Taken from Church History: Selections from the Encyclopedia of Mormonism, edited by Daniel H. Ludlow
The violent deaths of the Prophet Joseph Smith at the age of
thirty-eight and his brother Hyrum Smith (age forty-four), Associate
President and patriarch of the Church, dramatically ended the founding
period of the LDS Church. On June 27, 1844, they were mobbed and shot
while confined at Carthage Jail in Hancock County, in western Illinois.
Climaxing more than two decades of persecution across several states,
this event gave them an enduring place as martyrs in the hearts of
Nauvoo in 1844, a gathering place for the Saints on the Mississippi River,
contained elements of both greatness and dissension. Almost overnight,
it grew from a village of religious refugees and new converts to the
point where it rivaled Chicago as the largest city in Illinois. With
Democrats and Whigs both vying for the Mormon vote, Nauvoo was granted
one of the most liberal city charters in the state, an independent
military force, and a strong judicial system.
However, as in Missouri during the 1830s, natural rivalry with older
citizens in neighboring towns like Carthage (the county seat) and Warsaw
(the next largest port city) turned to jealousy and hatred as Nauvoo's
economic and political power grew.
These tensions coalesced around Joseph Smith. In addition to being
prophet and President of the Church, he also served as mayor, commander
of the Nauvoo Legion state militia, justice of the peace, and university
chancellor. Non-Mormon fears of this concentration of powers were
intensified by the Church's belief in the theocratic union of spiritual,
economic, and political matters under the priesthood. This and other
"unorthodox" doctrines, such as continuing revelation, temple ordinances
for the living and the dead, new scripture, and plural marriage, further
intensified political and economic
Illinois anti-Mormons, perhaps assisted by old enemies from Missouri,
joined with a handful of determined Mormon defectors within Nauvoo.
Several had held high Church positions and, when excommunicated, fueled
efforts to destroy Joseph Smith and the Church.
The Prophet's life and his plans to resettle many of the Saints in the
West were cut short by a series of explosive
confrontations with these conspirators. The igniting spark was the
destruction of the defectors' intemperate newspaper, the Nauvoo
Expositor, as a public nuisance by the Nauvoo city marshal, under orders
from Joseph Smith and the city council. Removal of this press came after
the first and only issue had vilified Joseph Smith, pledged to cause
repeal of the protective Nauvoo charters, and invited mob action against
the Saints. Joseph Smith's enemies countered the destroying of the press
with criminal charges against him and his brother for inciting a riot.
The brothers soon gained release from arrest on a habeas corpus before
an LDS tribunal. Then, following the advice of a state circuit court
judge, they appeared before a non-Mormon justice in Nauvoo and were
exonerated of the charges against them.
However, threats of mob violence increased. In Warsaw and Carthage,
newspapers called for extermination of the Mormons. On June 18, Joseph
Smith mobilized his troops to protect Nauvoo. When Illinois governor
Thomas Ford apparently sided with the opposition and ordered the Church
leaders to stand trial again on the same charges, this time in Carthage,
Joseph and Hyrum first considered appealing to U.S. President John
Tyler, but then decided instead to cross the Mississippi and escape to
the West. Pressured by family and friends who felt abandoned and who
believed Joseph to be nearly invincible, he agreed to return and
surrender; but he prophesied that he would be going "like a lamb to the
slaughter" and would be "murdered in cold blood" (HC 6:555, 559). Joseph
urged Hyrum to save himself and succeed him as prophet, but Hyrum
refused and accompanied his brother to Carthage.
Despite his promises of protection and a fair trial, Governor Ford
allowed the Smiths to be imprisoned by their enemies without bail and
without a hearing on a wholly new charge of treason for having declared
martial law in Nauvoo. Stating that he had to "satisfy the people," the
Governor ignored clear warnings of danger and disbanded most of the
troops. He then left the hostile Carthage Greys to guard the jail and
took the most dependable troops with him to Nauvoo.
During the governor's absence, a mob of between one hundred and two
hundred armed men-many of them from the disbanded Warsaw
militia-gathered in late afternoon, blackened their faces with mud and
gunpowder, and then stormed the jail. In less than two minutes, they
overcame feigned resistance from the Greys, rushed upstairs, and fired
through the closed door. Hyrum, shot first, died instantly. John Taylor,
an apostle, tried to escape out a window and was shot five times, but
survived to later become the Church's third President. Only Willard
Richards, another apostle, survived unharmed. Trying to go out the
window to deflect attention from the two survivors inside, Joseph Smith
was hit in the chest and collarbone with two shots from the open doorway
and two more from outside the window. His final words as he fell to the
ground outside the jail were, "O Lord, my God!" (HC 6:618). As rumors
spread that the Mormons were coming, the mob dispersed.
Several times during his last days Joseph Smith told the Saints that
while he had enjoyed God's safekeeping until his mission was fulfilled,
he had now completed all that God required of him and could claim no
special protection. Early in his career, the Prophet had recorded that
the Lord told him, "Even if they do unto you . . . as they have done
unto me, blessed are ye, for you shall dwell with me in glory" (D&C
6:30). Church leaders then and now have taught that the shedding of
these martyrs' innocent blood was necessary to seal their testimony of
the latter-day work that they "might be honored and the wicked might be
condemned" (D&C 136:39).