Daily VideoNovember 20, 2019
Impeachment Day 3: Role of Witnesses
Directions: Read the summary, watch the video and answer the questions. You can turn on the “CC” (closed-captions) function and read along with the transcript here.
Teacher’s note: For time’s sake, we recommend watching the start of the segment to 7m:25s to hear from Lt. Colonel Alexander Vindman and Jennifer Williams. Then watch 16m:30s to 21m:15s to hear from Ambassador Kurt Volker and Tim Morrison.
Impeachment hearing activity: You may want to have your students complete the impeachment hearing activity (PDF here) which can be applied to any lawmaker, Democrat or Republican, and to any witness.
Summary: Officials who were on the July 25th phone call between President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy testified in open hearings for the first time on November 20. Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman and the State Dept.’s Jennifer Williams both testified that they listened to the phone call. “What I heard was inappropriate,” according to Vindman, adding that, “It is improper for the president of the United States to demand a foreign government investigate a U.S. citizen and a political opponent.
“I thought that the references to specific individuals and investigations, such as former Vice President Biden and his son, struck me as political in nature, given that the former vice president is a political opponent of the president,” Williams said.
Republicans called two witnesses later in the day, Ambassador Kurt Volker, the U.S. Special Representative for Ukraine until his resignation on Sept. 27, 2019, and Tim Morrison, former senior director for Russia and Europe on the National Security Council.
Volker changed his original testimony to say that, “I now understand that others saw the idea of investigating possible corruption involving the Ukrainian company, ‘Burisma’ as equivalent to investigating former Vice President Biden,” adding that, “I saw them as very different. The former being appropriate and unremarkable, the latter being unacceptable.”
Morrison said he did not see anything inappropriate with the July 25 phone call but did report the conversation to a State Dept. lawyer, something he had not done prior in his career.
- Essential question: What is the most persuasive point you heard supporting the positions of Democrats and Republicans?
- Why do you think Lt. Col. Vindman discussed his family background, particularly his father?
- Do you think the attacks by Republicans on Vindman were warranted? Explain.
- Why did you hear so much discussion of Burisma, a Ukrainian energy company?
- Did you find Vindman and Williams’ testimonies compelling? How about Volker and Morrison’s testimonies? Explain.
- Do you think the Democrats and Republicans got what they wanted out of their witnesses? Explain.
- What would you say the overall tone was in the hearing room?
- Media literacy: Check out at least three additional news sites about Day 3 of the impeachment hearings. How is the coverage similar and different to the PBS NewsHour’s story?
Catch up on Day 2 of the impeachment hearings: Yovanovitch describes weakened State Department, questions ‘smear’ campaign
For monthly updates containing teacher resources on Election 2020, click here.
Sign up for short education highlights from the PBS NewsHour here.
Tooltip of related stories
Tooltip of more video block
Submit Your Student Voice
In this NewsHour lesson plan, discuss the ways city, state and national leaders have responded to civil unrest. Continue reading
In this NewsHour lesson plan, discuss the protests surrounding the killing of Minneapolis resident George Floyd. Continue reading
In this NewsHour current events lesson, find out how convalescent plasma from previous COVID patients may help researchers with treatment options. Continue reading
In this NewsHour EXTRA lesson, learn about Twitter’s new initiative to fact check the tweets of influential figures such as President Trump and how it has stirred debate over the role of social media platforms as content moderators. Continue reading
In this NewsHour EXTRA lesson, learn how the coronavirus is impacting the economy and how it compares to the Great Depression. Continue reading