Report Examines Structural Racism in New Jersey

It’s called “The Uncomfortable Truth.” A new report links chronic poverty to institutional racism. The Anti Poverty Network’s executive director Renee Koubiadis and board member reverend Charles Boyer recently joined NJTV News senior correspondent David Cruz to explain what they see as the effects of public policy on people still chasing the dream.


Cruz: The report is called, “The Uncomfortable Truth, Racism, Injustice and Poverty in New Jersey.” Renee Koubiadis is the executive director of the Anti-Poverty Network and Rev. Charles Boyer is pastor of AME Bethel in Woodbury and also a member of the APN board. So Renee, explain what you mean by structural racism.

Koubiadis: Sure. So, we are not talking about overt racism or we’re not blaming individuals. It’s really racism that exists in the structures within our state, within the institutions and I like to think of it as the kinds of things we don’t necessarily recognize in our everyday lives because they’ve just been there all along. And, unless we stop and actually look at them and study them, we don’t realize that they are structural racism.

Cruz: Where do you see these things manifest, reverend?

Boyer: We see these things manifest in multiple sectors, in housing, in criminal justice and in economics. We see it manifest itself in the education system, in the protections, the legal protections that residents have, so even in the environmental issues, we see it play out almost in every sector that we can think of.

Cruz: The report references racist results. What does that mean exactly?

Koubiadis: Sure, it just means lack of opportunities for people of color across our state. It means that we’re the third most segregated state in the nation right now. And, some of it has to do with policies both at the federal, state and local levels over the years that really have created this situation where people of color have less opportunity and barriers in place.

Cruz: So, does the report give facts and figures about where you see this the most?

Boyer: Yes, absolutely. The report in all of those various sectors, it really is focused on the results. One of the things in the crafting of this report, during that process everyone involved was really concerned with not to get caught up in individual racism. And, all of our discussion about race were often caught up in whether somebody says the “N” word, whether it’s this, whether it’s that. And, at the end of the day, the brilliance of the report is in the fact that we define racism in its most cogent and most potent attributes as the results, not so much as the intent. So, that’s what this report is based around — focusing on racism as a result-based piece rather than the overt racism. It’s more about the institution and how it manifested itself in all of the various sectors.

Cruz: So, you’re not just looking at the problem in this report, you’re also bringing up recommendations. Let’s talk about a few of those. What’s the top recommendation here, Renee?

Koubiadis: Well, there are five recommendations that are cross-cutting. They are requiring racial impact statements of all legislation and regulations in the state. Similar to financial impact statements that the Office of Legislation Services (OLS) does for the state for any legislation, they would be required to do racial impact statements to see the impact.

Cruz: It seems to me that if this report is correct, everything has a racial impact, yes?

Boyer: Yes, absolutely.

Cruz: The OLS, they’re just going to say yes, these are the impacts.

Boyer: Yes, and what’s really important about racial impact statements is that they give legislators and the community an opportunity to examine what the possible consequence is, the unintended consequences, that any piece of policy may have. And without having that data, oftentimes legislation may be well-intended, but often have very dangerous results.

Cruz: Right, these things that you don’t see, the unintended consequences. You also talk about re-establishing the Office of the Public Advocate, which had been through the Corzine administration.

Koubiadis: Yes, and we see that as a real key piece to helping people finding recourse when there is discrimination within the systems throughout our state. They can audit public agencies and really look at all of the pieces of the state.

Cruz: And, so this gives those affected an opportunity to have an actual advocate in the state government whose mission is to do that specifically.

Koubiadis: Yes, absolutely.

Cruz: It seems to me if we do a report like this in 10 years, that I’m afraid, and maybe you agree or disagree, that the results would not be much different without any serious radical change.

Boyer: Yes. Well, let me back up a little bit. The intent of this report is to put enough information in the hands of advocates and policy makers and all stakeholders so that we can avoid that very thing. So, that’s why there’s policy recommendations under each chapter. And so, what we’re hoping to do is use this as a tool so that all of us who are well-intentioned can move forward and actually do these things, take on that recommendation and not be in the same place. We do hope to make some progress.

Koubiadis: To that point, research just came out this week showing between 1983 and 2013 the wealth of blacks declined 75 percent. And the wealth of Latinos declined 50 percent over those 30 years. And it’s estimated that by the year 2024, whites will have 99 and 75 times the wealth of blacks and Latinos, respectively.

Cruz: Alright, Renee Koubiadis and Charles Boyer, thank you both very much for being with us.

TRANSCRIPT

it's called the uncomfortable truth a

new report links chronic poverty to

institutional racism the anti-poverty

networks executive director Rene

kumaradas and board member Reverend

Charles Boyer recently joined senior

correspondent David Cruz to explain what

they see as the effects of public policy

on people still chasing the dream the

report is called the uncomfortable truth

racism injustice and poverty in New

Jersey

Rene Gube eëitís is executive director

of the anti-poverty Network and Charles

Boyer is pastor of AME Bethel and

Woodbury and also a member of the APN

board right so Rene tell me explain what

you mean by structural racism sure so

we're not talking about overt racism or

we're not blaming individuals it's

really racism that exists in the

structures within our state within the

institutions and I like to think of it

as the kind of the kinds of things we

don't necessarily recognize in our

everyday lives because they've just been

there all along and unless we stop and

actually look at them and study them we

don't realize that they are structural

racism where do you see these things

manifest driven oh we see these things

manifest in multiple sectors and housing

in criminal justice in economics we see

it manifests itself in the education

system in the protections the legal

protections that residents have so it's

it's even in in the environmental issues

we see a play out almost in in every

sector that that we can think of the

report references racist results what

does that mean exactly

either way sure it just means lack of

opportunities for people of color across

our state it means that we're the third

most segregated state in the nation

right now and and some of that has to do

with policies both at the federal state

and local level over the years that

really have created this situation

where

people of color have less opportunity

and barriers in place does the report

give facts and figures about where you

see this the most yes absolutely the

report in in all those various sectors

yeah it really is focused on the results

one of the things in the crafting of

this report during that process everyone

involved was really concerned not to get

caught up in individual racism and all

of our discussions about race were often

caught up in whether somebody says the

n-word or whether is this or whether is

that and at the end of the day the the

report the brilliance of the report is

in the fact that we define racism and

it's most cogent and most potent

attributes as the results not so much as

the intent and so so so that's what this

report is based around focusing on

racism as a result based piece rather

than the overt racism is more about the

institution on how it manifests itself

in all the various sectors so you're not

just looking at the problem in this

report you're also bringing up

recommendations let's talk about a few

of those what's what's the top

recommendation hearing well there are

five recommendations there are

cross-cutting they are you know

requiring racial impact statements of

all legislation and regulations it seems

to me that if this report is correct and

everything has an array shal impact yeah

yes yeah and what's really important

about you know racial impacts they must

they give legislators in the community

an opportunity to examine what the

possible consequences the unintended

consequences that any piece of policy

may have and without having that data

often time legislation may be well

intended but often have very dangerous

results it seems to me like you know if

we do a report like this in ten years

that I'm afraid and maybe you agree or

disagree that the results would not be

much different

without any serious radical change

that's why there's policy

recommendations under under each chapter

and so what we're hoping to do is that

this is a tool so that all of us who are

well intentioned can move forward and

actually do the things take on these

recommendations and not be in the same

place we do hope to make some progress

and ten seconds I got sure to that point

research just came out this week showing

that between 1983 and 2013 the wealth of

blacks declined 75% and the wealth of

Latinos declined 50% over those 30 years

and it's estimated that by the Year 2024

White's will have 99 and 75 times a

wealth of blacks and Latinos

respectively stark numbers all right

Rene Gube eëitís and Charles Boyer

thank you both very much for being with

thank you

You May Also Like