aquaponics can also produce fish for consumption).
What are some social benefits of urban farming?
(Answer: community education and collaboration, neighborhood revitalization, diversifying economies, less food miles – or fossil fuels used to deliver food to consumers).
Are there any drawbacks to urban farming?
(Answer: space constraints, less output than industrial farming, some inefficiencies; aquaponics has a high startup cost).
1. Lab-based lesson (Grades 9-12): For a weeks-long, extended observation on nutrient cycling between fish and plants, check out “Classroom Aquaponics: Exploring Nitrogen Cycling in a Closed System” Teacher’s Guide by Sean Mullen of Cornell University.
2. The following are a list of resources to learn more about aquaponics and food sustainability:
Video: PBS NewsHour’s Inclusive wellness center is an oasis for a neighborhood left behind
PBS NewsHour article by Cat Wise: Nonprofit hopes to spread aquaponic farming to schools around the country with accompanying aquaponics images below.
Video/news article: “Next wave of ecopreneurs hopes to find key to making aquaponics profitable.” by Marion Renault of The Chicago Tribune
Article: “The real value of urban farming. (Hint: It’s not always the food.)” by Vox’s Brad Plumer
Article: “Mapping Urban Agriculture From the Sky” by CityLab’s Emily Badger
Jen Fuller is a PhD candidate in Environmental Social Science at Arizona State University studying renewable energy. She is currently a reserve teacher with Minneapolis Public Schools and a contributing writer to PBS affiliate Rewire.org. Jen has worked for a variety of environmental nonprofit organizations and has developed sustainability lessons across all subject areas and grade levels.
Tooltip of standarts
Relevant National Standards:
Next Generation Science Standards (9-12)
HS-ESS3-4. “Evaluate or refine a technological solution that reduces impacts of human activities on natural systems. http://www.nextgenscience.org/pe/hs-ess3-4-earth-and-human-activity
HS-LS2-7. Design, evaluate, and refine a solution for reducing the impacts of human activities on the environment and biodiversity. http://www.nextgenscience.org/pe/hs-ls2-7-ecosystems-interactions-energy-and-dynamics
HS-LS2-3 Ecosystems: Interactions, Energy, and Dynamics – Construct and revise an explanation based on evidence for the cycling of matter and flow of energy in aerobic and anaerobic conditions. http://www.nextgenscience.org/pe/hs-ls2-3-ecosystems-interactions-energy-and-dynamics
Next Generation Science Standards (6-8)
MS-LS2-5. Evaluate competing design solutions for maintaining biodiversity and ecosystem services. http://www.nextgenscience.org/pe/ms-ls2-5-ecosystems-interactions-energy-and-dynamics
LS4.D: Biodiversity and Humans
Changes in biodiversity can influence humans’ resources, such as food, energy, and medicines, as well as ecosystem services that humans rely on—for example, water purification and recycling.
ETS1.B: Developing Possible Solutions
There are systematic processes for evaluating solutions with respect to how well they meet the criteria and constraints of a problem.
 Please note that this map is not literal, but a depiction of land use to clearly show the relative sizes of different uses. This type of map is called a “tree map.”
Tooltip of related stories
More Lesson Plans
Tooltip of more video block
Tooltip of RSS content 3
Daily News Lesson: These students say returning to school feels ‘unpredictable, unprecedented’
Hear from students about what return to school during the continuing pandemic has been like for them Continue readingback to schoolcoronavirus pandemiccovid-19delta varianteducationGovernment & Civicslesson planspublic healthSocial StudiesSRL Student Reporting Labsstudent reporters
Educator Voice: My love-hate relationship with Constitution Day
A wall stating the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution is seen on the recently…Bill of RightsBill of Rights Institutecivic educationCivicsconstitutionConstitution DayEducator VoiceGovernment & CivicsicivicsNational Constitution CenterteachersTeaching for Democracy AllianceU.S. constitution
Daily News Lesson: Simone Biles, Aly Raisman and other gymnasts on how FBI ‘betrayed’ them, ‘enabled’ Nassar
Hear from U.S. gymnasts testify before Congress on why an FBI investigation into abuse on the team failed them Continue readingathletesathleticsCongressDepartment of JusticeFBIGovernment & Civicsgovernment reformLarry Nassarlesson planssexual abusesexual assaultSocial StudiesU.S. gymnastics
Daily News Lesson: Governor Newsom survives recall vote in California
Learn about the results of California’s recall election and why it was triggered Continue readingcaliforniaGavin NewsomGovernment & Civicsgovernorslesson plansrecall voteSocial StudiesState GovernmentU.S. government
Lesson Plan: Constitution Day — Civic empowerment and active citizenship
Explore the U.S. Constitution on Constitution Day! Continue readingCivicsclassroom activitiesconstitutionConstitution DayFederal GovernmentGovernment & Civicslesson planlesson plansnational holidaysSocial StudiesU.S. constitutionU.S. governmentU.S. history