Introduction:
In this activity, students will conduct a "model United
Nations General Assembly" session. The activity is designed
to acquaint students with issues in international relations
and the structure, aims and procedures used by the United
Nations to resolve disputes between nations. Students will
learn about the early history of the United Nations by examining
the contributions made by Ralph Bunche to the organization
during the first 25 years of its existence.
Subject areas addressed: American History,
World History, Communications (Speech), Civics (Government).
Objective:
Students will have the opportunity to:
Learn
about current and past problems and situations affecting
the United Nations
Learn
about the life, career, and philosophy of Ralph Bunche,
American diplomat and Nobel Peace Prize winner
Develop
cooperative learning skills and develop the ability
to reach fair compromises
Develop
critical thinking skills about historical issues as
well as current issues in international relations
Information
for Teachers:
Approximate
time for lesson: 6-8 class periods.Students will have the opportunity
to:
Materials:
- Copy of the video Ralph Bunche: An American Odyssey
-
TV and VCR (for showing video)
-
Computer(s) with Internet access
(Optional:
Letter cutters to make signs and flags for UN member states,
video equipment to tape the session, microphones and podium
for speeches).
Relevant
National Standards:
This
lesson addresses the following national technology standards
established by Mid-Continent Research for Education and Learning.
Understands
influences on international relations after World War II and
the effectiveness of the United Nations in reducing international
tensions and conflict
Understands
how post-World War II reconstruction occurred, new international
power relations took shape, and colonial empires broke up
Understands
the shift in political and economic conditions after World
War II (e.g., why and how the United Nations was established,
where it has been actively involved, and how successful it
has been as a peacekeeper; and the United States' international
leadership post-World War I and post-World War II).
Teaching
procedure:
The
teacher should open the lesson with a "warm-up question".
This might take the form of asking students what approach
they think should be used to satisfactorily resolve a current
classroom (or schoolwide) dispute. Suggestions may include
allowing an administrator or outside counselor to decide how
the dispute should be settled. Choosing a "peer mediator"
whom both sides feel can be trusted, and recommendations that
the students "hash it out" between themselves.
The
teacher may mention that disputes between nations are often
settled the same way, that this was the principal reason that
the United Nations was set up after World War II, and that,
often, the methods used by the UN arent much different
than those they recommended to resolve school disputes: mediation,
compromise, and conciliation.
The
teacher should introduce the "Model UN Project"
explaining that the class will be set up as a UN General Assembly,
and that the students (in most cases groups of students) will
represent member states. First, however, they will look at
a video about someone who played a key role in setting up
the United Nations and who had an impact on the policies and
procedures that are still in use today.
The
teacher then shows the video Ralph Bunche: An American
Odyssey to the class, noting that the students should
pay special attention to Bunches role as a UN mediator
and official.
It
should also be noted that Bunche was an international civil
servant, not a delegate or representative of the US. However,
Bunche could and did work effectively "behind the scenes"
to promote peace and justice throughout the world (More information
on this can be found on the Ralph Bunche: An American Odyssey
website pages, Mr. UN. and The Peacemaker.
Bunche also directly lobbied the US delegation for policies
that would strengthen the UNs position on human rights
(More information on this can be found on the Ralph Bunche:
An American Odyssey website page, The Scholar-Activist.
(If
time is limited, the teacher may omit the formative experiences
and academic career sequences in the video. Sequences dealing
specifically with the UN include the one beginning at the
43 minute 30 second point, with Bunche being part of the conference
which created the United Nations, working with Harold Stassen
to write the section of the UN Charter dealing with the status
of the colonies and trust territories (53 min.), continuing
through the segment of Bunche being awarded the Nobel Peace
Prize for his efforts in solving the Middle East crisis of
1948 (77 min 44 sec.). Also, of particular relevance is the
sequence on the first UN Peacekeeping operation (87 min. 10
sec. to 91 min.) and the section on East-West relations within
the UN and the operations of the Secretariat (85 min 29 sec.
to 87 min. 10 sec.)
After
viewing the video, the teacher should propose that the class
research the history and purpose of the United Nations. Using
the United Nations web site (web address below) or a comparable
site, the students will learn about the UN Charter and the
various organs and departments of the organization.
The
teacher should then explain to the students that in conducting
a "model UN General Assembly", in which they will
cooperate to solve major world problems, they have to keep
in mind that each nation is also trying to solve its own national
problems and promote its own interests. The teacher may wish
to ask the class what world problems are currently in the
news. Answers may include the Palestinian problem, issues
involving the former nation of Yugoslavia, instability in
former colonial areas of the world, such as Africa. The teacher
may note that many of the problems the United Nations must
deal with in the early part of the 21st Century
are related to issues the world was attempting to deal with
in the middle of the 20th Century. For example,
as they have seen in the video, the UN was involved in mediation
of disputes in the Middle East, dealing with emerging nations
on the African sub-continent, and human and civil rights.
The class can compare these issues with those that are of
concern today, for example, including the Palestinian question,
the conflicts in Africa, and human rights issues in various
parts of the world.
The
next step would be to assign students to represent various
"member states". This can be done by allowing students
to form their own groups (the size of each group will depend
on the number of students in a class, but it is recommended
that no more than six students make up any one group) or by
assigning students to a particular group. Care should be taken
to ensure that the ratio of "developed" to "developing"
nations in the model UN parallels that in the UN today. One
way to do this might be to have each group draw cards with
the number "1", "2", or "3".
If a group draws a "1" card, they can assume the
role of a developed nation, such as the United States. If
they draw a "2", then they should become a Communist
nation, such as Cuba or Vietnam. If they select a "3"
card, then they would be a developing nation, such as Bangladesh
or the Philippines.
Once
this step is completed, the students can choose the nation
they wish to represent, using the list of member states on
the web page, or the teacher may wish to arbitrarily assign
student groups to specific member states.
It
is recommended that the teacher supply each group with a "portfolio"
(a manila folder will do) in which the group can keep copies
of all information it collects, resolutions adopted, etc.
This file will serve as verification that the group did the
research and developed appropriate positions or resolutions.
(A suggested national delegate portfolio statement is included
below.)
The
students will develop a profile of the nation they will represent
by researching, either online or through conventional sources,
the background, economic system, and political system of the
specific nation they will represent. The profile should include
the following information: geographic location, physical features,
climate, a description of the political system, form of government,
demographic information, economic system and statistics, issues
of domestic concern, regional or local conflicts, membership
in major alliances and organizations, and global issues that
may have a direct impact on that nation. (Students can use
the attached national profile worksheet, or develop their
own.
Based
on the information the group has collected, it can draft "resolutions"
to be presented during the Model UN session. Teachers should
take care to ensure that the resolutions developed are related
to an actual conflict or problem, and that it is intended
to be of benefit to the nation that is presenting it. The
attached UN resolution Sheet Format will give students some
guidance on how to draft a resolution.
When
each group has finished preparing its portfolio, the class
is ready to focus on setting up the Model UN session
Questions
to be considered include:
-
Where the session will be held (in the classroom, school
cafeteria, auditorium)
-
Who (student or teacher) should act as the moderator ("Secretary
General") of the model United Nations session
-
What procedures to follow to allow nations to introduce,
debate, and vote on resolutions
-
What the time frame will be (How long should the session
run. One day? Several days?)
-
How the resolutions, student participation, and other
work will be evaluated
-
Whether the session should be videotaped
-
Should microphones, podium, and other accessories be used
The
answers to each of these questions will depend on the individual
classroom and teacher, but they are questions that should
be considered prior to the session.
The
teacher should either appoint (or the class can elect) a student
to serve as "Secretary General" and moderate the
session. Teachers and the class may wish to refer to the website
Parliamentary Procedure by John A. Cagle for further
information .
On
the first day of the session, the teacher might wish to remind
students of basic rules of order, how to submit a resolution,
voting procedure etc. The session can be called to the order
by the "Secretary General". It is recommended however,
that the teacher act as "UN Control" throughout,
assisting the delegates with whatever questions or issues
arise, and generally helping to keep the meeting running smoothly,
so that one group or resolution does not unfairly dominate
the meeting. It might be advisable to remind students that
delegates of member states function within certain strictures
at the UN. They must consider both their national interest,
their obligations to other nations with whom they have signed
treaties and their obligations as members of the United Nations.
An
assessment rubric should be used to determine student achievement.
It is recommended that the group be graded rather than individual
students. A sample rubric is provided.
Student
Handouts
Model
United Nations Online Resources
Wuzzardo's
Model United Nations Help Page
contains various links, including
starting a model UN, as well as links to other model UN sessions.
American
Model United Nations International
Yahoo
Government
search page with several links to Model United
Nations sites
United
Nations Cyber School Bus
site on model United Nations
University
of California at San Diego Model United Nations
page
Florida
High School Model United Nations
contains various links and
ideas from Florida model UN sessions that can be adapted for
other schools
"Electronic
Model United Nations
" site provides an opportunity for schools and students
to join an "online" Model UN.
Online
resources for Ralph Bunche, his life and work
Web-based
biography for Ralph Bunche on "Africana.com"
Ralph
J. Bunche International Affairs Center
(Howard University)
History
Channel biography
of Ralph Bunche
History
Channel information page regarding An American Dilemma
Ralph
Bunche section at the Schomburg Legacy Exhibition
"Britannica
Guide to the Nobel Prizes" page
featuring Ralph Bunche.
Includes a QuickTime movie clip of Bunch speaking which can
be downloaded. (Note: downloading the clip may take several
minutes on a slow Internet connection.)
Philadelphia
Daily News story
recounting Bunches role in settling
the Mid East crisis in the late 1940s
American
Heritage story on Bunche
American
Heritage story
on Bunche's role in helping to mediate the
Mid East crisis
Related
sites to assist in developing policy statements or finding
information about UN member nations
United
Nations
home page
Central
Intelligence Agency
CIA
World Fact Book
(includes government, economic, and social
information regarding more than 250 nations)
List
of UN member states
Index
of home pages
of member UN delegations
CNN
Home page
CBS
News
web site
ABC
News
web site
NBC
News web site
FOX
News
web site
PBS's
NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
National
Delegate Portfolio
Groups
should keep all materials relating to the Model United Nations
in this portfolio. All information collected will be used
to develop national policy statements and philosophy of ruse
in our Model General Assembly session.
Materials
to be included in portfolios include:
o Any
files downloaded from online sources regarding national
profiles and research on the nation the group has selected
to represent in the Model United Nations
o Any
files downloaded regarding United Nations history and/or
policies used by the group. This would include files from
the United Nations, or other news sources, such as CNN.
o Any
other sources (newspapers, magazines, etc.) that the group
used to develop their portfolios or resolutions. These
may be the actual stories or may be Xeroxed copies of
the stories.
o Text
of any statements or policies the group develops for distribution
for the Assembly as a whole, or for any other group or
organization.
These
materials should be brought daily to class by the group.
This
portfolio will be submitted for evaluation after the conclusion
of the Model United Nations session, or whenever UN Control
(the teacher) asks for a "hard copy briefing" of
group activities.
All
members of the group should do their best to contribute to
this project, just as actual nations find that it takes cooperation
between a nations citizens as well as cooperation between
nations to make a peaceful world community.
Signatures
of the nations delegates below indicate that they understand
their roles in the simulation and in successful completion
of the portfolio and all aspects of the Model United Nations.
Name
of nation: _______________________________________________________
National
Delegates:
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
National
Profile Worksheet
Directions:
Use this sheet to find information about the nation you have
chosen to represent in the Model United Nations. Look for
information in the web resources or through conventional resources
to answer these questions.
1. Description
of political system and form of government: (who is
the nations current leader? What kind of government
is in place? What are the governments goals, aims,
successes, and method of operation?
2. Demographic
information: List
data about the population of your country, its ethnic/religious
background, literacy rate, infant mortality rate, and
so on.
3. Economy:
Include information about the nations Gross Domestic
Product, inflation, unemployment, etc., and any other
relevant or revealing economic data.
4. Major
domestic issues of concern to the nation:
5. Recent
conflicts involving your nation (Be
sure to list both national and international conflicts):
6. Membership
in major alliances and organization: (Note influence
these memberships might have on your nation.)
7. Major
global issues that could have a direct impact on your
nation:
8. Date
of UN Membership: ______________________________________________
United
Nations Resolution
Format
Sheet
Following
is a framework of how a resolution should be constructed in
order to have the General Assembly consider it.
While resolutions do not have to strictly adhere to these
guidelines, it is suggested that they should be similar.
Submitting
Nation: __________________________________________________________________
Submitting
Delegate(s) (Principle authors name first): __________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
Submitted
on (date): _________________________________________________________________
Action
taken (pass, fail, tabled); ________________________________________________________
Vote
totals: ________________________________________________________________________
Signature
of the Secretary General of the United Nations:
Submitting
delegate(s) should add attachments (such as downloaded information
files, etc.) to the back of this resolution before consideration.
Model
United Nations Rubric
This
grade sheet will determine your groups grade for the
Model United Nations. All members of the group are given the
same grade
1. Research
(25 points): How did this group conduct its research?
Are copies of all web based and conventional based research
included in the portfolio? (________________ Points awarded).
2. Resolution
(25 points): How did the group develop their resolution
for submission to the General Assembly? Did it meet the
criteria set by UN Control? (________________ Points awarded).
3. Cooperation
(25 points): Did all the members of the group act in a
helpful and understanding manner during the session? Were
they argumentative or keep the session from reaching its
goal? (________________ Points awarded).
4. Speaking
ability/negotiation skills (25 points): Were the members
of this delegation skilled in being persuasive and being
able to negotiate to reach a consensus among the General
Assembly? (________________ Points awarded).
|