>> Sreenivasan: FOR MORE THAN 30
YEARS, MANY U.S. EMPLOYERS IN
SEASONAL BUSINESSES HAVE RELIED
ON FOREIGN WORKERS TO FILL
POSITIONS AMERICANS OFTEN WON'T
APPLY FOR.
THE H-2B VISA PROGRAM ALLOWS
COMPANIES TO HIRE MIGRANTS
TEMPORARILY FOR LOW-SKILLED,
NON-AGRICULTURAL JOBS IN
EVERYTHING FROM THE HOTEL
BUSINESS TO LANDSCAPING TO
MEATPACKING AND SEAFOOD
PROCESSING.
BUT THIS YEAR, WITH DEMAND
SOARING TO A HISTORIC RATE, MANY
COMPANIES HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO
SECURE H-2B VISAS FOR THEIR
WORKERS.
NEWSHOUR WEEKEND'S CHRISTOPHER
BOOKER REPORTS FROM MARYLAND'S
EASTERN SHORE, WHERE THE STATE'S
FAMED CRAB INDUSTRY IS FEELING
THE EFFECTS.
THIS STORY IS PART OF OUR
ONGOING SERIES ABOUT POVERTY AND
OPPORTUNITY IN AMERICA, "CHASING
THE DREAM."
>> Reporter: WHAT IS SAID TO
DIFFERENTIATE MARYLAND CRAB IS
THE SALTINESS OF THE CHESAPEAKE
BAY AND THE PERFECTLY SIZED
JUMBO LUMP OF MEAT THAT COMES
FROM THE BACK FIN.
THE EXTRACTION PROCESS IS
LARGELY THE SAME AS IT HAS BEEN
FOR THE PAST 100 YEARS, WITH THE
CRAB PICKED BY HAND,
TRADITIONALLY BY WOMEN, BUT THE
FACES OF THOSE DOING PICKING,
HAVE CHANGED.
>> THE AMERICAN CRAB PICKER HAS
GONE BY THE WAYSIDE.
THE OLDER LADIES HAVE DIED OFF
AND THE YOUNGER LADIES NOW WANT
A FULL-TIME JOB.
WE ONLY OFFER EIGHT MONTHS OUT
OF THE YEAR.
WE'RE SEASONAL.
SO THEY WANT SOMETHING THEY CAN
COUNT ON YEAR-ROUND WITH
BENEFITS, AND WE DON'T OFFER
THAT.
>> Reporter: LIKE OTHERS IN THE
AREA, HARRY PHILLIPS HAS GOTTEN
AROUND THE SHORTAGE OF AMERICAN
WORKERS WITH A MIGRANT
WORKFORCE, HIRED SEASON AFTER
SEASON, AND BROUGHT LEGALLY TO
THE U.S. ON H-2B VISAS.
>> YOU HAVE TO HAVE YOUR
PETITION IN THE 1st OF JANUARY
SO WE COULD HAVE OUR WORKERS
HERE THE FIRST DAY OF APRIL.
AND IT'S ALWAYS BEEN FIRST-COME,
FIRST-SERVE.
SO IT'S WORKED OUT PERFECT OVER
THESE LAST 25 YEARS.
>> Reporter: THE WAY IT WORKS IS
THAT AMERICAN COMPANIES
THEMSELVES APPLY FOR THE VISAS.
ONCE THEY'RE APPROVED, THEY
CAN INVITE FOREIGN WORKERS
TO COME.
BUT THIS YEAR THE ROOM IS EMPTY
WHERE 50 WORKERS, MOST OF THEM
WOMEN FROM MEXICO, USUALLY PICK
CRAB.
RECORD DEMAND FOR THE VISAS
ACROSS THE COUNTRY, COUPLED WITH
CHANGES TO THE PROGRAM, SQUEEZED
PHILLIPS OUT.
>> I NEED THIS, MY FAMILY NEEDS
THIS, MY CHILDREN, AND MY
GRANDCHILDREN COMING UP, THEY
ARE COUNTING ON THIS BUSINESS
TO KEEP THEM GOING INTO THE
FUTURE.
>> Reporter: THIS JANUARY, U.S.
COMPANIES APPLIED FOR MORE THAN
80,000 H-2B VISAS FOR THE SECOND
HALF OF THE FISCAL YEAR, BUT
ONLY 33,000 WERE AVAILABLE UNDER
A LONGSTANDING CONGRESSIONAL
CAP.
IN RESPONSE TO THIS YEAR'S
DEMAND, THE GOVERNMENT CHANGED
THE WAY IT AWARDS H-2B'S, MOVING
FROM A FIRST-COME-FIRST SERVE
SYSTEM TO A LOTTERY.
HARRY PHILLIPS' COMPANY WAS NOT
SELECTED.
>> MY ACCOUNTANT COMES EVERY SO
OFTEN, SHE SAID I'VE GOT SOME
GOOD NEWS AND BAD NEWS.
THE BAD NEWS WAS I HADN'T MADE
ANY MONEY AND THE GOOD NEWS WAS
I WASN'T GOING TO HAVE TO PAY
ANY QUARTERLY TAXES.
THAT TELLS YOU WHAT WE'RE DOING.
>> Reporter: WHILE IT IS QUIET
AT PHILLIPS' PLANT, ONE OF HIS
COMPETITORS, NEARBY LINDY'S
SEAFOOD, IS SURVIVING FOR NOW
WITH A FRACTION OF ITS USUAL
WORKFORCE.
THEY'RE WORKING OFF VISAS ISSUED
LAST FALL.
LINDY'S, TOO, WAS NOT SELECTED
IN THE LOTTERY.
>> THIS IS EVERYTHING.
MY FAMILY GREW UP HERE.
IN THE SUMMERTIME, THIS IS WHAT
WE DID.
WE DIDN'T TAKE VACATIONS, WE
CAME HERE AND PICKED CRABS.
>> Reporter: AUBREY VINCENT HAS
WORKED FOR THE FAMILY BUSINESS
SINCE SHE WAS 12 YEARS OLD.
SHE NORMALLY HIRES ABOUT 130
SEASONAL CRAB PICKERS.
THE MAJORITY ON H-2B VISAS.
WHY IS IT SO DIFFICULT TO HIRE
AMERICANS TO DO THESE JOBS?
>> I HAVE AMAZING AMERICAN TRUCK
DRIVERS, I HAVE SOME AMERICAN
PICKERS, I HAVE TONS OF PEOPLE
IN MY OFFICE, THE LADY THAT RUNS
THIS PLANT, SHE'S A FULL TIME
AMERICAN EMPLOYEE.
THE PROBLEM THAT I'M RUNNING
INTO IS, IS I DON'T HAVE ENOUGH.
SO, I USE THE H-2B PROGRAM TO
SUPPLEMENT THAT AMERICAN
WORKFORCE.
SO, I THINK A LOT OF IT HAS TO
DO WITH OUR AREA, WE JUST DON'T
HAVE THE PEOPLE.
THERE'S NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE
MOVING INTO THE AREA, BECAUSE
PEOPLE ARE LOOKING FOR FULL TIME
OPPORTUNITIES.
>> Reporter: VINCENT ESTIMATES
THE BUSINESS IS LOSING THOUSANDS
OF DOLLARS A DAY.
THE PASTEURIZER AND COOLER SHE
PURCHASED LAST WINTER SIT EMPTY
AND UNUSED.
THINKING OF THE LOSSES YOU'RE
TAKING NOW, IF YOU WERE TO
INCREASE YOUR WAGES, WOULD YOU
BE ABLE TO SHRINK THOSE LOSSES?
>> I PAY MORE THAN ANY PICKING
HOUSE IN THE AREA, SIGNIFICANTLY
MORE.
I PAY $4.50 A POUND, AND I PAY
$9.51 TRAINING WAGE.
SO, A LOT OF MY EMPLOYEES ARE
MAKING ANYWHERE FROM LIKE $12 TO
$16 AN HOUR.
WE'RE PAYING MORE THAN ANY OF
THE OPEN POSITIONS IN TOWN.
AND STILL, I CAN'T SEEM TO GET
PEOPLE INTERESTED.
>> Reporter: BY THE END OF
DECEMBER, ALL 19 OF VINCENT'S H-
2B WORKERS HAVE TO RETURN TO
HOME, AND THERE'S NO GUARANTEE
SHE WILL BE ABLE TO HIRE THEM
BACK NEXT YEAR.
>> I MEAN, OUR SITUATION IS BAD,
BUT THERE ARE PEOPLE IN THE
COUNTRY THAT HAVE IT MUCH WORSE
THAN US, AND THEY NEED TO MAKE
SURE THEIR REPRESENTATIVES
UNDERSTAND THAT.
INFORMATION ON H-2B?
>> Reporter: BUT VINCENT IS NOT
SITTING IDLE.
THIS SUMMER, SHE MOVED FROM
PHONE CALLS TO DIRECT
INTERACTION ON THE STREETS OF
WASHINGTON.
>> SOME INFORMATION ON THE H-2B
PROGRAM.
CONGRESS COULD FIX IT, THE
ADMINISTRATION COULD FIX IT,
THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENT
PEOPLE THAT, IF THEY WERE
WILLING TO STEP UP, AND REALLY
LOOK AT THE PROGRAM OBJECTIVELY,
THEY COULD FIX IT.
>> Reporter: THE MANY DIFFERENT
PLAYERS MIGHT BE PART OF THE
COMPLICATION.
WHEN THE H-2B PROGRAM HIT ITS
CAP, ONLY CONGRESS COULD
AUTHORIZE MORE TO BE RELEASED.
AFTER MONTHS OF DELAYS, IN
MARCH, CONGRESS DID AUTHORIZE
MORE THAN 63,000 ADDITIONAL
VISAS.
BUT THAT'S NOT THE END OF THE
STORY, THE VISAS MUST BE
APPROVED BY TWO ADDITIONAL
PARTIES, THE DEPARTMENT OF
HOMELAND SECURITY AND THE
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR.
THAT'S A SLOW PROCESS, ON TOP OF
THE CONGRESSIONAL DELAY.
SO FAR, ONLY 15,000 ADDITIONAL
VISAS HAVE BEEN ISSUED, ONCE
AGAIN THROUGH A LOTTERY.
ONLY ONE MARYLAND CRAB
PROCESSING COMPANY WAS SELECTED.
>> AN ISSUE VERY IMPORTANT TO MY
DISTRICT, I HAVE THE BEAUTIFUL
EASTERN SHORE OF MARYLAND, IS
THE H-2B VISA ISSUE.
>> Reporter: MARYLAND'S EASTERN
SHORE IS REPRESENTED BY
REPUBLICAN CONGRESSMAN ANDY
HARRIS, WHO SITS ON THE
SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF HOMELAND SECURITY.
>> THEY HAVE TO BRING THOSE
CRABS TO BE PROCESSED SOMEWHERE,
THEY HAVE TO BE PICKED, BECAUSE
WHEN YOU EAT A CRAB CAKE,
BELIEVE ME, YOU'RE NOT EATING
THE WHOLE CRAB.
>> Reporter: THESE VISAS ARE
SITTING WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF
HOMELAND SECURITY, AND THE
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR, READY TO
GO, BUT THE PROCESSING PLANTS
ARE SITTING EMPTY.
>> IT'S A FAIRLY LENGTHY
PROCESS.
IT NORMALLY TAKES A COUPLE OF
MONTHS, WE'RE HOPING THAT IT CAN
GET SHORTENED TO, YOU KNOW, ONLY
SEVERAL WEEKS, BUT THERE IS A
PROCESS.
>> Reporter: 15,000 IS WOEFULLY
INADEQUATE WHEN YOU'VE HAD SO
MANY APPLICATIONS.
THEY KNEW FULL WELL THAT THIS
WAS COMING.
>> YEAH, LOOK, THIS IS CONGRESS'
PROBLEM.
CONGRESS HAS SET THE CAP,
CONGRESS DELAYED DOING THEIR
OMNIBUS BILL, WE INCLUDED THE
FIX IN A LATE APPROPRIATIONS
MEASURE, AND EVERYTHING
CASCADED.
IT WAS A DOMINO EFFECT.
>> Reporter: CONGRESSMAN HARRIS
WAS ONE OF 82 REPRESENTATIVES TO
SIGN A LETTER CALLING ON THE
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
TO RELEASE THE ADDITIONAL VISAS.
>> THIS IS ACTUALLY THE IDEAL
FOREIGN WORKER TO COME IN,
BECAUSE THEY ACTUALLY ARE
SUPPORTING OUR MEDICARE SYSTEM,
SUPPORTING OUR SOCIAL SECURITY
SYSTEM, EVEN THOUGH THEY WILL
NEVER PARTICIPATE IN IT.
>> Reporter: BUT HARRIS SAYS,
CONVINCING GROUPS ON BOTH SIDES
OF THE POLITICAL SPECTRUM ISN'T
EASY.
WORKERS' RIGHTS AND CIVIL RIGHTS
GROUPS ARGUE THE SYSTEM NEEDS
REFORM AND INCREASED OVERSIGHT
TO PROTECT MIGRANTS FROM
EXPLOITATION AND UNION GROUPS,
LIKE THE A.F.L.-C.I.O., HAVE
ARGUED THAT ALLOWING MIGRANTS TO
WORK SEASONALLY DEPRESSES WAGES
FOR AMERICAN WORKERS.
AT THE SAME TIME, SOME
CONSERVATIVE LAWMAKERS HAVE
TAKEN A HARDLINE AGAINST
EXPANSION OF THE PROGRAM.
>> A LOT OF THE ARGUMENTS FOR
THIS KIND OF PROGRAM BOIL DOWN
TO THIS: NO AMERICAN WORKER WILL
DO THAT JOB.
THAT IS A LIE.
IT IS A LIE.
THERE IS NO JOB THAT AMERICANS
WILL NOT DO.
>> Reporter: CONGRESSMAN HARRIS
SAYS THE H-2B PROGRAM IS NOT
JUST ABOUT THE JOBS THAT THE
MIGRANT WORKERS ARE DOING.
>> FOR EVERY JOB THAT THEY'RE
FILLING, THERE ARE AT LEAST
THREE OR FOUR AMERICAN JOBS THAT
DEPEND ON THEM.
THERE'S THE PERSON WHO SUPPLIES
THE CONTAINERS THAT THEY'RE
GOING TO PUT THE CRAB MEAT IN.
THERE'S THE TRUCKER WHO TRUCKS
THE CONTAINERS IN, AND THE
FILLED CONTAINERS OUT.
THERE'S THE RESTAURANT WHO
SERVES THE CRAB, THERE ARE THE
DISTRIBUTORS, THERE ARE THE
WAITRESSES IN THE RESTAURANTS.
THERE ARE MANY DOWNSTREAM JOBS.
>> Reporter: THOSE DOWNSTREAM
ARE ALREADY FEELING THE EFFECTS.
AT OLD SALTY'S, A POPULAR
EASTERN SHORE RESTAURANT, OWNER
JAY NEWCOMB SAYS HE STRUGGLES TO
FIND ENOUGH FRESH CRAB FOR HIS
MENU.
>> LAST YEAR I PUT AWAY LIKE
4,000 POUNDS, AND THAT WAS ALL
BUT USED UP.
SO NOW WE'RE IN THE FRESH
MARKET, AND IT'S BEEN HARD TO
GET ALSO, PLUS THE PRICE IS UP A
LOT.
>> Reporter: HOW MUCH HAS THE
PRICE CHANGED?
>> 3 TO $4 A POUND.
>> Reporter: JUST THIS YEAR?
>> YES, JUST THIS YEAR.
>> Reporter: WHAT WILL IT MEAN
FOR THIS COMMUNITY IF NEXT
SUMMER IS LIKE THIS SUMMER AND
THEY HAVEN'T FIGURED IT OUT?
>> NEXT YEAR WE FEEL IT'S GOING
TO BE WORSE.
THERE'S A LOT MORE DEMAND THIS
YEAR, SO A LOT MORE NEXT YEAR,
AND WE JUST DON'T THINK THEY'RE
GOING TO BE AS LUCKY WITH THE
LOTTERY.
>> Reporter: WHO DO YOU THINK IS
RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT'S HAPPENED?
>> IT'S WASHINGTON.
>> Reporter: JUST THIS MONTH,
THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND
SECURITY RESPONDED TO
CONGRESSMAN HARRIS' LETTER,
INFORMING HIM THAT IT WOULD NOT
BE RELEASING ANY ADDITIONAL
VISAS.
WHERE ARE YOU NEXT YEAR IF YOU
DON'T GET YOUR VISAS?
>> SO MY FAMILY STARTED THIS
BUSINESS.
MY DAUGHTER IS TWO.
WHAT I PRAY, IS THAT I CAN KEEP
IT ALIVE ENOUGH THAT IT DOES GET
FIXED, AND THAT I CAN PASS THIS
OPPORTUNITY DOWN TO HER.
I LOVE THIS.
I LOVE THIS INDUSTRY, I LOVE
THIS AREA, WORST CASE SCENARIO,
IS I'M NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO
PULL THAT OFF.
AND THAT'S THE SCARIEST PART.
>> Reporter: LACKING SOLUTIONS,
HARRY PHILLIPS IS MAKING
CONTINGENCY PLANS.
>> I CAN'T DO IT TWO YEARS IN A
ROW, NO.
IF WE DON'T GET OUR WORKERS
ANOTHER YEAR, WE'LL SHUT THE
DOORS.
EITHER THAT, OR WE'VE EVEN
CONSIDERED, THERE'S CRABS IN
MEXICO.
WE'RE CHECKING TO SEE WHAT'S
GOING ON, AND WE'RE GOING TO FLY
DOWN THERE THIS WINTER.
>> Reporter: TO SEE ABOUT MAYBE
SETTING UP SHOP THERE.
>> SETTING UP SHOP IN MEXICO.
THE LADIES ARE THERE.
THEY'RE ALL WILLING TO WORK.
THE CRABS ARE THERE.
THIS IS ALL I KNOW.
I DON'T HAVE MUCH EDUCATION, AND
I DO KNOW WHAT I'M DOING HERE.
SO WHAT ELSE CAN WE DO?
WE CAN'T SIT HERE IDLE.