Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Frontline World

Dispatches from a Small Planet: Election 2004


Burma


Quick Facts
Burma's democratic party won by a landslide in 1990, but the country has yet to see a day of democracy.
learn more


Related Links
Find sites and books related to Burma's troubled politics.
learn more


Blogs
A blogger in Southeast Asia reflects on politics and posts articles related to Burma's stalled constitutional convention.
learn more


News Corner
The New York Times
News from the Asia Pacific section of The New York Times.

Yahoo! News Full Coverage - Myanmar
Breaking news from the Burma section of Yahoo! News.

email this page to a friend
problems printing?

React
Moderator Comment:
Should the U.S. reconsider its sanctions against Burma?
See what people said about "Dispatches from a Small Planet: Election 2004"

Read a discussion about this dispatch with FRONTLINE/World correspondent Joan Bieder on Washingtonpost.com.


Untitled Document

Dispatches From a Small Planet: Election 2004


Recent Dispatches
An Election Heard 'Round the World

GREENLAND:
Colin Powell's Glacier

SERBIA/CROATIA:
The Balkans

DOMINICAN REPUBLIC:
Dual Citizens

GERMANY:
Watching the Presidential Debate With Arabs in Berlin

EL SALVADOR:
Payback

CANADA:
Border Town

BELARUS:
The View From the Underground


CHAD/SUDAN:
A Question of Genocide


PAKISTAN:
The Hunt for Osama bin Laden


UGANDA:
President for Life?


KENYA:
Terror, Trade and Tourists


BURMA:
Can Sanctions Bring Democracy?


VENEZUELA:
Hugo Chavez, Clutch Hitter


EUROPE:
Continental Drift


THAILAND:
The Vet Who Didn't Come Home


SYRIA/LEBANON:
The Occupier and the Occupied



By the People - Election 2004 PBS


BURMA: Can Sanctions Bring Democracy?
Reporter Joan Bieder

FRONTLINE/World reporter Joan Bieder.
By Joan Bieder
August 31, 2004

A Country Without Elections

Americans remain divided this election season over the Bush administration's zeal to bring freedom and democracy to Iraq virtually alone and at the cost of American lives. But not many are aware that the United States is using economic sanctions to force regime change and promote free elections in a remote Asian country.

Myanmar is so far off the radar screen of most Americans that reference to it often draws blank stares. Renamed in 1989, it is still far better known as Burma, a leafy green, once-prosperous nation rich in rice and teak, prawns and gems. Bordered by India, China, Laos, Thailand, Bangladesh and the Bay of Bengal, Myanmar is an isolated country, home to more than 100 ethnic minorities and ruled by a military dictatorship since 1962.

Teak tree

A lone teak tree near a fishing village. Logging without replanting is depleting one of Burma's most precious natural resources and causing dangerous flooding.
I wanted to see the exotic country and what impact the sanctions were having on the Burmese generals and on ordinary people, but I did not want to support the junta. I compromised by booking a brief tour from Singapore, where I was spending the summer. It is easy to come and go to Myanmar from Singapore, as the nearby city-state is one of a handful of countries that trades actively with the former British colony, in spite of the U.S. sanctions.

"We are a mismanaged country, and the people are suffering," said a young Burmese man who worked as a part-time translator. "America is the only country that stands up and openly supports us against the regime. We like the sanctions."

I heard this view often, if surreptitiously, during my visit, but I also learned that the situation is more complex. There is a growing sense in Myanmar that the sanctions aimed at forcefully shoving the regime toward democracy are missing their target and punishing the poor.

The Clinton administration imposed sanctions on Myanmar in 1997. Congress overwhelmingly approved more rigorous sanctions with the Burmese Freedom and Democracy Act of 2003, banning all imports of Burmese products to the United States for one year, freezing the assets of senior Burmese officials and blocking virtually all remittances to Myanmar. In July 2004, President Bush extended the act for another year. The White House statement read, "We will maintain pressure on the regime until there is tangible progress toward the restoration of democracy and protection of human rights for all the peoples of Burma."

Senator John Kerry, a co-sponsor of the 1997 sanctions, continues to strongly support them, and he will do so, according to his campaign office, until legitimate dissent is allowed and there is democratic reform in Myanmar.

Sculpture of a Padaung woman

Sculpture of a traditional Padaung woman wearing necklaces that create the illusion of a long neck, but really push down the collarbones. Many ethnic minorities like the Padaung have fled Burma and now live in Thailand.
Back in 1988, Burmese students led a nationwide wave of protests, demanding political reform. But the military crushed the movement, killing an estimated 3,000 students, office workers and Buddhist monks. Many fled into exile. In a 1990 election, the Burmese voted overwhelmingly (80 percent) for the National League for Democracy party (NLD) and its leader, Aung San Suu Kyi. The military refused to accept the vote and placed Suu Kyi under house arrest. In 1991, Suu Kyi was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, and she was released in 1995. But since then, the 59-year-old pro-democracy leader has repeatedly been placed under house arrest, where she remains today.

The generals who seized power in 1988 originally called themselves the State Law and Order Restoration Council. More recently, they adopted the Orwellian name of the State Peace and Development Council. But they continue to suppress all dissent and to jail and torture their political opponents, and they haven't bothered to hold an election since they nullified the last one 14 years ago. It's the sort of regime that makes an overseas American grateful for the U.S. electoral system, however rancorous and deceitful the latest round of campaign ads.

Myanmar's military junta makes it difficult to learn what is happening in the country. There is no press freedom, and they tightly control access by foreign journalists. The main papers are the New Light of Myanmar, a government mouthpiece, and the independent Myanmar Times, which is not noted for its independence. The regime has jailed journalists, writers and poets, some of them for life. There is a joke going around Yangon, the capital city (formerly Rangoon), that you can pick up a live electrical wire and nothing will happen, but if you pick up a real newspaper you might get electrocuted. The man who told me this joke also told me that the comedian who made it up was thrown in jail.

Most of the conversations I had in Myanmar took place in tea shops or over coffee in cafés. Here, after looking over their shoulders to be sure no one was listening, men spoke about the country more candidly than I expected. To protect them, I agreed not to mention their names. I met people who told me they had been forced to leave their jobs to build roads in rural areas. They said forced labor continues in the countryside. They told me that away from the cities, unreported human rights abuses occur frequently, including soldiers raping ethnic minority women and taking young boys away to the army.

Rangoon, Burma

Rangoon has a population of five million and crumbling housing stock. In the far left corner is Shwedagon pagoda, one of the holiest sites in Burma.
Almost 5 million people live in the densely populated capital city. Most of the buildings are only three to five stories high and are in need of paint and repair. Yangon appears to be a city out of the past, not ready for the 21st century. I saw only a few satellite dishes. And although the telephones from the well-run hotel I stayed in seemed to work fine, I learned that it costs US$5,000 to buy a cell phone -- I saw only one during my visit.

Although the secretive and authoritarian regime has kept Myanmar isolated from the world, it now hopes that tourism will give a major boost to the economy. There are elegant hotels and restaurants in Yangon that are relatively cheap for Western tourists, and the local employees have been trained well to serve. The dark-red brick buildings that are leftovers from British rule -- the high court, the hospital and the broken-down, boarded-up railroad building -- speak of a more prosperous time. The dramatic golden spires of the Sule and Shwedagon pagodas are beautiful and mysterious.

Buddhism is the central religion, and among the throngs on the streets of Yangon each morning, one sees groups of Buddhist nuns dressed in faded pink -- with shaved heads and somber faces -- as well as barefooted monks in maroon togas carrying bowls to receive gifts of food. From early morning until evening, the main streets are filled with men and women wearing graceful longyi cloths, knotted at the waist. Yangon is one of the few large cities in Southeast Asia where almost all people still wear traditional clothing. The long skirts are a gentle and welcome change from the Nike sneakers, jeans and skimpy, branded T-shirts and the high-styled career clothes seen in the more modern Asian cities.

Men load up trucks with their goods that are for sale

Vendors come into the city from the poor outskirts -- unseen by most tourists -- to sell their wares.
Street vendors sit on the sidewalks, offering guava, lemon grass, cauliflower, all manner of greens, shrimp, duck, chicken, plastics and laminated maps, as well as meals of boiled noodles and food cooked in pots of oil. At almost every corner, a man or woman sits at a stand and wraps bits of betel nut in green leaves slathered with a white liquid of lime-calcium oxide to create a bite-sized packet that brings a bitter taste, brown teeth and a nicotine-like jolt.

An open stall sells used books and old magazines, including a copy of Life with Marilyn Monroe on the cover; a hardware stall sells hand tools and rusting nails. Battered, noisy buses charge by without windows and with passengers piled on top of each other and hanging out the back. The vendors are encouragingly approachable and happy to bargain. Having their pictures taken is still a new phenomenon, and few posed or protested. They are thin; in fact, everyone in the country is very thin, including the dogs outside the monasteries.

Two children sitting against a wall

Official statistics are often dated and inaccurate, but some estimate that nearly 30 percent of Burma's population live in poverty. Outside of Yangon, the standard of living can decrease by over 30 percent.
And then there were the children on the rutted streets who approached me, asking for food or money. The first was a small unwashed boy about 6 or 7 years old, carrying a smaller child, perhaps 1 or 2 years old, who was wrapped to his back by a piece of soiled cloth. He tugged at me for attention. He kept pointing to his stomach and his mouth. These children were the most vivid example of poverty that I saw. A Burmese told me that they come into Yangon from the "satellite cities" to beg.

I learned that the satellite cities on the outskirts of Yangon are where the poorest people live. The standard of living decreases there by more than 30 percent, said a knowledgeable American who lives in Southeast Asia. He told me that the government moved the poorest people out of Yangon in order to clean it up, but did not move them to land where they could grow their own food. This practice of forced resettlement can lead unquestioning tourists to believe that things are not so bad in the cities they visit.

Waiting and Hoping

Many pro-democracy Burmese strongly hope and believe that Aung San Suu Kyi will one day re-emerge from house arrest and resume her place as their active leader. U.S. sanctions sustain that hope. But other supporters acknowledge that years of repression have weakened the NLD. The regime outlaws NLD meetings, and the military hassles and jails supporters. It is dangerous for people to talk about their discontent. At the same time, those with the courage to speak want word of their plight to spread. One activist told me, "As soon as she [Suu Kyi] is freed, the regime can't stop her voice, and the NLD will rise like a Phoenix." But the activist also confided, "I don't think the regime will release Aung San Suu Kyi very soon."

As the Burmese wait for democracy, many complain that the sanctions have hurt ordinary citizens rather than the council of generals who rule the country. Since the 2003 sanctions began, exports have dropped an estimated 60 to 70 percent, causing widespread layoffs in the textile industry. In the summer of 2003, the private banks collapsed, credit cards were no longer accepted and U.S. cash became a standard currency. The sex trade has grown as unemployed women turn to prostitution, AIDS has spread, and young men find their future narrowed to becoming monks or joining the military.

I spoke with international NGO workers who are in close contact with rural villagers. Many have come to believe that U.S. sanctions are wrongheaded. "Hundreds of women lose their jobs when a Hong Kong- or Taiwan-owned factory closes or moves to Cambodia," said a worker. "These women are often the primary supporters of their families. So sanctions hurt the whole family." Some Burmese workers resort to crossing the border to Thailand illegally to work in factories, leaving them vulnerable to arrest.

I asked Burmese if the sanctions are worth the price of poverty, especially since there seems to be little or no progress toward democracy and freedom. Even the most idealistic Burmese woman I know admitted her goals seem elusive. "The sanctions won't work as long as China is backing the Burmese military regime and as long as ASEAN [the Association of Southeast Asian Nations] countries continue to trade with Myanmar," she said.

Myanmar joined the ASEAN in 1997. Since then, ASEAN members -- notably Singapore and Thailand -- have traded regularly with Myanmar. I saw old taxis on the streets of Yangon that had been purchased from Singapore. Burmese men and women -- those who are able to pay fees as high as $1,800 for a passport to leave Myanmar -- travel to Singapore to work as maids or in other jobs and send their wages to families back home.

But it is not only the ASEAN countries that are undermining the effect of U.S. sanctions. India, Japan and especially China trade openly with Myanmar. Some Burmese feel foreign investors take advantage of the country. "We are surrounded by carpetbag countries," said one Burmese. "They come in and they take everything and give us nothing."

China is now a major trading partner of Myanmar, whose textile factories, the ones that remain, are likely to be sewing army uniforms for export to China instead of clothing for export to America. China supplies military equipment, construction materials and information technology to Myanmar. A former Burmese schoolteacher told me, "Now we must lick the boots of the Chinese." Many pro-democracy Burmese hate the Chinese for supporting the regime and blunting the effects of the sanctions.

There have been reports that Thai fishermen trawl in Burmese waters for the shrimp and prawns that Burmese used to export to the United States. But the most cited example of exploitation is the deforestation of teak trees. "When the British were here," said a Burmese, "they replanted as they harvested trees. But the current government did not do that. It will take 80 years to bring our teak forests back to what they once were." As he talked, he pointed to a small, lone teak tree by the side of the road near a fishing village outside Yangon. Deforestation, according to other Burmese, has resulted in the flooding of cities along the main rivers, like the Irrawaddy, the Salween and the Chind. In northern Myanmar, one Burmese told me, a whole village was inundated, but the regime newspaper didn't report it.

The Burmese say that the generals usually take a percentage of most business transactions conducted with other countries and that they profit from the lucrative opium trade. They complain that the generals think little about the plight of the people, but instead fill their own coffers. They live in the plush suburbs around Yangon and prepare for comfortable retirement.

The military regime's development of active trade with China and the ASEAN indicates that despite U.S. sanctions, the generals have found a way to pursue the goals of entrepreneurship and profit. As a result, sanctions are having far less of an effect than the United States and pro-democracy Burmese desire. The National Bureau of Asian Research in Seattle, Washington, a nonpartisan policy institute, recently published seven essays by international scholars on U.S. relations with Myanmar. The report said that sanctions "undermine the position of the reformers within the military, strengthen the resolve of the opponents of reform in the military, make pro-democracy supporters seem traitors in the eyes of both reformers and opponents of reform within the regime, and have a deleterious social effect on an already poor country."

I did not hear such nuanced, sophisticated policy analysis during my brief stay in and around Yangon. Most of what I heard was the emotional plight of unhappy, desperate, yet still hopeful people. Sanctions may not solve the long-term problems of Myanmar, but Burmese activists do not want to them to end. Web sites such as the Democratic Voice of Burma and the Daw Aung San Suu Kyi pages favor sanctions and urge all nations to employ them.

Two kids in school uniforms

In Burma, many children and women apply thanaka, a paste made from bark, onto their faces. These school children are among the fortunate few whose families can afford to pay for some education.

Meantime, the daily miseries persist, even when the surface image may be pleasing to a tourist. In the countryside, I drove past a one-story concrete elementary school. I saw smiling children ready to learn in their green shorts and skirts with white laundered shirts and blouses. Their faces were covered with the pasty cream that comes from mixing water with the bark of the thanakha tree. Most Burmese believe the cream is healthy for the skin. The school and the uniforms appeared to be an example of how the government is providing for village children. Then I learned that the entrance fee was 2,000 kyat, about two U.S. dollars, and that a typical mother could only afford to send one of her many children. Poverty was limiting educational opportunity, no matter how lovely the photographs I was snapping.

Moving Backward

On the outskirts of Yangon, the government is building a tourist park called the National Races Village to celebrate the country's ethnic diversity. The Chinese built the bridge I crossed to get to where the "typical" native homes were displayed in the park. Full-sized dwellings from the seven states of Myanmar -- Karen, Rakhine, Mon, Kachin, Chin, Shan and Kayah -- made up the exhibition. Members of minority groups living in these states have fought the military regime and have been killed for it. But there is no mention of that here. There is a large wooden sculpture of the head and neck of a Padaung woman, including the 20-plus necklaces these ethnic women put atop their collarbone to heighten the impression of an elongated neck. Many Padaung women and other ethnic minorities have fled to Thailand to escape military repression and religious persecution. But here, in what the tourist brochure calls "Your one-stop destination for studying the cultural heritage of Myanmar national races and for relaxation," the minority groups are presented as national treasures.

By the end of my short visit, I had come to think of the country as being stuck in a tragic and unhappy present. And in the case of education and health, they are actually moving backward. On the way to the airport, my taxi passed under an ornate arch decorated in the striking gold paint that one sees on every city and village pagoda. A sign above it reads, "Moving toward a modern nation."

"Yes," said my cabdriver, "you are going to the airport and moving toward the modern nations of Singapore or Thailand -- even China -- but not here."

Joan Bieder is a senior lecturer at U.C. Berkeley's graduate school of journalism.

See what people said about "Dispatches from a Small Planet: Election 2004"


Go to Intro: Dispatches from a Small Planet: Election 2004

Sign up for the FRONTLINE/World newsletter foran email alert each time a new dispatch is posted.


*Editor's Note
Some facts on this page were slightly updated on September 9, 2004.



back to top