>>> GOOD EVENING, AND WELCOME TO
"METROFOCUS."
I'M JENNA FLANAGAN.
WHEN IT COMES THE TO THE MANY
DIRE CONSEQUENCES OF THE CLIMATE
CRISIS, THERE IS ONE THAT HAS
TYPICALLY NOT GOTTEN A LOT OF
ATTENTION OR RESEARCH, AND THAT
IS THE MENTAL HEALTH TOLL THAT A
WARMING PLANET CAN HAVE ON
PEOPLE AND COMMUNITIES.
THE PHENOMENON IS KNOWN AS
ECOANXIETY.
INCREASINGLY PSYCHOLOGISTS AND
CLIMATE ACTIVISTS ARE REALIZING
THE IDEA OF IMPENDING GLOBAL
DOOM CAN HAVE FEAR, ANGER AND
DESPAIR.
WHEN CHANNELLED CORRECTLY, THOSE
FEARS ARE ACT AS A CATALYST FOR
ACTION.
JOINING ME NOW TO TALK ABOUT
ECOANXIETY AND RECOMMEND HELPFUL
COPING STRATEGIES AS PART OF OUR
INITIATIVE REPORTING ON THE
HUMAN STORIES OF CLIMATE CHANGE
AND ITS SOLUTIONS IS BRIT WRAY.
BRIT IS A HUMAN AND PLANETARY
HEALTH FELLOW AT STANFORD
UNIVERSITY AND AUTHOR OF THE NEW
BOOK "GENERATION DREAD, FINDING
PURPOSE IN THE AGE OF CLIMATE
CRISIS".
BRIT, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
JOINING US ON THIS CHALLENGING,
CHALLENGING TOPIC.
>> HI, JENNA.
THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
>> SO, FIRST I JUST WANT TO
START WITH JUST THE NOTION OF
ECOANXIETY.
NOW, I WOULD SAY THIS, ALSO MAY
BE A BIT OF A GENERATIONAL
DIVIDE, BECAUSE SOMETIMES OLDER
PEOPLE FEEL YOUNGER GENERATIONS
ARE ANXIOUS ABOUT EVERYTHING.
WHAT MAKES THIS ANXIETY UNIQUE
AND SPECIFIC?
>> WE ARE IN THE MIDST OF AN
ESCALATING PLANETARY HEALTH
CRISIS, WHICH IS THE IMPACT OF
HUMAN BEHAVIOR ON THE
ENVIRONMENT, WHICH IS NOW COMING
BACK TO BITE US AS A NUMBER ONE
THREAT TO HUMAN HEALTH.
SO, YES, THE CLIMATE CRISIS BUT
ALSO LAND TRANSFORMATION, THE
BIODIVERSITY CRISIS, ALL KINDS
OF ISSUES.
WE'RE IN A PANDEMIC THAT RELATES
TO ZOONOTTICS.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR YOUNG MEME
WHO ARE BECOMING AWARE OF THIS
AND THOUSAND THE THREATS ARE
COMPOUNDING INTO A POLY CRISIS,
SO TO SPEAK IS THEIR FUTURES ARE
BEING ENDANGERED ON A DIRECT
HUMAN LEVEL AS THEY'RE BEING
FORCED TO COMBAT CLIMATE
DISASTERS POTENTIALLY SURPASSING
CLIMATE TIPPING POINTS AND
RECKONING WITH THE IDEA THAT
HOMELANDS AND ALIVELY HOODS AND
LIVES ARE BEING LOST.
SO IT'S NOT CATASTROPHIC
THINKING FORM OF ANXIETY.
IT'S NOT AN ANXIETY DISORDER
YOUNG PEOPLE ARE CONTENDING WITH
WHEN THEY SAY, HEY, I'M ANXIOUS.
IT'S RATHER HEALTHY TO A DEGREE
AS LONG AS IT'S NOT OVERWHELMING
AND DEBILITATING THEM, NORMAL
RESPONSE TO A SET OF THREATS
THAT ARE IMPINGING ON THEIR
ABILITY THE FLOURISH INTO THE
FUTURE.
HOWEVER, THE IDEA THAT IT IS A
BELIEF OF DOOM THAT'S CREATING
THIS IS REALLY SOMETHING THAT
NEEDS TO BE PICKED APART,
BECAUSE YOUNG PEOPLE ARE NOT
DOOMED.
HUMANITY IS NOT FACING
IMPENDING, INEVITABLE
CATASTROPHIC LOSS HERE.
RATHER WE'RE CONTENDING WITH THE
IDEA THAT SCIENCE IS SHOWING US
WE'RE IN A DIFFICULT PLACE
ALREADY AND IT'S BECOMING MORE
DIFFICULT, AND YET WE NEED TO
STEP INTO ROLES OF AGENCY, WORK
WITH OTHERS TO SHIFT THE NEEDLE
BEFORE MORE CATASTROPHIC EVENTS
BECOME INEVITABLE, RIGHT?
SO THERE'S A TENSION THERE AND
IT BRUCES ANXIETY WITHIN PEOPLE.
BUT IT CERTAINLY ISN'T A DEAD
END.
IT'S AN EMOTIONAL GRAPPLING WITH
HOW PEOPLE ARE GOING TO BE AT
THIS TIME.
>> IT'S INTERESTING YOU TALK
ABOUT THE EMOTIONAL GRAPPLING OF
HOW PEOPLE ARE GOING TO BE AND
HANDLE THIS.
BECAUSE SOMETIMES ANXIOUS OR
TENSION DRIVEN SITUATIONS CAN
BRING OUT DIFFERENT RESPONSES IN
PEOPLE.
SO WHAT HAS -- I MENTIONED AT
THE BEGINNING THAT FEAR AND
DREAD BUT ALSO ACTIVISM.
WHAT AT LEAST HAVE YOU FOUND
THAT THIS IS BRINGING OUT IN
POPULATIONS?
>> SO, IT'S NOT A MONOLITH.
IT SHOWS UP IN REALLY DIVERSE
WAYS ACROSS VARIOUS KINDS OF
PEOPLE'S EXPERIENCES RIGHT NOW.
WHETHER THAT BE JUST SHORT-TERM
DISTRESS WHEN CONFRONTING THE
NEWS, FOR EXAMPLE, OR SOMETHING
THAT ACTUALLY TRAPS PEOPLE IN A
PIT OF DESPAIR, WHEREBY THEY
START BELIEVING THAT IT IS TOO
LATE TO MAKE A MEANINGFUL
DIFFERENCE, AND THIS IS
NARRATIVELY -- THEIR FUTURE AND
CREATE DEBILITATING STRESS AND
IMPAIR FUNCTION.
MIGHT CAUSE PANIC ATTACKS OR
SLEEP DISTURBANCES OR EVEN FORMS
OF SELF-HARM.
THE LESS SEVERE END WE HAVE
PEOPLE RECOGNIZING THAT THEY ARE
WORRIED, THEY ARE DISTRESSED
ABOUT SOMETHING THAT IS
ABSOLUTELY VERY SENSIBLE AND
COMPASSIONATE TO BE STRESSED
ABOUT, BUT IT'S POINTING OUT
WAYS IN WHICH THEY CAN ADDRESS
THE THING THAT'S STRESSING THEM
IT BECOMES A NAVIGATIONAL TOOL,
BECOMES SOMETHING THEY CAN MOVE
THROUGH, EMOTIONAL WEIGHT
TRAINING SO THEY DON'T BECOME SO
BURNED OUT ON THE TOPIC, APPLY
SELF-CARE AND MOVE TOGETHER WITH
OTHERS TO TRY TO IMPROVE THE
OUTCOME.
SO IT'S -- I'M SEEING A
SIMPLIFICATION THESE DAYS, WHERE
A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE SAYING,
CLIMATE ANXIETY.
THAT EQUATES TO DOOMISM,
FATALISM.
THAT EQUATES TO PEOPLE GIVING
UP.
AND THAT'S NOT TRUE.
MANY PEOPLE SAY THEIR CLIMATE
ANXIETY IS THE SUPER FUEL THAT
ALLOWS THEM TO DO THE WORK.
THE QUESTION IS, WHAT DEGREES
CAN WE LIMIT IT TO IN OUR OWN
LIVES WHILE BRINGING IN THE
NOURISHING, JOYOUS ASPECTS OF
BEING HUMAN THAT CAN SUPPORT
NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE DOING
THIS WORK AND NOT CHECK OUT FROM
MENTAL EXHAUSTION.
>> LET'S GET INTO THAT, TERRIBLE
PART ABOUT NOT CHECKING OUT AND
WHAT IT IS WE CAN DO.
WHAT SIT FIRST OF ALL THINGS
THAT ARE STILL TANGIBLE THAT THE
AVERAGE, EVERYDAY PERSON CAN DO?
IT SEEMS OFTEN THAT WE HEAR
STORIES ABOUT, YOU KNOW, OH,
RECYCLING ISN'T AS BENEFICIAL AS
YOU THOUGHT IT WAS.
OR, OH, LIKE, YOU MIGHT DO THIS
ONE ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFIT, BUT
IT HAS THIS NEGATIVE IMPACT AS
WELL.
SO WHAT ARE SOME OF THE THINGS
WE CAN DO THAT ACTUALLY HELP?
>> WELL, THERE'S INTERNAL
ACTIVISM AND EXTERNAL ACTIVISM
IN THE CLIMATE CRISIS, AND BOTH
ARE WHAT'S PART AND PARCEL OF
WHAT'S NEEDED HERE.
.
WE NEVER TALK ABOUT THE
INTERNAL, BEING ABLE TO TAKE
CARE OF YOURSELF, EMOTIONS THAT
MIGHT BE EXISTENTIAL SO YOU
DON'T DROWN WITH THEM WHEN THEY
SHOW UP IN ONE'S LIFE, IF THAT
IS SOMETHING THE PERSON IS
CONTENDING WITH.
AND SO THAT REQUIRES THINGS LIKE
SELF-CARE, WHICH WE LEARN FROM
FEMINISTS LIKE AUDREY LORD THAT
IT'S A POLITICAL ACT TO CARE FOR
ONE'S SELF-IT'S AN ACT OF
POLITICAL WARFARE TO FILL ONE'S
CUP SO YOU CAN TAKE ON THE WORLD
AND EXTERNAL STRUCTURES.
THAT'S JUST AS RELEVANT HERE.
WAY OF COMMUNING.
PUT IT OUT ON THE TABLE, NOT
SUPPRESS IT AND MALADAPTIVELY
COPE LATER BECAUSE THE STRESSING
STOPS WORKING.
BUT ACTUALLY BE ABLE TO PROCESS
THIS AND SAY, HEY, THIS IS
VALID, LEGITIMATE.
WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO TO
SUPPORT EACH OTHER THROUGH THIS?
COMMUNITY BUILDING, HIGH SOCIAL
TIES ARE WHAT HELP PEOPLE MOVE
THROUGH ADVERSITY AND STRUCTURAL
DIVERSITY WHEN DISASTER HITS OUR
TOWN, FOR EXAMPLE.
BUT WHEN WE CAN THEN UNDERSTAND
THAT THIS IS A NORMAL NATURAL
RESPONSE THAT WE HAVE PEOPLE TO
MOVE THROUGH IT WITH, THAT WE
CAN START REINVESTING THE ENERGY
WE'RE LOSING FROM BEING
DISTRESSED INTO ACTIONS THAT
MATTER THAT WERE PURPOSEFUL AT
THIS TIME, THAT'S WHERE THE
EXTERNAL ACTIVISM IS WHERE WE'RE
SHIFTING OUR FOCUS.
THE INDIVIDUAL ACTIONS ARE NOT
GOING TO GET US THERE.
WE KNOW THAT.
IT CAN BE DEBILITATING TO THINK
OF ONE'S RECYCLING WHICH ISN'T
MAKING A DENT.
COLLECTIVE CHANGE IS REQUIRED.
THIS MEANS VOTING ON ISSUES THAT
ARE STRESSING YOU RELATED TO
CLIMATE AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
THIS MEANS PAYING ATTENTION TO
WHERE YOU'RE PUTTING YOUR MONEY.
YOUR BANKING.
WHICH ORGANIZATIONS YOU'RE
SIGNED UP WITH AND SUPPORTING
AND WHERE THEY ARE INVESTED.
ARE THEY FULFILLING FUTURE
EXISTENCE OF THE FOSSIL FUEL
INDUSTRY WITH THEIR INVEST MS.
PRESIDENTS, OR ARE THEY
DIVESTING AND PUTTING IT
ELSEWHERE?
PENSIONS, FORMS OF COMING
TOGETHER WITH CLIMATE ACTIVISM
GROUPS, WAY OF BRINGING THE
TOPIC INTO YOUR CLASSROOM IF
YOU'RE A TEACHER OR INTO THE
HEALTH-CARE SETTING IF YOU'RE A
HEALTH-CARE WORKER.
REALLY BECAUSE IT'S A CRISIS
THAT TOUCHES ALL ASPECT OF LIFE,
WE CAN ATTACK IT FROM ALL
ANGLES, WHETHER IT'S ACCOUNTANTS
RESTRUCTURING HOW THEY'RE DOING
THEIR BUSINESS OR CHILDREN
STRIKING FROM SCHOOL.
SO IT'S REALLY ABOUT IDENTIFYING
WHAT MAKES YOU FEEL ALIVE, WHAT
GETS YOU OUT OF BED, WHAT YOUR
SKILLS AND TALENTS ARE AND HOW
YOU CAN BRING THAT TO THE ISSUE
TOGETHER WITH OTHERS RATHER THAN
GET STUCK IN THOUGHT OF BEING A
CLIMATE HYPOCRITE BECAUSE YOU
HAVE A SUV AND YOU TOOK A FLIGHT
THAT TIME, THESE THINGS WHICH
REALLY FEED THE ENVIRONMENTALIST
CRITIC AND TEAR AWAY OUR ABILITY
TO ACT AND UNDERSTAND THAT
PERFECT IS THE ENEMY OF GOOD,
AND WE CAN ALL DO THINGS HERE TO
HELP BE PART OF THE COLLECTIVE
SOLUTION EVEN IF WE AREN'T
PERFECT, AND DO UNDERSTAND WE
UPHOLD PARTS OF THE STRUCTURES
THAT ARE MAKING US UNWELL,
BECAUSE WE'RE ALL IN THE SYSTEM
WHICH RUNS ON FOSSIL FUELS.
>> I CAN'T BELIEVE WE'RE ALMOST
OUT OF TIME.
WE'VE GOT ABOUT TWO MINUTES
LEFT.
I WANT TO ASK THE QUESTION, AS
WE COMPARE THE INDIVIDUAL TO THE
COLLECTIVE, ONE OF THE THINGS
THAT WE'RE SEEING YOUNGER PEOPLE
SAY IS, YOU KNOW, I DON'T THINK
I WANT TO HAVE KIDS AND ADD TO
THE COLLECTIVE PROBLEM OF A
CARBON FOOTPRINT.
AND I UNDERSTAND THAT'S A
QUESTION YOU WRESTLED WITH
YOURSELF.
>> NOT QUITE.
I WRESTLED WITH A DIFFERENT
QUESTION, WHICH IS WHAT WILL A
WARMING WORLD DO TO THE SAFETY
AND WELL BEING OF A CHILD THAT I
PUT INTO IT?
SO LESS OF THE IDEA THAT HUMAN
FOOTPRINT EQUALS CARBON
FOOTPRINTS AND THEREFORE IT'S AN
ECOLOGICAL SIN TO CREATE MORE
HUMANS WHICH IS A LONG STAND
TROPE IN ENVIRONMENTALISM WHICH
HAS BEEN DANIELING AND CURTAILED
THE CIVIL LIBERTIES OF PEOPLE
AROUND THE WORLD, PREDOMINANTLY
IN POOR NATIONS.
HOWEVER, THERE'S THIS OTHER
WORRY, WHICH MANY PEOPLE ARE --
ESPECIALLY YOUNG PEOPLE
CONFRONTING WHICH IS YES,
SOMETIMES THAT CONCERN ABOUT THE
FOOTPRINTISM, BUT MUCH MORE SO
I'M DISCOVERING IN MY RESEARCH,
WHICH IS GOING BACK MANY YEARS
AGO NOW FOR MY BOOK ON THIS
MATTER, THAT PEOPLE ARE WORRIED
ABOUT WHAT CLIMATE DISRUPTION
SCENARIO IS GOING TO DO TO
ENDANGER CHILDREN'S WELL BEING
AND TRAUMATIZE THEM IN THE
DECADES AHEAD.
SO THAT IS WHAT OFTEN CAN BURR
THE PAINFUL DILEMMA FOR PEOPLE
THAT WANT TO BECOME BIOLOGICAL
PARENTS BUT CONSIDER IT'S NOT A
MORAL THING FOR THEM TO DO AND
HAVE TO WRESTLE WE CO -- BEFORE
COMING TO A DECISION.
>> OF COURSE.
WITH ABOUT A MINUTE OR SO LEFT,
WE'RE SUPPOSED TO HAVE AN ACTIVE
HURRICANE SEASON, AND I KNOW
THAT'S SENTAWAYS OF ANXIETY FOR
A LOT OF PEOPLE, ESPECIALLY IN
THE NEW YORK AREA THAT REMEMBER
SUPERSTORM SANDY.
HOW WOULD YOU ADVISE PEOPLE TO
TAKE THAT ANXIETY ABOUT MORE
HURRICANES -- YOU KNOW, STRONGER
STORMS COMING.
HOW DO YOU TURN THAT INTO
SOMETHING POSITIVE?
>> I'D SAY GET TO KNOW THE
PEOPLE WHERE YOU ARE LIVING.
INVEST IN COMMUNITY.
COME TOGETHER AND TALK ABOUT HOW
YOU'RE FEELING.
BE ABLE TO PROCESS BY SHARING.
THAT'S IMPORTANT.
BUT WHAT'S EVEN MORE VITAL FOR
PROTECTING PSYCHOLOGICAL WELL
BEING, WHEN THOSE HURRICANES ARE
COMING IS TO KNOW YOU HAVE HIGH
SOCIAL CONNECTEDNESS, PEOPLE TO
RELY ON, AND FEEL THAT LACK OF
ISOLATION, LACK OF ALIENATION IN
ALL THIS WHICH UNDERGIRDS
RESILIENCE.
IT BUILDS OUR RESILIENCE TO KNOW
WE CAN -- SHARED GOALS.
TIME AND AGAIN, THE RESEARCH
CHOSE PEOPLE HAVE LESS PTSD
AND -- REBUILD AFTER LIVING IN
THAT COMMUNAL EFFECT.
ECOANXIETY CAN BE A TOOL FOR
POINTING OUT'ing THAT'S
SOMETHING YOU CAN DO FOR
YOURSELF.
>> I'D LIKE TO THANK MY GUEST,
BRIT WRAY, A HUMAN AND PLANETARY
HEALTH FELLOW AT STANFORD
UNIVERSITY, AND OF COURSE THE
AUTHOR OF THE NEW BOOK
"GENERATION DREAD, FINDING
PURPOSE IN THE AGE OF CLIMATE
CRISIS".
BRIT, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
TAKING TIME TO JOIN US ON
"METROFOCUS."
>> JENNA, THANKS FOR HAVING ME.