The Greatest Catastrophe That Never Happened
A Guest Dispatch: February 11, 1998
By meteorologist Peter R. Chaston previous |
With all of the recent focus on storms lashing California and Peru, it's
amazing to me that most people don't realize that in September, only by some
last minute luck, Los Angeles avoided what would have been the costliest and
most destructive weather catastrophe of all time. The bullet was in the
chamber, and the gun was pointed at Los Angeles....
In the winter of 1982-83, El Niño pummeled California and the West
Coast with a series of powerful storms. South of the equator, its rains
transformed the coastal deserts of Peru and Ecuador into grasslands dotted with
lakes and ponds; other effects led to massive bird and fish migrations away
from the South American coast. So, when surface water temperatures jumped
almost 10 degrees Fahrenheit above normal off Peru and Ecuador last summer,
meteorologists concluded that a major El Niño was underway, and knew
what to expect. Armed with new models, and given an earlier warning than ever
before, meteorologists issued advisories, detailing the possible serious
weather that might again plague the west coasts of both of the American
In particular, residents of southern California took the warnings to heart.
Scientists feared that an eastern pacific hurricane could take a northward
journey and decimate Southern California. Three key initial conditions caused
by El Niño were coming together to create an ominous threat to the area
from San Diego to Los Angeles:
The long stretch—over 1,500 miles—of heated ocean was warming the
air above it, allowing the air to absorb more water vapor from the ocean. This
set up a self-replenishing, long-distance source of warm, moist air to feed
into any developing storms, giving a powerful kick to tropical cyclones and, in
the coming winter and spring, non-tropical low pressure systems.
The southern branch of the jet stream was setting itself up to transport
the moisture-laden air into the West Coast.
The normally cool waters off southern California were warming
substantially, and would allow any hurricane that might approach that region to
maintain much of its intensity. (In California, you only had to look at surfers
to detect the warming of the sea; they stopped wearing wetsuits.)
Normally, hurricanes that form in the Pacific off Mexico strike the west
coast of Mexico or, most often, move out to sea. They almost never reach the US
because they must pass over cool water, which cuts off their energy source.
Until this year, hurricanes had affected the American southwest only three
times in the 20th century. In September of 1932 a hurricane moved up the Gulf
of California, producing gusty winds and heavy rainfall in the Arizona desert.
In September of 1939, a tropical storm slammed into San Diego with winds of 52
mph south of Los Angeles. And in September 1976, a hurricane gusted to 76 mph
at Yuma, Arizona. Since accurate and widespread observations of sea surface
temperatures were not or could not be taken until recently, we are not certain
if these three years were strong El Niño periods, but collateral
evidence suggests that they were.
On September 9th, 1997, Hurricane Linda formed about 700 miles
south-southwest of the Baja peninsula. As the storm slowly moved
north-northwestward, running along the Mexican coastline, El Niño's warm
waters caused Linda to grow explosively into a large howling hurricane, with
sustained winds on September 12th of 185 miles per hour, and gusts over 200
miles per hour! Linda had become the most powerful East Pacific hurricane in
the history of weather records, big enough to cause many scientists to propose
creating a new Category Six, for super hurricanes.
As the clock ticked and the storm raged, terrifying forecasts spewed
from computer models; the storm would most likely slam the coast somewhere
between San Diego and Los Angeles, more probably at Los Angeles.
A hurricane requires surface water temperatures of at least 79 degrees
Fahrenheit to keep growing. El Niño had made the water temperatures
ideal all the way up to the California border, greasing the slide. Los Angeles'
fate seemed sealed.
At almost the last moment, an upper-level trough (a fancy term for a sharp
dip in higher-level winds) moved erratically, and Hurricane Linda was turned
out to sea as it neared the California border.
The only time in history a hurricane with winds over 100 miles per hour has
struck Los Angeles was on August 23rd, 1838, and that leveled the then-small
city. In 1997, Los Angeles came incredibly close to experiencing a direct-hit
assault by the most powerful Eastern Pacific hurricane in history!
I inspected the Homestead area of south Florida, along with National
Hurricane Center specialists, after Hurricane Andrew smashed through in 1992,
with winds of at least 140 mph, and gusts of 175 mph. Many homes there are
similar in construction to southern California homes. Andrew destroyed or
damaged virtually every building there, and his winds were weaker than those of
Linda, his size was smaller, and his movement was faster. From my perspective,
I can assure you Linda would have made the damage done by Andrew seem almost
moderate. Most roofs cannot sustain continued winds in excess of 100 miles per
hour. After the roof goes, the walls and rest of the house are blown apart like
matchwood. I saw it in Andrew, a weaker storm than Linda; Linda would have
steam-rollered Los Angeles. Clearly Linda would have the exceeded in Los Angeles the
25 billion dollars of damage that Andrew caused in Florida.
That should give you a little perspective when you watch news accounts of
the rains and flooding this week. It could have been - should have been - far,
Peter Chaston is a professional meteorologist, weather consultant, and
author of "Terror from the Skies" and "Hurricanes!" In 1995, Chaston predicted
that the next El Niño would be abnormally strong.