A few weeks ago, we reported on the city homeless shelters you may have stayed in before: hotels. PIX 11 reporters Jay Dow and Mario Diaz joined us to show these “homeless hotels” in New York City that started housing families that are in danger of living on the streets, sometimes next to paying customers. Now, they are back to focus on the former Pan American Hotel that became a full-time homeless shelter in 2014, and their findings are worrisome to say the least: the shelter is home to level 3 sex offenders. In this Metrofocus special, we take a look this hotel and how this affects those that are trying to rise out of their situation.
>>> TONIGHT ON "METROFOCUS" --
SEX OFFENDERS LIVING ALONGSIDE
CHILDREN IN THE CITY'S SHELTER
SYSTEM.
PIX 11'S JAY DOW AND MARIO DIAZ
ARE HERE TO EXPOSE THE SHOCKING
TREND AND TRACK DOWN THE
COMMISSIONER OF HOMELESS
SERVICES AND DEMAND ANSWERS.
WHAT WILL THEY LEARN AND WILL IT
BE ENOUGH TO KEEP THESE FAMILIES
OUT OF HARM'S WAY?
THEY'LL BE HERE WITH THOSE
ANSWERS.
ALL THAT AND MORE AS
"METROFOCUS" STARTS RIGHT NOW.
>>> THIS IS "METROFOCUS" WITH
RAFAEL PI ROMAN, JACK FORD AND
JENNA FLANAGAN.
FUNDING FOR THIS PROGRAM WAS
PROVIDED BY --
>> PIX 11'S INTREPID REPORTERS
JAY DOW AND MARIO DIAZ ARE BACK
WITH "NO PLACE TO CALL HOME,
EXPOSING THE HOMELESS CRISIS."
THEY WERE INTRODUCED US TO THE
HOMELESS HOTELS, POPULAR LODGING
LIKE THE DAY'S INN AND THE SUPER
8 WHERE A PORTION OF THE ROOMS
HAD BEEN DEDICATED TO HOUSING
HOMELESS FAMILIES.
TONIGHT JAY AND MARIO ARE
FOCUSING ON THE FORMER PAN AM
HOTEL ON QUEENS BOULEVARD THAT
WAS TRANSFORMED INTO THE
FULL-TIME HOMELESS SHELTER IN
2014.
IT'S PART OF OUR SERIES,
"CHASING THE DREAM: POVERTY AND
OPPORTUNITY IN AMERICA" AND
LET'S LOOK AT MORE OF A
NIGHTMARE FOR THOSE TRYING TO
RISE OUT OF POVERTY THAN THE
HELP IT'S INTENDED TO PROVIDE.
>> MAYOR DE BLASIO CONVERTED THE
FORMER PAN AM HOTEL INTO THE
FULL-TIME HOMELESS SHELTER IN
2014.
THIS IS NOTHING NEW.
BUT WHAT IS SHOCKING TO THE
HOMELESS FAMILIES LIVING IN THIS
SHELTER IS THAT THE STATE SEX
OFFENDER REGISTRY CURRENTLY
LISTS TWO LEVEL 3 CONVICTED SEX
OFFENDERS WHO CURRENTLY CALLED
THE PAN AM HOME.
>> YOU HAVE SEEN [ BLEEP ] HERE
AT THE PAN AM?
>> I HAVE SEEN THEM.
>> INSIDE?
>> INSIDE.
>> LIKE SAYING OR JUST VISITING?
>> I THINK HE HAS A FAMILY IN
HERE.
>> WE ARE NOT GOING TO REVEAL
THE SEX OFFENDER'S IDENTITIES
BUT WE CAN TELL YOU ONE OF THE
MEN WAS CONVICTED OF FIRST
DEGREE ATTEMPTED RAPE, THE OTHER
FIRST DEGREE SEXUAL ABUSE.
AMONG THE VICTIMS, 10 AND
13-YEAR-OLD GIRLS.
IF IT SOUNDS COMPLETELY
ILLOGICAL AND IMMORAL, FOR
HOMELESS SERVICES OFFICIALS TO
PLACE THEM IN THE FAMILY SHELTER
WITH CHILDREN IN THEIR MIDST,
THEN IT MIGHT ALSO SURPRISE YOU
TO LEARN THIS PRACTICE IS A
FLAGRANT VIOLATION OF A POLICY
THE CITY PLANNED TO IMPLEMENT
MORE THAN A YEAR AGO.
>> I ACTUALLY SUPPOSEDLY WORKED
OUT OF THE AGREEMENT WITH THE
CITY OF NEW YORK.
>> CREATED LAST YEAR WITH THE
HELP OF NEW YORK'S STATE SENATOR
JEFFREY KLEIN.
>> ANYWHERE FROM 12 TO 13
DANGEROUS SEXUAL PREDATORS
LIVING IN CITY SHELTERS.
>> THIS WOULD APPEAR TO BE
ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF THE ONGOING
DISCONNECT OF POLICY SET FORTH
BY DEPARTMENT OF HOMELESS
SERVICES AND THE REALITY OF
WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE CITY'S
HOMELESS SHELTERS UNDER HOMELESS
SERVICES COMMISSIONER STEPHEN
BANKS.
SEX OFFENDERS IN SHELTERS IS
PART OF A SECURITY SYSTEM FILLED
WITH FLAWS.
LAST MONTH WE WENT UNDERCOVER IN
FIVE HOMELESS HOTELS, EXPOSING
ONE SECURITY LAPSE AFTER
ANOTHER.
>> WE LEVIED SOME FINES, WE
ENSURED A SUPERVISOR ON EACH
SHIFT.
>> THEN MORE THAN TWO WEEKS
LATER COMMISSIONER BANKS TOLD US
THAT HE ADDRESSED HOMELESS HOTEL
SAFETY ISSUES AFTER WATCHING OUR
REPORTS.
WE WONDERED IF BANKS MADE GOOD
ON HIS WORD, SO WE RETURNED
UNDERCOVER TO THE VERY SAME
SUPER 8 HOTEL IN THE BRONX AND
PARK HOTEL IN QUEENS.
THE RESULTS WERE THE SAME.
ONCE AGAIN, WE WERE ABLE TO
STROLL INTO BOTH FACILITIES.
>> GOOD MORNING.
>> GOOD MORNING.
>> EVEN WELCOMED INSIDE AS WE
WALKED THROUGH THE LOBBY INTO
THE ELEVATOR AND UP TO THE
FLOORS WHERE THE CITY CURRENTLY
SHELTERS THE HOMELESS.
NOT ONE SECURITY GUARD STOPPED
US.
SHOCKING CONSIDERING WHAT
COMMISSIONER BANKS PROCLAIMED ON
OUR AIR.
>> WHICH TOOK -- WE TOOK ACTION.
SECURITY IS CLEARLY AN IMPORTANT
PRIORITY FOR US.
>> I THINK WITH THIS
ADMINISTRATION IT -- THEY TALK A
GOOD STORY, BUT THEY DON'T
FOLLOW THROUGH.
>> NEW YORK STATE SENATOR TONY
AVELLA IS THE CHAIR OF A
HOMELESS TASK FORCE IN ALBANY.
HE CONTINUES TO BE A VOCAL
CRITIC OF MAYOR DE BLASIO'S
HOMELESS POLICIES.
>> WE'RE SUPPOSED TO PROTECT
THESE PEOPLE, WE'RE SUPPOSED TO
PROVIDE HOUSING FOR THE PEOPLE.
>> ARE YOU SATISFIED WITH THE
LEVEL OF TRANSPARENCY COMING
FROM THE DE BLASIO
ADMINISTRATION?
>> ABSOLUTELY NOT.
ANY TIME YOU ASK A QUESTION, MY
OFFICE ASKS A QUESTION OR
CHANNEL 11 DOES, YOU DON'T GET
AN ANSWER.
>> THEY'RE HIDING SOMETHING.
>> THEY'RE PLACING THE HOMELESS
FAMILIES IN JEOPARDY.
>> WE WANTED TO TALK ABOUT THE
TWO CONVICTED SEX OFFENDERS
PLACED IN THE PAN AM HOTEL.
WITH THIS MANAGER --
>> HAVE YOU SEEN THE TWO MEN?
>> NO.
>> BUT HE FELL BACK ON THE
STRATEGY THAT HAS BECOME ALL TOO
FAMILIAR TO US DURING OUR
REPORTING ON THE HOMELESS
CRISIS.
PASSING THE BUCK.
>> THEY ARE TWO OR THREE SEX
OFFENDERS.
YOU WALK AWAY AS -- AS YOU WALK
AWAY WE'RE TRYING TO HELP YOU
OUT.
>> SPEAKING OF BUCKS, TAXPAYERS
ARE ONCE AGAIN WELL ON THEIR WAY
TO SHELLING OUT MILLIONS OF
DOLLARS TO HOUSE THE HOMELESS IN
HOTELS.
BASED ON THE CURRENT SIZE OF THE
HOMELESS POPULATION.
>> SO 3,100 MEN, WOMEN AND
CHILDREN IN THOSE HOTELS.
THAT WAS COMMISSIONER BANKS IN
EARLY JUNE AND NOW THE PROBLEM
IS EVEN WORSE WITH HUNDREDS MORE
STAYING IN HOTELS.
SO IF WE USED THE FIGURES LISTED
IN THE LATEST MANAGEMENT REPORT,
BANKS AGENCY HAS SPENT MILLIONS
OF DOLLARS TO HOUSE THE HOMELESS
IN CORPORATE HOTELS.
JUST FOR THE FIRST HALF OF THIS
YEAR ALONE.
ALL AT TAXPAYERS' EXPENSE.
THAT'S JUST WHAT WE KNOW.
BECAUSE AT EVERY TURN, WE HAVE
BEEN UNABLE TO GET COMMISSIONER
BANKS' AGENCY TO DELIVER ON ITS
PLEDGE TO BE TRANSPARENT, ON HOW
MANY FAMILIES HAVE BEEN PLACED
IN HOTELS, HOW MUCH THEY ARE
SPENDING, AND HOW MANY HOTELS
ARE CURRENTLY BEING USED BY THE
CITY.
ALL OF THIS COMES JUST MONTHS
AFTER THE MAYOR DECLARED HIS
INTENTION TO SCALE DOWN AND
EVENTUALLY END THE CITY'S
DEPENDENCE ON HOMELESS HOTELS.
STATE SENATORS KLEIN AND AVELLA
DECLINED THE CITY'S APPROACH TO
HOUSING THE HOMELESS IN HOTELS
AS A COMBINATION OF
MISMANAGEMENT AND BLATENT
DECEPTION.
>> IF LET'S DO THE SOUND BITE
AND MAKE IT LOOK LIKE WE'RE
DOING SOMETHING, AND THEN WE'LL
FORGET ABOUT IT.
THAT SEEMS TO BE THIS
ADMINISTRATION'S POLICY.
IT'S IN ONE EAR OUT THE OTHER.
>> WHAT DOES IT SAY THAT WE
CONTINUE TO HEAR THESE TALKING
POINTS OF WE'RE GOING TO TAKE
ACTION, BUT YET THE ACTION ISN'T
THERE?
>> I THINK WHAT THEY'RE DOING IS
MISMANAGING THE SITUATION.
>> WE TRIED UNSUCCESSFULLY
DURING OUR REPORTING FOR THIS
STORY TO GET HOMELESS SERVICES
COMMISSIONER STEPHEN BANKS TO
SIT DOWN FOR A FOLLOW-UP
INTERVIEW.
ALL WE RECEIVED WAS A WRITTEN
STAY IN WHICH A DHS SPOKESMAN
INSISTED THAT THERE ARE NO SEX
OFFENDERS ON THE STATE REGISTRY
LIVING AT THE PAN AM.
THE SPOKESMAN CITED PENDING
LETGATION FOR THE CITY'S
INABILITY TO BAN SEX OFFENDERS
FROM HOMELESS SHELTERS.
HOWEVER, AS WE HAVE PREVIOUSLY
REPORTED, THERE IS A 1998
FEDERAL LAW ON THE BOOKS THAT
BANS SEX OFFENDERS FROM LIVING
IN PUBLIC HOUSING.
WHICH IS ESSENTIALLY WHAT THESE
HOMELESS SHELTERS HAVE BECOME.
ESPECIALLY NOW THAT FAMILIES ARE
STAYING THERE LONGER THAN EVER.
UP TO FOUR MONTHS A A TIME.
PERHAPS MOST TROUBLING -- THE
SPOKESMAN TELLS PIX 11
REGARDLESS OF RESIDENCY
RESTRICTIONS IF A SEX OFFENDER
IS A MEMBER OF FAMILY, THEY MUST
BE ALLOWED TO LIVE WITH THEIR
FAMILY.
THAT DOES NOT SIT WELL WITH THIS
HOMELESS MOTHER WHO CALLS THE
PAN A.M. HOME --
>> ARE THEY SEX OFFENDERS?
>> LEVEL 3.
>> I NEED TO GET OUT OF HERE.
I HAVE -- THAT'S WHY I DON'T
WANT MY DAUGHTER BACK HERE.
>> SO JAY DOW AND MARIO DIAZ ARE
JOINING US.
NICE TO HAVE YOU BACK HERE WITH
US.
FIRST QUESTION FOR YOU.
THERE ARE A LOT OF STORIES OUT
THERE THAT YOU DO.
WHAT WAS IT ABOUT THIS STORY --
WHAT WAS IT ABOUT THIS STORY
THAT DREW YOU TO IT?
>> ABOUT A YEAR AND A HALF AGO,
MARIO SAID YOU KNOW WHAT, ARE
YOU INTERESTED IN WORKING
TOGETHER ON A STORY, ON A
PROJECT.
WE BOTH AGREED WE'D COME BACK A
WEEK LATER WITH AN IDEA AND WE
BOTH CAME BACK WITH HOMELESS.
IT'S A STORY THAT WE HAD BOTH
BEEN COVERING IN OUR OWN LITTLE
WORLDS.
MARIO WORKS FOR THE EARLY
NEWSCAST AND I WORK FOR THE LATE
NEWSCAST.
EVERY DAY WHILE COVERING A
STORY, WHETHER IT'S A STORY LIKE
A FIRE, WE ARE STEPPING OVER ALL
HOMELESS PEOPLE, INCLUDING
MIDTOWN MANHATTAN.
GRAND CENTRAL STATION.
RIGHT IN FRONT OF OUR STATION ON
42nd STREET.
IT WAS SOMETHING THAT IT HAD
BECOME CLEAR THIS WAS A PROBLEM.
A GROWING PROBLEM.
>> WE HAVE HEARD MENTIONED IN
THE PIECE ABOUT IT BEING
CHARACTERIZED AS MISMANAGEMENT
AND DECEPTION.
YOU GUYS ARE THE CHRONICLERS
HERE, BUT FROM WHAT YOU HAVE
SEEN -- MARIO, LET ME ASK YOU IS
THAT A FAIR AND ACCURATE
CHARACTERIZATION OF WHAT YOU
DISCOVERED?
>> WELL, WHAT WE HAVE BEEN ABLE
TO IDENTIFY HERE IS AN
ADMINISTRATION THAT SAYS THEY'RE
GOING TO DO ONE STEP OF ACTION
OR TAKE ONE COURSE.
THAT'S REALLY NOT TAKING PLACE.
YOU SAW COMMISSIONER BANKS COME
ON OUR AIR BACK ON JUNE THE
12th, TELL JAY AFTER WHAT WE HAD
EXPOSED -- THE FACT WE'D BEEF UP
THE SECURITY MEASURES INSIDE THE
HOTEL, BUT WE WENT INSIDE THE
HOTELS, WE STAYED THE NIGHT
THERE.
WE RENTED ROOMS.
WE STAYED RIGHT BESIDE HOMELESS
FAMILIES, THERE WAS NOBODY
STOPPING US.
WHEN WE BROUGHT THE COMMISSIONER
ON THE AIR HE SAID WE'LL BEEF UP
THE SECURITY, THEY HAVE BEEN
ADDRESSED.
OBVIOUSLY WE APPRECIATE YOU
PUTTING THIS OUT THERE.
SO WE DID OUR JOB AS
JOURNALISTS.
WE IMMEDIATELY WENT BACK THERE
AND CHECKED ONCE AGAIN.
AS YOU CAN SEE, NOTHING HAD BEEN
DONE, JACK.
>> INTERESTING BECAUSE YOU LOOK
AT -- THIS IS ONE OF THE
PROBLEMS I'M SURE ABOUT
INTERMINGLING A TOURIST HOTEL
WITH A RESIDENCE FOR HOMELESS
PEOPLE.
BECAUSE IN ANY OTHER HOTEL YOU
WON'T HAVE THE TYPE OF SECURITY
THAT YOU WILL SEE IN A HOMELESS
SHELTER, FOR INSTANCE.
WHERE YOU SIGN IN.
THIS IS THAT, BUT IN A DIFFERENT
EDIFICE IF YOU WILL.
I GUESS THE QUESTION IS HOW DO
YOU RESOLVE THAT CONFLICT
BETWEEN THE TWO?
>> WELL, THE CITY IS TREATING
THESE HOTELS AS HOMELESS
SHELTERS BY PLACING LARGE
NUMBERS OF HOMELESS FAMILIES
INSIDE OF THESE FACILITIES.
THE SECURITY AS YOU SAID IS IN
PLACE IN A TRADITIONAL SHELTER,
A METAL DETECTOR, GUARDS,
PROTOCOLS.
SECURITY GUARDS PATROLLING THE
HALLWAYS.
NONE OF THAT IS GOOD FOR
BUSINESS.
>> RIGHT.
>> IN A TRADITIONAL HOTEL.
>> SURE.
>> BUT YOU'RE ABOUT TO CHECK IN,
WHOA, WHAT AM I WALKING INTO
HERE?
>> WHAT'S THE NUMBER ONE TOURIST
CITY IN AMERICA?
NEW YORK CITY.
CLOSE TO 50 MILLION CAME HERE
LAST YEAR, NOT GOOD FOR BUSINESS
OBVIOUSLY.
BUT THE CITY STATED TO US, IN
THE E-MAIL THEY SENT, THEY'RE
SUPPOSED TO HAVE PATROL --
SECURITY PATROLLING THE HALLWAY.
WE NEVER SAW THAT IN ANY OF THE
STORIES.
>> I'M SURE THAT TOURISTS
WOULDN'T MIND THAT AT ALL.
YOU KNOW, KNOWING THAT SOMEBODY
IS OUT THERE SORT OF CHECKING ON
THINGS.
>> IF THE TOURIST KNOWS.
IF THE TOURIST KNOWS.
>> THE GUY SAYS I WOULD HAVE
LIKED TO HAVE KNOWN.
>> THINK OF A TOURIST AT HOME IN
THE MIDWEST OR ABROAD, THEY'RE
ABOUT TO SPEND A FEW THOUSAND
DOLLARS ON A TRIP FOR, YOU KNOW,
THEIR FAMILY.
IF THERE'S A DISCLOSURE,
DISCLOSURE ON THE WEBSITE SAYING
THERE WILL BE HOMELESS FAMILIES
IN THIS HOTEL, DO YOU THINK
THEY'LL BE CLICK SUBMIT AND
PURCHASE?
>> AS YOU SAID, WHEN YOU LOOK AT
THE BOTTOM LINE COMPONENT OF
THIS.
YOU MENTIONED THIS TO ME WHILE
WATCHING THIS, WE TALKED
ABOUT -- WE SAW THE PICTURES,
BLURRED FACES OF THE SEX
OFFENDERS THERE.
>> RIGHT.
>> HOW DO THEY GET THERE?
>> CITY PLACED THEM.
>> SO THIS IS NOT A CHOICE BY
THEM?
>> NOT AT ALL.
WHEN WE EXPOSE THE FACT THAT THE
CITY HAD PLACED THE SEX
OFFENDERS INSIDE THE PAN AM
HOTEL WHICH IS A FULL-TIME
SHELTER, IT WAS OPENED UP AS A
SHELTER UNDER THE DE BLASIO
ADMINISTRATION EARLY ON, WE WENT
TO THEM AND WE DIDN'T GET ANY
ANSWERS.
YOU'D FIGURE THIS IS IS AN ISSUE
THEY'D WANT TO TRY TO ADDRESS.
THE PREVIOUS MIX --
ADMINISTRATION AT DHS, A
GENTLEMAN BY THE NAME OF GILBERT
TAYLOR, THE COMMISSIONER AT THE
TIME PROMISED TO CHANGE THIS
POLICY.
WELL, WE WENT TO COMMISSIONER
BANKS, WE HAMMERED THEM AND WE
SAID ARE WE CHANGING THIS, HOW
CAN THIS HAPPEN?
WHAT IS THE STATUS?
THEY DIDN'T WANT TO GO NEAR THIS
TOPIC WITH US.
>> YOU WOULD THINK THAT THE
CITY -- CERTAIN THINGS WOULD
RING ALARM BELLS.
>> CONSIDERING THE FACT YOU HAD
A MURDER INSIDE OF A HOTEL IN
STATEN ISLAND A FEW MONTHS AGO
YOU'D FIGURE THIS IS A SECURITY
ISSUE ONCE AGAIN COMING TO
LIGHT.
WE HAVE HAD A COUPLE OF STATE
SENATORS WEIGH IN WITH REGARDS
TO THIS.
WHO HAD MADE THIS A PERSONAL
ISSUE FOR THEM.
>> THIS GOES BACK TO SAFETY.
BECAUSE THERE ARE SAFETY ISSUES
INSIDE THE HOMELESS SHELTERS AND
HOTELS IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT
HOMELESS PEOPLE STAYING THERE.
THERE'S NOTHING WRONG WITH BEING
HOMELESS, YOU'RE DOWN AND OUT,
BUT THERE ARE DOCUMENTED ISSUES
INSIDE THE HOTELS THAT RINGS THE
ALARM FOR PEOPLE STAYING THERE
AND THE HOMELESS FAMILIES WHO
HAVE NO PLACE BUT TO STAY THERE.
>> BUT THE IDEA IS TO HELP THE
PEOPLE, NOT TO EXPOSE THEM TO
ADDITIONAL DANGERS.
>> RIGHT.
>> YOU MENTIONED BEING
TELEVISION PROFESSIONALS YOU SET
UP THE SEGUE VERY NICELY, WHERE
YOU'RE ACTUALLY ABLE TO ASK SOME
QUESTIONS OF THE COMMISSIONER.
>> NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF
HOMELESS SERVICES COMMISSIONER
STEPHEN BANKS AND HIS STAFF HAVE
BY SEVERAL ACCOUNTS CONSISTENTLY
FAILED TO DELIVER ON A PLEDGE OF
TRANSPARENCY WHEN IT COMES TO
SHARING THE TRUE DEPTH AND COST
OF THE CITY'S HOMELESS SHELTER
CRISIS WITH THE PUBLIC.
SO WHEN WE NOTICED COMMISSIONER
BANKS AT A MAYOR'S TOWN HALL IN
BROOKLYN LAST NIGHT --
>> WHEN YOU HAVE A MOMENT -- I'D
BE HAPPY TO TALK TO YOU.
>> DURING OUR REPORTING FOR AN
UNRELATED STORY ON THE END OF
GUN VIOLENCE AWARENESS MONTH WE
SEIZED THE OPPORTUNITY AND
APPROACHED HIM IN THE GYM AFTER
HIS STAFF DENIED OUR REPEATEDLY
E-MAIL REQUESTS FOR A FOLLOW-UP
INTERVIEW.
>> AS YOU KNOW, THERE'S PENDING
LITIGATION.
AND I CAN'T COMMENT ANY FURTHER.
>> COMMISSIONER BANKS WARNED US
HE COULD NOT DISCUSS THE REPORT
WE AIRED EARLIER THIS WEEK WHICH
INCLUDED THE EYE OPENING
REVELATION HIS AGENCY PLACED TWO
LEVEL 3 OR THE MOST DANGEROUS
TYPE OF CONVICTED SEX OFFENDERS
IN ONE OF ITS FAMILY HOMELESS
SHELTERS THAT HOUSES BOTH ADULTS
AND CHILDREN.
>> WE PLACED THEM CONSISTENT
WITH THE STATE LAW, ON WHERE SEX
OFFENDERS CAN BE HOUSED.
I'M NO LAWYER, I'M ASKING YOU,
DOES DHS -- DO YOU AS THE
COMMISSIONER HAVE THE DISCRETION
SAY YOU KNOW WHAT THE RIGHT MOVE
IS NOT TO PLACE THIS SEX
OFFENDER IN A FAMILY SHELTER
REGARDLESS OF WHAT STATE LAW
SAYS?
>> THERE ARE COURT ORDERS THAT
REQUIRE THE CITY TO PROVIDE
SHELTER TO ANY FAMILY WHO HAS NO
OTHER PLACE TO GO.
>> LATE THIS AFTERNOON,
COMMISSIONER BANKS CHANGED HIS
POSITION.
THIS NEWS RELEASE ISSUED BY TONY
AVELLA INCREDIBLY ANNOUNCED A
PROMISE FROM BANKS THAT HE MADE.
A COMMITMENT TO NO LONGER PLACE
LEVEL TWO AND THREE SEX
OFFENDERS IN THE PAN-AMERICAN
HOMELESS SHELTER.
THAT COMMISSIONER BANKS IS ALSO
COMMITTED TO FINDING A SOLUTION
SO THAT NO FAMILY HOMELESS
SHELTERS WILL BE SHARED BY LEVEL
TWO AND THREE SEX OFFENDERS.
A DHS SPOKESMAN CONFIRMS TO PIX
11 NEWS THE STATEMENTS
ATTRIBUTED TO COMMISSIONER BANKS
ARE INDEED ACCURATE.
TO BE CLEAR, THOSE NEWS RELEASE
STATEMENTS CONTRADICT WHAT
BANKS' SPOKESMAN HAS BEEN
TELLING US.
IN FACT, PRIOR TO AND AFTER OUR
REPORT REGARDING SEXUAL
OFFENDERS IN THE PAN AM, DHS
WOULD NOT PROVIDE WITH US A
STRAIGHT ANSWER WHETHER OR NOT
THE AGENCY HAD ACTUALLY PLACED
THEM THERE.
THIS ALL COMES ON THE HEELS OF
FLAWS IN CORPORATE HOMELESS
HOTEL SECURITY WE FOUND ONCE
AGAIN EARLIER THIS WEEK FLAWS
THE COMMISSIONER PREVIOUSLY TOLD
US WERE FIXED AND NO LONGER AN
ISSUE BACK ON JUNE 12th.
>> WE HAVE GONE BACK TO THE SAME
HOTELS THAT YOU TOLD US ON OUR
AIR WERE SAFE.
AND THEY ARE STILL UNSAFE.
MY QUESTION IS, HOW DO YOU
EXPLAIN THIS ONGOING PRACTICE
YOU HAVE OF SAYING ALL THE RIGHT
THINGS, MAKING THESE PROMISES,
BUT NONE OF IT HAPPENS?
THERE'S NO FOLLOW THROUGH?
>> AS SOON AS YOU IDENTIFIED THE
TWO HOTELS YOU HAD GONE, WE HAD
REACHED OUT THE THE POLICE
DEPARTMENT AND THEY WERE
FOLLOWED UP ON IT AND THEY HAVE
TAKEN THE ACTIONS TO MAKE SURE
THERE'S APPROPRIATE SECURITY IN
PLACE.
WHEN WE GET THE FINAL REVIEW
THAT WILL ENABLE US TO MOVE
FORWARD.
>> COMMISSIONER BANKS TAKES US
ISSUE WITH US SAYING HE HAD FJC
GUARDS FIRED AND EXPOSED THE
GUARDS AND THEY WERE NOWHERE TO
BE FOUND IN SEVERAL HOMELESS
HOTELS SO INSTEAD HE CLASSIFIES
THEM AS HAVING BEEN REMOVED FROM
THEIR POSTS AT THOSE SPECIFIC
HOTELS.
>> COMMISSIONER, WHAT DOES THIS
SAY ABOUT YOUR LEADERSHIP, YOUR
AGENCY, YOUR STAFF?
I UNDERSTAND THAT YOU'RE RELYING
ON THE POLICE DEPARTMENT BUT AT
THE END OF THE DAY IT'S YOUR
AGENCY THAT'S RESPONSIBLE FOR
KEEPING THESE FAMILIES SAFE?
>> WELL, ULTIMATELY THAT'S WHAT
WE WANTED THE POLICE DEPARTMENT
TO TAKE THE REVIEW OF THE ISSUE
THAT'S BUILT UP.
>> I DON'T WANT YOU TO
MISINTERPRET OUR INVESTIGATION
AS A MICROANALYSIS, RATHER WE'RE
LOOKING AT A WAY THAT YOUR
AGENCY DOES BUSINESS IN TERMS OF
SECURING THE HOTELS AND PRO --
PROTECTING THE FAMILIES THAT
STAY IN THERE.
>> WELL, BEFORE WE GOT INVOLVED
WITH THIS, THERE WAS NO FJC
SECURITY AT ANY OF THE HOTELS.
WE TOOK ACTION WHEN WE RECEIVED
REPORTS FROM YOU AND FROM
FAMILIES ABOUT INADEQUATE FJC
STAFFING AND WE TOOK ACTION TO
PROVIDE ADDITIONAL STAFFING.
>> COMMISSIONER BANKS DEFERRED
TO THE NYPD, AND WE DECIDED TO
REFER BACK TO ONE OF OUR KEY ON
THE RECORD E-MAIL EXCHANGES WITH
THE DEPARTMENT.
A SPOKESMAN FROM THE OFFICE OF
THE NYPD'S DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OF PUBLIC INFORMATION SENT US
THE BELOW BACK ON MAY 26th,
STATING THE NYPD HAS REVIEWED
THE SECURITY PROTOCOLS AT HOTELS
WHERE HOMELESS CLIENTS ARE
HOUSED.
WE DETERMINED THAT THE PRIVATE
SECURITY MEASURES AT THESE
LOCATIONS ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH
THE SECURITY REQUIREMENTS OF
THOSE SITES.
APPROXIMATELY TWO WEEKS LATER
ANOTHER HIGH RANKING NYPD
OFFICIAL REITERATED THIS STANCE.
YET, LESS THAN 24 HOURS AGO
COMMISSIONER BANKS STATED HIS
AGENCY CONTINUES TO WORK WITH
THE NYPD ON AN EXTENSIVE REVIEW
OF THE HOMELESS SHELTER SYSTEM
INCLUDING CORPORATE HOMELESS
HOTELS.
THE COMMISSIONER ADDING, WHEN
THE REVIEW COMES OUT, HE WILL
PROVIDE PIX 11 NEWS WITH A COPY.
>> WE ARE DEFINITELY BEEFING UP
THE SECURITY ELEMENTS OF OUR
SHELTERS.
>> MAYOR DE BLASIO HELD A NEWS
CONFERENCE TODAY.
FOLLOWING THE GRADUATION OF MORE
THAN 1,000 NYPD OFFICERS.
I QUESTIONED THE MAYOR OVER WHAT
WE HAVE UNCOVERED SINCE THE
MURDERS OF A HOMELESS MOTHER AND
HER TWO CHILDREN AND A CORPORATE
HOMELESS HOTEL ON STATEN ISLAND.
ON THE AFTERNOON OF FEBRUARY
10th, FOLLOWING THE MURDERS ON
STATEN ISLAND, YOU STATED TO THE
CITY IT WAS YOUR GOAL TO END THE
RELIANCE OF CORPORATE HOTELS TO
HOUSE THE HOMELESS.
SINCE THAT PERIOD, WE HAVE FOUND
OVERSPENDING IN SOME OF THE
HOTELS THAT ARE BOOKED BY DHS,
SECURITY FLAWS NOT BY THE NYPD,
BUT BY THE PRIVATE SECURITY
SERVICE CONTRACTED BY THE CITY.
AND ACCORDING TO DHS TODAY WE
STAND STILL AT 40 HOTELS.
THE GOAL DID NOT APPEAR TO BE
MOVING IN ANY POSITIVE
DIRECTION.
CAN YOU PLEASE WEIGH IN ON
THE --
>> SURE.
I'M NOT SURE I AGREE WITH YOUR
ANALYSIS.
THE NYPD HAS TAKEN OVER THE
TRAINING AND SUPERVISION OF THE
SECURITY.
THAT'S A WHOLE DIFFERENT
REALITY.
EVERY HOTEL HAS SECURITY
ASSIGNED.
>> THE MAYOR THEN WENT ON TO
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT HIS
ADMINISTRATION HAS FAILED TO
PRODUCE THE RESULTS REQUIRED TO
GET FAMILIES OUT OF CORPORATE
HOMELESS HOTELS.
>> WE HAVEN'T SEEN A KIND OF
REDUCTION THAT WOULD ALLOW US TO
ON A SUSTAINED BASIS GET OUT OF
THE HOTELS.
>> THE MAYOR DID NOT DENY THE
OVERSPENDING THAT WE HAVE
INVESTIGATED AND REVEALED,
STATING --
>> WE DON'T LOVE SPENDING THE
MONEY WE HAVE TO ON THE THOLE.
>> HOWEVER, THE KEY POINT AND
THE FINAL ONE MADE BY THE MAYOR
WAS A RESPONSE TO SECURITY.
>> SECURITY IS ASSIGNED TO EVERY
SINGLE HOTEL.
>> FOLLOWING UP ON THE LAST
POINT WE WERE ABLE TO PENETRATE
ON SEVERAL OCCASIONS WITH AN
UNDERCOVER CAMERA SHOWING THAT
THERE WAS NO SECURITY GUARD
INSIDE OF A FEW OF THESE HOTELS.
COMMISSIONER BANKS CAME ON AIR
ON JUNE THE 12th STATED THAT
WE'LL RECTIFY THIS PROBLEM.
ON MONDAY WENT BACK INTO THE
SAME HOTELS AND WE FOUND THE
SAME ISSUES.
IT WAS ON OUR AIR LAST NIGHT.
>> WE CERTAINLY WILL NOT
TOLERATE ANY COMPANY THAT'S
SUPPOSED TO ASSIGN THE GUARD AND
BE THERE AND WE'RE PAYING FOR IT
AND THEY'RE NOT DOING IT.
WE'LL DEAL WITH THAT COMPANY.
SO IF YOU HAVE UNCOVERED A
PARTICULAR FLAW WE'LL ADDRESS
IT.
EVERY HOTEL HAS A SECURITY
GUARD, AND IT'S NOT HAPPENING IN
ANY GIVEN PLACE WE WILL DEAL
WITH IT.
>> WE HAVE BECOME FAMILIAR IN
THE BUSINESS AND ECONOMIC REALM
OF THE EXPRESSION OF TOO A BIG
TO FAIL.
IS THE HOMELESS PROBLEM HERE IN
NEW YORK CITY, IN MANY WAYS TOO
BIG TO RESOLVE?
>> THIS IS A PROBLEM THAT IS
DECADES OLD.
MANY MAYORS HAVE TRIED AND
FAILED TO FIX IT.
I THINK THE FOCUS OF OUR
INVESTIGATION HAS NOT BEEN TO
PROPOSE OR COMPEL THE CITY TO
COME UP WITH A HARD CORE
SOLUTION, BUT TO WORK WITHIN THE
SYSTEM TO ADDRESS SOME OF THE
LOOPHOLES AND ISSUES THAT EXIST,
SAFETY, OVERSPENDING.
IF YOU HAVE TO DEAL WITH THE
HOMELESS PROBLEM THROUGHOUT THE
DURATION OF YOUR TERM, AT LEAST
PROTECT THE FAMILIES WHO ARE
STAYING IN THERE WHO ARE TELLING
US THAT THEY FEEL UNSAFE.
>> PART OF THAT COMES OFF THE
FACT THAT YOU HAVE HAD THE MAYOR
COME ON THE AIR AND HAVE A NEWS
CONFERENCE ON THE AFTERNOON OF
FEBRUARY THE 10th FOLLOWING THE
MURDERS OF THE FAMILY ON STATEN
ISLAND AND SAID, LISTEN, WE ARE
GOING TO END THE RELIANCE --
THAT IS OUR GOAL.
OUR GOAL IS TO END THIS RELIANCE
OF USING CORPORATE HOTELS.
WE ARE GOING TO BEEF UP SECURITY
DO ENSURE THAT THIS DOESN'T
HAPPEN AGAIN.
AS JOURNALISTS WE'RE GOING TO
FOLLOW UP AND EXAMINE THAT AND
SEE WHAT THE CITY HAS DONE.
IT'S WHAT EVERYBODY IN OUR FIELD
TENDS TO DO ON THE STORY LIKE
THIS.
AND WE DID AND WHEN THEY TOLD
USED THEY HAD RESOLVED IT ON
JUNE THE 12th, WHAT WE DID IS WE
CHECKED THE CRIME STATS REPORTS
FOR SOME OF THE PROPERTIES WE
HAD VISITED WITH OUR CAMERAS.
THERE WERE CASES OF A ROBBERY,
AN ASSAULT.
THERE WAS ISSUES INSIDE THOSE
HOTELS EVEN AFTER COMMISSIONER
BANKS HAD SAID THAT HE HAD
INCREASED SECURITY.
BUT IN GETTING BACK TO YOUR
POINT, THIS IS ABOUT EXAMINING
WHAT THE CITY SAID THEY'RE GOING
TO DO AND ACTUALLY SEEING
WHETHER OR NOT THAT'S BECOME THE
REALITY ON AN ISSUE THAT IMPACTS
ALL OF US HERE IN NEW YORK.
>> IS IT POSSIBLE -- I DON'T
WANT TO MAKE THIS SOUND TOO
SIMPLISTIC, BUT DOES THE CITY
HAVE THE INFRASTRUCTURE TO
ADDRESS THE ISSUES AND IF THEY
DO, IS IT A MATTER OF COMPETENCE
OF GETTING IT DONE OR FROM YOUR
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING FROM WITHOUT
AT THIS AND CHRONICLING THESE
PROBLEMS, IS IT A QUESTION OF
THEY DON'T HAVE THE TOOLS.
THEY DON'T HAVE THE LAWS OR THE
REGULATIONS.
WHATEVER IT IS THEY NEED TO GET
DONE.
>> THE INFRASTRUCTURE IS IN
PLACE AND SO ARE THE TAX
DOLLARS.
THESE AGENCIES, DHS, THE HUMAN
RESOURCE ADMINISTRATION, WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT TENS OF MILLIONS
OF DOLLARS EVERY YEAR AT THEIR
DISPOSAL.
BUT THERE'S A DISCONNECT BETWEEN
POLICY DECLARATIONS AND WHAT WE
HEAR AT THE PODIUM TO WHAT GOES
ON IN THE FIELD.
SO IT MAY BE AN ISSUE OF
COMPETENCE.
IT MAY BE AN ISSUE OF
SUPERVISION.
BUT IT'S NOT AN ISSUE OF HAVING
THE INFRASTRUCTURE AND THE
RESOURCES AVAILABLE.
>> WELL, I GUESS IT'S COMPELLING
JOURNALISM AT A TIME WHEN OUR
PROFESSION IS UNDER FIRE FOR
SPENDING TOO MUCH TIME ON SILLY
VIDEOS AND FLUFFY STUFF.
THIS IS IMPORTANT ISSUES AND YOU
HAVE DONE A FABULOUS JOB AT
SHINING A LIGHT ON THIS.
>> VERY QUICKLY, I WANTED TO ADD
ONE QUICK POINT TO THAT.
SOME OF THE REPORTS HAVE BEEN
THE HIGHEST RATED REPORTS AT OUR
STATION.
>> THAT PROVES THAT PEOPLE WANT
TO GET GOOD JOURNALISM.
DESPITE SOME OF THE DECISIONS WE
SEE BEING MADE IN OUR
PROFESSION.
BUT JAY, MARIO, FABULOUS WORK.
WE'RE LOOKING FORWARD TO GETTING
YOU BACK AGAIN.
>> APPRECIATE IT, JACK.
THANK YOU.
>>> FUNDING FOR THIS PROGRAM WAS
PROVIDED BY --
CORPORATE FUNDING FOR
"METROFOCUS" WAS PROVIDED BY
MUTUAL OF AMERICA.
YOUR RETIREMENT COMPANY.
AND BY PSE&G, SERVING CUSTOMERS,
STRENGTHENING THE BUSINESS
COMMUNITY AND INVESTING IN THE
FUTURE.