More Ways to Watch
PBS Airdate: July 15, 2015
NARRATOR: Pluto, an icy dwarf planet, three-billion miles from Earth. Our most powerful telescopes see only a blur, until now.
NEW HORIZONS MISSION CONTROL: We have liftoff.
NARRATOR: A space probe, called New Horizons, is on its way,...
ALAN STERN (NASA New Horizons, Principal Investigator): This is an epic journey.
NARRATOR: …to the far reaches of our solar system,…
ALAN STERN: It's going farther than any exploration by human beings ever has.
NARRATOR: …to capture images of a mysterious world that may hold the secret to the origins of our solar system.
CALEB SCHARF: (Astronomer, Columbia University Astrobiology Center): Are there going to be surprises? Absolutely.
NARRATOR: But not all the surprises are good.
ALICE BOWMAN (NASA New Horizons, Mission Operations Manager): About 1:55pm, local, we've lost signal with the spacecraft.
GLEN FOUNTAIN (NASA New Horizons, Project Manager): Could it be we hit something?
NARRATOR: But a last minute rescue saves the day, as Pluto comes into focus, revealing a world stranger than we ever imagined.
ANNETTE TOMBAUGH (Clyde Tombaugh's Daughter): Wow! There's a heart on it!
NARRATOR: Chasing Pluto, right now, on NOVA!
January 19, 2006: an Atlas V rocket, a 212-foot powerhouse, is prepped for launch at Cape Canaveral.
ALAN STERN: It was one of those days where you say to yourself, "This is it. Project succeeds or fails today." Because when things go bad on launch, they usually go bad in a spectacular way.
NEW HORIZONS MISSION CONTROL: T minus five, four, three, two, one. We have ignition and liftoff of the New Horizons spacecraft, on a voyage to visit the planet Pluto and beyond.
NARRATOR: It's the fastest launch ever recorded, 36,000 miles per hour.
New Horizons needs all the speed it can muster, on a journey that will take it clear across the solar system, to attempt something unique in the history of spaceflight: get an up close and personal look at Pluto, a mysterious, distant world, unlike anything we've explored before.
Back on Earth, at the Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory, the mission operations team for New Horizons is not quite ready to celebrate.
GLEN FOUNTAIN: Once the rocket took off, there was a great feeling of joy, and then you hold your breath for awhile, because you're not done until you get the signal back from the spacecraft that everything's okay.
ALICE BOWMAN: We don't have a mission until we know that the spacecraft is communicating with us.
NARRATOR: And so, they wait.
ALAN STERN: Everything is a concern. Things we've thought about, we know we've solved. To try and anticipate so many eventualities, it's the challenge of spaceflight.
NARRATOR: Almost an hour passes, and then mission ops receives the first signal from New Horizons.
LESLIE YOUNG (NASA New Horizons, Planetary Scientist): Scientists turn to each other and go, "I love you man." It was an astonishingly happy time.
ALICE BOWMAN: And that's the greatest feeling, because now we know we have a mission to Pluto.
NARRATOR: This is just the first of many challenges to come, on a journey that will take almost a decade.
HAL WEAVER: (NASA New Horizons, Planetary Scientist): Just nine hours after leaving the launch pad, it was already crossing the orbit of the moon.
NARRATOR: A trip that took Apollo astronauts three days.
But even traveling tens of thousands of miles an hour, it will take over nine years for New Horizons to reach its destination, to explore the far reaches of our solar system, more than three-billion miles from Earth,
beyond the planets we've come to know: Mars, with its rocky red surface; the gas giant, Jupiter, with its raging storm; and Saturn, with its stunning rings; Uranus, where turbulent winds blow over 500 miles an hour; and Neptune, a planet so far from the sun it takes 165 years to complete just one orbit.
Finally, New Horizons will arrive at Pluto, a world we can only picture with the help of artwork, like this, at least for now.
TEACHER, GRADE SCHOOL (Film Clip): Who can tell us about more about the planets?
NARRATOR: Back in the 1950s, every grade-schooler was taught there were nine planets, Pluto being the last and loneliest.
MIKE BROWN (Astronomer, California Institute of Technology): Everybody loved Pluto, because it was this, this funny, oddball, sitting out there, at the very edge.
ALAN STERN: You don't find that kind of name recognition and emotional connection and interest level for Uranus, or Mercury, or going down the list, but, somehow, Pluto just naturally attracts people's attention.
NARRATOR: What makes Pluto so popular?
It may have something to do with a playful bloodhound named "Pluto the Pup." It turns out the Disney character made its debut around the same time the planet was discovered.
Over the years, we've gotten to know this beloved little pup. The same can't be said for this mysterious little world.
The truth is Pluto and its moons have only been observed from billions of miles away, our best images, nothing more than a blur.
In fact, one of the biggest, baddest space telescopes in our arsenal, the Hubble, which takes stunning images of enormous distant galaxies, can only capture these pixelated images of Pluto, because, not only is it far away, it's really small.
But even at this resolution, they suggest something intriguing. Using these precious pixels, a computer-generated image reveals Pluto has a surprisingly varied surface.
The light areas could be miles and miles of ice.
CATHY OLKIN (NASA New Horizons, Planetary Scientist): The ices are the most obvious signature that you see, but you can discern that there's other components there, as well. But we just don't know exactly what they're made of.
NARRATOR: But here's what we do know, one of the few planets in the solar system with such a varied surface is planet Earth.
We also know that Pluto has a rather bizarre atmosphere. During its 248-year orbit, as Pluto gets closer to the sun, its frozen surface starts to thaw, and its atmosphere slowly emerges.
JOEL PARKER (NASA New Horizons, Astronomer): What we see in the atmosphere is gases that are coming off the surface, creating a temporary atmosphere, perhaps. Pluto has a unique type of atmosphere in this outer part of the solar system that we've never studied before.
NARRATOR: An area so distant and elusive we knew almost nothing about it until the 1990s, when powerful new telescopes discovered lonely little Pluto wasn't so lonely, after all. It's part of a region in the outer solar system, beyond the orbit of Neptune, called the Kuiper Belt. And it is enormous.
Billions of miles from the sun, the Kuiper Belt is filled with hundreds of thousands of icy objects. While they may look like asteroids, which are made of rock and metal, these objects, hidden in the solar system's deep freeze, are made of a mixture of rock and ice.
MIKE BROWN: These are basically frozen remnants of the early part of the solar system that are still in the freezer. You can start to read this fossil record of how the solar system evolved, by looking at these objects.
HAL WEAVER: You can't say, for the New Horizons mission, "Been there, done that," because it hasn't. We've already explored the terrestrial planet region, the giant planet region. Now, we're exploring a completely new portion of the solar system that's never been touched before.
MARK HOLDRIDGE (NASA New Horizons, Encounter Mission Operations Manager): We don't know what we're going to find. We really don't. I think that, that's what makes this exciting.
NARRATOR: How do you design a spacecraft that can survive a three-billion-mile journey to parts unknown?
JOEL PARKER: Any time you explore something new, there's always a little risk.
HAL WEAVER: The New Horizons mission faced a huge number of challenges. We're going to the outskirts of the solar system, you know, 30 times farther from the sun than the earth. And so, in order to get there in a reasonable amount of time, we had to build the lightest possible spacecraft that we could, put it on the largest rocket we could. There was no opportunity to fly big solar arrays, because the sunlight is just too faint, so we carry a nuclear-powered source.
We have a suite of instruments, seven instruments, to do very different things. And they weigh less than about 70 pounds, all of them, together.
NARRATOR: Seven scientific instruments, not much bigger than a grand piano, with whimsical names like PEPSSI, SWAP and an antenna named REX. Two are named after the lead characters in the 1950s television show The Honeymooners, Ralph and Alice. Together, these instruments will analyze Pluto's surface and geology and reveal secrets about its mysterious atmosphere.
Back in the 1980s, one of the best ways to observe Pluto's atmosphere was with this: a C141 cargo plane, with a makeshift observatory on its side.
The Kuiper Airborne Observatory was not what you'd call a first class ride.
LESLIE YOUNG: The Kuiper Airborne Observatory is not built for comfort. You're on headsets the whole time. It's very loud. It's very cold. The telescope—it's in the middle of an airplane—it bounces around.
NARRATOR: But by flying a telescope above the weather, they had a chance to capture a rare event called a "stellar occultation."
During this event, an object, like Pluto, passes in front of a bright star, blocking its light. If the object has an atmosphere, the light gradually fades out, then slowly fades back up again. But if it doesn't, the light abruptly disappears and then quickly reappears.
This is a recording of what happened on board the Kuiper Airborne Observatory the night of June 9th, 1988, when a group of researchers were determined to find out if Pluto has an atmosphere.
KUIPER AIRBORNE OBSERVATORY RESEARCHER #1: I think it's fading? It's fading.
KUIPER AIRBORNE OBSERVATORY RESEARCHER #2: No. Well.
KUIPER AIRBORNE OBSERVATORY RESEARCHER #3: It's faded on the tracker.
KUIPER AIRBORNE OBSERVATORY RESEARCHER #2: Yeah. It's faded here, too.
I think that thing has atmosphere, guys. Yep, atmosphere.
NARRATOR: The light behind Pluto slowly faded, and the crew made history.
LESLIE YOUNG: I was fortunate enough to be involved. I would call that the beginning of my being an astronomer. And it's a pretty good beginning.
NARRATOR: One of the instruments on board New Horizons that's designed to study Pluto's elusive atmosphere is Alice.
JOEL PARKER: This model is an actual-size model of Alice. Alice is an ultraviolet spectrometer. It's a telescope that breaks up light into a rainbow.
NARRATOR: Every chemical element reflects and absorbs light in a unique way, creating a pattern as distinct as a fingerprint. Hydrogen's fingerprint looks like this, while nitrogen's looks like this.
Powerful Earth-based telescopes have already detected molecules of nitrogen, methane and carbon monoxide on Pluto's surface and in its atmosphere.
JOEL PARKER: We suspect it has a number of others that we simply can't detect.
NARRATOR: As the spacecraft flies just a few thousand miles above Pluto, Alice will search for those fingerprints.
Then, at the end of the flyby, the spacecraft will turn around to give Alice a one-of-a-kind view of Pluto's atmosphere, as seen through the light of the sun.
JOEL PARKER: We can use the sun as our light source, to probe the atmosphere and look for those fingerprints of certain types of atoms and molecules.
NARRATOR: While Alice probes Pluto's atmosphere, her partner, Ralph, an infrared spectrometer, will be hard at work, searching for those chemical fingerprints of molecules on Pluto's surface.
HAL WEAVER: We want to know what's causing the very bright surfaces on Pluto, which we think is exotic snowflakes of molecular nitrogen and methane. But there are other regions that seem to be devoid of those snowflakes and are probably much redder, darker hydrocarbon deposits.
NARRATOR: Ralph will finally reveal what these strange, dark regions are made of.
But to get up close and personal images of Pluto, requires an instrument with a one-of-a-kind telephoto lens.
The largest imager on board New Horizons, named LORRI, will capture extraordinary images of Pluto's surface.
LORRI will take pictures so detailed that if it was flying over New York City you could see the Hudson River, the East River, even Central Park.
To put this in perspective, this image of the Big Apple was taken by a satellite traveling about 400 miles above Earth. LORRI is so powerful it could capture the same amount of detail from more than 7,000 miles above Earth.
But sending a telescope with a lens like this into the grueling subzero temperatures of the Kuiper Belt is risky business.
ANDREW CHENG (NASA New Horizons, Planetary Scientist): When you have a telescope, it's opened to space, and so it's cooling through that opening. The result is that you're putting part of the camera cold, part of it warm, and that changes the shape of the telescope and that tends to put it out of focus.
NARRATOR: And you can end up with pictures that look like this.
To solve this problem, they turn to a material found in bulletproof vests. What makes vests like this so strong is a compound called silicon carbide.
ANDREW CHENG: LORRI is made out of a special version of it, which is able to tolerate temperature gradients without distorting its shape. But it's also very strong and very light.
JOHN SPENCER (NASA New Horizons, Planetary Scientist): There's a lot of things that might go wrong, and we've tried to anticipate all those things, and work out contingency plans and contingency plans for those contingency plans.
ANDREW CHENG: We've been working for years to get the spacecraft ready, prepare for everything you could think of. In the end, it just, you know, you just have to sit there and wait. And it just either works or it doesn't.
NARRATOR: For the New Horizons team, waiting to find out if all their hard work will pay off just may be the toughest challenge of all.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: During the Pluto encounter, the spacecraft's basically pre-programmed to do everything on its own.
LESLIE YOUNG: If it gets into trouble, we can't help. We can't give it a call and say, "Whoops, you're looking at the wrong thing. Adjust your sights a little bit to the left."
NARRATOR: That's because, when the spacecraft flies by Pluto, it will take four-and-a-half hours for a radio signal to reach Earth and another four-and-a-half hours for instructions to get back to the spacecraft.
LESLIE YOUNG: If something went wrong, it would be more than nine hours before we could tell it to do something. The most important science is happening, really, only over about a 12-hour period.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: The timing has to be precise, because the onboard commands all have a predetermined time that this is supposed to happen. If that time changes too much, we'll get a lot of pictures of black space, and we'll miss the science.
NARRATOR: February 28, 2007: New Horizons has been en route for a little over a year. Back at mission operations at the Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory, the team prepares for the spacecraft's first real test since launch.
As New Horizons nears Jupiter, it must hit a mark just 500 miles wide, where it will get pulled into the gas giant's gravity and get flung out. At that point it will be traveling a lot faster.
Think of it like a clever maneuver used in roller derby, called the whip. One skater pulls another, propelling her forward with greater velocity. That's what Jupiter's gravity will hopefully do for New Horizons.
At mission operations, the tension is palpable, especially for the mission operations manager, Alice Bowman, also known as "M-O-M" She has spent years preparing for this moment, and she knows all too well what it means if this maneuver should fail.
ANDREW CHENG: It would take years longer to get to Pluto, if you did not have that flyby.
LESLIE YOUNG: If you think nine years is a long time, adding another couple years onto that, that would have been intolerable.
NARRATOR: The clock is ticking.
MOM, along with the mission ops team, waits to receive telemetry from the spacecraft. This data will reveal whether New Horizons successfully pulled off the gravity assist or not.
ALICE BOWMAN: Red is bad, green is good, gray means you don't have any data.
NARRATOR: Finally they hear from the spacecraft.
ALICE BOWMAN: PI, this is MOM on Pluto One. Spacecraft telemetry for all subsystems is nominal. Spacecraft is outward-bound from Jupiter, and we're on our way to Pluto.
JOHN SPENCER: So far, so great. This is good.
HAL WEAVER: By stealing some momentum from Jupiter, along the way to Pluto, we can actually increase the speed of the spacecraft by about 20 percent and cut three years off the travel time.
ANDREW CHENG: And at the same time, because in order to do the Jupiter flyby, you end up coming fairly close to it, it gives you an opportunity to do some great science.
GLEN FOUNTAIN: It was the only time we were going to have large objects for the cameras to actually point to and say, "Okay, are we doing this right?"
ANDREW CHENG: We used all the instruments on New Horizons, but LORRI was prominent.
HAL WEAVER: Oh, wow. Look at that.
JOHN SPENCER: Oh, yeah!
HAL WEAVER: And we got both of them; we got both of them.
ANDREW CHENG: It's beautiful!
NARRATOR: From more than a million miles away, LORRI captures a sequence of images of the eruption of a volcano on Jupiter's moon Io.
ALAN STERN: It was the first time that time lapse had ever been made of any volcano anywhere in the universe off the earth, so it was really unique.
JOHN SPENCER: It's another plume!
ANDREW CHENG: That's great. Perfect image.
JOHN SPENCER: Yeah!
ALICE BOWMAN: We were extremely lucky we got these fantastic movies. It made all those sleepless nights and all that hard work very much worth it.
NARRATOR: After the gravity assist, New Horizons goes into hibernation. Only essential systems are up and running. This limits the amount of wear and tear on the equipment. For most of its nine-year journey it will be asleep, but once a week, the spacecraft phones home to MOM.
ALICE BOWMAN: This is MOM on Pluto One, status check.
NARRATOR: And MOM lets the whole team know if all systems are in working order.
As New Horizons makes its way across the solar system, to the last and loneliest planet to be explored, back on Earth, a revolution in astronomy is taking place. After 75 years as the solar system's ninth planet, Pluto is getting its walking papers.
JON STEWART (The Daily Show with Jon Stewart/Film Clip): Pluto was, since 1930, was a planet. He had stature. He had friends.
SOLEDAD O'BRIEN (NBC NEWS CLIP): Could it be the final indignity for the farthest and smallest planet in our solar system?
SINGER: Rock on, Pluto. You'll always be a planet to me.
PROTESTER: Size doesn't matter. Pluto is a planet.
NARRATOR: The public takes to the streets to fight for Pluto.
PROTESTER: Go Pluto! Pluto forever.
NARRATOR: It's been America's favorite planet, since it was discovered, back in the 1930s, by the unlikeliest of planet hunters. Clyde Tombaugh was a self-educated farm boy who attended a one-room schoolhouse. His first job in astronomy included cleaning telescopes and sweeping up at the Lowell Observatory. He spent the rest of his time searching for something that could be causing disturbances in Neptune's orbit, the mysterious "Planet X."
Every few nights he placed a photosensitive glass plate on the telescope, securing it so it would not shift. Then he exposed the plate for one hour to the universe.
During that time, the motorized telescope slowly moved to compensate for Earth's rotation. Several days later, he'd retrace his steps, taking pictures of the same sections of the sky he had photographed earlier.
Then, using an ingenious device called a "blink comparator," Clyde aligned the two images, to carefully examine their differences. The blink comparator enabled him to shift back and forth, searching for the subtlest of changes. Although the human eye is good at spotting differences, finding a dim celestial object, billions of miles away, was a daunting task.
Month after month, he forged ahead, through a harsh cold winter.
ANNETTE TOMBAUGH: He almost froze to death one night, because his fingers got so numb he couldn't get the trap door open to get out of the dome. They were having a lot of problems with the photographic plates breaking in the cold weather, and he invented a new plate holder that would keep the plates from breaking. And that's what led to the discovery.
NARRATOR: After patiently searching for almost a year, a determined Clyde finally found a tiny dot slowly moving across the night sky.
Can you see it? Here it is.
Two months later, the Lowell Observatory proudly announced that a young assistant had discovered the ninth planet in our solar system.
ANNETTE TOMBAUGH: Because of the discovery, my dad got his college education. Otherwise, he probably would not have been able to afford to go to college. The discovery was, I would say, the driver of our life, in many ways.
NARRATOR: After discovering Pluto, Clyde taught astronomy, and for decades to come, he searched for another planet in the far reaches of the solar system. But as hard as he and other astronomers looked—and they looked hard—nobody found anything; until astronomers David Jewitt and Jane Luu took on the challenge. They started a search that would take a lot longer than they could ever imagine.
JANE LUU (Astronomer, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Lincoln Laboratory): Why did it take so long? It was a matter of technology catching up with the problem.
NARRATOR: While it's easy to see distant stars, because they radiate light, other celestial bodies are much harder to see. That's because light has to travel all the way from our sun to the object, reflect off its surface, and then make the long journey back to Earth. By then it's barely visible.
David and Jane hoped that advances in digital detectors, now standard in today's smart phones, would help them see a whole lot more.
After searching for five years, they finally found something.
DAVID JEWITT (Astronomer, University of California Los Angeles): Here is the set of discovery images for the first object. So, you can see this object, drifting from this picture, to this one, to this one. It's drifting slowly to the left.
NARRATOR: When they found several more of these slow-moving objects, David and Jane could finally declare Pluto is not alone. In fact, it's got plenty of neighbors.
They named this new region of the solar system the Kuiper Belt, after Gerard Kuiper, the astronomer who proposed its existence back in the 1950s.
The discovery of the Kuiper Belt expanded our understanding of the solar system in a profound way, but it also put Pluto's planetary status in jeopardy. Is it a planet or a Kuiper Belt object, one of many?
ANNETTE TOMBAUGH: My dad knew there were rumblings in the wind, and it upset him. It certainly was not easy for my father.
NARRATOR: But the final blow was yet to come.
A few years later, a young astronomer decided to look for more objects in the outer solar system. Mike Brown was determined to do something really big: find a Kuiper Belt object larger than Pluto.
MIKE BROWN: We even thought we might be finding things the size of Mars, the size of the earth. We really had no idea. So when we started off doing this, back in 1997, it was pretty exciting to think what might be out there.
NARRATOR: At the Palomar Observatory, in California, Mike had access to the largest digital camera on Earth. The images were uploaded to his computer, where he analyzed them every morning.
With technology on his side, the discoveries just kept on coming.
MIKE BROWN: We found Quaoar, which is an object out in the Kuiper Belt that's about half the size of Pluto. The next year, we found something about three-quarters the size of Pluto. And, the following year, we found this thing. And it was so bright and also moving so slowly, moving so slowly, because it was so far away.
NARRATOR: After all this time, Mike couldn't believe he might finally have found what he had been looking for.
MIKE BROWN: I looked at it, and I thought, "This can't be right. If it's that bright and moving that slowly, it's the furthest thing we've ever found. And it's the biggest thing we've ever found. It must be quite big, certainly bigger than Pluto, and that's crazy."
MARK SYKES (Planetary Scientist, Planetary Science Institute): It was the first object to be discovered that could have been larger than Pluto. And that caused a ruckus, because, well, if Pluto's a planet, then this has got to be a planet, right? So what are we going to call these things?
MIKE BROWN: Most people really didn't care that much about this thing that we just discovered. They wanted to know, "Well, what does it mean for Pluto?" It's like, "Oh, yeah, you found something bigger than Pluto, but what does it mean for Pluto?"
NARRATOR: For the past century, the I.A.U., the International Astronomical Union, has been in charge of naming celestial objects, but it couldn't give Mike's discovery a name, without knowing if it was a Kuiper Belt object or the tenth planet.
HAL WEAVER: I think it started an interesting conversation, because we didn't really have a definition for planets—okay, you know it came from the Greek "wandering star"—and we did need a better way of classifying things as being planets or small bodies in the solar system.
NARRATOR: At the I.A.U. meeting, in Prague, a vote was taken on a new definition of the word "planet." Pluto's fate came down to the phrasing of just one line: "a planet has cleared the neighborhood around its orbit."
Pluto resides in a crowded neighborhood, filled with thousands of Kuiper Belt objects. Unlike larger planets, tiny Pluto doesn't have enough gravity to clear them out of its way. It also has an extreme elliptical orbit, not on the same plane as the rest of the planets.
MIKE BROWN: Eight major things, which dominate the solar system, are planets. They're all big. They go in circular orbits in, in one disk around the sun. And everything else is much smaller; those are not planets.
NARRATOR: So, according to the I.A.U., Pluto is not a planet. It's a "dwarf" planet.
HAL WEAVER: There has been a consensus developed that Pluto is a dwarf planet. And you know, I have no problem with that, the controversy comes in when you try to say a dwarf planet is not a planet. Well, it seems a little ridiculous to have the planet in the word, the designation for an object and say, somehow, it's not a planet.
CALEB SCHARF: In a sense, this question of how do you label certain objects, is less important than understanding that objects like Pluto, the earth, Jupiter, exoplanets come in a remarkable variety and remarkably different configurations across the universe.
NARRATOR: While Pluto may no longer be the solar system's ninth planet, it turns out, it's got plenty of company. Planetary scientists continue to discover more dwarf planets, giving them temporary nicknames like Santa and Easter Bunny.
ALAN STERN: We've discovered that the outer solar system is littered with small planets. These are typically rocky and icy objects. Many have atmospheres; many—possibly most—have moons, all the things we are used to in the planets, we're familiar with, but in miniature. I think a decent analogy is when you see a Chihuahua it's still a dog, because it has the characteristics of the canine species, just in miniature.
NARRATOR: Not everyone agrees with Alan Stern's canine analogy. And as more Kuiper Belt objects are discovered, the question arises, "How did our outer solar system end up with these pint-sized dwarfs?"
To answer that, we may need to look back at the birth of the solar system.
CALEB SCHARF: We think that the solar system began to form about 4.5- to 4.6-billion years ago, when a cloud of nebula, a cloud of gas and dust, fell in on itself because of its own gravity. As it fell together, it began to turn into a great disc of orbiting swirling material. It's that disc of gas and dust that we think turns into planets. You make a planet from material sticking together and building larger and larger pieces.
NARRATOR: Scientists theorize that planets form when this material starts to stick together: pebbles turn into boulders; boulders into mountain-sized comets; comets turn into protoplanets; protoplanets turn into planets.
ALAN STERN: After objects reach a certain threshold in their mass, they can grow more rapidly than they could before, because they have substantial gravity.
NARRATOR: Gas giants, like Jupiter and Saturn, siphoned up massive amounts of hydrogen and helium, sweeping up everything in sight.
CALEB SCHARF: It seems plausible that Pluto originally formed somewhat closer in to the sun, but then as those major planets got larger and larger, it got pushed to a more distant orbit. We think that objects like Pluto and the other Kuiper Belt bodies are really the remains of that process of planet formation.
NARRATOR: They are sometimes called planetesimals, celestial objects that somehow stopped growing.
ALAN STERN: Dwarf planets were arrested in the mid-stage of planetary growth. They are actually planetary embryos. And to study those objects, rather than objects that grew to much larger scales, will give us a great window into the process of planetary formation.
CALEB SCHARF: Perhaps we can find clues in the surface of Pluto and its composition that point towards that deep history and, in turn, tell us about the architecture of the solar system, as it is now. Where did that come from? How did that happen?
NARRATOR: Pluto may even hold clues to unravel another great mystery. As far as we know, the requirements for life are water, energy and organic matter. A large number of dwarf planets may have all of these ingredients.
ALAN STERN: There are very reputable models of Pluto that suggest that there's a vast interior ocean, and that these may be common inside the dwarf planets. Wherever you have water, then you have the potential—and I want to stress that word "potential"—for biology. So, it may be that the dwarf planets are not only the most common kind of planet in the solar system, they may be the most common abode for life in the solar system.
CALEB SCHARF: Clearly, organic chemistry, carbon chemistry can take place on the surface of objects like comets and probably Kuiper Belt objects, too. Whether or not that relates to the existence of life on Earth, I think, is a totally open question. But just understanding the chemical richness of our solar system and the universe is a big piece of the puzzle. And it's a piece of the puzzle that we need to solve.
NARRATOR: June 8th, 2008: New Horizons has been soaring through space for more than two years. Today it passes the orbit of Saturn.
In three more years it passes Uranus. It's spent half a decade traveling through space, and it's still running like clockwork. But then the unexpected happens, putting the entire mission at risk.
Images taken by the Hubble Space Telescope reveal Pluto has, not one, not two, not three, not four, but five moons.
HAL WEAVER: All of these moons probably all formed in the same big cosmic collision, taking place about 4.6-billion years ago, where two Pluto-sized objects rammed into each other. And now we're seeing the aftermath of that.
NARRATOR: In the end, Pluto remained intact, but the other object broke into pieces, forming the five moons that we know of, some very oddly shaped.
HAL WEAVER: All of these small moons are debris generators, creating the potential of millimeter-sized dust forming a ring around Pluto. The spacecraft is flying so fast through the Pluto system, roughly 30,000 miles per hour, that if it hit even a millimeter-sized particle, it could blow a hole in the spacecraft, and it could destroy the mission.
NARRATOR: Back in 1967, this almost happened to the Mars probe, Mariner 4.
SIGRID CLOSE (Aeronautics & Astronautics, Stanford University): It ran into a cloud of space dust. And over the course of about 45 minutes, they were seeing thousands of impacts on the spacecraft, completely unexpected. Clearly, there are particles out there that we can't detect that could potentially cause a loss of mission.
NARRATOR: How much of a beating can New Horizons take?
We're about to find out, at one of the most powerful shooting galleries in the world.
NASA's hypervelocity gun can shoot the tiniest of pellets up to 17,000 miles per hour. The dust particles New Horizons might run into range from the size of the head of a pin, down to the size of a grain of sand. These little objects may not look very dangerous, but imagine a sandstorm with winds so strong that just one grain of sand could kill you.
The gun is loaded. The room is cleared.
This gun is so powerful, metal is pulverized from the impact. A pellet is propelled down this 120-foot long barrel, to a target made of the materials used in the construction of the spacecraft.
The first layer is the gold thermal blanket that covers New Horizons. The second layer is the spacecraft's wall. The third layer, a thin metal plate, represents the heart of the spacecraft, the electronics and scientific instruments.
Test after test is conducted, tiny pellets slammed into the target at lightening speeds. The results are mixed. Most of the pellets penetrate the gold thermal blanket but are stopped by the wall of the spacecraft, but not all. In fact, some, like this one, punch a hole right through it. A few more holes like this could put a quick and violent end to the mission.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: The potential for a debris impact that came out through the detection of the newer moons does add another layer of complexity to the flyby.
NARRATOR: The New Horizons team had to come up with alternate flight plans, or trajectories, for the spacecraft to travel. This is the ideal trajectory they are hoping for.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: There are actually four different trajectories that we could potentially go on, and we may not know until a couple of weeks out which one we're going on.
CALEB SCHARF: The worst possible scenario is it comes into the system, it starts taking images, it gets destroyed by some impact, and we'll never see the images, which is pretty nerve-wracking. I want to see the results. I'm glad I'm not the person waiting for that data to come.
ALICE BOWMAN: On the approach, we have planned observations to look for any other kind of debris or…we're calling them hazards now, not moons, hazards. It's funny how things change.
LESLIE YOUNG: There'll always be a little nagging question, you know, did we make it through? So, that first beacon that says we made it through, everybody is just going to…well, they'll breathe a sigh of relief, and then they'll look at each other and go, "Oh, I knew it all along."
NARRATOR: August 25, 2014: New Horizons reaches Neptune's orbit on the 25th anniversary of Voyager 2's encounter.
The original mission was designed to study only Jupiter, Saturn and their moons, but Voyager 2 went on to take stunning images of Uranus, Neptune and its moon, Triton.
ALAN STERN: In the '60s and the '70s and the '80s, we were exploring new planets all the time. First to Mars, first to Venus, first to Mercury, first to Jupiter, first to Saturn. That came to an end, in 1989, with Voyager. It's been 25 years. And now we're doing the next first mission. That's epic.
NARRATOR: December 6, 2014: After years in hibernation, the spacecraft is waking up. The final leg of its journey is about to begin.
ALAN STERN: Tonight we're ending hibernation. We've been hibernating the spacecraft for most of a three-billion-mile journey through the solar system. That's over now. It's really quite an historic day.
NARRATOR: Once the spacecraft has checked that all systems are up and running it will send a report back to MOM.
ALICE BOWMAN: So when we receive a signal from the spacecraft, it's data that the spacecraft sent four-and-a-half hours earlier.
NARRATOR: And it requires a special network of radio antennas to receive it. These enormous antennas are spaced across the globe, so, as the earth rotates, the team can stay in touch with the spacecraft 24/7.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: The spacecraft has a 10-watt transmitter. That we can pick that signal up on Earth is incredible.
NARRATOR: In comparison, your average radio station uses 50,000 watts to transmit a signal.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: It is an amazing accomplishment. And a lot of that's due to the technology that's at the stations, at the deep space network, these amazing antennas.
ALICE BOWMAN: Getting ready for show time, here.
NARRATOR: A few members of the team have gathered in the room next door, hoping to celebrate. But that moment will only arrive when a very tense MOM gets word from NASA's deep space network that they are starting to receive a signal from New Horizons.
Data begins to show up on her screen.
ALICE BOWMAN: We get it! We got it!
NARRATOR: But before she can breathe easy, all members of the mission ops team must verify that all systems are in working order.
ALICE BOWMAN: RF, MOM on Pluto one. Status check?
TEAM MEMBER #1: RF is green.
ALICE BOWMAN: Power, status?
TEAM MEMBER #2: Power system, green.
ALICE BOWMAN: Propulsion, status?
TEAM MEMBER #3: Propulsion is green.
ALICE BOWMAN: Oh, there we go! We have a nominal wake up of the New Horizons spacecraft on our way to Pluto.
The team is ready for the next leg of the journey.
ALAN STERN: We have an encounter coming, how about that?
GLEN FOUNTAIN: Some days it just goes like clockwork.
TEAM MEMBERS: All right! Cheers!
ALICE BOWMAN: We can all take a big breath, now.
HAL WEAVER: To Pluto and beyond. Here, here! To history.
ALAN STERN: This has been a very long road.
HAL WEAVER: For the MOM.
ALAN STERN: Well, it's just amazing! We're on the other side of the solar system, where we were meant to be.
ALICE BOWMAN: When we talk about the spacecraft, we talk about it as if it's, you know, our child, our baby. When it does something that we don't expect, we relate it perhaps to a terrible twos or something like that, so it really, it becomes part of us.
NARRATOR: Over the years, hundreds of people have dedicated themselves to this historic mission. For many team members, revealing Pluto's secrets is the challenge of a lifetime.
CATHY OLKIN: The New Horizons mission has been a large part of my life, and it's been the majority of my children's lives. I think they can't even imagine what it'd be like to have this data from Pluto, because they've been looking forward to it for their whole life.
NARRATOR: As New Horizons gets closer and closer to Pluto, the team determines there are no more moons and little risk of the spacecraft being destroyed by debris.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: They looked and they looked and they looked, but they couldn't find any new moons. I think they were kind of disappointed, from a scientific standpoint, but from a hazard standpoint, it was really good news.
NARRATOR: But the good news is short-lived.
ALICE BOWMAN: About 1:55 p.m., local, we've lost signal with the spacecraft. You just feel that pit in the bottom of your stomach. You're thinking, "Oh, my god." I can't believe this is happening.
GLEN FOUNTAIN: Your pulse goes up a little bit. Could it be, these millions of miles away, you hit something?
NARRATOR: Searching for a solution, mission ops tries to connect with New Horizon's backup computer, which transmits on a different radio frequency.
ALICE BOWMAN: Right away, deep space network locked up onto that signal, and it was such a great feeling, because we found our spacecraft.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: Turned out the main processor had reset, and it had switched over to the backup processor. That's sort of like your worst nightmare, a week before an encounter.
ALICE BOWMAN: We knew that we could fix it. The question was, "Were we going to be able to do that in enough time?"
GLENN FOUNTAIN: Alice, I swear, didn't get any sleep, but she said she slept on the floor for a few minutes one night.
ALICE BOWMAN: For a couple nights I slept there, you know, just like a child that's sick. You want to be there to help it recover along the way.
NARRATOR: The team fixes the problem just seven days before New Horizons is set to fly by Pluto.
HAL WEAVER: We did it with four hours to spare, or something like that!
ALICE BOWMAN: Yes, things are definitely back onto track.
NARRATOR: And the pictures are flooding in.
LESLIE YOUNG: Every day, it's been getting better and better. We've been getting beautiful stuff for the last week. We are drooling with anticipation.
ANDREW CHENG: The next picture from LORRI that we will see is a full-frame image of Pluto. And it's the one that we think is really going to tell us what's happening. I almost can't wait for it to come down.
NARRATOR: Taken from almost half-a-million miles away, this is New Horizons last portrait of Pluto, before its closest approach. Scientists speculate the light areas are ice; the dark could be a dusting of organic molecules that fall from the atmosphere.
HAL WEAVER: This is the heart, right? This is the heart-shaped region.
JOHN SPENCER: Clearly there's a lot of craters. Boy!
HAL WEAVER: It really is breathtaking and awe-inspiring.
JOHN SPENCER: I've never seen anything like this before.
NARRATOR: But there's one more hurdle, and it's a big one. The world watches, as the team tensely awaits a signal from New Horizons that it has made its closest approach to Pluto—less than 8,000 miles above the surface—and survived with all systems intact.
ALICE BOWMAN: Stand by for telemetry. PI, MOM on Pluto 1. We have a healthy spacecraft! We've recorded data of the Pluto system, and we're outbound for Pluto.
We did it!
CATHY OLKIN: Very relieved and happy, yeah.
MARK HOLDRIDGE: Every polling that was done, every subsystem that reported in was like music to my ears. It's never sounded that good.
NARRATOR: The next day, the tiny spacecraft, three-billion miles from home, starts beaming back the first close up pictures of Pluto, with icy mountains, 11-thousand feet high, and Pluto's biggest moon Charon, with hardly any impact craters.
It will take about 16 months for New Horizons to send back all the photos and data it has gathered, and years for scientists to analyze it, slowly revealing Pluto's secrets, as New Horizons, itself, heads out through the icy Kuiper Belt and beyond.
- WRITTEN, PRODUCED AND DIRECTED BY
- Terri Randall
- EDITED BY
- Jedd Ehrmann
- Joseph Friedman
- NARRATED BY
- Craig Sechler
- ASSOCIATE PRODUCERS
- Leslie Mullen
- CONSULTING PRODUCER
- David Grinspoon
- SOUND RECORDIST
- Paul Schmitz
- Dan Durda
Dan Durda Brian Edgerton
- ONLINE EDITOR
- Evan Anthony
- AUDIO MIX
- Sync Sound
- Leora Randall-Tavori
- PRODUCTION ASSISTANT
- Theresa Newton
- ARCHIVAL MATERIAL
- AIP Emilio Segre Visual Archives, W. F. Meggers Collection
Dr. R. Albrecht, ESA/ESO Space Telescope European Coordinating Facility; NASA Kelly Beatty
ESA/Hubble (M. Kornmesser & L. L. Christensen)
ESA/Hubble (M. Kornmesser, Colleen Sharkey & Lars Lindberg Christensen)
Free State Studios/KTKA TV
Indiana State Museum
International Astronomical Union
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Library
Mauna Kea timelapse sequences from the film 'Hawaiian Starlight' by Jean-Charles Cuillandre (Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope)
M.Buie/Southwest Research Institute/NASA/ESA
NASA, ESA, and K. Sahu (STScI)
NASA, ESA, and M. Livio and the Hubble 20th Anniversary Team (STScI)
NASA, ESA, and M. Showalter (SETI Institute)
NASA, ESA, and The Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA)
NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center Conceptual Image Lab
NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/Southwest Research Institute
NASA/JPL-Caltech/Arizona State University
NASA/JPL-Caltech/Space Science Institute/G. Ugarkovic
NASA, JPL; Digital processing: Björn Jónsson (IAAA)
NASA/JPL/MSSS; processings and mosaic: Olivier de Goursac, 2013
NASA/JPL/University of Arizona
Photograph by Dienst, Friebe Zurich, courtesy AIP Emilio Segre Visual Archives, W.F. Meggers Collection
Gregory H. Revera
Space Telescope Science Institute and Mark Showalter, SETI Institute
With thanks for the provision of archive material to the European Space Agency/ESA
- SPECIAL THANKS
- Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory
Helen E. Worth
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
Gotham Girls Roller Derby
Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii
Kris Koenig/Interstellar Studios/400 Years of the Telescope
Lunar & Planetary Library Laboratory, The University of Arizona
"Starlapse: The James Clerk Maxwell Telescope" time-lapse montage by William K Montgomerie
The Tombaugh Family
- NOVA SERIES GRAPHICS
- yU + co.
- NOVA THEME MUSIC
- Walter Werzowa
- ADDITIONAL NOVA THEME MUSIC
- Ray Loring
- CLOSED CAPTIONING
- The Caption Center
- POST PRODUCTION ONLINE EDITOR
- Spencer Gentry
- DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC RELATIONS
- Jennifer Welsh
- Eileen Campion
- ASSOCIATE RESEARCHER
- Diane Toomey
- PRODUCTION COORDINATOR
- Linda Callahan
- Sarah Erlandson
- TALENT RELATIONS
- Janice Flood
- LEGAL COUNSEL
- Susan Rosen
- DIGITAL MANAGING PRODUCER
- Kristine Allington
- SENIOR DIGITAL EDITOR
- Tim De Chant
- DIRECTOR OF DIGITAL MEDIA
- Lauren Aguirre
- DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATE
- Lisa Leombruni
- RIGHTS MANAGER
- Lauren Miller
- UNIT MANAGER
- Ariam McCrary
- POST PRODUCTION COORDINATOR
- Brittany Flynn
- SUPERVISING PRODUCER
- Kevin Young
- POST PRODUCTION EDITOR
- Michael H. Amundson
- BROADCAST MANAGER
- Nathan Gunner
- BUSINESS MANAGER
- Elizabeth Benjes
- DEVELOPMENT PRODUCER
- David Condon
- PROJECT DIRECTOR
- Pamela Rosenstein
- COORDINATING PRODUCER
- Laurie Cahalane
- SENIOR SCIENCE EDITOR
- Evan Hadingham
- SENIOR PRODUCER
- Chris Schmidt
- SENIOR SERIES PRODUCER
- Melanie Wallace
- DEPUTY EXECUTIVE PRODUCER
- Julia Cort
- MANAGING DIRECTOR
- Alan Ritsko
- SENIOR EXECUTIVE PRODUCER
- Paula S. Apsell
A NOVA production by Terri Randall Productions for WGBH Boston.
© 2015 WGBH Educational Foundation
All rights reserved
This program was produced by WGBH, which is solely responsible for its content.
Original funding for this program was provided by Google, the David H. Koch Fund for Science, Millicent Bell through the Millicent and Eugene Bell Foundation, Roger and Vicki Sant and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
- Image credit: (Artist's rendering of New Horizons spacecraft and Pluto)
- © Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/Southwest Research Institute (JHUAPL/SwRI)
- Alice Bowman, Mike Brown, Andrew Cheng, Sigrid Close, Glen Fountain, Mark Holdridge, David Jewitt, Jane Luu, Cathy Olkin, William Owen, Joel Parker, Caleb Scharf, John Spencer, Alan Stern, Mark Sykes, Annette Tombaugh, Hal Weaver, Leslie Young