Rochester Pastor Is Advocating for Change in Her Community After Daniel Prude Verdict
In September we reported on the horror and outrage in Rochester and across the nation when police bodycam footage capturing the death of Daniel Prude was finally made public. That footage revealed what has now become an all too familiar sight, police using excessive force against an unarmed Black man, resulting in his death. In the disturbing video, Prude can be seen naked, handcuffed, and hooded while his chest is pressed against the ground. In response, protests erupted in Rochester. And while police initially reacted with force, local leaders, including Reverend Myra Brown, intervened to ensure that the demonstrators could air their grievances peacefully, and without fear of harm. The footage also prompted a vow from the state Attorney General’s office to investigate Prude’s death. But Attorney General Letitia James recently announced that a grand jury has declined to bring any charges against the officers involved. Tonight the Reverend, lead pastor and priest at Spiritus Christi Church in Rochester and advocate for racial justice, joins us to discuss the grand jury decision and her role in promoting peace.
Our partners at MetroFocus report on this story.
TRANSCRIPT
> GOOD EVENING AND WELCOME TO METRO FOCUS.
I’M JACK FORD.
BACK IN SEPTEMBER WHEN ROCHESTER POLICE FINALLY RELEASED THE BODY CAM FOOTAGE OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES THAT LED TO THE DEATH OF DANIEL CRUDE, PEOPLE WERE HORRIFIED BY WHAT THEY SAW.
THE FOOTAGE REVEALED WHAT HAS NOW BECOME AN ALL TOO FAMILIAR AND TOO PAINFUL SIGHT.
POLICE USING EXCESSIVE FORCE AGAINST AN UNARMED BLACK MAN RESULTING IN HIS DEATH.
IN THIS DISTURBING VIDEO HE CAN BE SEEN NAKED, HANDCUFFED, HOODED, LYING ON THE GROUND.
AFTER THE FOOTAGE WAS RELEASED.
PROTESTS ERUPTED IN ROCHESTER.
TONIGHT AS PART OF OUR CHASING THE DREAM INITIATIVE ON POVERTY, JUSTICE AND ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY IN AMERICA WE’RE PLEASED TO BE JOINED BY LEAD PASTOR AND PRIEST AT SPIRITS CRISTIE CHURCH IN ROCHESTER, THE REVEREND MIRA FWROUN TALK ABOUT THE CIRCUMSTANCES AND THE AFTERMATH.
PLEASURE TO HAVE YOU HERE WITH US.
THANK YOU.
GOOD TO BE HERE, THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
BEFORE WE GET TO THE CIRCUMSTANCES AND THE AFTERMATH.
LET ME ASK ABOUT YOUR.
YOU LIVED THERE IN ROCHESTER.
YOU EXPERIENCED IT.
YOU TALKED TO PEOPLE.
WHAT WAS YOUR EXPERIENCE OF THE STATE OF ISSUES FOCUSING ON RACIAL EQUALITY, ESPECIALLY WITH REGARD TO POLICING IN THE JUSTICE SYSTEM?
SO ROCHESTER’S ALWAYS HAD KIND OF A DUALISTIC RELATIONSHIP WITH RACIAL JUSTICE.
HOME OAF FREDERICK DOUGLAS AND SUSAN B. ANTHONY AND ALSO A AREA WHERE THERE WERE KKK MEETINGS IN OUR SUBURBAN AREAS.
THERE’S BEEN POLICING ISSUES WITHIN COMMUNITIES OF COLOR FOR A LONG TIME.
AND, YOU KNOW, WE HAD THE UP RISINGS OF ’64 THAT CENTERED POLICING ISSUES WITHIN THE PLAQUE AND BROWN COMMUNICATE.
WE WERE JUST HITTING THE STREETS AND COMING BACK FROM PROTESTING AROUND WHAT HAPPENED TO GEORGE FLOYD.
AND THEN DANIEL PRUDE HAPPENED.
SO WHEN DANIEL PRUDE WAS KILLED IT REALLY EXACERBATED THE RACIAL DIVIDE THAT WAS ALREADY THERE BETWEEN THE POLICING SYSTEM AND BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITIES IN TERMS OF, YOU KNOW, WHETHER WE FELT SAFE ENOUGH WHEN POLICE CAME INTO OUR COMMUNITIES.
ONCE THE PROTESTS GOT UNDER WAY.
I MENTIONED THAT YOU AND OTHER COMMUNITY LEADERS WERE WORKING TO KEEP THEM PEACEFUL.
AND YOU WERE WORKING WITH AUTHORITIES.
WORKING WITH THE PROTESTERS.
AND I WANT TO ASK ABOUT A COUPLE OF THINGS THAT TOOK PLACE HERE.
ONE WAS, YOU ARE ENGAGING WITH ELDERS.
TO BE PART OF THE PROTEST MOVEMENT AND TO GUIDE IT AND PROVIDE WISDOM TO IT.
TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT NOTION OF ELDERS.
AND WHAT THEY CAN SKPROEFD WHAT THEY DID PROVIDE IN TERMS OF THE PROTESTS HERE.
AND THE ELDERS IS THE MODEL FROM THE BLACK COMMUNITY.
THE AS CULTURAL MODEL WHERE, YOU KNOW, THERE WAS A TIME IN HISTORY WHERE BLACK PEOPLE BECAUSE OF THE DOMESTIC TERROR AND JUST REALLY FEELING LIKE THEY HAD TO ATTEND — WE HAD TO ATTEND TO OUR OWN NEEDS.
WE HAD ELD ERLS IN OUR COMMUNITIES THAT KNEW HOW TO WALK ALONGSIDE OF US, HELP US TO DISCHARGE THE PAIN WE WERE FEELING, HOLD THAT PAIN, AND MADE SURE WE WERE SAFE AND KNEW THAT WE WERE NOT ALONE.
SO THAT CULTURAL MODEL REALLY IS TRANSFERABLE.
SO IN THE MOVEMENT, THERE WERE TWO FRIENDS OF MINE.
SHIRLEY AND — SHIRLEY — DRAWING A BLANK ON HIS NAME.
THAT IS WHAT A CAMERA DOES TO YOU.
HAPPENS TO ME ALL THE TIME.
YOU HAVE IT RIGHT THERE BUT YOU ARE LOOKING IN THE CAMERA AND WON’T COME OUT.
SHIRLEY AND JIM THOMPSON WHO PROPOSED THE ELDER MODEL THE DAY BEFORE THAT DAY IN SEPTEMBER.
BUT THERE WERE ONLY ABOUT FIVE ELDERS THAT SHOWED UP.
SO I ACTUALLY PROPOSED WE REINVIGORATE THAT MODEL, BRING IT BACK FOR THAT NEXT PROTEST ON THAT SUNDAY.
AND I PUT OUT A CALL FOR 50 ELDERS.
AND THEN A HUNDRED HELDERS SHOWED UP FROM THE COMMUNITY AND ANSWERED THAT CALL FROM THE PRESS CONFERENCE.
SO WE WERE ABLE TO PUT ELDERS AT THE FRONT OF THIS PROTEST LINE.
TO JUST COME ALONGSIDE OF THE YOUNG PEOPLE IN OUR COMMUNITY THAT WAS HURTING, THAT WAS TRAUMATIZED, RIGHT, THAT WAS GRIEVING.
SO THE ELDERS KNEW HOW TO HOLD THEIR PAIN, HOW TO COME ALONGSIDE OF IT, HOW TO HELP THEM DISCHARGE AND HOW TO STAND IN SOLIDARITY WITH THEM.
AND IT IS A VERY EFFECTIVE NON-VIOLENT MODEL THAT ALLOWS THE COMMUNITY TO MONITOR ITSELF, TO HOLD ITSELF, AND TO NOT HAVE TO BE AGGRESSIVELY POLICED BY A POLICE FORCE IN RIOT GEAR.
SO WE INTRODUCED THE ELDER MODEL INTO THE PROTEST IN A LARGER WAY.
AND IT WAS VERY EFFECTIVE.
STANDING IN SOLIDARITY WITH THEM.
NOT JUST FIGURATIVELY BUT LITERALLY STANDING ESSENTIALLY BETWEEN THE POLICE AND THE PEOPLE WHO WERE PROTESTING.
ABSOLUTELY.
IT CHANGED — I THINK IT CHANGED THE TRAJECTORY, REALLY OF THE POLICING RESPONSE TO PROTESTS.
BECAUSE ONCE YOU INTRODUCE THE MODEL AND YOU SEE IT, YOU CAN’T UNSEE IT.
PRIOR TO THAT —
IT WAS SUCH A VALUABLE IMAGE, I THINK.
AND CERTAINLY FOR OTHERS MOVING FORWARD.
WHAT WAS YOUR REACTION WHEN YOU HEARD THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SAY LOOK, THIS WAS PRESENTED TO A GRAND JURY, AND THE GRAND JURY DECLINED TO RETURN ANY CHARGES AGAINST THE POLICE OFFICERS?
YEAH.
I WAS HURT.
I WAS ANGRY.
AND — AND I ALSO FELT LIKE ‘I’M NOT SURPRISED.’
RIGHT?
BECAUSE WE HAVE — IN ROCHESTER WE’VE BEEN GIVEN THIS 18, 19 BLUEPRINT OF POLICING THAT WAS PATTERNED OFF OF SLAVE PATROLS.
SO THAT BLUEPRINT HAS PERMITTED ALL KINDS OF HARM AND TRAUMA AND AGGRESSION AND VIOLENCE AGAINST BLACK AND BROWN BODIES, WITHOUT ANY ACCOUNTABILITY.
NOT ONLY IN ROCHESTER BUT ACROSS THE NATION, AND ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
AND SO I WAS HOPING — WE’RE ALL HOPING, HOLDING OUR BREATH THINKING THAT MAYBE WE WOULD BE DIFFERENT.
BUT WE WEREN’T DIFFERENT.
AND IN FACT, YOU KNOW, I FELT LIKE THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE DIDN’T DO ENOUGH TO TRY TO GET AT AN INDICTMENT ON THE OFFICERS FOR DANIEL PRUDE’S KILLING.
AND THAT WAS FRUSTRATING BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, WE’RE TIRED OF THAT KIND OF ENDING.
EVERY TIME IT IS THAT KIND OF ENDING.
AND THE AFTERMATH OF THE DANIEL PRUDE KILLING, AND I KNOW THERE HAVE BEEN CONVERSATIONS, TAKING PLACE.
YOU HAVE BEEN INVOLVED, COMMUNITY LEADER, GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS.
TELL US ABOUT SOME OF THOSE CONVERSATIONS AND WHERE THEY SEEM TO BE GOING, IF ANYWHERE.
YEAH, SO WE’VE BEEN HAVING CONVERSATIONS.
WE’VE BEEN CALLING ON OUR MAYOR AND OUR PUBLIC OFFICIALS TO WORK WITH US TO CREATE A NEW POLICING BLUEPRINT.
ONE THAT IS NOT FROM 1819 THAT SAYS WHAT DO WE DO WITH BLACK PEOPLE WHO ARE OUT IN THE WORLD, HOW DO WE PATROL AND CONTAIN THEM, BUT A NEW BLUEPRINT.
A 21st CENTURY BLUEPRINT THAT ACTUALLY SAYS HOW TO WE GET TO PUBLIC SAFETY AND THRIVING COMMUNITIES?
IF WE ASK THE RIGHT QUESTIONS WE GET THE RIGHT BLUEPRINT AND WE CAN CREATE PUBLIC SAFETY FOR EVERYBODY.
RIGHT NOW BLACK AND BROWN PEOPLE ARE NOT SAFE IN THEIR COMMUNITIES UNDER THIS BLUEPRINT OF POLICING AND THE WAY IN WHICH IT ALLOWS CERTAIN POLICIES AND PRACTICES AND LAWS THAT REALLY BUBBLE WRAP AND PRESERVE POLICING IN A WAY THAT THEY DON’T EVER HAVE TO BE ACCOUNTABLE TO THE HARM DONE IN BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITIES.
AND SO WE ARE PUSHING THE BLUEPRINT.
WHAT WE NEED THOUGH IS FOR OUR STATE POLITICIANS TO STAND UP AND TO PUT FORTH LEGISLATION, TO ROLL BACK THINGS LIKE QUALIFIED IMMUNITY, THINGS LIKE THE TAILOR LAW.
THINGS LIKE THE TRIBUNAL LAW.
WE NEED THOSE THINGS CHANGED SO THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY HAVE ACCOUNTABILITY ACROSS THE BOARD.
BECAUSE IN OUR COMMUNITY, WHEN THERE IS A WHITE VICTIM AND A WHITE OFFICER, WE SEEM TO BE ABLE TO GET INDICTMENTS AND FIRINGS AND CHARGES AND POLICE REMOVED.
WHEN IT IS A BLACK VICTIM WE SEEM TO GET NOTHING EXCEPT A NO.
SO WE’RE HOPING TO REALLY CHANGE THAT ON THE GROUND.
CURIOUS ABOUT WHAT YOU NOT JUST AS A COMMUNITY LEADER BUT MAYBE MORE IMPORTANTLY AS A FAITH LEADER, SAID TO YOUR CONGREGATION.
AND MOST IMPORTANTLY PERHAPS THE YOUNGER MEMBERS OF YOUR CONGREGATION.
WHAT DID YOU SAY TO THEM AFTER THE INCIDENT WITH PRUDE AND AFTER THE GRAND JURY DECIDED NOT TO RUSH ARETURN ANY CHARGES.
I’VE BEEN TALK TO BE MY CONGREGATION ABOUT RIGHT ALONG ABOUT THE NEED TO P CHANGE SYSTEMIC RACISM.
AND WE PREACH THIS INTO OUR CONGREGATION.
WE HAVE A MORAL RESPONSIBILITY TO END OPPRESSION MORE PEOPLE.
TO STAND WITH THE VULNERABLE, RIGHT, TO WORK FOR JUSTICE AND THAT IT IS A LABOR OF LOVE WHEN WE DO THAT.
SO THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS I’VE SAID TO MY CONGREGATION.
WE’VE CREATED A RACIAL JUSTICE PAGE AND PUT A LOT OF EFFORT INTO EDUCATING OUR CONGREGATION AND I THINK WE’VE ALSO SAILED IT IS GOING TO TAKE ALL OF US.
ALL HANDS ON DECK IF WE’RE GOING CHANGE POLICING IN THIS COUNTRY.
THEN WE NEED EVERYBODY’S PARTICIPATION AND BUY-IN INTO CREATING A MORE JUST COMMUNITY.
LAST QUESTION FOR YOU.
GOT ABOUT TWO MINUTES HERE.
AS WE KNOW IN THE PAST SADLY OFTEN TIMES WE NEED TRAGEDY TO BE A SPRINGBOARD FOR PROGRESS.
WE’VE SEEN MARTYRDOM IN THE PAST.
IN THE CASE OF EMMETT TILL, THE YOUNG MAN FROM CHICAGO, MURDERED IN MISSISSIPPI IN THE 1950S, DESCRIBED OFTEN TIMES AS A SUPERFICIAL LAMB OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT.
ARE YOU AT ALL OPTIMISTIC IN TERMS OF HEALING AND CHANGE IN ROCHESTER THAT MAYBE THIS MIGHT BE THE MOMENT THAT WILL HELP THAT PROCESS?
YEAH, SO I THINK, YOU KNOW, THE JURY IS STILL OUT ON THAT.
I ALWAYS — I’M A HOPEFUL PERSON.
SO I HOPE, RIGHT, THAT WE SEIZE THIS MOMENT.
RIGHT?
AND THAT DANIEL PRUDE’S LIFE WAS NOT TAKEN IN VAIN.
WE HAD A 9-YEAR-OLD CHILD WHO WAS PEPPER SPRAYED AND HANDCUFFED, WHO WAS A BLACK CHILD.
I HOPE THAT HER, YOU KNOW, HER EXPERIENCES WAS NOT IN VAIN.
SO I — I — I HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF HOPE.
BUT, YOU KNOW, THE JURY IS STILL OUT.
BECAUSE WE REALLY NEED TO KNOW THAT THE POLITICAL LEADERS THAT ARE IN OFFICE AT THE STATE LEVEL ARE TAKING THE SAFETY OF BLACK AND BROWN FOLKS IN OUR COMMUNITY SERIOUS ENOUGH TO BE WILLING TO BE THOUGHT LEADERS.
RIGHT?
TO BE WILLING TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT AN 1819 SLAVE PATROL BLUEPRINT IS NOT HELPING ANY OF US.
IT IS JUST NOT HE HELPFUL TO OUR COMMUNITY AND WE NEED TO END THIS.
WE NEED TO END THIS IF WE HAVE ANY HOPE OF WORKING OUR WAY OUT OF THIS MESS THAT WE’RE IN AND THIS RACIAL DIVIDE THAT HAS REALLY TORN APART OUR COMMUNITY.
I THINK THAT IS A VERY GOOD POINT THAT YOU MAKE AND WE’VE SEEN IT MADE BEFORE, THAT THIS WILL HELP THE GOOD OFFICERS OUT THERE.
AND PEOPLE HAVE SAID THE VAST MAJORITY OF OFFICERS ARE GOOD.
THE PROBLEM IS WHAT HAPPENS WITH THE ONES THAT AREN’T.
BUT AGAIN THESE APPROACHES AND THESE CHANGES AS YOU SAID WILL HELP EVERYBODY.
ACROSS THE BOARD.
WELL, REVEREND MIRA BROWN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US AND SHARING YOUR THOUGHTS WITH US.
AND VERY THOUGHTFUL CONVERSATION.
WE APPRECIATE IT AND WE’LL LOOK FORWARD TO HOPEFULLY TALKING TO YOU AGAIN SOMETIME REAL SOON.
YOU BE WELL.
YOU TOO.
TAKE CARE.
TAKE CARE NOW.
BYE-BYE.
Aired on March 4, 2021.