Photo of Bill Moyers Bill Moyers Journal
Bill Moyers Journal
Bill Moyers Journal
Watch & Listen The Blog Archive Transcripts Buy DVDs
Shahan Mufti and Juan Cole
President Obama and Pakastani President Zardari, White House photo by Pete Souza
Watch Video
Read Transcript
May 15, 2009

Official Washington sounded the alarm — Pakistan, a nuclear-armed nation of 176 million people, might collapse at any moment and become a dangerous failed state.

The reports reverberating through the media do indeed sound dire: After took up positions within 60 miles of nation's capital, Islamabad (map), the Pakistani military struck back. The conflict has created a major humanitarian crisis as an estimated 1.3 million people are reported to have fled from the fighting.

In a May fourth WASHINGTON POST column, Ahmed Rashid, a Pakistani journalist wrote:

Pakistanis are beset by a galloping Taliban insurgency in the north that is based not just among Pashtuns, as in Afghanistan, but that has extensive links to al-Qaeda and jihadist groups in Punjab, Sindh and Baluchistan. That means the Taliban offensive in northern Pakistan has the potential to become a nationwide movement within a few months.

The situation is more complicated than that, say historian Juan Cole and journalist Shahan Mufti on BILL MOYERS JOURNAL. And while both agree that the insurgency in the north is a serious problem Pakistan must address, neither believes Pakistan is in immediate danger of becoming a failed state.

Mufti, who recently returned from Pakistan, argues that there are "huge stumbling blocks" to the Pakistani Taliban becoming a nationwide movement, noting that Washington and the American press seem far more concerned about the survival of Pakistan than Pakistanis:

Pakistanis, a lot of them, still see the Taliban as a fringe movement, which they are. The numbers say that. And a fringe movement which is able to wreak a lot of havoc. [...] But this threat of the state failing — I think Pakistanis, especially, say that this talk of Pakistan being a failed state, 'We've heard that. That's been around for 50 years, 60 years.' And nobody in that country takes that too seriously.

Supreme Court Protests
What's been lost in the alarm, Cole and Mufti argue, are the recent successes by Pakistan's growing movement for law and order.

In March, protests and marches erupted across Pakistan calling for the reinstatement of a system of checks and balances in the government. The democratically elected president, Asif Ali Zardari, initially embraced heavy-handed tactics to supress the protests. But, in the face of growing unrest, the government conceded the opposition's main demand, the reinstatement of the Supreme Court chief justice, Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry.

It was a great moment for Pakistan's democracy, Cole says, "For the longest time, for decades, the problem with Pakistan [...] is that the army keeps disrupting the power balance. And here the Pakistani people delivered a moment where, for the first time, they were able to check the power."

India and Kashmir
Pakistan map Pakistan, Mufti explains, "shares the border with China, India, Iran, Afghanistan and then has a 700-mile Arabian sea coastline. That's quite a cast of characters to be caught in the middle of." Add the United States' interest in the region — and their billions of dollars of funding for the Pakistani military — and it begins to explain what Mufti calls Pakistan's "schizophrenic" domestic and international policies.

But one nation looms largest in the minds of Pakistan's strategic planners — India. The animosity between the two nations began in 1947, when Britain partitioned its former colony into two independent states, Pakistan (which then included what is now Bangladesh) and India. The partition inspired a vast population movement and rioting, resulting in an estimated half-million deaths and one million people being left homeless.

From the very beginning, both India and Pakistan laid claim to Kashmir, a collection of provinces in the Himalayas between the two countries. In 1947, Pakistan supported a muslim insurgency in the then-independent principality. Kashmir's ruler asked India for military assistance and in return agreed to the accession of the state to India — a deal Pakistan holds India acquired by force.

Thus began the first of three wars between the nations, and a bitter rivalry that has played out in 60 years of scattered fighting in Kashmir, a nuclear arms race and a regional power struggle currently manifested in Afghanistan.

Links to the Taliban and Afghanistan
Shahan Mufti explains on THE JOURNAL that Pakistan's military has long relied on Islamic radicals as proxies to engage India in Kashmir.

The same holds true, he continues, for Afghanistan: "For the Pakistani security establishment [...] the Taliban, and the situation in Afghanistan, is about India." Pakistan, Mufti explains, sees Afghanistan as part of a chess board, and during the reign of the Taliban, Pakistan exerted a lot of influence there. But, President Karzai's government has strong ties to India, Pakistan's adversary: "So this whole scenario, in the last seven, eight years, has really made Pakistan even more paranoid than it usually is in that region."

The Pakistani security establishment has been hesitant to turn against the Islamic radicals they traditionally view as allies in their conflict with India.

U.S. Interests
Juan Cole explains to Bill Moyers that the United States no longer wants to tolerate this relationship:
Washington is alarmed at the spread of the Taliban in the northwest frontier province because it has implications for the security of southern Afghanistan, and therefore for US troops and NATO troops in Afghanistan. And so, from their point of view, this is a big crisis. They don't want more safe havens for the Taliban in Afghanistan who are killing US troops. And they were upset with the Pakistani elite for not taking this problem more seriously. And, I think, sort of saying that Pakistan is unstable, or it's about to fall, or the nukes are in danger, all of this sort of thing, is a signal to Islamabad that you had better get serious about this, because it matters to us. So this is Washington strong arming Pakistan.

Juan Cole
Juan Cole, Photo by Robin Holland Juan Cole is the Richard P. Mitchell Professor of History at the University of Michigan. He blogs about the Middle East, history and religion at INFORMED COMMENT.

He has written numerous books, including SACRED SPACE AND THE HOLY WAR and NAPOLEON'S EGYPT. His most recent book is ENGAGING THE MUSLIM WORLD. He lives in Ann Arbor, Michigan.

Shahan Mufti
Juan Cole, Photo by Robin Holland Shahan Mufti covers Pakistan for GLOBALPOST. He has been a correspondent for the CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR in Pakistan since 2007 and his work also has appeared in the BOSTON SUNDAY GLOBE, THE NATION, COLUMBIA JOURNALISM REVIEW and other publications. He also has reported for CNN, MSNBC, FOX, CBS, BBC, NPR and other television and radio channels.

Born to Pakistani parents in a small town in Ohio, he has made his home in many places between New Delhi and New Mexico. He served as a Fulbright scholar to India and has a master's degree in journalism from New York University and a bachelor's degree in International Political Economy from Middlebury College, VT.

Published May 15, 2009.

Guest photos by Robin Holland

Related Media:
Drone Bomber, photo by U.S. Air ForceAerial Bombing
Bill Moyers sits down with historian Marilyn Young and former Pentagon official Pierre Sprey, to discuss the use of aerial bombing, including drones, in warfare. (January 30, 2009)

FBI Domestic Spy PosterSarah Chayes
As a new administration is set to take over in the White House, Bill Moyers checks in with author Sarah Chayes on the state of affairs in America's other war in Afghanistan. An author and former journalist, Chayes has lived the last seven years in Afghanistan helping to rebuild the country. (December 19, 2008)

Christian ParentiForeign Policy and the New President
What will President-elect Obama's promises of change mean for the Middle East? JOURNAL guest host Deborah Amos sits down with Elizabeth Rubin, the Edward R. Murrow press fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, and Slate magazine columnist Fred Kaplan. (November 14, 2008)

March in PakistanPakistan in Peril
Bill Moyers on the unrest in the streets of America's ally. (November 9, 2007)

FBI Domestic Spy PosterChristian Parenti
Journalist Christian Parenti, back from his fourth visit to the forgotten frontline, speaks to Moyers about the growing influence of warlords in government and the resurgence of the Taliban (June 8, 2007)

FBI Domestic Spy PosterThe War Briefing
FRONTLINE producer Marcela Gaviria and correspondent Martin Smith offer harrowing on-the-ground reporting from the deadliest battlefield in the mountains of Afghanistan, and follow the trail to the militant safe havens deep inside the Pakistani tribal areas, probing some of the most urgent foreign policy challenges facing the next president. (October 28, 2008)

References and Reading:
Shahan Mufti

"News of Pakistan's doom greatly exaggerated"
By Shahan Mufti, THE GLOBALPOST, May 5, 2009.

Video: "Vulnerable supply lines put US mission at risk"
By Shahan Mufti, THE GLOBALPOST, April 1, 2009.

"The slow demise of a proud nation"
By Shahan Mufti, THE GLOBALPOST, March 23, 2009.

"Jubilation at ruling on Pakistani judges"
By Shahan Mufti, THE GLOBALPOST, March 16, 2009.

Video: "The Hindus who stayed in Pakistan"
By Shahan Mufti, THE GLOBALPOST, March 2, 2009.

Pakistan Coverage from THE GLOBALPOST

Juan Cole

Juan Cole's blog on the Middle East, history and religion.

"The hidden hand of Dick Cheney"
By Juan Cole, SALON.COM, May 13, 2009.

"Obama's domino theory"
By Juan Cole, SALON.COM, March 30, 2009.

"Obama's Vietnam?"
By Juan Cole, SALON.COM, January 26, 2009.

Supreme Court Protests

"Pakistan Leader Backs Down and Reinstates Top Judge"
By Jane Perlez, THE NEW YORKER, March 15, 2009.

"Pakistan Leader Backs Down and Reinstates Top Judge"
By Saeed Shah and Jonathan S. Landay, THE CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR, March 18, 2009.

"Can Pakistan Be Governed?"
By James Traub, THE NEW YORK TIMES, March 31, 2009.

India and Kashmir

BBC: Kashmir Flashpoint
Collected coverage and information from the BBC on the conflict surrounding Kashmir.

"Letter from Kashmir: Between the mountains"
By Isabel Hilton, THE NEW YORKER, March 11, 2002.


"Commentary: Pakistan isn't falling"
By Peter Bergen,, April 27, 2009.

"Viewpoint: Exaggerating the Pakistan problem"
By Steve Chapman, THE BALTIMORE SUN, May 11, 2009.

"Pakistan's Fatal Shore"
By Robert D. Kaplan, THE ATLANTIC, May 2009.

"Talking to the Taliban"
By Robert D. Kaplan, THE ATLANTIC, April 6 2009.

Times Topic: Pakistan.
Collected coverage of Pakistan in THE NEW YORK TIMES.

"Pakistan Says 1.3 Million Flee Fight With Taliban"
By Dexter Filkins, THE NEW YORK TIMES, May 12, 2009.

"Right at the Edge"
By Dexter Filkins, THE NEW YORK TIMES, September 5, 2008.

Guest photos by Robin Holland

Published May 15, 2009.

Also This Week:

As the world follows the violence and unrest in Pakistan, Bill Moyers speaks with historian Juan Cole and journalist Shahan Mufti about how the US's relationship with the troubled nation will impact prospects for peace, human rights, and democracy in the war-torn region.

Daniel Goleman explains to Bill Moyers how better educated consumers can help build a sustainable economy.

Explore the JOURNAL's coverage of the American collapse.

Our posts and your comments
For Educators    About the Series    Bill Moyers on PBS   

© Public Affairs Television 2008    Privacy Policy    DVD/VHS    Terms of Use    FAQ