What if you knew that many feel that
using the data would make us the Nazi experimenters' moral accessories?
Rudolf Brandt, an SS officer and aide to
Himmler, was found guilty of a host of war crimes, including conducting medical
experimentation and killing tuberculosis-infected people. Sentenced to death,
he was hanged on June 2, 1948.
Many hold that making use of the data wrenched so brutally from helpless
victims would not only validate the Nazi doctors' unthinkable acts, but also
make us the victims' "retrospective torturers" (attorney Baruch Cohen) and them
our "retrospective guinea pigs" (Dr. Harold M. Spiro, Department of Internal
Medicine, Yale University). [13 & 14] Indeed, Lord Immanuel
Jakobovits, Chief Rabbi of the British Commonwealth of Nations and an expert in
Jewish medical ethics, felt use would only serve to further dishonor the
victims , while the late Harvard Medical School professor Dr. Henry
Beecher believed publishing unethically obtained medical data would cause a
"far-reaching moral loss to medicine." 
"The idea behind the negative reaction now is that the Nazis were criminals; we
are decent. That's not true. What we've done is not as evil, but it's in the
—Dr. Arthur Caplan, bioethicist now at the University of Pennsylvania,
commenting about uproar surrounding physiologist Robert Pozos' proposed use of
Nazi data on hypothermia
"The conduct of Nazi physician-scientists was barbarous, revolting, monstrous,
devoid of any decency. Their research defiled human beings, medicine, science,
and humanity. They dragged through bloody mud an honorable profession to which
contemporary physician-scientists who now wish to make use of these results
—Jay Katz, M.D., Yale University School of Law
"Today some doctors want to use the only thing left by these victims. They are
like vultures waiting for the corpses to cool so they could devour every
consummable part. To use the Nazi data is obscene and sick. One can always
rationalize that it would save human lives; the question should be asked, at
—Eva Mozes Kor, survivor of Dr. Josef Mengele's twins experiments at
"We must not add our numbers to the multitudes of onlookers who slept
peacefully through the nights of anguished cries while dreaming their sweet
dreams of a better tomorrow."
—Dr. Willard Gaylin, psychiatrist and former president of The Hastings Center,
a biomedical ethics thinktank
13. Cohen, p. 27.
14. Spiro, Howard M., M.D. "Let Nazi Medical Data Remind Us of Evil" (Letter to
the Editor). The New York Times 4/19/88, p. 30.
15. Cohen, p. 30.
16. Beecher, Henry K. "Ethics and Clinical Research." The New England
Journal of Medicine, Vol. 274 No. 24, 6/16/66, p. 1360.
17. Siegel, p. 1.
18. Katz, Jay. "Abuse of Human Beings for the Sake of Science." In
Caplan, p. 265.
19. Kor, Eva Mozes. "Nazi Experiments as Viewed by a Survivor of Mengele's
Experiments." In Caplan, p. 7.
20. Gaylin, Willard. "Commentary" (responding to "Nazi Data: Dissociation from
Evil"). Hastings Center Report, Vol. 19, July/August 1989, p. 18.
Photo: Hedy Epstein, courtesy of USHMM Photo Archives
The Director's Story |
Timeline of Nazi Abuses
Results of Death-Camp Experiments: Should They Be Used?
Exposing Flawed Science |
Site Map |
Holocaust on Trial Home
Editor's Picks |
Previous Sites |
Join Us/E-mail |
About NOVA |
Site Map |
PBS Online |
NOVA Online |
© | Updated October 2000