Driving While Black: A Look Into the Mobility Restraint on People of Color
From slavery to Jim Crow to the civil rights era and to modern day, the new documentary “Driving While Black: Race, Space, and Mobility In America” chronicles the riveting history of Black Americans and their complex relationship to the road, the automobile and the series of paradoxes that relationship has engendered. Tonight the film’s directors – acclaimed historian Gretchen Sorin and award-winning documentarian Ric Burns – join us on this exploration of how the right to move freely and safely across America has been circumscribed by race.
Our partners at MetroFocus report on this story.
TRANSCRIPT
WHAT IT MEANS TO BE AMERICAN IS TO TAKE TO THE ROAD.
MOBILITY IS ESSENTIAL TO FREEDOM.
DISCOVERY, FREEDOM.
THE NOTION OF DRIVING WHILE BLACK REMINDS US THAT’S NOT AVAILABLE TO ALL AMERICANS.
TO BE ABLE TO MOVE FREELY.
WE LIVE IN A COUNTRY WHERE IT’S NEVER BEEN EVERYBODY’S RIGHT.
THERE ARE STILL SO MANY DANGERS.
WE HAVE TO ENGAGE HISTORY WITH THE KIND OF BRUTAL HONESTY.
♪
> HELLO, I’M RAFAEL PI ROMAN.
YOU NO E THE CLIP WE JUST SAW WAS A PREVIEW OF ‘DRIVING WHILE BLACK,’ A NEW PBS DOCUMENTARY THAT CHRONICLES THE HISTORY OF THE COMPLEX RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN AFRICAN-AMERICANS AND THE AUTOMOBILE AND THE SERIES OF PARADOXES THAT THAT RELATIONSHIP HAS ENGENDERS.
FROM SLAVELY TO JIM CROW TO THE CIVIL RIGHTS ERA TO THE PRESENT DAY, THIS DOCUMENTARY BY ACCLAIMED HISTORIAN DR. GRETCHEN SORIN AND AWARD WINNING DOM MEN TARN RIC BURNS EXPLAINS HOW THE RIGHT TO MOVE FREELY AND SAFELY ACROSS AMERICA HAS BEEN — AND JOINING US NOW TO TALK ABOUT ‘DRIVING WHILE BLACK,’ THE FILM’S DIRECTORS, GRETCHEN SORIN AND RIC BURNS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US TODAY.
THANKS FOR HAVING US.
THANKS, RAFAEL.
SO, GRETCHEN, THE AMAZING THING ABOUT THIS FILM IS HOW THIS PARTICULAR SUBJECT THAT YOU COVER OPENS UP A WINDOW TO THE WHOLE, ALMOST TO THE ENTIRE AFRICAN-AMERICAN EXPERIENCE IN THIS COUNTRY.
SO, LET ME BEGIN WITH THE OBVIOUS QUESTION, HOW DOES THIS PROJECT COME TO BE?
WHAT WAS IT GENESIS?
I WAS WORKING ON AN EXHIBITION, I’M AN EXHIBITION KUR YEAH OR THE, AND I WAS WORKING ON AN EXHIBITION ON THE HISTORY OF AFRICAN-AMERICANS IN SARATOGA SPRINGS, NEW YORK, WHICH IS A RESORT COMMUNITY.
AND A COLLEAGUE OF MINE HANDED ME A XEROXED PAGE THAT HAS THE COVER OF THE NEGRO MOTORIST GREEN BOOK.
WELL, I HAD NEVER HEARD OF IT.
AND I WAS SURPRISED THAT SOMEONE WHO STUDIED AFRICAN-AMERICAN HISTORY THAT THERE WAS SOMETHING THAT I JUST HAD ABSOLUTELY NO IDEA ABOUT.
AND I WANTED TO KNOW MORE.
SO, I REALLY STARTED THE RESEARCH LOOKING AT THE GREEN BOOK AND IT JUST EXPANDED AND EXPANDED AND EXPANDED.
THE MORE I DUG INTO IT.
AND I REALIZED THAT THE GREEN BOOK WAS REALLY JUST A LITTLE PART OF THE STORY AND THAT THE STORY WAS REALLY A STORY ABOUT THE AUTOMOBILE AND THE AFRICAN-AMERICAN EXPERIENCE AND HOW IT WAS DIFFERENT FROM THE WHITE AMERICAN EXPERIENCE WITH THE AUTOMOBILE.
AND, OF COURSE, WHEN YOU’RE TALKING ABOUT THE AUTOMOBILE, YOU OPEN UP AN ENTIRE WORLD THAT REALLY TALKS ABOUT TRAVEL AND VACATIONS AND TRANSPORTATION ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND HOW WE DECIDED TO BECOME A NATION OF DRIVERS INSTEAD OF A NATION OF PEOPLE WHO TOOK PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION.
AND RIC, HOW DID YOU GET INVOLVED IN THE PROJECT?
I’VE KNOWN GRETCHEN SINCE BACK THE LATE 19 90s AND GRETCHEN WAS A REMARKABLE ON-CAMERA INTERVIEWEE FOR THAT, TALKING ABOUT EARLY NEW YORK, SO, WE’VE BEEN KIND OF UNINDIETED COCONKON -CONSPIRATOG ON AND OFF.
AND SHE SAID, RIC, I WANT YOU TO LOOK AT THESE IMAGES AND POPPED OPEN HER LAPTOP, SHOWED ME HUNDREDS, THOUSANDS OF IMAGES SHE HAD COLLECTED OVER THE YEARS ABOUT KIND OF, LIKE, THE AMERICAN ROAD, THE WORLD OF THE AMERICAN CAR AND THE HIGHWAY FROM THE EARLY 20th CENTURY DOWN THROUGH THE EARLY 21st CENTURY, AED WHAT WAS UNCANNY, THERE WAS THIS DOUBLE EXPERIENCE, THE PARADOXAL EXPERIENCE, AS YOU SAID, RAFAEL, IN WHICH — IT’S A WORLD THAT, YOU KNOW, WHITE AMERICANS CAN SEE.
THE ROAD SIGNS AND THE HOTELS AND THE RESTAURANTS.
BUT THERE ARE THESE THINGS WHICH WERE REALLY SHOCKING TO SEE, YOU KNOW, COMING INTO A TOWN IN NORTH CAROLINA, THE KKK RIGHT NEXT TO THE ROTARY CLUB, YOU KNOW, ABOVE THE MAIN STREET OF GREENVILLE, TEXAS, GREENVILLE, THE BLACKIST SOIL, THE WHITEST PEOPLE.
SO, YOU SEE, LIKE, WOW, THE AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE LANDSCAPE HAS BEEN HAUNTED FROM THE BEGINNING WITH THIS DOUBLE INSCRIPTION, YOU KNOW, AND THAT THE WAY, AS YOU SAID, RACE BASED MOBILITY HAS BEEN UNEQUAL IN AMERICA FROM THE START.
AND BY THE END 0 OF THAT DISPLAY, GRETCHEN HAD SOLD ME.
THIS WAS GOING TO BE THE NEXT PROJECT THAT I WAS GOING TO WORK ON AND SHE AND I HAVE BEEN WORKING ON IT FOR THE LAST FIVE YEARS.
WOW.
AND GRETCHEN, AS I SAID, THE FIRST PARADOX, OF COURSE, IS THE FACT THAT WHILE THE AUTOMOBILE ALLOWED AFRICAN-AMERICANS TO LEAVE THE INDIGNITY OF JIM CROW PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION, IT CREATED A WHOLE NEW SET OF PROBLEMS, YOU KNOW, REAL FEARS, REAL THREATS ON THE ROAD AND A WHOLE NEW SET OF INDIGNITIES.
TALK ABOUT THAT FIRST PARADOX.
WELL, YOU KNOW, IT WAS DANGEROUS FOR AFRICAN-AMERICANS TO GO OUT ON THE ROAD.
IT TOOK A LOT OF COURAGE.
YOU DIDN’T KNOW, AS YOU WERE TRAVELING ACROSS THE COUNTRY, WHERE YOU WOULD BE WELCOME.
AND ESPECIALLY BEFORE THE INTERSTATE HIGHWAY SYSTEM, AFRICAN-AMERICANS WOULD HAVE TO DRIVE THROUGH THESE SMALL TOWNS.
WELL, YOU NEVER KNOW WHAT YOU COULD ENCOUNTER WHEN YOU WERE GOING THROUGH THESE SMALL TOWNS AND THERE WERE MANY STORIES OF PEOPLE WHO, YOU KNOW, DROVE THROUGH A TOWN AND THEY HAPPENED TO COME UPON A LYNCHING OR THERE WAS AN ANGRY WHITE MOB THAT ACCOSTED THEIR CAR.
SO, YOU REALLY DIDN’T KNOW WHAT COULD HAPPEN AND IF YOU COULD IMAGINE WHAT WOULD HAPPEN WHEN YOU GOT INTO A CAR ACCIDENT.
THERE WERE ONLY 200 AFRICAN-AMERICAN HOSPITALS THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE UNITED STATES, SO, IF YOU WERE IN A CAR ACCIDENT, FIRST OF ALL, THE WHITE PEOPLE WOULD BE TAKEN BY WHITE AMBULANCE, BECAUSE THE AMBULANCES WERE SEGREGATED, TO THE HOSPITAL FIRST AND ONLY THEN WOULD THE BLACK AMBULANCE BE ALLOWED TO COME IN.
MANY OF THE AMBULANCES WERE CONTROLLED BY THE FUNERAL HOMES, SO, YOU WERE ACTUALLY RIDING IN WHAT WAS CALLED A COMBINATION COACH, WHICH WAS — IT WAS BOTH AN AMBULANCE AND A HEARSE, THAT IT COULD BE CONVERTED, DEPENDING ON WHETHER THE PERSON IN THE BACK WAS ALIVE OR DEAD.
SO, YOU COULD IMAGINE WHAT THAT MUST HAVE BEEN LIKE, IF YOU WERE TRAVELING AND YOU HAD TO BE TAKEN TO A HOSPITAL.
AND MANY PEOPLE WENT FROM HOSPITAL TO HOSPITAL TO HO HOSPITAL, BECAUSE NO HOSPITAL WOULD ACCEPT THEM AS AFRICAN-AMERICANS.
SO, THOSE ARE JUST REALLY A FEW OF THE THINGS THAT HAPPENED.
AND THEN OF COURSE, THE INDIGNITIES, BECAUSE IT WAS A RARE GAS STATION OR RESTAURANT OR HOTEL OR MOTEL THAT AFRICAN-AMERICANS COULD PATRONIZE ON AMERICAN ROADS.
BUT THAT BRINGS US TO THE SECOND PARADOX, WHICH IS, AS A RESULT OF THAT, A WHOLE NEW NETWORK, AND THIS IS NEW TO ME, A WHOLE NEW NETWORK OF MOSTLY AFRICAN-AMERICAN-OWNED BUSINESSES SPROUTED UP ACROSS THE COUNTRY, HOTELS, MOTELS, RESORTS, YOU NAME IT, THAT CREATED A NEW POWER BASE FOR AFRICAN-AMERICANS AND A WHOLE NEW COMMUNITY THAT AFRICAN-AMERICANS COULD SHARE.
TALK ABOUT THAT.
YEAH, BECAUSE AFRICAN-AMERICANS WANTED TO TRAVEL.
THEY WANTED TO SEE THE COUNTRY, AND SO, IF YOU TRAVELED, YOU NEEDED GUEST HOUSES AND TOURIST HOMES, RESTAURANTS, PLACES TO STOP AND EAT.
AND GAS STATIONS.
AND SO, THIS NETWORK, PRIMARILY — PRIMARILY ON THE EAST COAST TO THE MISSISSIPPI AND THEN MANY OF THEM WERE ALSO ON THE WEST COAST, NOT AS MANY — NOT AS MANY WEST OF THE MISSISSIPPI TO THE WEST COAST, BUT THERE WAS A LARGE NETWORK OF VIBRANT AFRICAN-AMERICAN BUSINESSES THAT SERVED THIS MARKET.
THE IRONY IS, THOSE BUSINESSES GO OUT OF BUSINESS, MANY OF THEM, MOST OF THEM GO OUT OF BUSINESS WHEN AFRICAN-AMERICANS START TO FREQUENT PUBLIC ACCOMMODATIONS THAT ARE OPEN TO EVERYONE.
SO, WHEN HILTON HOTEL, WHEN HOWARD JOHNSON, ARE NOW AVAILABLE TO AFRICAN-AMERICANS, THEY GO BECAUSE THEY CAN, BECAUSE THEY WORKED SO HARD TO BREAK THESE PLACES OPEN AND THAT KILLED MANY OF THE BLACK BUSINESSES.
BUT AS, AND THIS IS A POINT THAT I THINK RIC MAKES VERY ELOQUENTLY, THAT URBAN RENEWAL DESTROYS SO MANY BLACK COMMUNITIES AND BLACK NEIGHBORHOODS THAT — THAT’S ANOTHER WAY THAT THESE BUSINESSES GET TAKEN, THEY GET TAKEN BY IMMINENT DOMAIN.
RIGHT, SO, TALK ABOUT THAT, RIC.
TALK ABOUT HOW THE DECISION TO MAKE AMERICA A NATION OF DRIVERS ON THE ONE HAND, BY THE CREATION OF THE INTERSTATE HIGHWAY SYSTEM, WAS A POSITIVE FOR AFRICAN-AMERICANS, BECAUSE IT MADE TRAVEL SAFER, ON THOR HAND, IT HAD THIS EFFECT THAT GRETCHEN JUST TALKED ABOUT.
ELABORATE ON THAT.
IT’S EXTRAORDINARY.
ALL THE ISSUES THAT HAVE TO DO WITH MOBILITY HAVE TO DO WITH POWER, HAVE TO DO WITH WHO CONTROLS THE POWER, THE POWER TO MOVE, WHERE YOU CAN GO, WHEN YOU CAN GO, HOW YOU CAN GO.
AND WHEN THE REMARKABLE 41,000-MILE EVENTUALLY LONG INTERSTATE HIGHWAY SYSTEM STARTS BEING BUILT IN THE 1950s, THE QUESTION IS ALSO, LIKE, WHERE ARE THOSE HIGHWAYS GOING TO BE BUILT?
AND WHEN ANY OF THEM COME TOLL YOUR TOWN, OR CITIES, THERE’S ENORMOUS STRUGGLE TO SAY, NOT IN MY BACKYARD.
AND, OF COURSE, THE BACKYARDS IN WHICH THE INTERSTATE HIGHWAY SYSTEM BUILT WAS ALMOST INVARIABLY IN THE BACKYARDS OF PEOPLE OF COLOR.
IF YOU JUST TAKE 10, ONE OF THE LEGENDARY, YOU KNOW, INTERSTATE HIGHWAYS, IT GOES FROM, LIKE, RIGHT ACROSS THE BOTTOM OF AMERICA, YOU KNOW, WHERE IT GOES THROUGH IN NEW ORLEANS, FOR EXAMPLE, IS RIGHT THROUGH THE HEART OF ONE OF THE MOST VIBRANT BLACK COMMUNITIES, WHICH NOW HAS VERY, VERY POIGNANTLY PAINTED MURALS ON THE PILOTS OF THE OVERPASSES, YOU KNOW, THE FIGURES OF THE — OF THE KIND OF LEGENDARY MEN AND WOMEN WHO WERE THE — KIND OF THE LEADERS OF THOSE COMMUNITIES, INCLUDING, YOU KNOW, WYNTON MARSALIS’S FATHER.
THE MARSALIS HOTEL WAS A FAMOUS WEIGH STATION ALONG THE ROUTE OF THE NEGRO MOTORIST GUIDE ITINERARY ACROSS AMERICA.
ALL THE WAY OUT TO LOS ANGELES, WHERE, ONCE AGAIN, RIGHT THROUGH CENTRAL AVENUE IN LOS ANGELES, WHAT YOU FIND IS THAT, YOU KNOW, THIS POOR COMMUNITY AND THE COMMUNITIES OF COLOR, DID NOT HAVE THE POLITICAL POWER TO PREVENT THE HIGHWAY, INTERSTATE HIGHWAY FROM CRASHING THROUGH THEIR DOMAIN.
YOU KNOW, THE FILM CULMINATES WITH WHAT MOST OF US ARE FAMILIAR, ASSOCIATE WITH DRIVING WHILE BLACK, WHICH IS THE PRESENT DAY AND THE CONFRONTATIONS BETWEEN THE POLICE AND AFRICAN-AMERICAN MOTORISTS.
AND THIS IS WHERE, IN THE DOCUMENTARY, THE SCHOLARS STOP TALKING ABOUT THE HISTORY OF THIS EXPERIENCE AS OBJECTIVE SCHOLARS AND START TALKING ABOUT PARTICIPANTS OR PROTAGONISTS OF THAT STORY, AND GRETCHEN, YOU’RE ONE OF THEM.
YOU TALK ABOUT THIS EXPERIENCE AS A PARENT.
TELL US ABOUT THAT EXPERIENCE.
YOU KNOW, MY KIDS GREW UP IN A RURAL AREA, COOPERSTOWN, NEW YORK, AND IT’S A BEAUTIFUL AREA AND IT’S A GREAT PLACE TO RAISE CHILDREN.
BUT WHEN MY SON TURNED THE AGE TO GET HIS LICENSE, DRIVER’S LICENSE, I HAD TO GIVE HIM THE TALK.
THE TALK THAT EVERY AFRICAN-AMERICAN PARENT GIVES THEIR CHILD.
AND THAT TALK IS — YOU’VE GOT TO BE CAREFUL WHEN YOU’RE STOPPED BY THE POLICE.
BECAUSE THE POLICE DON’T SEE YOU AS A GOOD KID.
THEY SEE YOU AS A BLACK KID.
AND IT WAS INTERESTING, MY SON WORKED ON THIS PROJECT AS A COPRODUCER FOR THE FIRST THREE YEARS OF ITS LIFE AND WHEN WE GATHERED ALL OF THE SCHOLARS TOGETHER, HE HEARD SCHOLAR AFTER SCHOLAR AFTER SCHOLAR SAID THE SAME THING.
YOU’VE GOT TO BE CAREFUL.
AND, YOU KNOW, HE NEVER BELIEVED IT, YOU KNOW, MOM, COME ON, MOM.
MOM, I’M OKAY, EVERYTHING WILL BE FINE.
BUT I THINK HE STARTED TO UNDERSTAND THE REAL DANGER FOR AFRICAN-AMERICAN — ESPECIALLY FOR MEN, BUT IT SEEMS NOW IT’S ALSO FOR WOMEN, WE’VE SEEN SEVERAL EXAMPLES THAT ARE — THAT ARE PRETTY FRIGHTENING.
YOU KNOW, THAT — WE’RE NOT SAYING, WE NEVER SAY THAT POLICE ARE BAD, WE DON’T BELIEVE THAT POLICE ARE BAD.
WHAT WE’RE SAYING IS, YOU DON’T WANT TO ENCOUNTER THAT ONE POLICEMAN OR POLICEWOMAN WHO ONLY SEES THE COLOR OF YOUR SKIN.
AND DOESN’T — AND IS AFRAID OF YOU FOR THAT REASON.
IS TERRIFIED OF YOU, MORE TERRIFIED OF YOU THAN PERHAPS YOU ARE OF THEM.
IN THE FILM, YOU SAY AT SOME POINT THAT SOMETIMES YOU’RE HOPEFUL AND SOMETIMES YOU DON’T HAVE SO MUCH HOPE.
WHAT GIVES YOU HOPE AND WHAT TAKES IT AWAY?
OH, THAT’S A BRILLIANT QUESTION.
YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT GIVES ME HOPE IS THAT ACCOMPLICES LIKE RIC BURNS ARE WILLING TO SAY, YOU KNOW, LET’S — WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THIS.
YOU KNOW, THERE ARE TIMES IN AMERICAN HISTORY WHEN WHITE AMERICANS HAVE JOINED WITH AFRICAN-AMERICANS TO TRY AND MAKE CHANGE.
AND THAT’S REALLY ONE OF THE KINDS OF THINGS THAT GIVES ME HOPE.
EVERY TIME I SEE OR HEAR OF ANOTHER BLACK MAN BEING MURDERED BY THE POLICE, I — YOU KNOW, MY HEART SINKS A LITTLE BIT.
YOU KNOW, I THINK, WHEN WILL THIS STOP, WHEN WILL THIS STOP BEING JUST A REGULAR PART OF OUR EXISTENCE?
LET’S HOPE IT WILL STOP SOON.
AND WE HAVE TO STOP, BECAUSE WE’RE OUT OF TIME.
THANK YOU BOTH SO MUCH FOR JOINING US TODAY.
IT’S A WONDERFUL FILM.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH, RAFAEL.
THANKS FOR HAVING US.