NOVA

Search for a Safe Cigarette

Student Handout

cigarettes in ashtray

Who Should Decide What's Safe? Part II

The American Lung Association has compiled a comprehensive guide to state tobacco control laws, titled State Legislated Actions on Tobacco Issues.* The following is an excerpt of some of those laws.

State Legislated Actions on Tobacco Issues

Restrictions on Smoking in Public Places

Forty-nine states and the District of Columbia have clean indoor air provisions restricting smoking in certain places. These laws range from simple limited restrictions, such as designated areas in schools, to laws that limit or ban smoking in virtually all public places, including elevators, public buildings, restaurants, health facilities, public conveyances, museums, shopping malls, retail stores, and educational facilities (Vermont). California requires enclosed separately ventilated smoking areas in private workplaces including bars and restaurants, or smoking must be banned entirely. Fourty-four states and the District of Columbia restrict smoking in government workplaces and twenty-two states and the District of Columbia restrict smoking in private sector working places.

Tobacco Excise Taxes

Cigarettes

All 50 states and the District of Columbia impose an excise tax on cigarettes.

Youth Access

Age Restrictions on Sales of Tobacco Products

All 50 states and the District of Columbia prohibit the sale of tobacco products to minors. Most states define minors as persons under 18 years of age, however, enforcement varies widely.

Penalties to Minors

Forty-four states penalize minors for tobacco-related offenses.

Restrictions on Distribution of Tobacco Product Samples or Sales of Single Cigarettes

Tobacco Product Samples

Forty-five states and the District of Columbia restrict the distribution of free samples of tobacco products.

Sales of Single Cigarettes

Thirty-three states restrict the sale of cigarettes outside of their original package.

Restriction on Sales of Tobacco Products in Vending Machines

Forty-three states and the District of Columbia restrict the placement of tobacco product vending machines. Fifteen states allow vending machines in any location with a locking device or within the direct line of sight of clerks.

Smoker Protection Laws


Twenty-nine states and the District of Columbia passed some form of smoker protection legislation between 1989 and 1996.

Tobacco Product Disclosure


Five states require tobacco product disclosure information.

Tobacco Divestment


Massachusetts passed the first state law to prohibit new public pension funds from investing in stocks, securities, or other obligations of any companies that derive more than 15 percent of their revenue from the sale of tobacco products and requires divestment of existing investments.

Tobacco Liability

Industry Protection

Five states passed legislation that effectively caps the appeal bond for the punitive damages portion of a judgment in a civil action. Florida and Kentucky have set the limit for supersedes bonds at $100 million, while Georgia, North Carolina, and Virginia have imposed a limit at $25 million.

Tobacco Settlement Funds

Forty-one states have made decisions with provide for the allocation of settlement dollars to tobacco prevention programs. The amounts rage from $18.8 million for prevention programs in Maine, to $500,000 in Kansas. Eight states have allocated settlement amounts close to or above the Centers for Disease Control minimum recommendations for statewide tobacco prevention programs.


cigarettes

Questions
Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.

  1. State laws regarding tobacco issues vary widely. Which state laws do you think go too far in their mandates? Which don't go far enough? Explain your reasoning.

  2. What role, if any, should the federal government play in regulating tobacco products? What role, if any, should each state play? What role, if any, should each citizen play? Who should decide what is and is not safe and why?

  3. If the tobacco industry introduces a safer cigarette, who should evaluate that product's safety? The government? The tobacco industry? The press? Non-profit organizations? People who smoke? Some other group or person? A combination of groups? Explain your choice of evaluator.

*Excerpted with permission from 2000 State Legislated Actions on Tobacco Issues
Copyright © 2001 American Lung Association



-->