Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Lesson Plans

Lesson plan: Trick or truth? Why social media posts hit the misinformation sweet tooth

October 27, 2022

 

Every year we hear warnings about Halloween Candy — razor blades in apples THC-laced chocolates and now fentanyl disguised as SweeTARTS. These claims spread quickly without much evidence because they evoke a strong emotion — fear.

Strong emotions cause us to act quickly — but that’s when we especially need to stop for a minute and check things out. This lesson explores all the tips and tricks for how to recognize a post that evokes strong emotion and choose the best search terms to find and evaluate sources. These search skills will help you find better answers to your other interests as well, such as “best exercises to work off all of my kid’s halloween candy.”

Overview

This lesson will equip students with the tools to use more effective search phrases and evaluate the reliability of the search results. Students will also be able to explain why posts that evoke strong emotions can contribute to the spread of misinformation. Students will be able to answer the following questions:

  • Why are posts that trigger strong emotions without evidence more likely to be shared?
  • How can I write a more effective search phrase to find the most relevant search results?
  • How can I determine which sources in a search result are the most credible?

This lesson was developed by PBS NewsHour Student Reporting Labs in partnership with MediaWise and the Teen Fact-Checking Network, which are part of the Poynter Institute. This partnership has been made possible with support from Google.

Objectives

Students will be able to:

  • Explain why we are more likely to share misinformation that evokes strong emotions.
  • Identify the most credible sources in search results.

Subjects

media literacy, social studies, language arts, journalism

Estimated Time

Up to 45 minutes for slide deck only, or up to 60 minutes with extensions

Full Lesson

View

Materials

Activator

(SLIDE 1) — THINK, PAIR, SHARE (5 Minutes)

Think – Pair – Share Activity

  • What emotions does a social media post like this evoke?
  • Why would someone share a post like this without evidence intentionally?
  • Why would someone share a post like this without evidence unintentionally?

(SLIDE 1) Presenter Notes

  • Ask students to write down their thoughts.
  • Share with a peer.
  • Share with the class.

These types of posts evoke a sense of fear.

These types of posts are shared  intentionally because they know it will be re-shared because of the strong emotions it evokes.

These types of posts are shared unintentionally by parents wanting to protect their children. We feel urgency to share this information to protect others.

(SLIDE 2) — KEY VOCABULARY (5 Minutes)

Key Vocabulary

  • Fentanyl — A powerful synthetic opioid similar to morphine but much more powerful. Though it has medical uses, fentanyl can cause overdoses and death and is often manufactured and sold illegally.

(SLIDE 2) Presenter Notes

  • Explain that we will look at why it is important to recognize satire online to avoid spreading misinformation from satirical sources that are mistaken for legitimate news sources.
  • Review the key vocabulary, review the examples, and let students know they will use these terms throughout the lesson.
  • Discuss the message each example is trying to communicate.

(SLIDE 3) LONG-TAIL KEYWORD SEARCH TRAITS (5 Minutes)

(SLIDE 3 ) Presenter Notes

Explain that long-tail keyword searches should:

  • include 4 or more words
  • include specific names or places
  • target the specific claim or goal
  • aim for credible sources

(SLIDE 4) APPLICATION (15 Minutes)

  • Write a long-tail keyword search term to find evidence about this claim.
  • List the two most credible sources in your results.
  • Explain why they are credible.

(SLIDE 4) Presenter Notes

  • Students can work individually, in pairs, or groups. Ask them to consider what may make a source more credible than others.

(SLIDES 5-6) MEDIAWISE FACT CHECK

  • What long-tail keyword search did the MediaWise teen fact-checker use?
  • Why is the source they found credible?

What long-tail keyword search did the MediaWise teen fact-checker use? Answer — “halloween candy dangers 2022”

Why is the source they found credible? Answer: Professor Joel Best, probably the nation’s top expert on Halloween candy incidents who has collected data for 64 years.

(SLIDE 7) DISCUSSION OR EXIT OUT THE DOOR

“What’s the Big Idea?” Discussion Questions

  • Why do strong emotions like fear contribute to the spread of misinformation?
  • How can you determine whether a source is credible or not?
  • What are four indicators that a source is credible?

(SLIDE 7) Presenter Notes

  • Examine the source’s and author’s credentials and affiliations.
  • Evaluate what sources are cited by the author.
  • Make sure the source is up-to-date.
  • Check the endorsements and reviews that the source received.

(SLIDE 8) EXTENSION AND REFINING ACTIVITY

Extension and Refining Activity

  • Choose a topic you would like to learn more about
  • Visit https://trends.google.com/
  • Enter your topic and list the top five long-tail search phrases being used worldwide

Additional Resources


MediaWise is a digital media literacy initiative of the Poynter Institute, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization. Now in over 170 middle and high schools, PBS NewsHour Student Reporting Labs (SRL) is a national youth journalism program that trains teenagers across the country to produce stories that highlight the achievements and challenges today’s youth face.

SUPPORTED BY VIEWERS LIKE YOU. ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PROVIDED BY: